Johannes Kepler (1571–1630) is a much-understudied figure in the history of science. Compared to other luminaries like Galileo, Descartes and, in particular, Newton, literature on Kepler is scarce. Aviva Rothman's book, based on her 2012 dissertation with Anthony Grafton, is therefore a more than welcome addition to the existing scholarship on a man whose ideas contributed immensely to our understanding of the cosmos. As the title suggests, Rothman focuses on the concept of harmony and how it permeated all aspects of Kepler's life and writings, by discussing these aspects thematically. Although the subtitle lists only three topics – cosmos, confession and community – these are in fact summary themes covering everything from geometry, to state, to calendar reform.
In The Pursuit of Harmony, Rothman first introduces the reader to Kepler's idiosyncratic ideas about the role and function of geometry, which he considered, in Platonic fashion, to be coeternal with God. Thus geometrical intuitions could be trusted, and operationalized to arrive at a full understanding of the cosmos based on harmonic principles. Second, Rothman introduces the reader to strife and unity – or harmony – within Christianity and society more broadly defined. What was at stake was the role of the mathematician in matters theological, a role deemed of crucial importance by Kepler but denied by his fellow theologians. The topic of Christian harmony was especially dear to the Lutheran Kepler, who, contrary to many of his contemporaries, adopted a reconciliatory stance towards the two other main denominations, the Calvinists and the Roman Catholics, despite seemingly incommensurable differences. One of these was the interpretation and meaning of the Eucharist and Christ's bodily presence in the host, a rather intricate and difficult topic which Rothman explains with delightful lucidity.
Rothman devotes ample attention to Kepler's interaction with Galileo and the rhetorical strategies he proposed for the dissemination of knowledge. According to Kepler, both patrons and the general public had to be convinced of the validity of the Copernican model by the invocation of ancient and modern authorities as supportive of the new cosmology, thus using deception to arrive at the truth. Whether this is indeed a form of Tacitean dissimulation, as Rothman argues, is highly debatable, as dissimulation does not entail deceit, but rather concealment. Instead, as Francis Bacon already argued in his essay on the topic, the strategy suggested by Kepler is more one of simulation, which should only be used ‘in great and rare matters’ (Francis Bacon, Essays, Civil and Moral, vol. 3, part 1, 1909–1914). Obviously the Copernican truth was one of these great and rare matters, and thus warranted such an approach. It is in fact one of the rare instances in which Kepler forcefully promotes a distinct opinion. As Rothman shows, Kepler's overall stance was one of unpartheylickeit, impartiality, not be confused with indifference. Although she goes to great lengths to explain the early modern meaning of the word and its historical significance, the author omits mention of what are the key passages from which this word derives, and by which Kepler is informed, those of Jesus praying for unity among his disciples (John 17:21) and Paul and James arguing against partiality (1 Corinthians 1:10 and passim; James 2:4).
From Rothman's book, it is clear indeed that the topic of harmony, or the search therefor, played a pivotal role in Kepler's many undertakings. These also include his ironical stance towards the new Gregorian calendar, and his recommendations in the use of astrology – Kepler was court astrologer to the Holy Roman Emperor – were one should be careful in giving advice based solely on the study of the heavens. The former, introduced in 1582 by Pope Gregory XIII, was meant to replace the lagging Julian calendar, and was received with much hostility by most Protestants primarily for its papal origins. The Lutheran Kepler, however, embraced the new calendar, though with some emendations, both openly and in his unpublished writings of the early 1600s. Here too the ideal mathematician returned, superseding matters theological and political, the role Kepler stylized for himself.
There are issues with Rothman's thematic approach. By moving back and forth on the timeline of Kepler's life, the temporal connections between his many activities and the thematic connections between these activities at any given time become obscure. Moreover, the reader is hard-pressed to find any help to navigate this timeline, as Rothman omits all but the most summary details about Kepler's life – a simple and short biographical overview would have been useful. At times, Rothman invokes the authority of other scholars without explicit mention in the main text; this works fine with footnotes – not, however, with endnotes. The most striking problem with this book is its conclusions, or rather the absence thereof. Each and every chapter ends with a paragraph labelled ‘conclusions’, yet the author invariably uses these to introduce yet more material, making the volume very difficult to digest. The reader would be greatly helped by simple summaries; instead, one is bombarded with new details, including those found in the final, supposedly concluding, chapter. For all the richness of the materials presented there and in the preceding chapters, its final lines are baffling. Here Rothman draws parallels between our modern world and Kepler's ideal of harmony, claiming that ‘as Kepler himself would argue, we can hold a vision in common without agreeing to the particulars that support it in each case; the pursuit of harmony need not rely even on Kepler's God to sustain it’ (p. 282). I am quite sure Kepler would have vehemently disagreed with this statement, as his God was not just one of the particulars, but at the core of his beliefs.
In summary, The Pursuit of Harmony is a rich book, providing a thorough study of the concept of harmony and the pivotal role it played for Kepler. Her interpretation of Kepler's tactics as ‘dissimulation’ is debatable, yet the debate is very welcome. Although at times a difficult read, Rothman's work is a welcome addition to the existing scholarship on Kepler.
