Lord George Curzon's often quoted statement following World War I that “the Allies floated to victory on a wave of oil” indicates the importance of the role that oil was beginning to play on the world stage by the end of the war. Therefore, it is not surprising that two major users of the commodity, the United States and Great Britain, clashed over the future development of the oil industry. Nowhere were their differences more intense than in Persia and Mesopotamia. So intense was the competition between oil companies that the interwar years have been referred to as the age of “oil imperialism.” Oil and the Killing of the American Consul in Tehran concentrates on this interwar period, when the competition between the British and American oil companies, primarily the Anglo–Persian Oil Company, Standard Oil Company of New Jersey, and the Sinclair Oil Company, was at its height.
This study is based primarily on information from American diplomatic papers. The structure of the book is of long, direct quotations from these papers, with short passages of information and observations by the author. In spite of the significance of the data, much of the material could easily have been paraphrased. This would have improved its readability. However, the author has assembled material that will greatly add to the scarcity of studies previously available on this subject, especially concerning the positions taken by the American government on the oil question in Persia and the Middle East.
The book is divided into seven chapters. The first five, based primarily on U.S. Department of State files, present a detailed account of the Anglo American controversy over the development of Persian and Middle East oil concessions. The last two chapters are devoted to events surrounding the death of Robert Whitney Imbrie, the American vice-consul in Tehran.
Chapter 1 presents background material. By the end of World War I, Anglo American conflicts over the Near East had already surfaced. In 1919 the U.S. government learned of the signing of the ill-fated Anglo–Persian Agreement, which Americans saw as giving Great Britain a virtual monopoly over all Persian affairs. American oil interests were also especially concerned over this turn of events. Majd gives extensive coverage to the correspondence between the United States and Great Britain over the Anglo–Persian Agreement and the oil question.
Chapter 2 deals primarily with efforts to reach a compromise between Great Britain and the United States over the further development of oil in Persia. Britain had signed an agreement with Persia on 20 May 1914 that led to the establishment of the Anglo–Persian Oil Company (APOC) and gave it extensive control of oil exploration over all but the five northern provinces. In 1921, leaders in Washington and London concluded an agreement on a number of issues, and at that time Britain assured the United States equal opportunity in oil development in the Middle East.
Negotiations from 1919 through 1924 between Standard Oil, APOC, and Sinclair, as well as the governments of the United States, Great Britain, and Persia are examined in Chapters 3, 4, and 5. The on-again, off-again cooperation that developed between APOC and Standard Oil over a concession in Persia's five northern provinces is a complex study of the inner workings back and forth across the Atlantic between the British and American governments and their attitudes concerning the participation of American oil companies in an area dominated by both the British government and APOC. Another issue that receives extensive coverage is the Persian government's desperate need for a loan. This was complicated by the fact that the Persians preferred to deal with the Americans, delaying negotiations. A third major issue is the entrance of the Sinclair Oil Company into an already complicated fray. The author covers a vast amount of material, concluding with the Persians finally offering the northern provinces concession to Sinclair in return for a $10 million loan.
Fast passage of the final bill through the majlis was expected, but things took an unexpected turn on 18 July 1924, when Robert Imbrie was killed in Tehran. This event, plus the Teapot Dome Scandal, contributed to Sinclair's inability to continue its negotiations with the Persian government.
In the last two chapters, Majd closely examines this brutal killing. The basic events have been known for some time; however, he provides a highly detailed account based on U.S. diplomatic papers. He examines the version of the encounter that was officially accepted by the American government, that Imbrie was brutally murdered by a mob of religious fanatics taking part in an anti-Bahai demonstration. Majd suggests that the story of the killing is much more complex than this conclusion indicates. However, there is nothing in the material that indicates that Imbrie's killing was premeditated; in fact, it is highly unlikely that his itinerary for the day was specifically known. As revealed in the diplomatic papers, rumors ran rife throughout Tehran and other world capitals. Some reports of events stated that Imbrie's death was accidental and that the person who was supposed to be killed was Ralph Soper of the Sinclair Oil Company, connecting the incident to the intense rivalry for control of the oil concessions in northern Persia.
Many in Iran blamed the British for the killing, but in this reviewer's opinion there is no conclusive proof of British direct involvement on that particular day. In these chapters we see Reza Shah emerge as an important figure in events in Persia surrounding Imbrie's death. American diplomatic reports reveal his procrastination in investigating and bringing to justice those accused of being involved in the killing. However, the American government persisted in demanding a timely conclusion to the Imbrie affair. Reza Shah had little choice but to act against what he saw as his own best interest.
Majd's two concluding chapters certainly invite academic discussion about Imbrie's death and the influence it had on British, American, and Persian affairs in the years up to the outbreak of World War II. Given the complexity of events involving the development of the oil industry at the time of Imbrie's killing, it may be that all of the pertinent facts needed to clearly establish blame may never be known.
The book would have been immensely strengthened if it had included a short introduction in which the author clearly defined the purpose of his study and introduced Robert Whitney Imbrie to the reader before turning to lengthy chapters of background events leading up to his murder. Imbrie is not mentioned until page 207, and then Majd refers only to a report Imbrie had written. A bibliography would have been useful, particularly to provide background sources on British, Russian, and Persian diplomatic relations prior to the interwar years.
Nonetheless, the book should be of special interest to those who are interested in the history of the oil industry.
