Sumptuously illustrated with panoramic photographs and exquisite close-ups, this volume attempts to be a survey of the major Mughal monuments and gardens in precolonial north India from the sixteenth to the early nineteenth century. At first glance, art historian George Michell and photographer Amit Pasricha's effort seems to be a rather heavy coffee table book. But after a closer engagement, the reader may realize that it requires more than just a cursory glance typically afforded to coffee table books. It provides extensive descriptions of design and contextualizes the architecture and gardens in their urban locales. The reader is taken from the Mughal capitals of Delhi, Agra, and Fatehpur Sikri to Kashmir in the north, a site of leisure for the royalty, and from Bengal in the east to Lahore in the west and Daulatabad in the southwest.
Michell gestures towards the intended audience, stating, “If the volume can in any way enthuse students and scholars, let alone influence the itineraries of interested travelers, then he will be well pleased” (p. 13). The authors succeed in addressing both academic and lay audiences to an extent. With the extensive contextualization of the sites supported with ground plans and by going beyond the traditional Mughal sites of Delhi and Agra into Kashmir and Bengal, the authors address art historians, architects, and landscape architects. Besides the introduction, however, the book consists of double-spread, glossy photographs supported with paragraphs of text that describe the design and layout of the sites and therefore seeks the attention of those with an amateur interest in the topic and prospective travelers. The photographs take center stage, and the supporting text functions almost like museum pedagogical labels. Given the large format, it is of course not a guidebook that can be carried by travelers. Instead, much like the nineteenth-century Murray and Baedeker handbooks, which quite unlike modern guidebooks contained extensive historical information so that tourists could “improve” themselves intellectually, this book also intends to inspire travelers to go off the beaten track.
The fairly extensive introduction is divided into four sections. The first traces the lineage of the Mughal visual idiom to Central Asia and Afghanistan, the homeland Babur missed so desperately and attempted to recreate through gardens, fruit trees, scented plants, and flowing water in a land described by him, in the Baburnama, as oppressively hot and humid and lacking the gardens and clear air of his homeland in Ferghana (Stephen Frederic Dale, “Steppe Humanism: The Autobiographical Writings of Zahir al-Din Muhammad Babur, 1483–1530,” International Journal of Middle East Studies 22, no. 1 (Feb. 1990), pp. 48–49). The second section illuminates various Mughal garden types such as those with multilevel terraces and those using the traditional charbagh layout—a garden divided into four square plots by intersecting water channels and walkways. Besides garden design, this section also describes the various technologies that made it possible to lift and conduct water into channels and fountains in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. The third section discusses the various “building typologies” that will be explored, such as palaces, forts, tombs, mosques, and service structures such as hammams (baths), suqs (markets), and baolis (step-wells). The last section describes the impact of building materials and techniques on design.
Despite this valuable information, the focus seems to be primarily on description and not on analysis. For example, the text for the Kala Burj in the seventeenth-century Lahore Fort mentions the presence of painted “flying angels and birds in European style” but does not explain the sociopolitical or cross-cultural implications of this imagery (p. 278). Unlike the work of Ebba Koch, Catherine Asher, and James Wescoat, who focus on visual symbolism, sociopolitical issues of patronage, and the relationship of architecture and garden design to painting, Michell's purpose is not to analyze designs but to simply tell the reader of their presence (for example, see Ebba Koch, Mughal Art and Imperial Ideology [New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2001]; Catherine Asher, Architecture of Mughal India [Cambridge, UK, and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992]; James L. Wescoat, ed., Mughal Gardens: Sources, Places, Representations, and Prospects [Washington, D.C.: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection, 1996]).
The introduction follows quite a school textbook-like, linear history of Mughal architectural and garden patronage. Beginning with terms such as “refinement” and “eclectic synthesis” to reference the patronage of Jahangir and Akbar, Shah Jahan's patronage is called the “climax” and that of Aurangzeb and his successors is described as being in “decline” (pp. 19–25). While the patronage of the early Mughal rulers is praised, Michell states that, “over time … Mughal architecture passed on from an era of innovation to one of mere repetition thereby losing much of its initial inventiveness” (p. 19). Art historians tend not to relate political disorder to artistic decline and therefore such an analysis in a 2011 book is surprising. In addition, the French term “arabesque,” meaning “in the Arab fashion,” is used to describe vegetal designs. While art historians used this term in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, few use it today because of its links to an earlier Orientalist mindset that assumes an essential Arab-ness in vegetal patterns (see Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. “Vegetal Patterns in Islamic Art.” http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/vege/hd_vege.htm).
Overall, however, with its focus on previously understudied Mughal sites such as Kashmir, it is a very valuable addition to art history survey texts, which are lacking in the non-Western sub-field. The photographs, in particular, will be extremely useful for teaching, especially because Pasricha includes interiors of buildings such as the sixteenth-century Jamali and Kamali tomb in Delhi, which are often difficult to access without official permission.
