The essence of Kaya Şahin's accomplished book is concisely stated: “The reigns of Selim and Süleyman were instrumental in the creation of a new Ottoman imperialism as an answer to developments in early modern Eurasia” (p. 186). Arguing that the relatively neglected reign of Selim I was the significant and essential precursor that enabled Süleyman's much-lauded achievements, Şahin analyzes the empire through the eyes of Celalzade Mustafa, Süleyman's chancellor from 1534 until 1557. Discarding notions of exceptionalism, he posits, through a reading of Mustafa's career and writings, that the empire's history followed a comparable trajectory to that of contemporary states in east and west.
Mustafa has long been considered one of the men who shaped the Süleymanic age by establishing the chancellor as the chief authority on dynastic law and professionalizing the bureaucracy. Yet he has remained a shadowy presence awaiting a study such as that under review to put flesh upon these bones. Şahin maintains that Mustafa helped create the new imperial edifice both through his bureaucratic activity and his contributions to the new ideology. Mustafa was the author of, most notably, two monumental works: the Tabakatüʾl-memalik ve derecatüʾl-mesalik, which covers Süleyman's reign until 1557 and the completion of the Süleymanic mosque complex, and the Tarih-i Sultan Selim. The Tabakat is Şahin's main source, and his understanding of it relies on the facsimile of the Berlin manuscript, one of the oldest of seventeen known manuscripts, which was published by Petra Kappert in 1981. He has taken on the considerable task of penetrating Mustafa's prose—“that is often metaphor-laden, rich and thick . . . [that] both entices and deters . . . with its elaborate weaving of Turkish, Arabic and Persian through the intermediary of the rhyming prose” (p. 167)—to extract a portrait of the man and a revisionist interpretation of his times that is illuminating and engaging. All the familiar events and characters of Süleyman's reign are here, but their recounting by Mustafa and re-evaluation by Şahin provide us with new insight.
Mustafa's family background and early career must be pieced together. His father was a madrasa teacher and judge from northern Anatolia, but he himself completed his education in Istanbul at a time when freeborn Muslims could enter the askeri ruling class, in the days before men of kul (slave) origins became fully ascendant. His father's contacts, as well as his own capacities, must have helped him find his first position, as a secretary of the imperial council in 1516; he rose to become chief secretary from 1525–34. In Şahin's words, Mustafa made “a wise career choice at a favourable moment,” (p. 28) implying that the job was his for the taking.
This is a book of two parts: Şahin first considers Mustafa's formative years and succeeding stages of his career at the heart of government, and then the image of the empire that he wished to emerge from his writings. In Mustafa's texts, these are intertwined. The events of the era are well known: Selim's response to the challenge presented by Shah Ismail set in motion a struggle on the military, cultural, and religious fronts that drew on ideas that included messianism, universal monarchy, and the Ottoman sultan-as-caliph, as these rivals sought pre-eminence in the Islamic world. But Selim's territorial conquests, achieved on the cusp of the gunpowder era in the Middle East and the more destructive warfare initiated by this weapon, were insecure, unless a convincing ideological discourse could be brought to prevail. Şahin sees the preamble of the new Egyptian law code of 1525 as a thoroughgoing manifesto for the emergent order, embodying the new “political theology” whereby the sultan-caliph was divinely ordained to reign both temporally and spiritually over his realm with perfect justice. Mustafa asserts that the complex law code and its preamble were devised by himself and Ibrahim Pasha, whom he accompanied to Egypt. Şahin shows how Mustafa, having been present at Süleyman's sieges of Rhodes and Belgrade, had picked his way cleverly through the vizieral struggles he describes in Tabakat, and was well placed to take advantage of the elevation of Ibrahim to the grand vizierate in 1524. As in the east, so in the west, where Süleyman's victory at Mohacs over a Christian king established his claims to divine sovereignty and universal monarchy against those of his European rivals, the neighbouring Habsburgs foremost among them. In Şahin's assessment, Süleyman could now inhabit his role more confidently, with Mustafa as his inspired propagandist.
Şahin proposes that the diploma that elevated Ibrahim to share power with the Sultan in 1529 was among the most sensitive of the many state documents that Mustafa composed. He explains how Mustafa's relationship with Ibrahim was tested during the less than glorious campaign of the “Two Iraqs” of 1534–36, albeit that Mustafa describes the conquest of Baghdad as a miracle, and a sign of the End Time. He was appointed chancellor during the campaign, and when he came to write of this episode, he deftly distanced himself from his patron. Ibrahim was executed soon after his return from the front, and Mustafa justifies this act with the benefit of hindsight, blaming Ibrahim for the partial failure of the campaign, saying that his character had changed so that his arrogance, as exemplified for instance in his use of the title “Sultan,” overwhelmed his piety. He was similarly circumspect regarding the execution of Prince Mustafa in 1553. By retiring in 1557, Şahin asserts, he spared himself the distasteful task of having to formulate a convincing line on the vicious succession struggle of Princes Selim and Bayezid of 1558–59.
Following Ibrahim's demise, the experimentation Süleyman's one-time favorite had promoted waned, and piety, law and order, and systematization and efficiency in administration, became the hallmarks of the regime. Denying the evidence of less than stellar military adventures and more equal diplomatic settlements, Mustafa composed elegant fictions to mask the shift in favor of the rivals of the Ottomans. As Şahin reveals, ideology and reality were drifting apart, and Mustafa adapted his language and tone to mask the unpalatable truth.
Mustafa gave the final form to his memoirs in his retirement. The Tabakat embodies the principles he had striven for—his insistence on bureaucratic merit, his enthusiastic imperialism, and his Sunni triumphalism as the bedrock of the Ottoman state. Perforce, he demonstrated a more conciliatory tone in the document produced at Amasya in 1555 to seal Ottoman containment of the Safavids, a milestone that was the last instance of state business in which he had a hand. Şahin affords us a glimpse of Mustafa's last years, in a dervish lodge in Eyüp, with attached garden and his own mosque complex nearby—a busy place, with poets, historians, and bureaucrats coming and going, visiting this paragon of their professions. The former chancellor came out of retirement to accompany Süleyman on the Sigetvar campaign in 1566, and was briefly re-appointed by Grand Vizier Sokullu Mehmed Pasha on the Sultan's death. He himself died the following year, still in office.
Şahin employs the analytic tools of today's historians, contending that Mustafa's self-conscious narrative should be viewed as being directed towards the protection and preservation of the system of which he was part, and as an assertion of his own place in that order. History writing was a lively arena during Süleyman's reign—Şahin sees a “historiographical explosion” (p. 162)—where many and varied writers set out their appraisals of the times in which they lived. Tabakat demands our attention not least by virtue of being the most detailed account of Süleyman's reign composed by a contemporary; moreover, it is written in the first person and includes key contemporary documents. Mustafa oversaw the development of bureaucratic institutions and practices that, as in other early modern Eurasian states, had to be capable of controlling extensive territories, managing elites, keeping records, and creating the various writings aimed at commanding the allegiance of the ruled to the monarch. As elsewhere at this time, ideas of “reason, efficiency, merit and law” (p. 215) were considered the litmus test of good governance.
As a postscript to his incisive study of one of the key figures of the Ottoman 16th century, Şahin reminds us how the trauma of the transition from empire to republic produced a variety of readings of the Ottoman state that are long since outmoded, and outlines how subsequent attempts to analyze it through less “Turkish” eyes typically positioned it prejudicially, above all as non-European. The Ottoman case is now included in wider debates about early modern state and empire formation—and Şahin's consideration of Celalzade Mustafa's career and writings is a significant contribution to these debates. Nevertheless, backsliding is still ubiquitous, and the tendency to view the Süleymanic age as the acme of Ottoman rule followed as it inevitably must be by decline, persists. As demonstrated in this volume, the new wisdom is far more interesting. With his scrutiny of Mustafa's life and work, Şahin has ensured that the voice of this participant–observer of events both great and small can no longer be disregarded. In doing this, he has added to the growing number of studies that are altering perceptions about Ottoman history. His book demands to be widely read, not least by the many historians for whom the Ottoman world of the 16th century has relevance.
