Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:53:52.311Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Nudging-based data assimilation of the turbulent flow around a square cylinder

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 March 2022

M. Zauner
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, F-92190 Meudon, France
V. Mons*
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, F-92190 Meudon, France
O. Marquet
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, F-92190 Meudon, France
B. Leclaire
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, F-92190 Meudon, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: vincent.mons@onera.fr

Abstract

We investigate the estimation of the turbulent flow around a canonical square cylinder at $Re=22\,000$ based on temporally resolved but spatially sparse velocity data and solving the unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (URANS) equations. Flow reconstruction from sparse data is achieved through the application of a nudging data assimilation technique. It involves the introduction of a feedback control term in the momentum equations which allows us to drive URANS predictions towards reference data, which are here extracted from a direct numerical simulation. Such a data assimilation approach induces negligible supplementary computational cost compared with that of a standard URANS simulation. The influence of the spatial resolution of the reference data on the reconstruction performances is systematically investigated. Using a spacing of the order of one cylinder length between data points, we already observe synchronisation of the low-frequency vortex shedding between the full reference flow and the one that is estimated by URANS. The present data assimilation procedure allows us to compensate for deficiencies in standard URANS calculations and leads to a significant decrease in temporal and spectral errors as computed by spectral proper orthogonal decomposition. Furthermore, high accuracy in terms of mean-flow prediction by URANS is achieved. When considering spacings between measurements that are of the order of the wavelength of the Kelvin–Helmholtz vortices, such phenomena in the shear layers at the top and bottom of the cylinder are correctly estimated, while they are not self-sustained in standard URANS. The influence of the structure of the feedback control term in the data assimilation procedure is also investigated.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Sketch of the computational domain $\varOmega$ for URANS simulations, where red dots denote positions $(\boldsymbol {x}_{k})_{k=1 \dots M}$ of velocity measurements in the internal domain $\varOmega _{I}$ (bounded by the red frame). These so-called nudging points are uniformly separated in both directions by a spacing distance $\Delta s$. The domain that is external to the measurement area is denoted as $\varOmega _{E}$. (b) Typical triangular mesh used for the standard and nudged URANS simulations around a square cylinder.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Results for (a,b) reference (DNS) and (c,d) estimated (standard URANS) flows. (a,c) Instantaneous spanwise vorticity field $\bar {\omega }_z$ at $t=50$, where black iso-curves denote $\left \langle \bar {u} \right \rangle =0$. (b,d) Fourier spectrum of the streamwise velocity at the green monitor point in panels (a,c) (full black line). For the sake of comparison, the DNS spectrum is duplicated in panel (d) with the grey curve. Vertical dashed and dotted lines indicate the low-frequency peak associated with large-scale VS ($St_{VS}=0.137$ for DNS while $St_{VS}=0.126$ for URANS) and the high-frequency bump linked to KH instabilities ($St_{KH}=4.384$ for DNS), respectively.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Instantaneous vorticity fields of (a–c) the reference flow $\boldsymbol {\bar {u}}_{r}$ (DNS) and (d–f) estimated flow $\bar {\boldsymbol {u}}$ (standard URANS) at times (a,d) $t=15$, (b,e) $t=30$ and (c,f) $t=150$. (g–i) Instantaneous error fields $e(\boldsymbol {x},t)$ between the reference and estimated flows (definition in (2.5)) at the corresponding instants. (j) Temporal evolution of the global error $E(t)$ (see (2.6a,b)), where the bottom axis reports the (non-dimensional) time while the top axis reports the number of low-frequency cycles determined as $t/\tau _{VS}=t \, St_{VS}$ with $St_{VS} = 0.137$. The grey circles indicate times $t=15$, $30$ and $150$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a,b) Streamwise component of the time-averaged (a) reference flow $\langle \bar {\boldsymbol {u}}_{r} \rangle$ (DNS) and (b) estimated flow $\langle \bar {\boldsymbol {u}} \rangle$ (standard URANS). (c) Associated discrepancy field $e_{\langle \bar {\boldsymbol {u}} \rangle }$ as defined in (2.7). In panels (a,b), black curves correspond to contours of zero streamwise time-averaged velocity, which delineate the recirculation region.

Figure 4

Figure 5.SPOD analysis of the VS phenomenon in the reference (DNS) and estimated (standard URANS) flows: streamwise velocity contours of the imaginary part of the dominant (a) DNS and (c) URANS SPOD modes for the fundamental frequency $St_{VS}$. Modes are phased so that each of them reaches its maximum value at the green monitor point. (b) Spectra showing the largest eigenvalue $\lambda$ as a function of the frequency $St$ in the low-frequency range $0 \leqslant St \leqslant 1$ for DNS (black curve) and URANS (grey curve). The vertical lines indicate low-frequency peaks at $St_{VS}=0.137$ and their harmonics for DNS results. The modal discrepancy field $\varPhi _e$ in (2.8) between the modes in panels (a,c) is reported in panel (d).

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Contours of transverse velocity fluctuations are shown for the real part of the dominant SPOD mode of DNS that is associated with KH instabilities ($St_{KH}=4.384$, only captured with DNS). (b) Spectra showing the largest eigenvalue $\lambda$ as a function of the frequency $St$ in the high-frequency range $1 \leqslant St \leqslant 7$. Black and light grey curves correspond to DNS and URANS results, respectively.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a–c) Contours of transverse velocity fluctuations are shown for the real part of the dominant SPOD mode at (a) $St=3.454$ (vertical dashed line in panel (d)), (b) $St=St_{KH}=4.384$ (vertical full line in panel (d)) and (c) $St=6.510$ (vertical dash-dotted line in panel (d)) for a URANS calculation in which white noise is injected at the black dot. (d) Spectra showing the largest eigenvalue $\lambda$ as a function of the frequency $St$ in the high-frequency range $1 \leqslant St \leqslant 7$. Black and light grey curves correspond to DNS and unperturbed URANS results, respectively, while the dark grey curve refers to the URANS calculation with white noise.

Figure 7

Table 1.Time-averaged and unsteady characteristics of the flow obtained with DNS and standard URANS simulations. The first two columns report the maximal lift variation and time-averaged drag coefficients, respectively. The remaining columns report the dominant eigenvalue $\lambda$ for various frequencies $St$ from the SPOD analysis, considering the fundamental harmonic for the von Kármán VS, its second (${VS,2}$) and third (${VS,3}$) harmonics, and the dominant frequency for the broadband emission of KH vortices.

Figure 8

Table 2.Description of three groups of measurement datasets which are named from the targeted flow phenomenon by the nudging approach: the von Kármán VS, the KH vortices and both phenomena ($\textrm {VS}+\textrm {KH}$). Their frequency $St$ and period $\tau =1/St$ as captured by DNS are recalled in the second and third columns, respectively. These dataset groups are characterised by the time interval between consecutive measurements $\Delta t$ (fifth column), the number of measurement snapshots $N_m$ (sixth column) and the total measurement time $T_m$ (seventh column). The last two columns report the number of snapshots per cycle (of the target flow phenomenon) and the total number of cycles.

Figure 9

Table 3.Test matrix indicating, for the three dataset groups VS, KH and $\textrm {VS}+\textrm {KH}$ in table 2, the number of measurement points $N_{s} = \lambda _{x}/\Delta s$ that sample the wavelength $\lambda _{x}$ of the corresponding spatial structures (indicated in the fourth column of table 2) when varying the spatial sampling $\Delta s$. For instance, the dataset VS(a) corresponds to $(\lambda _{x}=4.00,\Delta s=0.03125)$, thus $N_s=128$.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Results for (a,b) standard and (c,d) nudged URANS with the dataset $\textrm {VS}+\textrm {KH}$(a). (a,c) Instantaneous spanwise vorticity field $\bar {\omega }_z$ at $t=50$, where black iso-curves denote $\left \langle \bar {u} \right \rangle =0$. The extent of the nudging region is delineated by black lines in panel (c). (b,d) Fourier spectrum of the streamwise velocity at the green monitor point in panels (a,c) (full black line). For the sake of comparison, the DNS spectrum is also reported (full grey line, well hidden in panel (d)). Vertical dashed and dotted lines indicate the low-frequency peak associated with large-scale VS and the high-frequency bump linked to KH instabilities, respectively.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Instantaneous vorticity fields of (a–c) the reference flow $\bar {\boldsymbol {u}}_{r}$ and (d–f) the estimated flow $\bar {\boldsymbol {u}}$, with nudging relying on the dataset $\textrm {VS}+\textrm {KH}$(a) at times (a,d) $t=15$, (b,e) $t=30$ and (c,f) $t=150$. (g–i) Instantaneous error fields $e(\boldsymbol {x},t)$ between the reference and nudged flows (see (2.5)). (i) Temporal evolution of the global error $E(t)$ (see (2.6a,b)) between the nudged and reference flows (black curve) and between the standard URANS and reference flows (grey curve). The bottom axis reports the (non-dimensional) time while the top axis reports the number of low-frequency cycles determined as $t/\tau _{VS}=t \, St_{VS}$ with $St_{VS} = 0.137$. The grey circles indicate times $t=15$, $30$ and $150$.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Temporal evolution of (a) external error $E_{E}$ and (b) internal error $E_{I}$ (see (3.5)) for standard URANS (grey lines) and nudged URANS with the dataset $\textrm {VS}+\textrm {KH}$(a) (black lines).

Figure 13

Figure 11.Results for nudged URANS simulations in dataset group VS with spatial spacings (a,b) $\Delta s = 1.66$, (c,d) $\Delta s = 1.5$, (e,f) $\Delta s = 0.5$ and (g,h) $\Delta s = 0.125$. (a,c,e,g) Instantaneous spanwise vorticity field $\bar {\omega }_{z}$ at $t=50$, where black iso-curves denote $\left \langle \bar {u} \right \rangle =0$, while dots refer to nudging points. (b,d,f,h) Fourier spectrum of the streamwise velocity at the green monitor point in panels (a,c,e,g) (full black line), the reference spectrum to recover is also reported (full grey curve). Vertical dashed lines indicate the low-frequency peak associated with large-scale VS.

Figure 14

Figure 12.(a) Dominant Strouhal number and (b) phase angle with respect to reference results as a function of the spacing between nudging points $\Delta s$, or equivalently the number $N_{s}$ of nudging points per characteristic wavelength, for nudged URANS simulations of dataset group VS. Results are obtained from the Fourier analysis of the signal at the same monitor point as in figure 11. Filled symbols correspond to the case where the estimated shedding frequency is $St_{VS}=0.137$, as in DNS results, while open symbols correspond to $St_{VS}=0.126$, as in standard URANS.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Time-averaged errors as a function of the spacing between nudging points $\Delta s$, or equivalently the number $N_{s}$ of nudging points per characteristic wavelength, for nudged URANS simulations of dataset group VS. (a) Total error $\langle E \rangle$ in (2.6a,b), which may be decomposed as the sum of (b) internal $\langle {E_I} \rangle$ (black symbols) and external errors $\langle {E_E} \rangle$ (grey symbols). The reported values are normalised by the total time-averaged error for the standard URANS solution. Filled symbols correspond to the case where the estimated shedding frequency is $St_{VS}=0.137$, as in DNS results, while open symbols correspond to $St_{VS}=0.126$, as in standard URANS.

Figure 16

Figure 14.(a) Frequency and (b) kinetic energy of the dominant SPOD mode corresponding to VS as a function of the spatial sampling $\Delta s$ for nudged URANS simulations of dataset group VS. The dashed and dash-dotted horizontal lines in panel (b) correspond to the energy of the SPOD mode for the standard URANS and reference solutions, respectively. The spatial structure of a few modes is displayed in figure 15. Filled symbols correspond to the case where the estimated shedding frequency is $St_{VS}=0.137$, as in DNS results, while open symbols correspond to $St_{VS}=0.126$, as in standard URANS.

Figure 17

Figure 15.SPOD analysis of the VS phenomenon for nudged URANS simulations in dataset group VS with spatial spacings (a,b) $\Delta s = 1.66$, (c,d) $\Delta s = 1.5$, (e,f) $\Delta s = 0.5$ and (g,h) $\Delta s = 0.125$. (a,c,e,g) Streamwise velocity contours of the imaginary part of the dominant SPOD mode for the fundamental frequency $St_{VS}$. While the frequency of the mode in panel (a) is $St_{VS}=0.126$, remaining modes oscillate at $St_{VS}=0.137$. Modes are phased so that each of them reaches its maximum value at the green monitor point. (b,d,f,h) Corresponding modal discrepancy field $\varPhi _e$ in (2.8).

Figure 18

Figure 16.Mean-flow results for nudged URANS simulations in dataset group VS with spatial spacing (a,b) $\Delta s = 1.66$, (c,d) $\Delta s = 1.5$, (e,f) $\Delta s = 0.5$ and (g,h) $\Delta s = 0.125$. (a,c,e,g) Streamwise component of the mean flow. Black curves correspond to the isocontours of zero streamwise velocity. (b,d,f,h) Mean-flow error field $e_{\langle \bar {\boldsymbol {u}}\rangle }$ in (2.7). The extent of the nudging region is delineated by black lines.

Figure 19

Figure 17.(a) Spatially integrated mean-flow error $\int _{\varOmega _{\langle \bar {\boldsymbol {u}}\rangle }} e_{\langle \bar {\boldsymbol {u}} \rangle } (\boldsymbol {x})^{2} \,\textrm {d}\boldsymbol {x}$ of the nudged URANS simulations of dataset group VS as a function of the spatial sampling $\Delta s$. This integrated error is evaluated over a spatial domain $\varOmega$ that extends in the streamwise direction in the range $-1.5 \leqslant x \leqslant 12.5$ and is restricted in the cross-stream direction to (squares) $-4 \leqslant y \leqslant 4$ or (circles) $-1.5 \leqslant y \leqslant 1.5$. (b) The integrated error in the restricted domain $-1.5 \leqslant y \leqslant 1.5$ is decomposed as the sum of internal (black) and external (grey) errors with respect to the nudging region. Reported values are normalised by the corresponding error of the standard URANS solution.

Figure 20

Figure 18.SPOD analysis of KH phenomena as estimated by nudged URANS simulations for the dataset group KH with (a,b) $N_s=1$ ($\Delta s=0.25$), (c,d) $N_s=2$ ($\Delta s=0.125$), (e,f) $N_s=4$ ($\Delta s=0.0625$) and (g,h) $N_s=8$ ($\Delta s=0.03125$) nudging points per wavelength of the KH instabilities. (a,c,e,g) Real part of the transverse component of the SPOD mode for $St_{KH}=4.384$ and (b,d,f,h) SPOD spectrum for nudged URANS (black), the DNS results (grey) are also reported for the sake of comparison.

Figure 21

Figure 19.Results for nudged URANS simulations in dataset group VS with spatial spacing $\Delta s = 1.5$ where nudging is applied either (a,b) in its standard punctual form or (c,d) through interpolant. (a,c) Instantaneous spanwise vorticity field $\bar {\omega }_{z}$ at $t=50$, where black iso-curves denote $\left \langle \bar {u} \right \rangle =0$, while dots refer to nudging points. (b,d) Fourier spectrum of the streamwise velocity at the green monitor point in panels (a,c) (full black line), the reference spectrum to recover is also reported (full grey curve). Vertical dashed lines indicate the low-frequency peak associated with large-scale VS.

Figure 22

Figure 20.Real part of the transverse component of the SPOD mode for $St_{KH}=4.384$ for nudged URANS simulations in dataset group KH with $\Delta s=0.125$ where nudging is applied either (a) in its standard punctual form or (b) through interpolant.

Figure 23

Table 4.Sensitivity of time-averaged total, internal, external errors (respectively $\langle {E} \rangle$, $\langle {E}_I \rangle$ and $\langle {E}_E \rangle$), and forcing magnitudes ($\langle ||f_x||^{2}\rangle$ and $\langle ||f_y||^{2}\rangle$) to the nudging coefficient $\alpha$ for the dataset of group VS with $\Delta s=0.125$ (see tables 2 and 3). In the fourth and fifth rows, the values of $\langle ||f_x||^{2}\rangle$ and $\langle ||f_y||^{2}\rangle$ are normalised by their values for standard URANS.

Figure 24

Figure 21.Sketch of (a) standard punctual and (b) interpolant-based nudging. The black triangular mesh corresponds to the one that is used to solve the nudged URANS equations (with associated basis functions $(\varphi _{i})_{i=1 \dots N_{u}}$). Red dots refer to measurement locations $(\boldsymbol {x}_{k})_{k=1 \dots M}$. In panel (b), these locations are used as vertices of the so-called measurement mesh which is reported in red (with associated basis functions $(\tilde {\varphi }_{k})_{k=1 \dots M}$).