Susan Goodier begins her study of New York State anti-suffragist women in 1894, when they first organized in order to give the lie to Susan B. Anthony's claim that New York women “do not oppose” the ballot. She follows them all the way through 1927, later than other scholars, who have ended similar studies in 1920. Goodier argues that the New York State “Antis” were “the most dynamic and influential” of all the organized anti-suffragists in the country, notably “more politicized” than their counterparts in other states (9). They also exercised more national influence, she argues. For example, New York women took the lead in forming the National Association Opposed to Woman Suffrage in 1911, an event that took place in a Park Avenue drawing room. Women who actively opposed their own enfranchisement have certainly been studied before. In fact, there is an extensive literature on the anti-suffragists, including five books and a number of articles.Footnote 1 Goodier would have done a service to her readers if she had provided a comprehensive survey of that earlier work and positioned her book more clearly in relationship to it, especially since other scholars have used a state focus, and her work is implicitly and often explicitly comparative. As it is, historiography is relegated to the footnotes, yet only parts of this book make truly original contributions. It is hard to say whether Goodier makes her case for New York State as compared to, say, Massachusetts, but this is a deeply researched and well-written book on a significant subject.
Like previous scholars, Goodier describes anti-suffragist women as wealthy, educated, and socially prominent. They were usually WASPs related to powerful men, and they were active in charitable and other voluntary associations. Goodier suggests that their anti-suffragism expressed a “separate spheres” ideology reminiscent of Catharine Beecher: they favored women's educational advancement, and appointment to public positions, but they feared that the vote would endanger the power and influence that women—at least elite white women like themselves—had already come to exercise. They saw no need for male leaders. Up through 1914 or so, their New York State Association Opposed to Woman Suffrage considered men to be “antagonistic” or at least “unhelpful” to women's anti-suffrage activism (7). Goodier goes so far as to say that both suffragists and anti-suffragists “believed in some form of women's rights” (7). No Votes for Women helps to bring New York anti-suffragist leaders into focus by providing brief biographies that leave a vivid impression of just how well connected, privileged, and assertive these women were. Goodier takes them seriously, assuming they were sincere and conscientious, not just a front for male or corporate interests, and she argues that woman suffragists and anti-suffragists influenced one another, engaging in what she calls a “reluctant reciprocity” (12). Her point seems well taken, since the New York Antis proved unusually adaptable, willing to match the suffragists’ methods and style. They became effective debaters and lobbyists, attuned to public opinion and political action.
By focusing on New York, Goodier is able to devote particular attention to two suffrage referenda that took place in that state in 1915 and 1917, and here she makes an important contribution to scholarship. The anti-suffragists won in 1915, but suffrage forces immediately regrouped to try again two years later. Their 1917 New York referendum victory was a turning point in suffrage history. Suffrage forces had proved a point by winning in a diverse and heavily populated eastern state; the tide was turning. Thereafter they ceased to pursue state referenda, focusing instead on the federal amendment. Historians have generally attributed the suffragists’ 1917 victory to things they did, such as neutralize Tammany Hall, or unite behind Carrie Chapman Catt's leadership, or build coalitions across class and ethnic lines. But Goodier argues that it was also a matter of what anti-suffragists did not do. When the United States entered World War I, she argues, the Antis threw themselves into the Red Cross and other patriotic efforts, and as a result, did less and less about suffrage. In 1917 the Antis held fewer meetings and at the end almost ceased to campaign at all, allowing New York suffragists a walk-over victory. The idea that World War I helped women win the vote thus takes on an ironic spin.
Goodier also describes the evolution of the anti-suffrage movement. Convinced that they had lost the 1917 referendum due to feminist, pacifist, and socialist influences, the New York Antis shifted priorities, became more open to male leadership, and adopted a shrill, red-baiting tone. Other historians (e.g., Jablonsky, Maddux) have noted this change, but Goodier provides more detail. Goodier explains, for example, that after New York women were enfranchised in 1917, the Antis organized themselves into the “Woman Voters Anti-Suffrage Party,” whose members were to register and then use their votes to take revenge on male politicians who had supported giving them the vote. Any member who failed to execute this tactical somersault was condemned as a “moral shirker” (120). As she tells the story of how anti-suffragists worked themselves into a lather, Goodier carefully maintains a calm, objective tone. As she follows anti-suffragists beyond the usual cut-off date of 1920, she observes that the Antis, who had become politically proficient during the anti-suffrage struggle, seem to have accommodated themselves to ordinary party politics more readily than did suffragists. Most became conservative Republicans. Because they had such low expectations, they suffered little disappointment with the post-suffrage political order. Along the way, the Antis had helped to delay woman suffrage, and they ended by founding a tradition of ultraconservative women's politics that would echo down through Phyllis Schlafly to Sarah Palin. Goodier reaffirms and elaborates many of the findings of previous scholars about anti-suffragists, but she also provides an innovative account of the 1917 New York referendum that will command the attention of all scholars who seek to understand the vicissitudes of the women's movement.
