This book presents a fresh and timely assessment of the exploding growth of corporate social responsibility (CSR) in Latin America, documenting progress in five countries: Brazil, Argentina, Chile, Colombia and Mexico. Little is known about the extent of CSR in Latin America; some observers consider it the least covered of the developing-country regions and/or a region for which widely cited studies underestimate the practise of CSR, relying on websites and company annual reports.
Lester Salomon, a world authority on third-sector (non-profit) organisations, has long worked with leading academic institutions and civil society organisations (CSOs) across Latin America. His book draws on in-depth studies prepared at the behest of the US government-sponsored Inter-American Foundation (IAF), which allowed him to develop the work as he saw fit. Profusely illustrated on-site reports include interviews with CSR leaders and CSO managers, as well as case studies. The IAF sought to obtain the overall outcomes of its projects to promote corporate social engagement (CSE) with grassroots non-profit organisations. CSE is defined more narrowly than CSR, a concept that spans abiding by the law, treating employees and business partners fairly, avoiding or minimising damage to stakeholders and assuming responsibility for promoting the welfare of society.
Discarding the view that CSR in Latin America is concentrated in a few countries and is heavily influenced by multinational companies, international NGOs and multilateral institutions, Salomon deems CSR growth to be a repackaging of long-standing traditions, a view consistent with that of other observers. As Vives et al. discovered in their study of 1,300 small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in eight countries of the region, religious beliefs are a major motivator of CSR, and many companies forgo some profits to help the less fortunate (Responsabilidad social de la empresa en las PYMES de Latinoamérica (Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank, 2005)). As evidence of CSE growth, Salomon notes that IPEA, a prestigious economic research agency in Brazil, found social activity outlays by large companies (500 or more employees) represented 0.4 per cent of GDP – four times the 0.1 per cent of GDP that US companies contributed as of 2005. Moreover, the percentage of firms (large companies and privately owned SMEs) addressing community needs rose from 59 to 69 per cent in only four years.
Salomon grants that systematic data are not available for other countries, where CSE growth is tracked using various sources such as the numerous institutions that sponsor CSE projects. The book notes that jointly sponsored undertakings don't mean focused collaboration, and that many companies spend more on publicising social outlays than implementing them. Progress is uneven across countries, and may not be permanent; SMEs are considered only indirectly. Nonetheless, the author shows that the paternalist and ‘assistentialist’ philanthropy typical of the past has given way to business approaches to social issues, supported by such innovative measures as a self-imposed tax on corporate payrolls employed in Brazil, Colombia and Mexico.
Both demand- and supply-side factors explain Latin America's CSR upsurge. The former span neoliberal policies adopted in the 1990s that harnessed government spending, placed a greater burden on business to foster social progress and changed the terms of public debate by putting elites on the defensive: decentralisation of the state, growth of CSOs, and new business players resulting from globalisation. Supply-side factors include diffusion agents that helped shape business responses to social ills, and company policies that replaced well-intentioned family members with professional managers. The upshot is an emerging cult that sees business as the leading agent for social change: a sense of collective business responsibility for solving societal problems, or new social contract, being implemented by novel institutional structures adapted to perceived local needs. Salomon distinguishes between real CSE and public relations ploys by citing the ‘MBA approach’, featuring three effectiveness indicators: proliferation (among firms, plus recognition by key stakeholders), professionalisation (institutionalised, strategic focus) and profitability (contributing to broader company strategy). However, he considers that the Latin American context requires three additional CSE indicators to increase payoff and avoid the kind of inside-out, top-down limitations of imposing corporate priorities, let alone arousing public distrust: participation (the active engagement and empowering of communities in identifying CSE objectives and designing initiatives), partnering (the degree of seriousness in overcoming problems being addressed, including cross-sector alliances to root CSE more deeply in local realities) and penetration (whether CSE impacts a firm's core business, with regard to factors such as hiring practices, production and suppliers). Such indicators appear to parallel issues faced by Latin American firms that seek to develop inclusive business ventures.
In sum, this book sheds considerable light on CSR in Latin America and helps overcome a northern bias that dominates the global debate. CSR critics such as Prieto-Carrón et al., writing in the journal International Affairs, consider that ‘the debate should be globalized by incorporating southern perspectives … that reflect experiences “on the ground” in developing countries’ (82: 5 (2006), p. 977). Salomon has uncovered a good many of these.
