Two-year-old Florence stands unsteadily at the drum and reaches out, excitedly beating irregular rhythms with her hands. As her enthusiasm mounts she loses balance, tips back and lightly knocks her elbow on the rim of the drum. Shrieks of fear and distress burst out of her and she is quickly scooped up by her mother and cuddled but is not consoled. Her crying increases and she seems lost in a world of her own. I change my lively singing and piano playing to a slower 6/8 rhythm, modulate the harmonies to a simple tonic-sub-dominant alternating pattern and sing Florence's name. Florence's mother responds by rocking her in time with the music and Florence's panic starts to subside. She appears to become more aware of her mother, lets herself take in her embrace and comfort, and is quickly restored. As she turns back to me I resume the lively drumming music; Florence smiles, gets down from her mother's lap and takes her place once again at the bass drum.
This incident from a recent group music therapy session came to mind as I read this book. It reminded me again of how effective music can be to support and facilitate the development of a healthy bond between a parent and their child. Florence and her mother have the potential for a close and loving relationship, but often Florence's learning and physical disabilities mean that it is difficult for this to be experienced by both of them. The musical support offered to this couple enabled Florence and her mother to engage with each other, so that Florence could be consoled.
Music Therapy and Parent–Infant Bonding considers how music therapy can assist in the development of healthy bonds between an infant and its parent or primary carer. The importance of a child's start in life, and the types of early relationships or attachments it makes are being increasingly recognised as having a major effect on their psychological and emotional stability, and on their later capacity to learn, work and interact with others. Government programmes such as Sure Start Children's Centres in the UK are responding to this by identifying vulnerable children and parents and providing support and treatment for them together. However, it is often necessary to continue to nurture and repair this early relationship as the baby grows; this is reflected in the range of work presented in this book, from newborns to older children, and to work with mothers who have been abused as children themselves.
In her opening chapter, Edwards gives a comprehensive overview of research into this area of music therapy and makes a compelling case for how music therapists can assist with the development of parental bonds and relationships where this has not occurred naturally, has been prevented or disrupted. The succeeding 12 chapters fall into three main areas, the first exploring music therapy in early infant work, the second presenting a range of group work, and finally three short chapters focusing on work within hospital settings. Authors come from the English-speaking world, mainly Australia, the UK and Ireland, with one chapter from the USA. This range of nationalities provides a corresponding range of music therapy approaches as the profession has developed in both similar and distinctive directions in different countries.
A wide range of clinical work is described. There are fascinating accounts of music therapy being used to help with traumatised children and their adoptive parents (Hughes), of the sensitivity needed in using music to help strengthen the bond between depressed mothers and their babies (Levinge), and of music being used to assist parents who, for reasons of their own vulnerability, whether traumatised through abuse, refugee experiences, deprivation or social isolation, have lost the capacity to connect sufficiently with their infant or child. Burrell describes how parenting skills can be learnt through musical interactions, for example in how to time a response, whilst the parents’ perspective is given in Oldfield's chapter through inclusion of their own voices. A different approach is described in the medical settings, where the huge care and attention to detail taken in every musical interaction with a premature or sick infant is highly impressive.
A major strength of the book is the inclusion of short clinical vignettes in all of the chapters which bring the work to life. The music therapy methods described are varied and reflect both cultural models of music therapy and the need to respond to a range of circumstances with different approaches. They include improvisation, interactive musical play, song-writing and infant-directed singing to name a few.
Perhaps of particular interest to readers of this journal are the chapters which describe work in schools. Whilst all three of these refer to work undertaken in Ireland, they will have relevance to many settings. Kell and Ledger both describe school-based work with families who have been identified as vulnerable, in areas of high economic and social deprivation and exclusion. It can frequently be very difficult for these children to have a successful experience of schooling, a pattern which repeats through the generations; therefore early input is seen as crucial. In the projects described, parents attend the school to join their child for a series of groups in which a programme of musical activities are undertaken to help support and develop the parent–child relationship, and to help the parent get to know their child better. The early years’ groups aim to give the child the best possible start at school whilst Ledger, working with slightly older children up to the age of six, addresses relationships within hard-to-reach families. Both accounts include evaluations of the programmes which demonstrate many beneficial results, not least of which is the effect of the programmes on the parents’ relationships with the school itself. For those whose own experience of schooling was negative, the programme enabled them to view it more favourably, and to be more confident and comfortable within the school. This has obvious implications for enabling parents to work together with the school for the benefit of their child. Ledger also looks at some of the practical difficulties of running therapy groups in schools. She highlights issues involved in working together with teachers and the changes in role and approach which need to be carefully considered and prepared for before undertaking this work.
This book can be dipped into – each chapter stands alone, and where this leads to a little repetition of theory, the different ways in which it is used and applied mean it is never without interest. Whilst describing skilled music therapy interventions, some of the many musical ideas presented could be adapted for different purposes and settings. As someone who became a musician first, then a music therapist and finally a mother, it resonated for me on all three counts. I found it hugely inspiring and enjoyable and recommend it to anyone who is interested in the effects of music on children and on relationships.
