Like the case of many fundamentals in the Islamic belief system, the ethics of Islamic charity were traditionally rooted in the Qurʾan. In Islam's holy scripture a connection is made between belief and charitable deeds, whereby the true Muslim has an obligation for the beggar and the destitute. Hadiths pertaining to early Islam only concretize this concept when relating how the Prophet sent out his men to collect obligatory alms (zakat) by taking from the rich and giving to the poor. The fact that such was embedded in Islam's most sacred texts shaped charity (ṣadaqa) as “a form of worship,” in the words of Yaacov Lev (p. 145) in his industrious attempt to provide a synthesis of the work of charity in the large world of medieval Islam.
This was material worship that could accrue spiritual benefits to the performer, for charity was thought to provide a way of communicating with God or expiating sins; it was a key to salvation and a means to implore God for deliverance at times of personal distress. In Abbasid Baghdad, as in Fatmid Cairo, it became standard practice to distribute charity, clothes, and food to the poor during sickness and upon recovery. Charity was a token of gratitude to heaven for deliverance from the hands of enemies and for surviving life-threatening incidents; when repenting on one's deathbed or following the death of a person, it symbolized acceptance of the fate ordained by God. Lev has diligently collected numerous illustrations, from across the centuries and various Islamic regions, to document such practices in the first two chapters of his book. One should emphasize, however, that as is normally the case with medieval Islamic sources, we get a fair knowledge of the deeds of rulers but are largely in the dark about the charitable activities of the so-called middle class.
As the centuries passed, however, other complex motives, such as cultural values or altruism, were also at work. Thus, placing an emphasis on the education of orphans exemplifies, according to Lev, both the dynamics of social interpretation of the Qurʾan and the values of Islamic society. Charity also enhanced the position of donors in their society and, of most significance, it served as a political tool. Through charity, rulers earned the appreciation and legitimization they initially might have lacked; they could emerge as benevolent rulers, integrate marginal groups into mainstream society, and more.
In the vast regions where believers of the three monotheistic religions coexisted, the performance of charitable deeds among medieval Muslims, Christians, and Jews sprang from related ideologies and assumed similar meanings and forms. However, as Lev points out, there were also differences in the way charity became institutionalized in the two worlds of Islam and Christendom. Of most significance, although the church was the leading agent of charity in medieval Christendom, in the absence of churchlike institutions in Islam, individuals, mostly rulers, were expected to assume the role of benefactors. Men in power came to play central roles in charitable activities, and these were not solely motivated by a commitment to aid the poor and the needy. In other respects, Islam resembled Christianity more than Judaism. One clear difference between the Islamic and Jewish concepts of charity, as well as the impact they had on practical policies, emerges in Mark Cohen's recent study on poverty and charity in the Jewish community of Egypt, which is based on the Geniza materials. Although Islam, like Christianity, admired ascetic poverty, rabbinical Judaism did not.
Perhaps the most fascinating aspect of charity in medieval Islam was its institutionalization through the pious endowment (waqf) system. Lev devotes three of the seven chapters of his book to various aspects of the system, occasionally repeating much that is already known about this well-studied topic and at times providing examples, such as libraries, that are not actually relevant. However, the ground is solidly covered, and as Lev rightly argues, it is impossible to overestimate the impact of pious endowments on Muslim towns for a whole gamut of institutions, from mosques to water installations. A waqf, as long as it was not subject to abuse, stood for perpetual charity that would continue to benefit the donor even after his death.
A deed document of an endowment created in 1324 by the Mamluk sultan al-Nasir Muhammad stands as a typical example of a waqf that related to a wide range of charitable purposes such as the provision of food, water, and clothing, as well as care for pilgrims (p. 143). Other waqfs were set up to maintain Qurʾanic schools for orphans and made a considerable impact at a relatively low price. In the context of widespread poverty, it is clear that schools that offered a daily food ration, two sets of clothes per year, and a standard education made a great difference to those receiving philanthropy. In Mamluk Egypt between 1300 and 1517, at least forty-six such schools were established.
Hospitals are another prominent example of waqf. Some of them are described in their endowment deeds as houses for the sick and helpless poor, who were given meals and heating in the wintertime. There were also charitable ribāts and zāwiyas, built not, as was normally the case, for Sufis but for the aged, especially elderly women and widows. They provided shelter and food. Lev sees the proliferation of waqfs and waqf-supported institutions as giving an impression of a “charitable society” (p. 160), whereby the charitable drive in the form of the sacred duty to give ṣadaqa came to dominate many aspects of communal life. However, the caveat he pertinently makes is that one should not confuse this impression with the notion of a welfare society.
In fact, to what extent the Islamic medieval state was concerned with the welfare of its subjects is a complex question, according to Lev, who pays less attention than one would expect to treatment of charity by contemporary theologians. Take, for example, the view of al-Ghazali that epitomizes the practical marginality of the poor in this context. This prominent scholar is interested in the payer of zakat much more than in the pauper receiving it. However, Lev has convincingly made the point that, in terms of practical policies, the provisions made for the weak were few and far between and that regimes, in many of the endowments, were more committed to the welfare of the religious class than to the paupers. There was little interest in housing the poor; even grain policy, which at times involved distribution of surplus to the poor, was not an important priority. The figure suggested by Adam Sabra in his book on Mamluk charity of about 1,000 poor receiving food from waqfs in Cairo at one time illustrates their marginality in a city where their number must have been dozens of thousands. The overall social impact of charity was limited; zakat did not evolve into any kind of social leveler, its handling by the state was a failure, and there is serious doubt whether it was given to the needy.
In sum, as Lev concludes in his solid and well-researched book, the alleviation of poverty was not the primary objective of charity in Islam, and it was an inadequate tool for dealing with welfare problems.
