Alan Craig's International Legitimacy and the Politics of Security examines the central moral problem of contemporary warfare: how can civilians be protected in asymmetric wars that pit states against nonstate actors operating in civilian areas? How much harm to the civilian population of an enemy is justifiable in the interests of protecting the civilians of one's own state? And how far should states go in risking the lives of their own soldiers to protect the civilian population of their enemy? These questions are at the heart of fierce disagreements over Israel's conduct in its recent conflicts with Hamas and Hizbullah, and are the empirical focus of Craig's analysis. They have wide-ranging implications for assessing the US War on Terror and the many less visible counterinsurgency wars throughout the world.
Craig approaches these questions by parsing out the complex relationship between the law, morality, and legitimacy of harming civilians in armed conflict through four case studies of Israeli military operations: the targeted killing program during the second intifada, the 2006 Lebanon War, Operation Cast Lead, and the Mavi Marmara incident of 2010. His analysis draws on the English School of International Relations, which views states as members of an international society motivated by the desire to promote their legitimacy and retain their membership in this society. Craig asks how the legality and morality of a state's actions affect its legitimacy, where legitimacy is understood as “shared belief in the ‘rightness’ of a state or its policies” (p. 13). Legal acts are not always perceived as legitimate (as in the use of cluster bombs that cause disproportionate harm to civilians), while illegal acts are not always perceived as illegitimate (as in the case of NATO's humanitarian intervention in Kosovo without authorization from the UN Security Council). Moreover, law itself often contains a variety of answers to the question of when harm to civilians is justifiable, depending on whether civilians lose their noncombatant status by virtue of their actions, how risks to soldiers are assessed, who is presumed to bear greater responsibility when armed actors are embedded among civilians, and which moral arguments (security concerns or human rights norms) inspire the legal argumentation. Hence, instead of determining whether Israel's actions are legal or illegal, Craig argues that states, including Israel, draw on the multivocality of law to construct legal arguments that justify their security policies, with the end goal of maintaining legitimacy. These legal arguments exist in uneasy tension with competing legal and moral arguments based on human rights norms that more highly value civilian lives. International law is not irrelevant to state behavior in this perspective, but its effect operates through legitimacy rather than through states’ automatic compliance with international law or through the intrinsic morality of international rules.
The book draws on original interviews with Israeli government lawyers and moral philosophers, as well as a plethora of legal and institutional documents such as court decisions, the reports of Israeli and international investigation committees, and human rights reports. It is generally well written, but plagued by numerous typos. Part 1 focuses on moral and legal arguments about the protection of civilians in armed conflict. These arguments include Just War Theory and alternative perspectives based on human rights, pacifism, militarism, and religion, as well as the legal doctrines of distinction and proportionality that regulate violence against civilians during armed conflict. Part 2 analyzes competing legal arguments advanced by various actors in the four case studies, tracing these arguments back to practices of categorization (for instance, whether a building is classified as civilian infrastructure or a “dual use” building, whether police officials working for the Hamas government are deemed civilians or military targets, etc.) and the moral worldviews upon which they draw. The case study chapters make up the most fascinating part of the book.
The book's main conclusion that advocates and critics of Israel's security policy articulate competing legal arguments is not entirely surprising. Nor is the author's point that states care about their legitimacy groundbreaking for international relations theory. One of the important claims of the book is that legitimacy is audience bound: states worry more about the views of some states than others. Yet this important insight is not matched with a systematic analysis in the empirical chapters of the legitimacy costs of specific Israeli actions with respect to different audiences. While the argument seems to be that Israel cares about the views of Western democracies that support Israel, the analysis does not clearly establish that there were no legitimacy costs to Israel's actions within this audience. Nor does it explain why Israel has devoted considerable resources to develop a legal infrastructure both to justify and to monitor its security policies. In other words, the author does not satisfactorily address whether membership in a community confers legitimacy irrespective of a state's actions.
The book makes a more original contribution to the field of sociolegal studies by implicitly addressing this literature's central question of whether law offers activists useful channels for translating their demands into enforceable rights or undermines their struggle by justifying—and legalizing—the status quo. In the context of the Israeli occupation, law's greatest promise is to offer morally defensible, and not overtly politicized, criteria to distinguish between the permissible and impermissible uses of violence. Yet, the effort to establish such criteria encourages legal actors to articulate new categories (for example, “unlawful combatants,” who are not entitled to the protection of either civilians or combatants) that blur previously accepted distinctions and restore discretion, flexibility, and potentially arbitrariness, re-empowering states in an increasingly legalized field where actions have to be justified through legal discourse. Craig's analysis perceptively underlines the indeterminacy and multivocality of law by demonstrating how each actor constructs a legal argument based upon its own categories and an underlying morality that is fundamentally at odds with the moral worldview of its rival. Within sociolegal studies, the role of law in restraining and enabling Israel's occupation has been analyzed by Lisa Hajjar, Ronen Shamir, Lori Allen, and Tobias Kelly, among others. International Legitimacy and the Politics of Security speaks to the issues raised by these works, but falls short of their theoretical rigor. Nonetheless, the case study chapters are sure to be of value to instructors looking for material with which to teach the moral and legal controversies pertaining to Israel's security policy, while the book as a whole will interest sociolegal scholars and international relations theorists.
