In the moral and legal vacuum of international relations, the transformative impact of international and supranational organisations has been slowly and surely creeping up on scholars of politics and law. These institutions and regimes generate challenges to mainstream methods of understanding the way international politics operates and provoke new ways of thinking, not only in political sciences but also in other disciplines professing an emergent global “angle”.
Beyond Networks casts itself as a book that addresses the interaction between European and global “administrative legal” frameworks. However, this rather mundane expression of the text’s objective hides a far more ambitious agenda. Gianluca Sgueo attempts to unravel the connections between legal orders at the national, European and global levels, whilst showing that the central protagonists are no longer solely state actors, but also diverse networks of civil society organisations. The subtitle of the book “Interlocutory Coalitions, the European and Global Orders”, goes some way to describing his approach. The text is firmly rooted in legal analysis, but leans towards a broad understanding of the political environment in which legal decisions are made.
Situating itself within the context of scholarly debate on the contested and vague term “globalisation”, the book recognises that after several decades of discussion and debate, the field is now approaching a “confluence” of sorts. Sgueo continues this debate with a text that is both timely and insightful. Despite recent “populist” assertions to the contrary, these institutions, and other aspects of globalisation are still very much a driving feature of contemporary political affairs, although there seem to be elements of fragmentation and incompatibility throughout. Despite these challenges, global and European institutions grow their own supporting “logics” and instruments. Jurisprudence and legal analysis support the development of so-called “administrative spaces” that influence policymaking at all levels: global, European and national.
The main discussion in this book relates to the role of an emergent civil society at the global level. This is dealt with from a legal perspective rather than from its traditional “support base” in sociological studies or political science, and hence brings a slightly different set of questions to the fore: instead of focusing on how these civil society organisations work, or what influences they have on policymaking, the book focuses on coming to terms with a better understanding of the framework in which they are able to operate, or understanding the legal practices that enable or hinder “impact” of civil society in a transnational sphere. The work is firmly planted in the emergent tradition of Global Administrative Law (GAL), a field that has recently manifested itself as a space for scholarly work that encompasses the space between national and global regulatory practices. GAL attempts to untwine the “complex network of cooperative measures” established by policy objects and subjects transgressing bordersFootnote 1 .
The book elaborates on its guiding principles in the first chapter, identifying the scope for investigation in subsequent chapters. It takes some time to get to the key pillar of the text, focusing on Global Civil Society (GCS), and what the author refers to as the “Global Associational Revolution”, but this provides the beating heart of the text’s narrative. Here, Sgueo shows the power and importance of GCS movements. Citing figures from a project managed by the Johns Hopkins University, the author shows that “Volunteerland” (a fictional country where all the world’s volunteers lived) would be the second most populous country in the world (in terms of adults), and the seventh largest workforce in the world.
This book is not the first to look at the power of global civil society movements, and will certainly not be the last. However it deals with the emergent space in which they operate in an innovative way, drawing upon a range of literature and examples to show the importance of this different dimension to understanding how interests are represented beyond borders. Sgueo’s work specifically analyses the role of the networks that bind the various actors together to try to explain how various legal orders are interacting. By their very nature, GCS play a crucial role in fomenting political transformation, and the book makes it very clear that they have a role to play. The book also recognises that Civil Society at the global level is not without its conceptual and practical challenges. The author outlines two of the major issues relating to the way in which global civil society influences globalised decision making processes. First, accountability is raised as an issue, where the ambiguity of the roles played by GCS are highlighted; as Sgueo notes, “NGOs and other non-state actors claim to have the right to speak for people that have not been consulted in any meaningful way” (pp. 34–35). Second, issues of efficiency are brought to the fore. The text reveals that although there is an increasing tendency to move towards engaging “democratically” at the global level, there are still challenges of both a practical and conceptual nature that need to be addressed before we fully appreciate the role that GCS, or indeed transnational civil society, can play in responding to globalisation.
Sgueo deals with some of these challenges in the main part of his text. Chapter 2 focuses on the emergence of civil society networks, developing a clear understanding of a range of different factors that have influenced the emergence of these networks. These range from technological means and a globalised media, to mass mobility, global education and knowledge. It is in this chapter that the concept of “interlocutory coalitions” (IC) is outlined, before being dealt with in much greater detail in the subsequent two chapters. The author describes these interlocutory coalitions as being situated between pluralist and globalist conceptualisations of civil society movements. In other words, interlocutory coalitions are, on the one hand, composed of a multitude of various actors, and, on the other hand, they assist in developing norms at the global level. Combined, this allows the author to develop the argument that GCS plays a “confluential” and active role in the politics of international organisations.
The author goes to great lengths to deepen the definition of IC, thereby ensuring that it can be a useful concept for continuing debates on the impact of GCS on international organisations. We are furnished with examples from environmental NGOs and NGOs working for transparency in lobbying. These roles are played out in three main ways. First, the ICs internally mediate amongst all parties that are part of their network. They then use the resulting agreements to externally mediate, ensuring that the agenda-setting role of the IC is visible and active. Finally, where possible, ICs also participate in rule-making through standards development. Bringing this together in the final two chapters, Sgueo asserts that ICs can and do participate in developing convergence across administrative spaces, thereby reducing fragmentation in a globalised world.
The author rounds off his work with a final assessment of the impact of ICs on supranational democratic governance practices. He states that “it may be argued that the ICs offer the exact kind of infrastructure needed to develop more democratic governance at the global level” (p. 182).
Whilst generally an interesting and intriguing read, the text suffered from being too dense in places, making it difficult to digest the author’s key points. The text also felt at some points that it was digressing from the main line of argumentation in each chapter. It was also, at times, challenging to dissect the layers of analysis from each other: the three main points in a sub-chapter were sometimes hidden in a sea of other interesting and yet less important points in the chapter’s argumentation. However, the prize underneath this relatively superficial opacity is a sparkling read, and one that would enlighten most observers of international relations.
The book presents a convincing argument as to why we need to continue to dig deeper into the roles taken by private interests in decision making that takes place beyond the state. It shows that this activity is present and constantly evolving in reaction to the growth of global institutions. The author succinctly shows the interaction between the European and Global Administrative Spaces, and thus achieved what he set out to do with this text. As such, the text is a fascinating read for the non-legal expert who is interested in understanding how legal spaces help define political action. It is a “call to arms” for scholars wishing to understand the importance of the role of Global Civil Society in participating in the constant and yet wavering movement towards a more globalised world.
