The historical importance of the 12 symphonic poems that Franz Liszt composed as Kapellmeister in extraordinary service to the Weimar court (1848–1861) is indisputable. They marked a new degree of sophistication in orchestral programme music's ongoing development. Their explicit connections with salient themes of European literature and art, coupled with attendant formal innovations, provoked vitriolic responses from advocates of absolute music. They also directly motivated composers of diverse nationalities to contribute to the genre, including Saint-Saëns, Smetana and Borodin.
Nevertheless, they are surprisingly underserved in scholarly discourse. Indeed, the lone English-language book on the subject with any pretensions to comprehensiveness was until now Keith T. Johns’ The Symphonic Poems of Franz Liszt, graciously edited by Michael Saffle and posthumously published over 20 years ago.Footnote 1 Several German monographs on the subject, some billed as concert guides, date from Liszt's day through the 1930s. Articles in periodicals or edited collections are more numerous, but in general they either cursorily survey the symphonic poems or examine a single work in the series.
Not only are existing studies of the symphonic poems scarce, but they also often adopt restricted perspectives. Whereas Johns’ investigations of each score dwell on contemporary reviews and straightforward identifications of musical topics, other analyses of individual pieces typically emphasize Beethoven's influence or seek to relate Liszt's distinctive musical structures to normative sonata forms. Such preoccupations frequently yield disagreements over the locations of structural boundaries and overlook insights that Liszt's programmes offer into the relationship between a work's expressive gestures and its unique unfolding.
By contrast, Joanne Cormac provocatively contends and persuasively demonstrates that Liszt's symphonic poems are most fruitfully understood as products of their original contexts at the Weimar court, where they crucially involved theatrical performances or the inspiration of Liszt's theatrical experiences. To support her contention, Cormac closely integrates a dizzying array of ancillary subjects and methodologies: theatre history, contemporary reception, Hegelian philosophy, archival excavation, manuscript studies, performance practice, sonata theory, topical analysis, principles of the visual arts and more. The result is that Liszt and the Symphonic Poem is not merely a welcome addition to a sparse secondary literature, but instead offers cohesive, intriguing views of Liszt as a man of the theatre, of his symphonic poems as works of astonishing ambition and breadth and of his pivotal position as an innovator in the tradition of nineteenth-century orchestral music.
Critical to Cormac's argument is that Liszt's immersive theatrical activities not only influenced his symphonic poems, but also represented significant contributions to German theatrical history. As Cormac's introduction and opening chapter nonetheless remind us, Liszt initially was ambivalent about assuming full-time duties as a Kapellmeister in the provincial court city of Weimar after he withdrew from the concert stage in 1847. He instead likely hoped to establish himself permanently in a cosmopolitan European capital, though opportunities in Paris, Berlin and Vienna eluded his grasp. Upon settling in Weimar, however, he industriously embarked on a nationalistic agenda to restore the city to its former glory during the eighteenth century, when Goethe, Schiller and other illustrious figures of the German Enlightenment had enjoyed the local aristocracy's patronage.
To document the means whereby Liszt attempted to realize his ambitions, Cormac consults chronicles of Weimar's rich cultural life and unearths new archival evidence. Liszt cultivated cordial relations with reigning aristocrats, negotiated the theatre's internal politics, conducted opera four months every year, presented pioneering concert programmes for special occasions and improved performance standards by adopting productive rehearsal schedules and by engaging Europe's leading instrumentalists, singers and actors. Liszt's rarely acknowledged achievements in these areas, Cormac reveals, match those of Weber, Mendelssohn and Wagner (pp. 38–48, 56–68). Liszt's efforts to remain faithful to a composer's intentions, an emerging trend at mid-century, are similarly overlooked, even though he reformed court practices by conducting operas without cuts, by presenting entire symphonies rather than their extracted movements and by insisting that overtures and entr'actes anticipate the mood of ensuing stage action (pp. 48–56). Such fidelity refutes mistaken but seemingly intractable perceptions of Liszt as a brilliant pianist who capriciously altered other composers’ works to indulge in superfluous virtuosity. All these factors, Cormac asserts, profoundly influenced his compositions.
Broad affinities between the symphonic poem as a genre and the theatre are nonetheless well recognized. In as widely consulted a source as The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, for example, Hugh Macdonald observes that the genre is ‘related to opera and sung music in its aesthetic outlook’.Footnote 2 Many Lisztians likewise remember that several of Liszt's symphonic poems originated as overtures to theatrical works. Cormac, however, is the first to examine this musico-dramatic relationship extensively and to show how it partners instrumental music with multiple theatrical genres – spoken play, melodrama and pantomime – and not just opera.
To frame various modalities of linkage between these theatrical genres and Liszt's music, Cormac invokes the aesthetics of Hegel, who derived three types of poetry from ancient Greek models: the epic, the lyric and the dramatic (pp. 16–19). The epic is objective, describing the external environment and reflecting a nation or an age in its action; epic heroes are consequently not individualized, and their personal thoughts and tribulations do not disrupt the tranquillity of the typically narrated discourse. The lyric is subjective and limited to an individual's inner world; its absorption in ‘immediate emotional experience’ engenders ‘sudden, violent transitions’ and ‘excessive contrasts’. The dramatic combines universal objectivity with individual subjectivity; its actions must be directly presented to the senses, as opposed to the epic's description and narration, and these actions must involve an individual's conflict with the external world and its resolution. Along these theatrical and Hegelian axes, Cormac situates five symphonic poems (Chapters Two through Six) and evaluates the Weimar period's legacies (Chapter 7).
Early during his Weimar tenure, Liszt began writing orchestral scores that he later published as symphonic poems. He initially aligned these programmatic works with Hegelian lyric poetry, as Cormac deduces from revisiting Liszt's essay, ‘Berlioz and his “Harold” Symphony’,Footnote 3 and other writings published in German periodicals:
Liszt identified the reproduction of the passions, feelings, and inner workings of the human soul as central to music … so it is logical that he found that programme music was most aptly united with lyric poetry. … The first symphonic poems Liszt composed were closely related to modern lyric poetry; the series bore no relation to dramatic forms (p. 20).
However, Liszt's aesthetics changed radically as he revised his early orchestral scores and wrote new ones, in response to his simultaneous engagement with theatrical activities and his composition of an opera (Sardanapale), a crucial test for any composer entertaining cosmopolitan ambitions.
Cormac's analysis of Tasso precisely illustrates how Liszt's lyric conception evolved toward a dramatic realization and is thus worth detailed consideration. The orchestral score's antecedent was the first of several piano pieces that constitute Venezia e Napoli (1838–1840), an appendix to the second book of Liszt's Années de pèlerinage. Sifting through Liszt's letters, Cormac unravels the piece's tangled associations with Byron's The Lament of Tasso and Childe Harold's Pilgrimage, both of which epitomize Hegelian lyric poetry by contemplating the ‘immediate emotional experience’ of two individuals, the much persecuted sixteenth-century poet Torquato Tasso and the fictional Harold, a social outcast.
Liszt preserved this lyric connection when he used the piano piece as the basis of an overture that he composed and conducted for a revival of Goethe's play, Torquato Tasso, in August 1849. Indeed, Cormac's transcription of a draft of the overture (pp. 87–95) discloses that Liszt simply orchestrated extracts from the piano piece and incorporated them into the full score. However, the piano piece's form – a monothematic, variation-based fantasy – scarcely reconciled with contemporary precepts governing theatrical overtures. Liszt consequently began to infuse his lyric conception with elements derived largely from Beethoven's theatrical overtures, especially the second Leonore Overture. A tonally unstable slow introduction nonetheless maintains an individualized lyric orientation, wavering between the bleakness and agitation that Tasso experiences in Byron's Lament. Other new passages initiate a dialogue with sonata form: an exposition links a lugubrious, C-minor version of the Venezia melody and its majestic, brassy, E-major transformation with one of many modulatory transitions; a central trionfo episode emulates a development section by modulating frequently; a partial recapitulation transposes the majestically brassy theme to C major; and a bipartite coda consisting of a religioso apotheosis and rapid-fire, non-thematic closing material fulfils nineteenth-century expectations for a theatrical overture, though they reflected neither Byron nor Goethe, but rather Liszt's notion of the long-suffering Tasso, redeemed by lasting admiration after his death.
Finally, when Liszt decided to include Tasso in his series of symphonic poems, he still referred to lyric poetry's inward, personal emotions in his programmatic preface, but he also expanded the score with another ‘dramatic’ episode that has ‘direct parallels in Goethe's play’ (p. 111). According to Liszt's preface, a minuet depicts Tasso as he ‘glides among the fêtes of Ferrara – the birthplace of his masterpieces’. Now appropriately titled Tasso: Lamento e Trionfo, the symphonic poem exhibits greater formal flexibility. Liszt, having observed in an essay on Beethoven's Fidelio that the four Leonore overtures ‘demonstrated the “crippling” of the master's thoughts due to formal constraints’ (p. 109), excised the programmatically redundant recapitulation entirely and lengthened several transitions and the coda. These formal traits and ‘direct parallels’ to literary episodes, Cormac explains, recur throughout the series of symphonic poems and thus, for Liszt, represented defining traits of the genre. Their symbiotic evolution also furnishes a vantage point for evaluating discrepant formal analyses that have plagued the symphonic poems’ reception since their publication.
As Cormac develops equally nuanced contexts for four additional symphonic poems, other considerations supplant Liszt's compositional process in her novel arguments. Prometheus, for example, requires a different critical framework because it occupies a different point on the Hegelian spectrum and incorporates dramatic musical gestures differently. Like Tasso, Prometheus originally functioned as an overture to a theatrical work during a festival that commemorated a Weimar luminary, in this case, Johann Gottfried Herder's Der entfesselte Prometheus (Prometheus Unbound), produced in August 1850. Herder's ‘thirteen mythological scenes’ intersperse the title character's monologues, which largely narrate past actions and anticipate their fulfilment, with the visitations of choruses who lament his imprisonment, thank him for bestowing gifts on humankind, predict his redemption through divine justice and praise him. Cormac accordingly shows that Liszt aligned Herder's scenes with the Hegelian epic because of their narrative traits, their hero's impersonalized treatment and their relation to Weimar's nationalistic renewal (pp. 132–5). But to compensate for a static text and its staging as a series of nearly motionless tableaux vivants, Cormac posits, Liszt devised dramatic, or, more accurately, melodramatic music as a ‘substitute’ for stage action and visual display (p. 146).
Prometheus achieves this end by quoting choruses and incidental music that Liszt composed for Herder's scenes and by presenting ‘features that are only described in the narration’ (p. 181). Musical events accordingly enact the trajectory of Herder's scenes, just as a melodrama's music reacts to a spoken text. For Cormac, the introduction recalls the audacity of Prometheus’ defiance of Zeus and the brutality of the landscape where he is imprisoned; the ensuing sonata exposition's primary and secondary themes respectively consist of ‘agitated scenic music’ (p. 181) and a redemptive hymn (quoting the Chorus of Invisibles); and the development elaborates on humanity's praise for Prometheus (quoting the Chorus of Muses). Thus, aside from recurrent recitative-like passages that introduce new themes, Prometheus embodies one of the more straightforward sonata forms in Liszt's series. Cormac, however, detects significant departures from symphonic conventions (pp. 171–83). Melodrama accounts not only for the score's assembled thematic trajectory, but also for the primary theme's tonal instability, motivic fragmentation and ostinato-like accompaniment. The development likewise eschews symphonic convention by altogether avoiding the exposition's materials in favour of subjecting a new theme to fugal treatment. Tense engagements with sonata form resurface in other symphonic poems.
Orpheus originally replaced Gluck's disconcertingly festive overture during the court's revival of Gluck's Orphée et Eurydice in February 1854. Although Cormac omits Hegel's name from her discussion, she unmistakably considers Orpheus dramatic, yet it differs from Prometheus because it is operatic, not melodramatic. Its two main themes do not relate to characters, narratives or scenic designs, but instead embody singing voices through contrasts of lyricism and declamation, song-like accompaniments, individualistic orchestration and the rejection of symphonic motivic techniques. Cormac associates these voices with ‘friezes’ that Liszt's preface identifies as depictions of vocal utterances: Orphée enchanting the wild beasts (not part of Gluck's scenario) and Orphée weeping for Eurydice, respectively abstracted, with reference to Felix Draeseke's critique, as ‘the civilising beauty of song and the grief caused by lost love’ (p. 198). Sequential thematic construction and the lack of a proper development section, Cormac maintains, likewise indicate that Orpheus is conceived more vocally than symphonically. Analysts may nonetheless quibble that sequential themes commonly occur in diverse types of nineteenth-century orchestral music, operatic overtures often lack development sections and this deficit scarcely stifles Orpheus’ conversation with sonata principles. More persuasive is Cormac's discovery of motivic resemblances between Liszt's themes and melodies in the first scene of Gluck's opera, which strengthen agreement between the score's pervasively sombre affect and the mood of Gluck's first scene, where Orphée mourns Eurydice's death. Both melodies also illustrate the ‘noble simplicity’ advocated in the preface to Gluck's Alceste. Thus, Liszt joins Berlioz and Wagner in observing the spirit of Gluck's intentions more faithfully than earlier nineteenth-century Gluck revivalists, who flagrantly added and cut material to suit contemporary tastes.
Cormac's choice of Festklänge is bold because Liszt composed it not for a theatrical performance, but as an overture for a concert in November 1854 that celebrated the anniversary of Grand Duchess Maria Pavlovna's arrival in Weimar (pp. 242–5). Only later, Cormac postulates, did it acquire dubious associations with Liszt's optimism about his forthcoming wedding to Princess Carolyne Sayn-Wittgenstein, perhaps in 1860, when he appended to the score several ‘variants’ that allude to the Princess’ Polish heritage, including a polonaise (pp. 237–42). Festklänge therefore evades theatrical contextualization, but it nonetheless utilizes ‘dramatic’ techniques: its lamenting recitatives are ‘overcome’ by martial triumph; its thematic ‘fragmentation’ is melodramatic; and its ‘monumental’ style and related nationalistic signifiers project a narrative of restoring Weimar's Golden Age (pp. 243–52). But unlike much contemporaneous ‘monumental’ music, Festklänge manifests sophisticated formal techniques related to Hegel's process of ‘becoming’, which Beethoven's ‘Tempest’ Sonata famously illustrates.Footnote 4 Motives gradually coalesce into themes; obscure harmonies progress toward clearly defined keys; and formal junctures become discernible only in retrospect. Although such complexities have problematized analysis of its ‘traditional structure’, Cormac observes, ‘of all the symphonic poems, Festklänge is arguably most clearly in open dialogue with sonata form’ (p. 236).
The opposite is true of the subject of Cormac's final inquiry, Hamlet, completed in 1858 as the last of the Weimar symphonic poems. Though designated as a prelude (Vorspiel) to Shakespeare's tragedy, Hamlet was not commissioned as an overture to a stage production. It was instead inspired by Liszt's encounters with Bogumil Dawison, known for a new, intensely expressive acting style that challenged an older, classically reserved tradition sanctioned by Goethe (pp. 286–95). Scenes that critics ‘considered among the most distinctive of Dawison's Hamlet portrayal’ are mimicked by the score's musical gestures, more graphically than in any of Liszt's other symphonic poems. Four such events occur in the introduction alone: the opening sequential phrases duplicate the speech rhythms and inflections of the first line of Hamlet's soliloquy, ‘To be, or not to be’; 12 chords strike midnight; melodramatic tremolos and supernatural trombones mark the ghostly appearance of Hamlet's father; and a long transition equates with Hamlet's indecision (‘Where should I turn?’), as Liszt later confided to August Göllerich. Thereafter, transformed versions of the soliloquy theme alternate with other dramatic episodes, vividly evoking Hamlet's decisiveness (a noted aspect of Dawison's interpretation), ‘a shadow picture suggesting Ophelia’ (as described in Liszt's preface), Hamlet mocking her (‘Get thee to a nunnery’), Hamlet stabbing Polonius and, lastly, a dirge (299–313). This melodramatic mapping of musical events onto the tragedy's text, in conjunction with a tonal scheme that reconciles poorly with sonata-form exigencies, yields an innovative rotational form. These factors fully justify Cormac's unequivocal assertions that it is ‘meaningless’ and ‘mistaken’ to place Hamlet within a post-Beethovenian symphonic tradition’ (pp. 286, 313).
After such plentiful and brilliant insights, the final chapter is somewhat anticlimactic. It reviews Liszt's theatrical achievements thoroughly enough, but in comparing the selected symphonic poems to other works by Liszt, it too often reads like an index of musical topics and their exemplars. Perhaps more illuminating would have been a short appraisal of whether Liszt's dramatic techniques, not the topics, inform his non-theatrical symphonic poems or works in other genres (subjects sometimes addressed in previous chapters) or other composers’ programmatic pieces. The final section, ‘What is a symphonic poem?’ might have interrogated Carl Dahlhaus’ notion that Liszt's scores sought to reconcile the symphonic tradition's thematic-motivic legacy with the romantic era's new topical content.Footnote 5 They achieved a great deal more, as Cormac's study decisively shows.
Cambridge generously included 70 music examples (and seven more online), nine figures, 11 tables, nearly 800 footnotes, an appendix and an 18-page bibliography. The index, however, should have been expanded, and the final copy-editing left behind enough minor errors to draw attention. (‘Symbol crashes’ is wonderfully evocative, for example, but ‘cymbal’ was plainly intended [p. 250].) These last two issues doubtless involve the economics of academic publishing and related increases in authorial responsibilities. Fortunately, they scarcely detract from Cormac's path-breaking ideas.
