Ethnomusicologist Jennifer Kyker describes her multimedia Sekuru’s Stories project as a “born-digital monograph.” In essence a work of tribute, the website and linked digital recordings focus on the life history and musical career of a single Zimbabwean musician: gwenyambira (Sh.: respected mbira player), oral historian, and ritual specialist Tute Chigamba. The voice of Sekuru (Sh.: grandfather; respected elder) Chigamba is foregrounded here in chiShona and English translation, rendering the work an important contribution to the archive of firsthand African accounts of lived history. Sekuru’s Stories is hosted by and was created with the assistance of the University of Rochester’s Digital Scholarship Lab (https://dslab.lib.rochester.edu/). The choice of open access allowed the creator to offer a sizeable repository of information without restrictive paywalls, and thus expand its accessibility beyond academic audiences. One tradeoff, however, is that there is no set peer review process for electronically-published material in general. A digital humanities scholar has reviewed the project positively (Yeku Reference Yeku2019); this reviewer, however, appears to have no expertise in ethnomusicology or mbira music.
Sekuru’s Stories adds to the growing number of life histories in ethnomusicology. In a fortuitous coincidence, its publication preceded by a few months Paul Berliner’s longitudinal exegesis of the career path and practices of recently-deceased gwenyambira Cosmas Magaya (Reference Berliner2020). While Berliner and Magaya’s work refers to a companion website for access to digital audio and video recordings, the work reviewed here appears entirely online in its present form. The electronic medium is an excellent presentational choice for Sekuru’s story, as photographs and clips of music referred to within the narrative provide immediate illustration of the text. In addition to the embedded audio, more complete musical performances abound. The linked Bandcamp digital files featuring Sekuru performing solo on mbira, guitar, and two different musical bows (chipendani and mukube) are offered for download free of charge, as is streaming of an additional curated playlist on Soundcloud (https://soundcloud.com/user-120200834/sets/sekurus-stories-i-1). The latter recordings, some of which have been published elsewhere, include other performers, and are reproduced with permission (hint: clicking on the link to the Soundcloud site will bring up more information about each track). The assistance of digital experts has enabled a number of special features, including layered interactive maps and a three-dimensional rotatable image of a mbira instrument (however, the mbira labeling was not fully functional at the time of this writing).
Narrative portions of Sekuru’s Stories are available in English or chiShona, Sekuru’s first language. Thus, the intended audience for the work includes not only English speakers and a chiShona-speaking Zimbabwean audience, but also readers with an interest in learning the chiShona language—likely a first for such a work. It should be noted that a growing community of North Americans, Europeans, and East Asian (especially Japanese) students of mbira music constitute a large potential audience. The multimedia approach serves well as an initial informational experience for those new to the culture and history of Zimbabwe and is a good source for teachers seeking educational material.
The core of Sekuru’s Stories consists of narratives in Sekuru Chigamba’s words, divided up among five main chronological divisions (“chapters”) of the website. These are oral histories, framed within the Shona narrative genre of nhoroondo, ranging from legends and myths to personal accounts of life dating from colonial days into the post-independence era. One can appreciate the manner of Sekuru’s delivery, as his aural art as a storyteller comes across even in English translation.
The Nziyo/Songs page in the “Mbira” chapter (https://sekuru.org/nziyo/) yielded an unexpected pleasure to my ear. Here, a collection of Sekuru’s explanations of the meaning for each of thirty-five mbira pieces—some from the shared repertoire and some of his own compositions—is accompanied, in most cases, by a two-minute track. Sekuru’s accounts, like those of most accomplished chiShona verbal stylists, are never one- or two-word definitions. Rather, each account presents a story, perhaps a striking image or reason why the piece is important, on what occasions it might be played, or some related historical tale. Experienced mbira players will likely find that the explanations here differ from the accounts of other Shona musicians—but such is to be expected. (Note to webmaster: several of the song explanations are available only in chiShona, as the English version is missing.) This chapter is also accessible from a sixth non-chronological section inviting the reader to “Explore”: here one can also find resource material on the instruments; maps; a timeline; and even Chigamba’s family tree.
Each of the five chapters of Sekuru’s Stories ends with a concluding essay. These are not available in chiShona translation, and one assumes they are author Kyker’s words, targeted towards an English-speaking audience of students and scholars. The essays constitute an attempt to analyse the significance and meaning of Sekuru’s narratives and put them into context within the appropriate scholarly literature. For example, the conclusion to the “Independence” chapter (https://sekuru.org/independence-conclusion/) draws on anthropological writings on religion and heritage to grapple with Sekuru’s dual allegiances to the ancestral “proto-nationalist” spirit Chaminuka and the Apostolic Christian prophet Mutumwa. The “Ancestors” conclusion engages writings in anthropology and pre-colonial history to make the case that Sekuru Chigamba’s nhoroondo accounts function as claims to power (https://sekuru.org/ancestors-conclusion/). (Note to author/webmaster: Despite the advertised completion/publication date of September, 2019, the above two sections appear to have been added or revised in mid-2020, and not all of the works cited appear in the Reference list. In addition, clicking on the “Next” button at the bottom of the final narrative of “Ancestors” [https://sekuru.org/disappearing-shrines/] takes the reader to a “Coming soon” error message.)
Conclusions to the remaining three chapters address topics more specific to mbira music structures and processes. In places, the author’s claims that her work with Sekuru Chigamba has broken new ground overlook or misunderstand previous scholarship, weakening the value of the work as an ethnomusicological analysis. In order to bring out the voices of other scholars of mbira, I have framed the following comments as an interactive call and response, in the spirit of African performativity.
Musical Life—Conclusion (https://sekuru.org/musical-life-conclusion/)
Call: In “Conservatism versus flexibility,” the author writes: “Writing on the mbira dzavadzimu, scholars have struggled to reconcile apparently competing tendencies toward conservatism on the one hand, and flexibility on the other.” She cites Andrew Tracey and Thomas Turino as depicting Shona music and spiritual practice as “inherently conservative.” She sees Paul Berliner, however, as taking a broader view in observing that Shona music has “long been characterized by innovation and change” ([Reference Berliner1978]1993:23).
Response: Tensions around vexing traditional/modern dichotomies pervade Kyker’s analyses as she portrays Chigamba as “at once firmly rooted in indigenous lifeways and decidedly creative, even cosmopolitan,” while critiquing scholars whose statements she perceives to be in conflict with hers. These binary tensions fall away when the focus is on the music—the flexibility inherent in the form and structure of mbira music—rather than on individual practices. A significant body of work elucidating the harmonic structure of mbira music has now provided underpinning for Berliner’s position. Andrew Tracey first described the existence of a single harmonic progression or “standard sequence” common to the repertory of all the large Shona lamellaphones, and determined that the same sequence could be found in songs of the matepe/hera mbira in all seven possible transpositions of the heptatonic scale (Reference Tracey1970). The same was subsequently found to be true of the mbira dzavadzimu repertoire by Brenner (Reference Brenner1997) and Grupe (Reference Grupe2004), whose analyses of perception, melodic variation, and tuning are specifically acknowledged by Berliner (Reference Berliner2020) as shedding light on his enquiry into the manipulation of rhythm and melody within the set harmonic framework (49; 549n2). Similarly, the foundational understanding of this reviewer’s work on mbira dzavadzimu tunings and the mbira orchestras (Jones Reference Jones and Brenner2019) is that the capabilities of creating new sounds through tuning from different mbira keys “derive directly from the structural-harmonic system that underlies the repertoire” (202). Credit is due to Andrew Tracey for calling attention to the “system of mbira,” of which he wrote that “far from being limited by this approach to chord movement, it is actually a most generative and versatile system. …The essence of this complex harmonically-based generative system…offers a great, almost endless potential for modern Shona composers” (Reference Tracey1989:54).
Call: In “Ephat Mujuru’s role,” Kyker writes that Sekuru Chigamba attributed the addition of an extra key on the mavembe tuned mbira, meant to be played by the left forefinger, to Ephat Mujuru. As Chigamba explains: “He’s the one who introduced this key, because he went to Makonde. He saw them playing njari. So, he took that type of instrument, then he said, ‘Maybe if we put this, we can play [the njari piece] Marenje.’” According to Kyker, this “resulted in a significant modification of the mbira’s layout, and made a substantial contribution to mavembe repertory.”
Response: Point of fact regarding this rarely-found key or keys on the upper left manual of the mbira dzavadzimu: Andrew Tracey described a diagram of a Karanga mbira dze midzimu (equivalent term for dzavadzimu) drawn by explorer Karl Mauch in 1872 that includes not one, but two upper left notes (keys) meant to be played by the index finger plucking from below (Reference Tracey1972:95). Further, Hugh Tracey photographed a mbira in 1932 with those same extra notes. Ephat Mujuru once told me that an older mbira in his family’s possession had these notes (personal communication, c. 1982), and I would surmise that they were more commonly included on mbira dzavadzimu instruments in the past. In any case, few other Zimbabwean players of the mavembe/magandanga mbira have the aforementioned note on their instruments, and it is not crucial to the tuning of the mbira.
Call: Sekuru Chigamba states in the narrative section of “Composition” (https://sekuru.org/composing-songs/): “I am different than other people. Some people write their songs, and other people dream of them. But I don’t. When I dream, I dream of songs I already play. But my own songs just arise while I am working.”
Response: Sekuru Chigamba tells us that he is different from other mbira players: how is he different? Any discussion of composition within a non-Western traditional practice should address how that society conceives of and evaluates musical creations in general. Many Shona mbira players state that they receive songs in dreams, and pieces learned from dreams are said to come from the ancestral spirits (Berliner [Reference Berliner1978]1993:86). According to indigenous scholar Perminus Matiure and his consultants, “all the modes [song families] played on mbira dzavadzimu belong to the ancestral spirits” (Reference Matiure2009:68).
Call: Kyker writes in “Sekuru Chigamba as composer” (https://sekuru.org/musical-life-conclusion/) that “Descriptions of the mbira as inherently conservative often focus on the instrument’s repertory. From this perspective, old songs are valued for their ability to attract the spirits to possess living mediums, while new compositions are not highly valued, or are even considered undesirable.… That most mbira players do not compose original songs may itself be interpreted as a sign of musical conservatism.”
Response: An alternate interpretation is that many accomplished mbira players who perform their own unique versions of known songs do not consider them to be original compositions or give them new titles as does Sekuru Chigamba. Turino cited the late mbira maker Chris Mhlanga’s description of a mbira piece as a “bundle of resources” that can be drawn on in different ways in each performance such that largely differing renditions are still identified as the same piece rather than as new compositions (Reference Turino2000:281–282). A useful aspect of Turino’s analysis is that he characterises individuals as speaking from, and sometimes shifting between, indigenous views on composition and cosmopolitan perspectives (i.e., notions of intellectual property based on novelty and originality, and the consequent prestige awarded to the artist). Sekuru Chigamba is much admired by a cosmopolitan North American audience, but many knowledgeable Zimbabwean mbira players coming from an indigenous perspective do not recognise Sekuru Chigamba’s named songs as new compositions, since most can be heard as derivative of those in the known repertoire. This view in no way diminishes either the high regard for Sekuru Chigamba as an expert gwenyambira or his creative explorations within mavembe tuning.
Mbira—Conclusion (https://sekuru.org/mbira-conclusion/)
Call: Kyker writes in “Repertory crossing over” that “Kaemmer’s treatment of this type of ‘cross-fertilization’ continues to maintain a division between the performance of these songs on the mbira dzavadzimu, which are treated as separate from their performance on other instruments. …Sekuru Chigamba, on the other hand, describes how songs move between different types of mbira during encounters between musicians from various regions, who play different instruments.”
Response: As written, this section conveys a message that only the depiction of Sekuru Chigamba’s activities authentically portrays cross-fertilisation between mbira instruments. I fail to see how the original Kaemmer passage and the anecdote about Sekuru Chigamba finding ways to play his mbira dzavadzimu along with matepe are not manifestations of the same phenomenon: the shared mbira system and a common repertoire among the large lamellaphones. One could cite numerous anecdotes or other examples in the literature of different types of mbira being played together: recent ones include the long-standing practice of large karimba and matepe performing together in northeastern Zimbabwe (Moon Reference Moon2018; first noted and recorded by Andrew Tracey in 1969) and the mixing of karimba with differently-tuned mbira dzavadzimu in the mbira orchestra of Mbira DzeNharira (Jones Reference Jones and Brenner2019).
In sum, the Sekuru’s Stories website provides an excellent one-stop resource for individuals seeking more than a casual understanding of Zimbabwean mbira and world music teachers looking for an inter-disciplinary approach that blends cultural and historical background with African musical studies. The narratives reveal the diverse talents of Sekuru Chigamba as an oral historian and ritual specialist. Recordings showcasing his proficiency on acoustic guitar and the bow instruments will likely be a revelation to those familiar with his mbira mastery. If the author’s aim is to make a comprehensive contribution to the scholarship on the Shona mbira, a more objective approach admitting other indigenous and scholarly perspectives is warranted. As it stands, however, the project serves as a wide-ranging tribute to the life and work of gwenyambira Sekuru Chigamba.
