The American Negro Theatre and the Long Civil Rights Era is an insightful, concise, and significant addition to the study of not just African American theatre and performance but US American culture overall. The greatest strength of this text, which Shandell describes as the first sustained critical investigation of the American Negro Theatre (ANT), lies in the breadth and depth of his analysis of ANT's lasting legacy. The group left an indelible mark on US theatre and pop culture by giving us figures such as Alice Childress, Abram Hill, Owen Dodson, Harry Belafonte, Ruby Dee, and Sidney Poitier, to name only a few. Integration, racism, colorism, and race relations were common themes in ANT's repertoire, and they often found themselves walking a tightrope between black empowerment and the legalized white supremacy of the Jim Crow era. ANT embodied the W. E. B. Du Bois–Alain Locke debate on the purpose of theatre, fostering an inherent tension within the group over highlighting black voices versus white establishment theatre. The Du Boisian notion of a Krigwa theatre—for us, by us, near us, about us—served as fallow ground out of which tensions grew between the articulated positioning of African American perspectives and the group's actual engagement with texts of Western European playwrights. Shandell effectively and efficiently details the historiographical chasm in the literature as it pertains to ANT by contextualizing it as within the shadow of the Federal Theatre Project and paints a rich picture of a vital time in US American cultural history.
Shandell divides the book into an Introduction and seven chapters, which follow a Foreword by James V. Hatch and Carlye Eckert. Chapters 1 and 2 detail a history of Harlem theatre and the dedicated struggle to Krigwa-centric offerings. Chapter 1 chronicles ANT's founding in relation to the New York City theatre scene and the development of the group's artistic voice. Chapter 2 is a who's who of black dramatists and plays and delves into the productions of On Strivers Row (1940, 1946), Natural Man (1941), and Garden of Time (1945), which remain the group's strongest and clearest commitments to “experimental works by African American playwrights” (35).
Chapter 3 focuses on the troubled legacy of Anna Lucasta (1944), which Loften Mitchell describes as “‘one of the great tragedies of the ANT and the American theatre itself’” (40). This was ANT's most successful production, yet a major contributor to the group's demise (71). Chapters 4, 5, and 6 discuss three individuals associated with the group: Frederick O'Neal, Alice Childress, and Sidney Poitier. Founding member O'Neal was a moderate voice in relation to the aesthetic and political divides within the group, whereas Childress is credited as the first African American woman with a professionally produced play in New York City. An ANT actor who developed into a key literary voice of the twentieth century, she wrote her first play, Florence, in response to Poitier's challenge that the only interesting interracial story that happens onstage is lynching (115). Chapter 6 specifically details Poitier's involvement with ANT, even as it also notes that his life, work, and influence cannot be contained to one single chapter (133). Poitier's “ebony saint” (135) and the “‘Poitier effect’” (135) of nonthreatening black character are analyzed over the oeuvre of his film work, and Shandell considers how they led to his controversial involvement with the film Porgy and Bess (1959) and ultimately his 1961 performance as Walter Lee Younger in Raisin in the Sun.
Shandell begins Chapter 7 with Poitier's Western film Buck and the Preacher (1972) before tracing ANT's legacy into The Cosby Show and the Classical Theatre of Harlem. The film was a stark contrast to the Blaxploitation films of the time, and its antiracist commentary not only rescued Poitier from white Hollywood's stagnant positioning of him but also impacted perceptions of blackness in performance that “transformed the spirit of the American Negro Theatre for a new era” (162). Shandell explains how ANT's legacy is directly linked to The Cosby Show, as ANT actors Earle Hyman and Clarice Taylor portrayed Cliff Huxtable's parents. Additionally, criticism of Cosby that labeled it “racial imitation” (166) and of Leave It to Beaver in blackface noticeably echoed ANT's conflict between commercial success and the perceived lack of vibrant African American voices.
Shandell's text ends with a brief discussion of the Classical Theatre of Harlem (CTH) and how ANT's legacy can be seen and felt in both their repertoire and the surrounding questions of CTH's connection to the community. Shandell describes attempts to continue within Du Bois's Krigwa blueprint but details CTH's early struggle over questions of authenticity and communal belonging. Like others before him, Shandell poses the question of whether CTH's continued production of works written largely by dead white men, and filtered through an abstract postmodern lens, can be received as “about us” (171). CTH's intersections with ANT's history include not only questions about their play selections but also their leadership (two white men started the group in 1999) and production history. As was the case with ANT's Anna Lucasta, CTH's Broadway success of The Blacks: A Clown Show (2003) prompted many concerns regarding the group's mission and identity, culminating in 2009 with leadership and organizational changes. The chapter ends describing the many ways in which the Classical Theatre of Harlem continues to redefine itself and its connection to the community.
Overall, The American Negro Theatre and the Long Civil Rights Era is a highly recommended, accessible text for researchers, faculty, and students, as it widely surveys an influential, yet overlooked, era of US American theatre history. This great strength, however, may also be its one shortcoming. Because it offers such an influx of information and presents so many areas for further research, a reader might easily miss the forest for the trees in an attempt to follow the many trails of bread crumbs. Ultimately, though, Shandell authoritatively analyzes the past, considers its implications for the present, and gestures toward possible futures—futures structured around representations with which people self-identify and futures freed from the jurisdiction of an oppressive, myopic trajectory. The American Negro Theatre's short-lived but incredibly rich history deserves further scrutiny, and this book proves we have only begun to scratch the surface.
