No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
This comprehensive study presents an overview of the Ottoman Empire—or, rather, its ruling class—from its emergence in late medieval times through its maturation in early modern times. Lucidly written, Colin Imber's book lays out this large subject for a non-specialist audience. It is important at the outset, however, to be aware of what the book does and does not do. Imber himself states in the Introduction that his approach to the subject is “narrow.” To wit, the book examines the institutions and practices of Ottoman government—“the structure of power” of the title—through the empire's formative centuries and into the stressful first half of the 17th century. It does not concern itself, except peripherally, with society, religion, or culture—in other words, with the subject population's own experiences and responses to the power exercised on it. What this study does, it does extremely well, by virtue of the author's wide reading in both the primary sources and the secondary literature and his own previous contributions to the study of dynastic ideology, law, and the navy, and his reconstruction of a chronology of the early centuries.
Following a long and dense account (“Chronology”) that details the creation of the empire and its first significant losses in the 17th century, Imber takes up a variety of topics in individual chapters. Given the book's focus on power, which Imber regards as residing above all with the sultanate, the first two chapters treat “The Dynasty” (its structure, reproduction, and modes of legitimation) and “Recruitment” (the non-dynastic cadres of the ruling class and the shifting strategies that underlay their composition). Subsequent chapters (“The Palace,” “The Provinces,” “The Law,” “The Army,” “The Fleet”) trace the various venues and institutional structures through which power was enacted, delegated, negotiated, and sometimes stymied. Particularly outstanding is the discussion of decision-making in the chapter titled “The Palace” and its account of the Imperial Council. For this non-military historian, the chapters on “The Army” and “The Fleet” offered new information and perspectives. A brief conclusion is followed by a glossary of terms; a list of primary sources quoted; a select bibliography by chapter of secondary works in English, French, and German; and an ample index.
All the chapters delineate change over time, though Imber pays more attention to the 15th and 16th centuries and rather less to the transformations of the 17th. Each chapter stands alone, happily making it possible to read in random order (or to assign select chapters in undergraduate courses). Apart from the rather daunting (though valuable) “Chronology” chapter, the book is eminently readable—indeed, enjoyably so. This is in no small part because of the wide range of illustrative examples and the many marvelous and telling quotations from contemporary (primary) sources. One of these is an early-17th-century work called The Laws of the Janissaries, from which Imber culls observations such as the ban on recruiting “fresh faced and beardless” lads because they will appear “despicable to the enemy.” Another example is the 15th-century Genoese merchant Iacopo de Promontorio's list of Rumelian provinces—including “Aranti's Albania,” “Scanderbeg's Albania,” “Lazar's Serbia,” and the “Despot's Serbia”—which Imber cites to bolster his point about the remarkable degree to which the Ottoman regime preserved the boundaries (and the memory) of pre–Ottoman rulers. My personal favorites among the chapters are “Recruitment” and “The Law”; my least favorite is “The Provinces,” which bogs down somewhat in a prolonged treatment of the timar (military fief) and suffers from the absence of provincial power brokers and thus of the dynamics of center–periphery “structures of power.”
On its surface, this work is descriptive rather than analytical. Although the book is about structures of power, the author is less interested in relations of power as they are approached in cultural studies than in the anatomy of authority and government. As he does in his study of the 16th-century mufti Ebu Su

ud, Imber for the most part leaves readers to draw their own conclusions. However, knowledgeable readers will readily discern a degree of analytic commentary in Imber's choice of material, incidental remarks, and emphases. An example of the latter is the recurring emphasis on Islam, and in particular its law, which the author regards as the principal formal limitation on sultanic power. Another example is Imber's discussion of the pro-war policies of the late 16th century, which, without trumpeting the point, belies common assumptions about the inattentiveness of Sultans Murad III and Mehmed III. Even the chronology chapter, more a reference document than a narrative overview, has, as a result of its admirable comprehensiveness, the potential to support debate about the nature and evolution of the Ottoman regime.
In Imber's definition, the Ottoman Empire was multinational, neither exclusively Islamic nor exclusively Turkish. It was also dynastic, an empire in which “the only loyalty demanded of all its multifarious inhabitants was allegiance to the sultan.” Power was disseminated through personal ties centering on the figure of the sultan. When, from the end of the 16th century, the empire suffered a long season of military, economic, and social disruptions and sultans could no longer sustain the kind of heroic career exemplified by their forebears, the empire's “capacity to weather crises,” Imber argues, depended on two institutions: the legal system and its courts, which kept the confidence of subjects, and the scribal bureaucracy, which collected taxes and equipped the military, despite rapid turnover at the top. He concludes that it was “the continuity in these mundane functions of government that ensured the Empire's survival.”
As a comprehensive and well-written digest of current knowledge about Ottoman practices of government, Imber's book is a welcome contribution to the field of Ottoman studies, which has until recently suffered from the lack of general treatments that are both accessible and scholarly. One of the particular virtues of the book is the rich illustration from a wide range of primary sources. If it is largely innocent of analytic commentary, this account of the pre-modern Ottoman Empire arms readers with the knowledge to articulate their own conclusions.