I. INTRODUCTION
In their recent article “Anti-Semitism in Progressive Era Social Science: The Case of John R. Commons” (2016), Luca Fiorito and Cosma Orsi set out to indict John R. Commons of anti-Semitism, defined as a “persisting latent structure of hostile beliefs towards Jews as a collectivity, manifested in individuals as attitudes, and in culture as myth, ideology, folklore, and imagery, and in actions—social or legal discrimination political mobilization against the Jew, and collective state violence—which results in or is designed to displace or destroy Jews as Jews” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 57; italics in original). Their indictment rests on three sources: an interview in which Mark Perlman spoke of his father, Selig; a report that Commons wrote for the United States Industrial Commission; and a book that collected articles written by Commons for the Chautauqua Institute. When their treatment in each of these three sources is examined, however, the meaning of their indictment grows elusive.
II. THE INTERVIEW
In their account of Mark Perlman’s interview, Fiorito and Orsi cited words that cannot be found in the published transcript. For example, in their concluding remarks they wrote, “Still, as recounted by Perlman to his son, Commons did not hesitate to express disdain towards Jews on many occasions both public and private” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 75). These were not in the transcript. Moreover, Mark Perlman never used the phrase “veiled hostility toward Jews” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 59). In fact, it is impossible to find in that interview any word or deed of Commons that could be interpreted as unequivocally anti-Semitic.
Mark Perlman did indeed characterize his father’s personal relationship with Commons as “strange,” and one can pick passages that relate the “strangeness” to some presumed anti-Semitism on Commons’s part. Fiorito and Orsi took a snippet from one such passage—about Commons’s response when he learned that Selig was worried about the welfare of his parents in Bialystok, then part of the Russian empire.
My father went to Commons, bringing up what he thought to be his horrendous personal problems. Commons gave him a massive salary increase with which my father brought his parents to America and tried to plunk them down with his mother’s siblings in Woonsocket, Rhode Island, where they were very unhappy. Much to his further embarrassment, he decided to bring them to Madison, where all would live in what was called Greenbush, the ghetto or Jewish section of Madison. My father realized all this emphasis on the Jewishness of his family put him at a great disadvantage with Commons.… The changes stamped my father not only as a Jew, or as an immigrant Russian Jew, neither of which he ever denied, but as a poor Russian Jew rather than as an intellectual Russian Jew. That, as I understand it, was the great problem for him. (Fink Reference Fink1991, pp. 512–513)
This introduces the first confusion. The only action of Commons described in this larger passage was the part omitted by Fiorito and Orsi: he responded to Selig’s concern for his parents with a “massive salary increase.” And, in the part that they chose to cite, Mark Perlman spoke of his father’s fears of what Commons might think—not of anything that Commons said or did. Finally, in this passage, the meaning of anti-Semitism when it is applied to Czarist Russia is clear. How can the same word apply to Commons? How did this massive salary increase symbolize “veiled hostility” toward Jews?
Mark Perlman did say that Commons did not like Jews. If Commons had said that he did not like Jews, that would indicate anti-Semitism. But Mark Perlman did not support the assertion with anything Commons said, but with Commons’s book Races and Immigrants (which will be dealt with later). Mark Perlman also recognized a problem with his own statement because Commons was on good terms with a number of Jewish students. He mentioned David Saposs and William Leiserson (Fink Reference Fink1991, pp. 526–527). He could have added Elizabeth Brandeis. He could have added the Jewish labor leader, Samuel Gompers, for whom Commons wrote a glowing eulogy (Commons Reference Commons1925). How can these reveal a “veiled hostility toward Jews”?
The authors cite, as their ultimate proof, the Friday-night dinner at which Commons announced that he was retiring, and that Edwin Witte had been hired to take his place. According to Mark Perlman’s account, Commons said that he was glad to get Witte because otherwise Selig would have taken his place. One must add that this is what Mark Perlman said. We have no record of what Commons said. In any case, Selig took offense and stopped coming to the Friday-night dinners. Again, Fiorito and Orsi omit a passage in the interview: “A month or so later, John R’s daughter, Rachel, a wonderful person, but driven to a miserable life including drink and suicide, came to the house, crying and saying that her father had not really meant what he said and that he would apologize at a Friday Night, but my father would not [go]” (Fink Reference Fink1991, p. 522).
So, Commons might have said something that was not intended the way that Selig Perlman understood it. Commons and Perlman were both full-time professors. Witte was an unpaid part-time lecturer. It made sense to give Witte the full-time job. It is hard, on the other hand, to make sense of the notion that one full-time professor can replace another. Commons could have meant that without Witte, Perlman’s workload would have increased. What he meant is, of course, lost.
When Commons’s daughter died, the first person he called was Selig Perlman. He offered Selig Perlman his library (Fink Reference Fink1991, p. 524). How can these actions be consistent with a “veiled hostility toward Jews”? Commons’s praise for Perlman in his memoir was dismissed both by Mark Perlman and by Fiorito and Orsi, who added, “We are all aware that Mark Perlman’s recollections about his father must be taken cum grano salis” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 56).
Well, yes, but recollections can be checked. When this is done, the interview grows problematic. Two examples are relevant to the problem of applying the adjective of “anti-Semitic” to Commons.
First, when Selig Perlman went on the job market in 1916, he encountered anti-Semitism at Cornell and at the University of Arkansas. In the interview, Mark Perlman said that Commons’s wife, Nell, and the sociologist Edward Alsworth Ross engaged in academic politics to get Selig an appointment at Madison (Fink Reference Fink1991, pp. 519–520). This much seems accurate. But Mark Perlman has Nell and Ross unseating Richard T. Ely as chairman and Ross getting his sociology department in the process. Ely had stepped down as chairman in 1911. The official chairman from 1911 to 1916 was Thomas K. Urdahl; and the sociology department did not split off until 1929 (Lampman Reference Lampman1993, pp. xxiii, 350). It needs to be noted here that Commons had offered Perlman an assistantship, so in what way was he anti-Semitic in the same sense as the administrations at Cornell and Arkansas that had refused to hire Perlman because he was a Jew?
There are other inconsistencies, but a second example deserves specific attention. The image of Commons’s personality portrayed in this interview, and, for that matter, by Fiorito and Orsi—a hard, unapproachable, dictatorial taskmaster—is contradicted by every other depiction I have been able to find. Here are a few: Theresa McMahon received her PhD in 1909, and in 1958 she told an interviewer, “Commons was a kindly, sweet gentle sort of man, a man you just loved; he possessed a most attractive smile, was soft-spoken, and looked as if he suffered from chronic ill health. You never criticized or fought with him, you might say. I don’t believe the man ever had an enemy” (McMahon Reference McMahon and Jonçich1958, p. 247).
Here is David Saposs:
Closest to us of course was Commons or “John R” as we worshipfully referred to him. In his bearing, appearance, manner, and casual relations he was the extreme opposite of the exuberant, extrovert type. His shabby and ascetic appearance and his obviously reserved air would be likely to discourage and even unintentionally repel those not aware that his forbidding exterior sheltered a sensitive genius who warmheartedly overflowed with inspiring ideas and sympathetic appreciation of the trials and tribulations of novitiates. (Saposs Reference Saposs1959, cited in Harter Reference Harter1962, p. 6)
Edwin Witte described Commons as “ever modest and always giving credit to his students even for ideas which really came from him; he inspired students to work on the practical problems assigned to them with a devotion and intensity they did not develop in any other courses” (Witte Reference Witte1954, p. 131). Harold Groves wrote: “As a teacher he had a profound influence on those with whom he worked, and he had a positive genius for team work with graduate students” (Groves Reference Groves1957).
The reasons for these inconsistencies can be partially explained by time. Mark Perlman was born on December 23, 1923. Selig Perlman died on August 14, 1959. The interview took place on January 29, 1989. So, Mark Perlman was recalling events that were between seventy and thirty years in the past—many before he was born. He was nine years old when Commons retired. But on this basis, Fiorito and Orsi begin their portrait of Commons’s “persisting latent structure of hostile beliefs toward Jews as a collectivity.”
They shore up this terrifying portrait by selecting and interpreting passages from Commons’s report on immigration for the United States Industrial Commission (USIC) and from his Immigrants and Races. But the passages they cite and their interpretations only further confuse the meaning of “anti-Semitism” as they apply it to Commons.
III. THE INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION REPORT
The United States Industrial Commission owed its origin to a bill designed to investigate the economic aspects of trusts such as Standard Oil and US Steel. As the bill wound through Congress, it picked up other goals, finally creating a committee “to investigate questions pertaining to immigration, to labor, to agriculture, to manufacturing, and to business”—in short, to investigate all the problems that accompanied America’s first great horizontal merger wave (Wunderlin Reference Wunderlin1992, pp. 28–71). The committee combined congressional hearings with investigations conducted by staff trained in the new social sciences. Commons was the staff member who reported on the economic effects of immigration. With Charles Edgerton and E. Dana Durand, he also wrote the report on labor, and, with Kate Claghorn, he wrote the introduction to the final volume, “Progress of the Nation” (Durand Reference Durand1902, p. 572n).
Fiorito and Orsi, ignoring this larger context, fastened on Durand’s citation of Francis Amasa Walker’s claim that immigration caused falling birth rates in America’s pre-existing white population (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 59; Walker 1892). The descendants of America’s 1790 population, according to Walker, did not want to bring children into a society where they would be compelled to live with immigrants from eastern and southern Europe who were driving down living standards by accepting lower wages and befouling the social environment with their repulsive habits. Fiorito and Orsi imply that Commons agreed with Walker.
He did not. In Races and Immigrants (1920, pp. 202–208), Commons demolished Walker’s argument. He showed how rising living standards and urbanization—not immigration—accounted for the declining birth rates (race suicide) of America’s pre-existing population.Footnote 1 Here, in his USIC report, he restated one part of Walker’s thesis as a question, which he answered in the negative. “Suppose, instead of immigration during the past fifty years, the same growth of population would have occurred through the natural increase of American stock already in the country, as maintained by Professor Walker in the article quoted on page 277, would such natural increase have caused a fall in wages and lack of employment?” (Commons Reference Commons1901b, pp. 304–305).
To answer the question, Commons projected a labor force assuming that the 1790 age, sex structure, and rate of increase had not changed—roughly shifting the aggregate labor supply curve to the right. Then he projected an increase in production—roughly shifting the aggregate labor demand curve to the right. Though he used different words, he found the demand curve shifting further than the supply curve with a resulting increase in average wages. So, he rejected part of the Walker thesis that Fiorito and Orsi claim he accepted. In other words, he rejected the hypothesis that immigration in the aggregate forced down average wages.Footnote 2
He then turned to what he considered actual problems with unregulated immigration. First, immigration was pro-cyclical. During the cyclical upswing from 1869 to 1872, the number of immigrants had increased from 352,768 to 459,803. By the trough in 1879, the number had fallen to 138,469. By the next peak in 1882, the number had risen to 788,992. Immigrants came for other reasons. The year 1848, a recession year, was marked by high immigration due to revolts in Europe and famine in Ireland. The steady secular increase in wages showed that immigration was a minor influence on wages. Immigrants might have prevented wages from rising during cyclical upswings, but the statistics did not show it. Immigrants did, however, add to unemployment during cyclical troughs particularly in the occupations to which they gravitated (Commons Reference Commons1901a, pp. 42–43; 1901b, pp. 305–309).
Unlimited immigration also hindered union organization: (1) foreign workers were hired on contract as strikebreakers; (2) new hard-working immigrants were unfamiliar with the advantages of organization—when a union succeeded in educating one wave of immigrants, they were replaced by another wave; and (3) union organization was made difficult in occupations employing workers of many nationalities of many cultures speaking many languages (Commons Reference Commons1901b, p. 312).
Immigrants tended to crowd into industries in which other economic forces were already driving down wages. Commons embarked on an examination of these industries, starting with the garment industry. Fiorito and Orsi base their charge of anti-Semitism on seven pages in which Commons reported on New York’s garment industry (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, pp. 60–62; Commons Reference Commons1901b, pp. 320, 325–328, 346–347). Where did these pages come from?
As Fiorito and Orsi noted, to gather evidence on the garment industry, Commons spent six months traveling the country with Abram Bisno, a Jewish cloak maker and union leader. They stayed together in cheap hotels and settlement houses. Fiorito and Orsi did not address the problem of fitting the labels of “xenophobia” and “veiled hostility” toward Jews on a man who willingly spent six months in close company with a Jewish labor leader. Neither did they tell their readers what Commons told the readers of his memoir.
Commons wrote, “I had him [Bisno] dictate to my stenographer his interviews and interpretations which I then clipped and pasted into an orderly analysis of the American sweatshops. Was I an editor or a plagiarist? The chapter was printed as mine by the Industrial Commission ‘with the assistance of Abram Bisno.’ The words and thoughts were Bisno’s; the credit was mine” (Commons Reference Commons1934a, p. 69). So, the question arises: How can Commons be accused of anti-Semitism by using the words of a Jewish union leader? This, of course, leads to a further question about whether Fiorito and Orsi gave the words a meaning unintended by Bisno or Commons.
Thus, they wrote, “Of central import in the present instance is that Commons came to see the sweatshop as reflective of some distinct ‘racial’ characteristics of immigrants. Commons’s targets were eastern European Jews—the group that had virtually monopolized the garment industry and sweatshops” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 59). How is this consistent with this statement—perhaps by Bisno, perhaps by Commons—“Whereas in New York the Jews largely predominate, yet in Chicago they number only about 25 per cent of the trade” (Commons Reference Commons1901b, p. 325)? Moreover, the sweatshop market described in the immigration report was an oligopsony, with many contractors selling to a few wholesalers or warehousemen (Commons Reference Commons1901b, p. 320n). Commons and Bisno considered the Russian Jews of New York to be not monopolists, but poorly organized victims of oligopsony power.
How is the “central import” of “targeting eastern European Jews” consistent with Commons’s (or Bisno’s) own conclusion?
The clothing trade has been affected more than any other trade by successive waves of immigrants, especially Irish, Germans, Scandinavians, Jews, Italians, Poles, Bohemians, and Lithuanians.… The organization and evolution of the trade have passed through four stages: (1) the journeyman tailor; (2) the home shop; (3) the task shop or small contractor’s shop; (4) the factory. (Commons Reference Commons1901b, p..368)
Precisely how does this summary “target eastern European Jews”?
Fiorito and Orsi drew anti-Semitism from Commons’s statement that “the Jew’s individualism” makes him unsuitable for the “life of the wage earner” and especially for the discipline of the modern American factory (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 59). In Races and Immigrants, Commons also wrote that “among the American-born workmen, as well as the English and Scotch, are not found the docility, obedience to others, and patient toil which employers desire where hundreds and thousands are brought like an army under the direction of superintendents and managers” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 129). So, perhaps Fiorito and Orsi could write an article on Commons’s anti-Americanism, since Commons considered American workers, like Jews, Scots, and Englishmen, unsuited to factory work. Fiorito and Orsi seem naive about what went on in factories at the turn of the last century. They also treat Commons’s term “individualism” as synonymous with “selfishness” or “uncooperativeness.” Commons did not use the term in a pejorative sense (Commons Reference Commons1895).
Fiorito and Orsi did not put this passage in the overarching conclusion of the USIC investigations—the death of the abolitionist free labor ideal stated most famously by Abraham Lincoln: “The prudential penniless beginner in the world labors for wages awhile, saves a surplus with which to buy tools or land for himself, then labors on his own account another while, and at length hires another beginner to help him” (cited in Richardson Reference Richardson2001, p. 6). This ideal was consistent with the notion of the firm in Adam Smith and the classical economists, a notion that Commons later identified with the sweatshop (Commons Reference Commons1934b, pp. 864–865).
That is, for Commons, the term “sweatshop” referred to several types of organizations characterized by contracting and subcontracting. What made it a sweatshop was the absence of responsibility by contractors or manufacturers for working conditions. (For a contemporary application, see McIntyre and Ramstad Reference McIntyre, Ramstad, Champlin and Knoedler2004, and Weil Reference Weil2014.)
The individualism he found in the first generation of Russian Jewish immigrants resembled the individualism of Lincoln’s tradesman. But the rise of the large corporation had made the ideal of free labor unachievable. Most people would spend their lives as propertyless wage workers. This was why, with his associates on the committee, Jeremiah Jenks, Durand, and Edgerton, Commons turned to unions as the only way that workers could match the bargaining power of corporations.
Noting that Commons supported unions, Fiorito and Orsi fired their next charge of anti-Semitism: “Commons, in fact, regarded the sweatshop as the center of a rising immigrant economy, threatening to undermine not only the wages and well-being of ‘American’ workers, but also the stability and efficacy of the union movement” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 61). First, Commons’s summary, cited earlier, shows that he did not regard the sweatshop as the center of a rising immigrant economy. He saw factories replacing sweatshops. As for the implication that Commons was interested only in the well-being of “American” workers, consider that a few pages earlier, he had written:
Now, labor organization in America, as regards immigration, has two aspects. It is, first, apart from legislation, the only bulwark the Americanized workmen are able to erect against the flood of immigration, and second, in case this bulwark is broken down and the occupation has been filled by immigrants, organization is the only means by which the immigrants themselves can rise to the standards of those whom they displace. (Commons Reference Commons1901b, p. 312)
So, Commons seemed interested in the welfare of workers whether American or immigrant, and he tended to view immigration as a source from which corporations created a reserve army of unemployed—benefitting neither immigrants nor domestic workers.
Next, Fiorito and Orsi selected a long passage from the report (Commons Reference Commons1901b, p. 312; Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 61). They omitted a previous definition of “the problem” with which this passage dealt: that garment workers had been unable to improve their living standards by forming permanent unions. In many places the problem had been aggravated by waves of new immigrants unaccustomed to trade unions. But, in New York, one ethnic group, Russian Jews, dominated the contractor–worker population. So, there had to be another explanation for their inability to form permanent unions. Fiorito and Orsi began their selection with this sentence referring to the New York market: “The problem is the nature of the Jew himself. The Jew’s conception of a labor organization is that of a tradesman rather than a workman.” The passage describes a strike joined by 95% of the workers, and then adds this sentence. “But once the strike is settled, either in favor or against the cause, they are contented, and that usually ends the union, since they do not see any practical use for a union when there is no cause to fight for” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 61).
A later paragraph in this long selection begins with this sentence. “The Jew is exceedingly abstract and metaphysical and greatly interested in general principles. His union is always, therefore, except in time of a strike, a forum for the discussion of socialism and the philology of the labor movement” (ibid.).
Here is the interpretation of Fiorito and Orsi: “Commons argued that the Jew’s individualistic and uncooperative (but also abstract and metaphysical) nature would weaken the development of permanent unions.” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p, 61). First, I do not find the word “uncooperative” in the text. Moreover, the context of the passage was the problem of stagnant living conditions of workers in the garment industry, not the threat to American unions by garment workers. Finally, where did this passage originate? Again, Commons told the readers in his memoir:
I visited with him [Bisno] in New York one of the garment workers’ strikes which occurred at the semi-annual opening of the busy season. It was certainly a mass movement. All of the workers in that branch of clothing were out. Thousands were on an open space in the streets, listening to the eloquence of Emma Goldman, while the organizers of the upstart union were negotiating with their employers. Then Bisno interpreted to me Emma’s anarchism. He said that within a month these masses would quit paying dues and would begin secretly cutting wages by connivance with their bosses. The union rules would be evaded and the union would dissolve. So it happened, and I reached a conclusion that the individualist Jew could not maintain a permanent union. But I was wrong. (Commons 1934, p. 70)
So, again, Fiorito and Orsi derived an anti-Semitic interpretation from a statement by a Russian Jew.
Fiorito and Orsi found a problem in Commons’s admission, written in 1934, that he was wrong since the New York Jews had organized a permanent union after this report was written (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, pp. 76–77). Actually, Commons had corrected himself earlier, in 1920, in the introduction to the second edition of Races and Immigrants where, beginning with the IWW strikes in 1911, he summarized strike activity, commenting that for the most part strikes were lost and that permanent unions were not maintained, but he found some exceptions.
Yet remarkably survivals occurred. The Russian Jews, whose seasonal sweatshop strikes we noted in 1906, at last effected permanent organizations, almost completely controlling the clothing trade of the country, doubling their wages and reducing their hours to forty-four a week. Fleeing from Russia, these immigrants, with their Italian and Polish associates, were the most revolutionary, in theory, of all immigrants. Yet no nationalities have demonstrated more conclusively the moderating effects of power and responsibility. (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. xxi)
So, how was Commons an anti-Semite in his report on immigration? Well, he must have been an anti-Semite in the same way that Abram Bisno, the Jewish labor leader, was an anti-Semite. In other words, the meaning of the term grows more confusing as one works one’s way through the Fiorito and Orsi article. Neither did their treatment of Races and Immigrants clear anything up.
IV. RACES AND IMMIGRANTS
In Races and Immigrants Commons asked how American political institutions could survive a massive influx of new members culturally conditioned to survival under the despotic rule of European autocrats or of southern slave masters. Would these new members be capable of sustaining America’s representative democracy by fulfilling the duties and demanding the rights of citizens? If so, how could they learn to do that (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 3)? They would be capable, he wrote, if their characters exhibited three qualities: “intelligence,” which he defined as “the power to weigh evidence and draw conclusions, based on adequate information”; “civic virtue,” which he called “manliness”—“self-respect, self-control, and that assertion and jealousy of encroachment which marks those, who knowing their rights, dare maintain them”; and “capacity for cooperation, that willingness and ability to organize, to trust their leaders, to work together for a common interest and toward a common destiny” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 6).
Then he summarized the histories and characteristics of the major ethnic groups, beginning with the first European settlers and ending with the peoples of southern and eastern Europe. The offensive stereotypes of this summary made Races and Immigrants his worst book. But, if read carefully, the book comes out slightly less bad. Many of the most offensive passages are footnoted to what seemed like science at the time (for example, Tillinghast Reference Tillinghast1902). And Commons answered the first question in the affirmative, and his policy proposals made some sense. Yes, he concluded, all newcomers were capable of citizenship. Then he proposed policies and educational institutions that could transform former peasants and slaves into citizens in America’s democratic experiment.
But Fiorito and Orsi found no redeeming characteristic in the book. With three references they supported their claim that Commons’s treatment of the Jews here followed “the same line of stereotyped arguments” that they claimed to have found in the immigration report (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 62).
The first of their three references placed Jews in a discussion of antagonisms among different ethnic groups in the Austro-Hungarian Empire: Magyars, Ruthenians, Poles, Finns, and Bohemians (Commons Reference Commons1920, pp. 80- 82). The others resented the Jews because they were so dominant in Hungary’s financial sector. In the second reference cited by Fiorito and Orsi, Commons stated that Jews were not well adapted to the pioneer life or factory work, but that they gravitated to peddling and merchandising (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 133). As noted earlier, he also considered American, Scot-Irish and English workers ill fitted for factory work, though not obviously for pioneer work. So if this statement represents anti-Semitism, Commons must also be accused of anti-Americanism.
Their third reference (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 94) comes toward the end of Commons’s treatment of immigrants from Russia. He had noted that the Jews were not genetically distinct from other Europeans. That is, he did not make them a “separate race” as the term is currently understood. He added, “That which makes the Jew a peculiar people is not altogether the purity of his blood, but persecution, devotion to his religion, and the careful training of his children” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 93). Fiorito and Orsi (pp. 64–65) ignored the admiration expressed in this sentence. They first expressed confusion about his consistent use of the term “race,” even though Commons had clearly written that he planned to use “race” as a synonym for what we now call “ethnic group” (Commons Reference Commons1920, pp. 12–13). And they ignored the next two pages in which Commons expressed even greater admiration for Jewish immigrants. To grasp the significance of this final passage, one must recall that in his refutation of the Walker thesis, Commons showed that people respond to rising income by reducing their birth rates in order to ensure that their children will enjoy at least the same higher living standard that they had attained (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 202)
In his interviews, he must have learned that other eastern European immigrants were alarmed at the natural increase of the Jewish population. That increase, he wrote, was “the highest mark of their virtue,” of their “vitality,” “sobriety,” “temperance,” and “self-control” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 94). Then, his final sentences on the Russian Jews are again complimentary: “Of the Jew it might be said more truly than of any other European people that the growth of population has led to overcrowding and induced immigration. Yet of no people is this less true, for, were it not for the discrimination and persecution directed against them, the Jews would be the most prosperous and least overcrowded of the races of Europe” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 95).
Fiorito and Orsi concentrated less on alleged anti-Semitism in their treatment of Races and Immigrants and more on alleged xenophobia, starting with a selective quotation from a passage that came near the end of the book, and that, in their view, “reflected the general tenor of hostility toward immigration we have found in the Industrial Commission Report” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 62). In that passage Commons supported a proposed literacy test that required of adult wage earners only that they be literate in any language, not necessarily English. Commons continued:
With these reasonable limitations it would exclude only 1 in 200 of the Scandinavians, 1 in 100 of the English, Scotch, and Finns, 2 or 3 in 100 of the Germans, Irish, Welsh, and French; but it would exclude one-half of the South Italians, one seventh of the North Italians, one-third to two-fifths of the several Slav races, one-seventh of the Russian Jews, altogether one-fifth to one fourth of the total immigration.
Fiorito and Orsi stop here, omitting the following qualification:
But these proportions would not long continue. Elementary education is making progress in Eastern and Southern Europe, and a test of this kind would stimulate it still more among the peasants. Restrictive at first, it is only selective; it would not permanently reduce the number of immigrants, but it would raise their level of intelligence and their ability to take care of themselves. (Commons Reference Commons1920, pp. 234–235)
So Fiorito and Orsi stopped before the section in which Commons anticipated that more people would pass the test and that greater literacy would enable immigrants to care for themselves. The entire passage does not reflect “hostility,” as the word is generally understood—the first dictionary meaning is “enmity”; neither does it suggest “weeding out of inferior races,” as Fiorito and Orsi claim. It just supports a requirement of literacy as a prerequisite for citizenship. It is based on the same assumptions that grounded campaigns for universal compulsory education.
Commons was, of course, opposed to unregulated immigration. In Races and Immigrants, he repeated the arguments of his report for the Industrial Commission, but he stressed the part played by recruiters—steamship recruiters anxious to sell tickets, corporation recruiters seeking a reserve army of the unemployed, and mine recruiters seeking strikebreakers or purposely mixing nationalities and languages in order to hinder union organization. “Indeed, almost the only device and symptom of originality displayed by American employers in disciplining the labor force has been that of playing one race off against another” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 150).
Fiorito and Orsi seem naive about the reality of immigration at the turn of the twentieth century. Joseph Conrad, in his short story “Amy Foster,” drew a more realistic picture in his description of a recruiting session:
[The Polish youth] himself had great difficulty getting accepted, and the venerable men in uniform had to go out of the room several times to work the telegraph on his behalf … those only who had money could be taken.… His father sold an old cow, a pair of piebald mountain ponies of his own raising, and a cleared plot of fair pasture on the sunny slope of a pine-clad pass … to pay the people of the ship that took men to America to get rich in a short time. (Conrad Reference Conrad2007, pp. 229–230)
In Industrial Goodwill, Commons wrote about “a member of the American Labor Mission sent to Europe … met by the retort of returned Italian workers that America had ruined their health and exploited their labor” (Commons [Reference Commons1919] 1969, pp. 130–131). Finally, there is no iron-clad ethical case in favor of unlimited immigration (Rawls Reference Rawls1999, 38–39).
V. CONCLUSIONS
So, in what sense can John R. Commons be posthumously forced to wear the scarlet letter of anti-Semitism? Fiorito and Orsi based their indictment on an interview in which Mark Perlman spoke of the strained relationship between his father and Commons, on Commons’s USIC immigration report, and on his book Races and Immigrants.
As for the interview, their quotations went beyond the text, as when they wrote that Commons “did not hesitate to express disdain towards Jews on many occasions” (Fiorito and Orsi Reference Fiorito and Orsi2016, p. 75)—a statement not found in the text. Neither did he, as they claim in their conclusion, define Jews as a race in the strict sense of the word. Moreover, the text itself does not relate any statement or act of Commons that can be unequivocally interpreted as anti-Semitic. It contains unequivocal examples of anti-Semitism—in the pogroms of eastern Europe and in the refusal of other colleges to offer Selig Perlman a job. But Commons doubled Selig’s salary so that he could rescue his parents from the pogroms of eastern Europe, and Commons was not prevented by Perlman’s Jewishness from offering him an assistantship, from supporting his full-time job at Wisconsin, and from seeking his assistance in his project on labor history. So where is the unequivocal evidence of anti-Semitism?
It is, of course, understandable that misunderstandings might arise between two men, one of whom grew up in small-town America’s Middle Border and another who spent his childhood in a Polish-Russian shtetl. For example, Commons, who grew up “speaking Hoosier” in an egalitarian Middle Border culture, could not possibly have cared whether or not Perlman spoke like an “intellectual” Jew.
Selig Perlman was a great scholar and a beloved teacher (Taft Reference Taft1976). But some of his private fears and resentment, as he confided them to his son—and to no one else, as far as I have been able to ascertain—can be legitimately questioned. Selig Perlman bore scars of real anti-Semitism, scars that might have caused him to see hostility where there was none. Thus, when Philip LaFollette urged Harold Groves to seek a seat in the assembly, Groves sought the advice of his fellow students. “I was flattered but considerably frightened by the idea. The advice of my colleagues was conflicting: Selig Perlman was sure that Phil LaFollette and Bill Evje would use me and knife me when they found it convenient. Martin Glaeser thought it an opportunity which one should not spurn. Susie agreed with Martin” (Groves Reference Groves1962, p. 140).
Add to this the many factual errors in the interview and the fact that the interview took place thirty years after Selig Perlman’s death, and it becomes a source to be used cautiously—not to destroy a man’s reputation.
The second source from which Fiorito and Orsi leveled their charge was Commons’s report on immigration for the United States Industrial Commission. They chose 7 out of roughly 300 pages. Those seven pages were most likely dictated by Abraham Bisno, a Russian Jewish labor leader. So Fiorito and Orsi were, for the most part, accusing a Russian Jew of anti-Semitism. Moreover, as was shown above, when they made statements about the general arguments of the report, those statements disagreed drastically with what Commons (or Bisno) seemed to consider the general arguments.
Their third source, Races and Immigrants, was filled with stereotypes and phony science offensive to twenty-first-century sensibility. Careful rereading and attempts to understand the fears of American Protestants does not save it but renders it less bad. What appears today to be racial pseudo-science seemed less pseudo then. And Commons did explicitly refute Walker’s “race suicide” thesis. The fact that he kept the term “race suicide” but gave it a different meaning might confuse someone, but it could confuse no one who read with an open mind his entire argument (Commons Reference Commons1920, pp. 202–208). One can also find some redeeming aspects in Commons’s policy prescriptions, which centered on education. With respect to Jews, one can cherry-pick both positive and negative statements, but it remains hard, on the basis of any full reading of his treatment, to accuse him of harboring hostility toward Jewish immigrants. He did not, as Fiorito and Orsi claim in their conclusion, “define Jews as a race.” “It should not be inferred that the Jews are a race of pure descent” (Commons Reference Commons1920, p. 93).
So, what remains? Commons was a nineteenth-century product of America’s Midwest. He learned to read with Foxe’s Book of Martyrs, which inculcates the superiority of everything Anglo-Saxon. So there may have existed among his habitual assumptions—perhaps unacknowledged—a belief in the superiority of Anglo-Saxon dissenter rural culture. Nevertheless, it seems difficult to support or even to understand the indictment of hostility, xenophobia, and anti-Semitism brought against him by Fiorito and Orsi.
