Since its initial application to patients with sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD), significant technical improvements have been made to the real time-quaking-induced conversion (RT-QuIC) assay in CSF, making it much faster and more accurate.Reference Orrú, Groveman and Hughson1 CSF analysis by second-generation RT-QuIC Improved QuIC conditions yielded a sensitivity of 95% and a specificity of around 100%, as only a few false-positive cases have been reported out of thousands of CSF samples tested.Reference Slota, Myskiw and Peterson2 In this retrospective study, 2667 CSF samples were collected from individuals with suspected prion disorder from 2016 to 2024 across Canada provinces.Reference Green3 These samples were analyzed for 14.3.3 and Tau levels and by end-point QuIC (EP-QuIC). This assay identified 535 positive CSF samples, with sCJD pathological confirmation in 284 CJD cases. The overall sensitivity was 95%, with a single false-positive result from a patient with immune-mediated encephalopathy.Reference Green3 These results are in line with the extensive studies in CSF of sCJD patients and confirm the high-fidelity and diagnostic strength of the QuIC assay, also in sCJD subtypes, showing a higher sensitivity in MM2 and VV mixed compared to previous studies.Reference Hermann, Schmitz and Cramm4 Paradoxically, a higher number of EP-QuIC-negative CSF samples belonged to the MM1 subtype, which is usually characterized by a typical disease phenotype. The negative results were related to blood contamination. However, it has been demonstrated that diluting and retesting these false-negative CSF samples can further increase the sensitivity of the assay.Reference Fiorini, Iselle and Perra5 CSF biomarkers, such as 14-3-3 and tau protein, were also determined quantitatively, and their levels were related to the extent of disease progression. The high diagnostic accuracy of RT-QuIC assays has, of course, radically changed clinicians’ attitudes toward sCJD diagnosis worldwide, fostered by reproducibility among laboratories. Notably, prior to the introduction of RT-QuIC assays, the detection of 14-3-3 in CSF supported a CJD diagnosis, but the low specificity of this test resulted in uncertainty and the pursuit of additional, unnecessary diagnostic investigations. This study provides further confirmation of the success of RT-QuIC assays in sCJD diagnosis. Although RT-QuIC does not detect genetic prion diseases (i.e., Fatal Familial Insomnia and Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker) or variant CJD with the same accuracy as sCJD, family history or genetic testing can confirm the final diagnosis. A single patient with variant CJD and MV at codon 129 has been reported, which could be confused with sCJD.Reference Mok, Jaunmuktane and Susan6 However, the intensive surveillance system for CJD has made variant CJD an exhausting disease.
Since its initial application to patients with sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD), significant technical improvements have been made to the real time-quaking-induced conversion (RT-QuIC) assay in CSF, making it much faster and more accurate.Reference Orrú, Groveman and Hughson1 CSF analysis by second-generation RT-QuIC Improved QuIC conditions yielded a sensitivity of 95% and a specificity of around 100%, as only a few false-positive cases have been reported out of thousands of CSF samples tested.Reference Slota, Myskiw and Peterson2 In this retrospective study, 2667 CSF samples were collected from individuals with suspected prion disorder from 2016 to 2024 across Canada provinces.Reference Green3 These samples were analyzed for 14.3.3 and Tau levels and by end-point QuIC (EP-QuIC). This assay identified 535 positive CSF samples, with sCJD pathological confirmation in 284 CJD cases. The overall sensitivity was 95%, with a single false-positive result from a patient with immune-mediated encephalopathy.Reference Green3 These results are in line with the extensive studies in CSF of sCJD patients and confirm the high-fidelity and diagnostic strength of the QuIC assay, also in sCJD subtypes, showing a higher sensitivity in MM2 and VV mixed compared to previous studies.Reference Hermann, Schmitz and Cramm4 Paradoxically, a higher number of EP-QuIC-negative CSF samples belonged to the MM1 subtype, which is usually characterized by a typical disease phenotype. The negative results were related to blood contamination. However, it has been demonstrated that diluting and retesting these false-negative CSF samples can further increase the sensitivity of the assay.Reference Fiorini, Iselle and Perra5 CSF biomarkers, such as 14-3-3 and tau protein, were also determined quantitatively, and their levels were related to the extent of disease progression. The high diagnostic accuracy of RT-QuIC assays has, of course, radically changed clinicians’ attitudes toward sCJD diagnosis worldwide, fostered by reproducibility among laboratories. Notably, prior to the introduction of RT-QuIC assays, the detection of 14-3-3 in CSF supported a CJD diagnosis, but the low specificity of this test resulted in uncertainty and the pursuit of additional, unnecessary diagnostic investigations. This study provides further confirmation of the success of RT-QuIC assays in sCJD diagnosis. Although RT-QuIC does not detect genetic prion diseases (i.e., Fatal Familial Insomnia and Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker) or variant CJD with the same accuracy as sCJD, family history or genetic testing can confirm the final diagnosis. A single patient with variant CJD and MV at codon 129 has been reported, which could be confused with sCJD.Reference Mok, Jaunmuktane and Susan6 However, the intensive surveillance system for CJD has made variant CJD an exhausting disease.
Author contributions
GZ and MB contributed equally in drafting the manuscript.
Funding statement
This work was supported by Creutzfeldt-Jakob Foundation research grant to GZ.
Competing interests
None.