In and after 1857, Indo-Muslim elites saw their world crumble as quickly as the buildings around them. While many nobles were imprisoned, executed and expelled from the city,Footnote 1 forced to leave their belongings and properties to be seized as the “Delhi Prize”,Footnote 2 many of the finest monuments of Lahore, Agra, Lucknow and Delhi were destroyed or rehabilitated as chapels, hospitals, railway stations, post offices or military quarters.Footnote 3 In Delhi, the transformation was dramatic: after 1857, the crowded areas around the Red Fort were entirely demolished and most of the remaining buildings within the Fort were requested for military use. In 1882, Henry Cole, Curator of Ancient Monuments, reported that “the great pillared Diwan-i Am, with its fine marble mosaic canopy and throne, is used as a canteen, and on the right of the throne is a bar for serving out liquor! To the left of the throne is an enclosure of bamboo screen-work in which Nubbi Bux keeps a soldiers’ coffee shop!”Footnote 4 After 1857, the colonial state soon began to remodel the city by introducing Western technology (railways, and later electricity, etc.), sanitising the town (through waste disposal and water supply systems, etc.) and modifying the structure of the walled city.Footnote 5 In the city, the palaces and properties of the Nawabs of Jhajjar, Ballabgarh, Bahadurgarh, and Farrucknagar, the hawelis of Nawab Wazir, Kucha Bulaqi Begum, the Akbarabadi Masjid and many madrasahs were destroyed.Footnote 6 As Ghalib wrote to his friend Husain Mirza on 31 December 1859 about the aftermath, “the orders issued here in Delhi are the decrees of fate and destiny, against which there is no appeal. Say to yourself: “We were never nobles; rank and wealth were never ours; we had no property, and never drew a pension”.Footnote 7
The aim of this article is to investigate the ways in which the events of 1857 were narrated and remembered in the decade immediately following 1857 by looking at one collection of Urdu poems entitled Fuġhān-e Dehlī (The Lament for Delhi) (1863). Although scholars have recently noticed the significance of shahr āshob poetry after 1857,Footnote 8 it has generally been neglected in comparison to other and perhaps more ‘factual’ sources of the period. I shall argue here that the poignant narratives of loss of The Lament for Delhi reveal significant change in the process of remembering and in the mentalities of Urdu-speaking ashrāf in the middle of the nineteenth century. With the development of the ‘secular marṡiyah’, poets articulated a distinctive narrative of 1857 as cultural trauma through the resort to Shia aesthetics, the collective performance of mourning and the ‘sacralisation’ of the pre-1857 urban landscape. Successfully re-channelling the deep emotions of grief and nostalgia into a strong attachment to the urban, the poems of The Lament for Delhi increasingly exalted the city's materiality.
The Lament for Delhi: elements of context
In 1863, only six years after the Uprising and one year after Muslims were finally readmitted in Delhi, the poet Tafazzul Husain ‘Kaukab’ (1833-1873/4)Footnote 9 published an anthology of poems on 1857 entitled Fuġhān-e Dehlī (The Lament for Delhi) by the Akmal ul-Maṯābʿa publishing house.Footnote 10 The compilation, which gathers fifty-nine poems composed by thirty-eight poets, is divided into three “sparks” (sharār): the first contains four pre-1857 poems (one by Bahadur Shah Zafar and three by Sauda); the second fourteen poems on 1857 in the musaddas form with one tarīḵẖ; and the last thirty-eight ghazals and two qaṯ‘ahs on 1857. In each section, the poems are arranged according to the alphabetical order of their authors – though the most eminent poets are listed first – and every poet is introduced by a couple of lines in Persian indicating his name, and sometimes the names of his father and ustād in the manner of tażkirahs. Most poems were composed by some of the most famous poets of the time (Sheftah, Azurdah, ‘Aish, Dagh, Salik, or Saqib) who belonged to noble Muslim families of Delhi, although the poet Zahir was a Hindu Khatri and a couple of other authors seem to have come from humbler backgrounds, sometimes even making errors of grammar or pronunciation.Footnote 11
In the foreword, Kaukab described the anthology as a “new” type of guldastah (anthology) that interwove “the tears, sighs, and heart-burnings of the natives of Delhi like a mirror”.Footnote 12 As a matter of fact, The Lament for Delhi was presented and described as an attempt to record the collective grief of the post-1857 period by publishing poems that circulated orally and would otherwise, and most probably, have been lost. The exact way in which the poems were collected, however, remains quite obscure. In his preface to the book Salik emphasised both the thriving of oral shahr āshob poetry after 1857 and Kaukab's efforts in the gathering and publishing of these poems:
In this city, lots of musaddas and ghazals have been composed on this topic [the destruction of Delhi in 1857], but no one had thought about gathering them and making of them a substantial anthology for the public. [. . .] Munshi Muhammad Tafazzul Husain Khan, taḵẖalluṣ Kaukab assembled them with extreme effort, and looking from place to place, had them sent to him. He organised them in a compendium, gave it to print to the publishing house Akmal ul-Maṯābʿa, and entitled it The Lament for Delhi.Footnote 13
Khan has, however, recently argued that elements from the poems give evidence of the “existence of a community of poets interacting amongst themselves” rather than “of a scattered set of materials which Kaukab has brought together for the first time”.Footnote 14 Almost all of the ghazals of the collection were composed in the same zamīn (metre) and radīf (rhyme) – ‘ān-e Dehlī’ which conveniently rhymes with the title of Fuġhān-e Dehlī – and the work displayed a couple of examples of intertextuality, poets quoting verses from one another.Footnote 15 Scholars indeed argued that the poems of The Lament for Delhi stemmed from an organised context of composition, maybe a ṯaraḥī mushāʿirah, a poetic assembly that is ‘patterned’, a common practice at the time. Malik Ram for instance, argued that “after the bloody disturbance of 1857, when peace and calm was re-established in the city the citizens probably held a mushāʿirah during which the major master-poets of the time cried over the devastation of the city”.Footnote 16 The attribution of the poems to one poetic event, however, seems rather limiting. Internal elements suggesting different dates of composition,Footnote 17 signs of intertextuality in poems that are set in different patterns and the mention of oral recitation may also point at the continued liveliness of shahr āshob performances in the aftermath of 1857.Footnote 18 As Urdu poets left Delhi to return to their hometowns, such as Panipat, Aligarh, or Jahangirabad, or to settle in regional courts (Hyderabad, Alwar, Rampur, Jaipur or Tonk) where patronage was still provided, poetic milieux that sustained the composition of shahr āshob poetry undoubtedly persisted. For instance, after having spent a few years at Hali's ancestral property in Panipat, Majruh successively travelled to the courts of Alwar, Jaipur, and Rampur. Until 1874, when Shivdan Singh died, the court of Alwar employed several of the poets whose poems are gathered in the anthology, like Majruh, Salik or Zahir.Footnote 19
All the poems of the anthology invariably belong to the shahr āshob style.Footnote 20 In Urdu, the relatively new genre was essentially characterised by a particular mood, melancholy, and especially by a particular subject: the city.Footnote 21 In the Islamic world that “had an overwhelmingly urban focus”Footnote 22 the city was usually celebrated through the vivacity of urban life and its idealised moral order: cities were often described as gardens of paradise on earth and conveyed particular ideas of harmony and virtue. Although tażkirahs and travelogues often described urban landscapes in some way or other, the genre of shahr āshūb or shahr angez in the Turkish and Persian traditions, which was greatly appreciated in the late Timurid and early Safawid periods,Footnote 23 consisted in humorously praising a city by describing the positive uproar caused by its many beautiful young citizens (or ‘city-disturbers’). Instead of also describing monuments as in Sanskrit literature or in the Arabic rithā’ al-mudun genre, it portrayed sometimes satirically the inhabitants of various professional, ethnical and religious backgrounds.Footnote 24 The representation of the city as a space where moral values and behaviours were epitomised eventually emphasised the morality and righteousness of its ruler. Seventeenth-century Persian shahr āshobs composed in India by Kalim Hamadani, Munir Lahori and Fani Kashmiri, for instance, served to exalt the greatness of the Mughal Empire by describing peaceful cities characterised by the diverse composition and impeccable morality of their inhabitants.Footnote 25
From the eighteenth century, when the genre was adapted in Urdu, however, poets increasingly resorted to it to portray the social disarray of Indian cities and it rapidly evolved into a “poetry of nostalgia and pessimism”Footnote 26 that mourned the decline of the Mughal Empire. The function of the city-poem thus radically changed in Urdu to describe and lament (sometimes still satirically) the ‘disturbed city’ and the confused state of affairs of different classes of inhabitants in a world ‘turned upside down’, with the morally and occupationally ‘inferiors’ rising in status.Footnote 27 This new development and the fact that shahr āshob writers usually used plain and simple language led the Urdu genre to be considered as “democratic”Footnote 28 and “historical”, the change in fortunes pointing for instance at the growing social tensions between Hindu commercial groups and the Indo-Persian gentry during the eighteenth century.Footnote 29 After the sack of Delhi by Ahmad Shah Abdali (1756), Urdu poets gradually abandoned their satirical tone and the caricature of all types of citizens to become more emotional and lament the city's devastation. After 1857, Urdu poets naturally turned towards shahr āshob poetry to express their grief at Delhi's desolation. However, they not only claimed continuity with the Urdu tradition but also developed the genre in unprecedented ways and made of the urban space the very centre of their nostalgic reflections.
The ‘secular marṡiyah’ and the construction of 1857 as cultural trauma
While The Lament for Delhi placed itself in continuity with previous shahr āshob poems, it also attested rupture and, I argue, intended to do so. From the later part of the eighteenth century but especially in the mid-nineteenth century, indeed, shahr āshobs started to be composed “in a new way, in which the ‘colour’ of the marṡiyah was prominent”.Footnote 30 Shahr āshob writers increasingly adopted Shia aesthetics, which were most efficient in conveying collective grief and tales of common dispossession. Part of this change was visible in the fact that from 1857 shahr āshob writers massively used the musaddas and ghazal verse forms. While the marṡiyah originated in the secular Arabic lamentations traditionally recited at funerals or at the loss of cities like Baghdad or Cordoba,Footnote 31 the genre in Urdu and Persian was mainly used in a religious context to commemorate the martyrs of Karbala and especially Imam Husain. The adoption of the musaddas by shahr āshob poets was hence unequivocal: originally developed in the Shia kingdom of Lucknow and developed with Mir Damir, the musaddas under Anis and Dabir was considered “the most suitable form for a marsiyah”Footnote 32 and had become the fundamental characteristic of nineteenth-century Shia elegies. As C. M. Naim argued, the change was most probably linked to a change in context as “the marsiyah moved indoors” and poets abandoned singing for declaiming (taḥt ul-lafẕ).Footnote 33 The musaddas meter moreover, enabled elegists to commemorate the hardships suffered by the martyrs of Karbala with more detail and realism.
The use of the musaddas associated with Shia elegies for shahr āshob poetry seems to have been a deliberate choice made by post-1857 poets to emphasise and describe the sufferings of the citizens with particular pathos. With heartrending descriptions of massacre and misery declaimed in a particular way and tone, the marṡiyah aimed at generating a particular collective mental and emotional state of mourning considered religiously rewarding among the audience. The main quality of marṡiyahs is that of evoking emotions (ras-bhāv)Footnote 34 - and of acting as “emotives”Footnote 35 - to an audience and, with this collective emotional “contagion” (or “collective effervescence”), of reinforcing sentiments of group belonging and solidarity.Footnote 36 Much indicates that the poems of The Lament for Delhi generated similar collective expressions of mourning in a non-religious and more secular way as shahr āshob writers clearly stated to espouse the elegists’ tasks of weeping and of making others weep (ronā aur rulānā). While the poems swarm with comparisons between shahr āshob poets and Shia elegists (marṡiyahḵẖwāns) and display the frequent use of interjections of sorrow (wāe, hāe, ḥaif, etc.), references to the effects of shahr āshob verses on the audience within the poems further hint at their aim to make the audience cry and re-live the traumatic experience at poetic gatherings. As Salik illustrated in the preface of the collection, the composition and recitation of shahr āshob poems in the aftermath of the Uprising may have consisted in a “disguised repetition of the traumatic event”Footnote 37 by inscribing the traumatic experience in collective memory, thus “allowing the pent-up emotions of loss and mourning to be expressed” through public acts of commemoration:Footnote 38
if you look carefully, every musaddas is an elegy (marṡiyah), and every ghazal is a requiem (nauḥah). Who has the power, listening to them, not to cry? Whose heart is not brimming with blood because of this pain? When one listens to someone's verses on that matter, his ears go dumb, he has knots in his stomach, he remembers his own hardships, and that crossing of the desert comes into sight again.Footnote 39
The reference to the impact of the verses on the audience is also an enduring theme developed in the poems themselves. At least one verse of every poem, often in conclusion to poignant portrayals of loss, is dedicated to the description of its capacity to make listeners burst into tears:
The fact that shahr āshob poems, like Shia elegies, could have been recited or chanted in a particular way to arouse and heighten emotions in the audience may have resulted in the trope of the “weeping Hindustani” (poet and/or musician) lamenting the end of the Mughal world, notably developed in early twentieth-century Bengali literature.Footnote 41
By collectively grieving and representing the events of 1857 as rupture, notably through the use of the secular marṡiyah, Urdu poets narrated a tale of cultural trauma and identified themselves as a “people of suffering” (ahl-e dard).Footnote 42 As scholars of cultural trauma like Kai Erikson have highlighted, trauma can indeed affect communities too: it can damage the “tissues of community” and “create a mood, an ethos - a group culture, almost”.Footnote 43 Most scholars, however, agree that traumas do not just occur, but are socially constructed. It is only through a complex meaning-making process, during which “cultural carriers” create culturally relevant “narratives of social sufferings”,Footnote 44 that collective pain is inflicted and transmitted. I argue that shahr āshob poets could have taken part in a similar meaning-making process. They indeed expressed some of the psychological symptoms usually associated with trauma. They represented their experience of 1857 as indelible “parasite”Footnote 45 memories in the Indo-Muslim collective consciousness by describing the experience of 1857 as still actively distressing in the present. In many instances the acuteness of the shock is asserted through the recurrence of traumatic memories and poets often express their need but have difficulty speaking about the events.Footnote 46 Although Urdu shahr āshobs had always documented social dismay, they had never presented the events described with such pathos or as a “culturally undermining” experience, one of the most central elements in the construction of cultural traumas. Contrary to previous shahr āshobs, post-1857 poems increasingly tended to direct their gaze toward pre-traumatic glory and inscribe this yearning as a part of their collective identity. As Ghalib lamented in one ghazal:
Traumatic cultural damage was also clearly expressed by Urdu poets through the unanimous representation of 1857 as a rupture, a breach in the history of Urdu-speaking ashrāf that was equalled to the apocalypse or the end of history itself, sometimes by linking conspicuously the events in Delhi to those of Karbala.
The representation of 1857 as a cultural rupture further materialised in the poems in the desperate nostalgia for the pre-1857 city as poets constantly lingered on descriptions of paradise lost. Stark oppositions between past and present illustrated well the feelings of loss, which Svetlana Boym linked to the arrival of modernity or to the aftermath of the fall of empires.Footnote 49 One of the most notable innovations of post-1857 shahr āshob poetry was indeed that it was less a literature about the city than a literature about the city of the past. In the poems, past and present invariably appeared in pure antagonism and nostalgia surfaced from each couplet through various “then and now” images: paradisiac gardens turned into deserts, beautiful princes into beggars, etc. This way of representing the events of 1857 continued onto the early twentieth century. From 1914, Khwajah Hasan Nizami for instance accompanied his Ghadr-e Dehlī ke afsāne Footnote 50 with touching drawings similar to the images evoked in shahr āshob poems, thus indicating the inter-mediality of these motifs.Footnote 51
Nostalgia and the city: the collective mourning of pre-1857 urban landscapes
While post-1857 shahr āshobs are, like their antecedents, narratives of loss and ruin, the use of specific literary devices (the adoption of Shia aesthetics and the emphasis on historical rupture) helped construct the memory of 1857 as cultural trauma. I argue that particular representations of the urban landscape and the collective emotions that were inscribed onto it further reinforced this narrative. As we have seen above, traditional shahr āshob literature described cities through their people. In Sanskrit literature, the description of cities with their palaces and buildings was one of the characteristics of a good poem,Footnote 52 and Arabic poetry too had a long tradition of describing deserted camps and other places. As Charles Pellat noted, Arabic poets used to mourn over aṭlāl (ruins) and lament the destruction of buildings (and mosques in particular), especially after the destruction of Baghdad by the Mongols or at the loss of cities in Ifriqqiya or al-Andalus (especially Cordoba) during the Reconquista.Footnote 53 If people and souks were mentioned in praise of the cultural and economic bloom of cities, Hassen noted that “an emphasis is often put on the caliphs’ palaces and mansions, on their grandeur and rich architecture, on the parks and gardens that surround and embellish them. We are sometimes told of chandeliers and pounds with water-jets, and sometimes, even if fragmentarily, the interiors of apartments or royal chambers are described”.Footnote 54 In Turkish and Persian, however, it was people rather than buildings that formed the urban landscape. Writers usually memorialised the diversity of the population making of the city a glorious habitat in tażkirahs, travelogues or shahr āshob poems. This was also how cities came to be described in the Indo-Persian tradition. In the first half of the eighteenth century, as Margrit Pernau for instance has noted about the famous travelogue of Dargah Quli Khan entitled Muraqqa‘-ye Dehlī (The Delhi Album, c. 1739–1741) “the complete absence of descriptions of the buildings of Delhi is conspicuous”.Footnote 55 It was people, living and dead, who framed the city landscape. In his account, Dargah Quli Khan indeed only incidentally described buildings and most of his work consisted in listing and describing Sufi saints, poets and entertainers. Apart from a few dargāhs, marketplaces were the only urban spaces that were given some attention.Footnote 56
The poems of The Lament for Delhi also retained this traditional way of describing the city in exalting the virtue and quality of its many residents, “doctors, poets, scholars, mathematicians, and wise men”Footnote 57 and the ruin of the city was still described through the ruin, death, and exile of the citizens in most of the poems. However, some shahr āshobs of the collection also started putting more stress on the materiality of the urban landscape that concretely embodied lost Mughal culture as poets increasingly linked collective grief to monuments. A new emphasis on buildings seems to have begun to develop from the middle of the eighteenth century, after the sack of Delhi by Ahmad Shah Abdali (1756), in Sauda's and Mir's writings. At the time, the theme of the city ruins was sometimes used as a motif to express feelings of despair and grief at the desertion of north Indian cities but ruins usually remained metaphorical, abstract and anonymous.Footnote 58 On the contrary, the poets of The Lament for Delhi amplified it in an unprecedented way: in addition to the melancholic description of the ruins of nameless houses and buildings, particular monuments were now mentioned by name and sometimes briefly described. The city's splendour was no longer exclusively attributed to its people but also to its monuments:
Along with the three major areas of Old Delhi (the Red Fort, Jama‘Masjid, and Chandni Chowk), a number of streets (particularly Ballimaran), canals, shops and other buildings entered the poetic realm. Poets started picturing Delhi with unusual attention: while the poet Shamshir for instance mentioned the Khas bazaar between the eastern gate of the Jama‘ Masjid and the Red Fort, Mirza ‘Aziz evoked Lal Diggi,Footnote 60 a water reservoir built in front of the Red Fort, also known as the Ellenborough tank (1846).Footnote 61
The new concern with monuments that was also displayed in early nineteenth-century travelogues, paintings and antiquarian writings is often explained in scholarship by the growing influence of Western scholars and colonials from the middle of the eighteenth century but most importantly from the beginning of the nineteenth century. C. M. Naim, Faisal Devji and Margrit Pernau, for instance, have argued that this new approach to monuments had been encouraged by Western scholars, officers and tourists interested in the historical heritage and spatial mapping of north Indian cities.Footnote 62 One of the first works that conceptualised the city as a primarily built environment was Mirza Sangin Beg's Sair al-Manāzil (“A Walk through the Houses”) composed in 1820 and possibly commissioned by Thomas Metcalfe.Footnote 63 In 1824, Lalah Sil Chand compiled his Tafrīḥ al-‘imārāt describing the buildings in Agra and accompanied by drawings under the instigation of John Steven Lushington,Footnote 64 and in the late 1840s and early 1850s, Syed Ahmed Khan edited his two versions of Āṡār uṣ-Ṣanādīd at the behest of a British judge.Footnote 65 Margrit Pernau has recently argued that, from the 1840s, these new representations of the city indicated that the link between people and spaces was broken “and hence the possibility for the endowment of spaces with feelings”.Footnote 66
Other circumstances, however, can explain the emergence of a greater emphasis on architecture and I argue that it not necessarily reveals rupture between people and their built environment. On the contrary, shahr āshob poems indicate that Delhi's monuments became charged with deep emotions notably because they stood in place of the people when most of them had left or died. This intimate relation between the people and the urban was echoed in the poems by the idea that the fortunes of the population and of the buildings mirrored each other. Social upheaval was thus paralleled by the despair generated by urban ruin, monuments echoing the citizens’ ordeal and reflecting human finitude. In a couple of instances, poets expressed the idea that, just as poets mourned the devastation of the city landscape, edifices too were wailing over its population.
The strong reciprocity between the built landscape and the people that transpires through some of the poems seems to further translate the loss generated by 1857 into cultural dislocation, with the loss of the environment being equalled with the death of culture itself. Scholars of urban memory have indeed frequently noted how changes in the urban landscape tremendously affect social memory since the built environment both creates a “sense of community”Footnote 69 and acts as a powerful reminder of collective history by forming a “topography of remembering” which embodies the past “through traces of the city's sequential building and rebuilding”.Footnote 70 In the poems, the Red Fort represented Indo-Muslim aristocrats, Ballimaran poets and Chandni Chowk the hustle and bustle of daily Mughal life. The loss of buildings echoed the loss of the people who interacted in and around them and vice-versa if buildings still stood then maybe life could also resume.
While Western influence probably accentuated changes in the conception of the urban, I argue that the growth of a sense of place and the emotional investment in the architectural environment in The Lament for Delhi also undoubtedly resulted from the changing nature of Mughal travelling practices from the eighteenth century onwards and from the narrative construction of cultural trauma by the poets.
The Mughals like the Timurids and Safawids under whose rule shahr āshob literature thrived had incredibly mobile courts and retained a nomadic way of life.Footnote 72 Although Mughal emperors built fine capital cities and encouraged urbanisation, the Mughal court consisted, first and foremost, of a camp.Footnote 73 As late as 1739, Mughal emperors spent around forty per cent of their time in tours of one year or more. When they left with their camp, the city was emptied of its population and dramatically declined since the entire court (with the women, cooks, water-carriers, craftsmen, etc.) followed.Footnote 74 As Abul Fazl described in his Aʿīn-i Akbarī, massive tents were erected as the imperial court moved from one place to another, forming veritable “tent cities” with palaces, streets and bazaars.Footnote 75 When Shahjahanabad was constructed from 1648, the imperial camp that had become an essential symbol of Mughal power even served as archetype for the construction of the Red Fort of Delhi whose layout reproduced the model of the camp.Footnote 76 Even in the capital city, tents were still erected in and around buildings, and awnings and canopies were rigged to the palaces;Footnote 77 architecture and “tentage” thus continued to be combined as late as 1857.Footnote 78 However, as travelling practices started to wane at the beginning of the eighteenth century, probably as a result of the unmanageable size of the imperial camp but also with the decline of Mughal power and territory, the court remained increasingly immobile. Most probably around that time, when Mughal territory was reduced to the territory of Delhi itself, a new sense of place started to develop amongst Mughal elites and city's buildings became imbued with symbolism.
In the aftermath of 1857, the shahr āshobs of The Lament for Delhi also consciously encouraged particular representations of the city that further helped build a poetic narrative of cultural trauma. The representation of Indo-Muslim elites as “victims” merged with a reading of 1857 as damaging to the very essence of Indo-Muslim culture that was epitomised by the Mughal city. As scholars like Daniela Bredi have noted, the choice to remember pre-1857 Delhi as a Mughal city was indeed not entirely accurate. Although the Mughal emperor still reigned over the Red Fort, his influence had become mostly symbolic and his resources were limited. After Shah Alam II's difficult return to Delhi in 1774 and the British occupation of Delhi from 1803, the proverb used to mock that the Mughal “empire” only stretched from Delhi to Palam.Footnote 79 As a matter of fact, Delhi, from 1803 to 1857 was very much governed by the British. In 1937, ‘Arsh Timuri remembered in his city memoirs that the Mughal king had to obtain permission from the British Resident every time he planned to leave Delhi, even to spend a few days in his hunting lodge on the outskirts of the city.Footnote 80 The profound nostalgia and romantic memory of the period as “an imagined place embodying the final splendour of the Mughal age”Footnote 81 displayed by Urdu poets in the aftermath of 1857 clearly participated in the articulation of narratives of cultural trauma that emphasised major cultural loss and did not wait the 1930s to develop.Footnote 82
As a matter of fact, the pre-1857 city of The Lament for Delhi constantly appeared as a holy place. It was sometimes described as at the very centre of creation or as a second Mecca and Delhi's urban space was often integrated into the world of Islam, which was reciprocally incorporated into Delhi's landscape. Since the beginning of Muslim rule Delhi had often been compared to a little MeccaFootnote 83 and, as Marcia Hermansen has noted in her study of Indian tażkirahs, the sacralisation of cities was a way of memorialising Islam in the urban space and affirming Muslim identity through the configuration of new centres and circuits of pilgrimage.Footnote 84 The exaltation of the pre-1857 landscape in The Lament for Delhi, however, seems to go beyond the definition of space as a memorial of religious piety since the places of pilgrimage and worship that were praised in tażkirahs were far from being the only spaces sacralised in 1857 shahr āshob poetry: it was the entire Mughal city with its language and culture that was described as the place of God's manifestation.Footnote 85 The poets aimed at emphasising the pre-1857 urban landscape in order to accentuate the cultural damage that its devastation implied, notably by partly drawing on traditional theories of Islamic architecture in which the Emperor and his imperial city (or camp) were conceived as the axis mundi, the imperial Fort acting as the “symbolic centre of a nested hierarchy: city, empire and universe”.Footnote 86 Perceived as both the macrocosm of man and the microcosm of the empire, the city was often compared to human anatomy (maybe as an allegory for the Mughal king), with the main market acting as its backbone, the palace as its head and the great mosque as its heart, smaller streets and buildings acting as ribs and organs, and walls defining its body.Footnote 87 Strikingly, such theories were exactly reproduced in one of Ahsan's verses:
As Soofia Siddique has shown, the metaphor of the body was an important image in Mughal ideology and authority was asserted through the “ritual and relational hierarchy of the different parts of the body”Footnote 89 for instance materialised in the ceremonious giving of the ḵẖila‘t (honorific robe) which incorporated subjects into body politics. Rosalind O'Hanlon argued that the just emperor and his norms and values were seen as the agents of cohesion and harmony in the articulation of the different bodies composing the empire and regulating, by moral virtue, the different spheres of the kingdom, household and individual.Footnote 90 The Mughal emperor was the symbolic centre of the city and Empire, acting as the “divinely ordained focus [. . .] of society”.Footnote 91 By nostalgically “sacralising” the pre-1857 city and durably linking the shahr āshob genre to the marṡiyah, shahr āshob writers intimately linked collective emotions of grief to the urban landscape. As the poets Dagh and Saqib both illustrated, the death and life of the city's culture was increasingly linked to the destruction and reconstruction of buildings.
Conclusion
The post-1857 shahr āshob poems that were gathered in Kaukab's anthology displayed significant innovations from pre-1857 shahr āshob poems in Urdu. They aimed at constructing 1857 as a cultural trauma for Urdu-speaking ashrāf through the oral performance of secular marṡiyahs that efficiently conveyed emotions of collective grief as well as through the emphasis on the urban landscape as the very centre of their narrative of loss. On one hand, the constant references to oral performance and to the impact of shahr āshob verses on the audience in the poems clearly indicate peculiar memory practices in the period following 1857. Like Shia elegists, shahr āshob poets seem to have cultivated a culture of ‘āshobgoī’ which implied collective commemoration and communal weeping. On the other hand, the city was exalted as the core of the Mughal elites’ identity with buildings acting as concrete sites for Indo-Muslim cultural mourning. The significance of the built environment for north Indian ashrāf was further illustrated by the growing preoccupation for the protection of heritage sites and town improvement measures in the aftermath of 1857. In 1865, two years after the publication of the anthology, reports from the vernacular press showed that Urdu editors often voiced concerns over colonial urban planning projects by frequently lamenting and opposing the destruction of some garden, well, mosque or ancient gate.Footnote 95
While scholars have highlighted the relationship between a growing interest in the city's material landscape and the influence of Western scholarship and tourist practices, this article has shown that evolutions in the conception and representation of the city were probably also triggered by the imperial court's increasing immobility with the decline of the Mughal Empire in the early eighteenth century and by the narrative construction of 1857 as cultural trauma which interwove collective emotions with buildings. At a time when monuments were destroyed to create wide public streets, Mughal gardens remodelled according to Victorian tastes and city gates renamed after British queens,Footnote 96 the city of Delhi became charged with powerful emotions. It became the symbol of an Indo-Muslim culture and identity that was increasingly used in politics, especially during the construction of New Delhi, when ‘attacks’ on the material ruins of the Indian Muslim past became a popular motive for anti-colonial mobilisations. The Mughal city of shahr āshob recollections indeed remained a significant locus of nostalgia for Muslim ashrāf, well beyond the publication of Fuġhān-e Dehlī.
