Subalterns and Social Protest is a volume that attempts to challenge history and historiography of the Middle East and North Africa “from above” by assigning agency to nonelite social groups. In terms of its historical span, extending from the 16th century to the present, and its geographical diversity, the collection is a unique contribution to the effort of recovering the subaltern margins of society. The volume includes an introduction and twelve essays, which are grouped into six parts: the urban crowd and popular protest, poor-people's politics, peasants and nomads, marginals and outcasts, European subalterns, and subalterns and national movements.
Part I focuses on urban centers as sites of intense popular political activity. James Grehan examines social protest in Ottoman Damascus from the 16th to the 18th centuries, and Vanessa Martin directs her attention to the role women played in political demonstrations leading up to the Constitutional Revolution in Iran. Both articles point to the importance of bread riots and in that respect suggest the notion of “moral economy” developed by E. P. Thompson to describe crowds as defenders of customary practices.
Part II deals with different forms of resistance and self-defense adopted by subordinate groups when faced with the challenges of heightened political control or economic reorganization. John Chalcraft examines the resistance movements of workers and small cultivators in 19th- and early 20th-century Egypt, Asef Bayat deals with the struggles of the unemployed in postrevolutionary Iran, and Lamia Zaki focuses on shantytown dwellers’ fight for electricity in Casablanca during the late 1990s. Despite vast differences in time and space, the articles intersect well, as they all deal with creative forms of resistance devised by subaltern groups.
Part III, composed of a single article, focuses on the rural poor. In her detailed study of the countryside in early Pahlavi Iran, Stephanie Cronin links the emergence of novel forms of consciousness among the rural poor to changes in the relations of production in the countryside. In that respect, her research findings coincide with those in Part I.
Part IV brings further social extremes into sight with its focus on Gypsies and slaves. Faika Çelik discusses how Gypsies were conceptualized legally and socially at the margins of Ottoman state and society in the 15th and 16th centuries. Fatiha Loualich directs her attention to emancipated female slaves in Algiers in the 16th to 18th centuries. Given that both groups have very little voice in the “archives,” the articles attempt to discover the invisible in documents such as imperial decrees, sultanic laws, and notarial deeds.
Part IV comprises two very innovative and well-written articles dealing with European migrant workers under a “veiled protectorate” regime in precolonial Tunis and Egypt (1882–1914). Focusing on the networks they established to empower themselves, Julia Clancy-Smith's treatment of former slaves presents them not as marginal but as strongly rooted in Tunisian society. Anthony Gorman's discussion of European migrant workers conveys their influential role in the development of an international movement that sought to defend the rights of both Egyptian and foreign workers.
The final section analyzes the role of subalterns in nationalist movements and questions the forms of inclusion and exclusion of these groups in elite agendas during the periods before and after independence. Although imbued with discomforting essentialist assumptions (exemplified by phrases such as “Ottoman-occupied Greek lands” [p. 263] or “strong dislike of Ottomans towards the sea” [p. 266]), Gerasimos Karabelias's article discusses the important role of bandits in the Greek war of independence (1821–33) and their altered position vis-à-vis political authority after the creation of the new state. In a similar way, Roger Heacock details how the underprivileged in the “occupied territories”—or those lands lost by Israel's Arab neighbors and gained by Israel in the Six Day War, including Judaea and Samaria (previously occupied by Jordan and now known as the West Bank), the Golan Heights (previously part of Syria), and the Gaza Strip (previously occupied by Egypt)—showed the greatest readiness for resistance and agency, as opposed to local elites who were reluctant to lead a movement.
Some of the articles communicate closely with each other despite being situated in different sections. For example, Cronin's conclusions fit well with those of Chalcraft because both associate peasants’ discontent with new forms of social exploitation and commercialization. Due to his interest in the working classes and the patterns of their organization against new commercialized market forces, Gorman's article also dialogues with that of Chalcraft. Clancy-Smith's article likewise appears as a counterpart to Loualich's study because they both discuss the life prospects of freed slaves in societies built on lineage and kinship networks.
The collection as a whole attempts to uncover the “politics of the people” in its effort to write “history from below” and thus restore a sense of agency to subaltern social classes by highlighting their ability to pioneer action and play crucial roles in historical change. In that respect, the book aims to “rescue the ordinary people” by recognizing their “consciousness, agency and independence” (p. 2).
The articles employ a range of theoretical and methodological approaches, including British Marxism, subaltern studies, and the Gramscian notion of “independent initiative on the part of the subaltern groups” (p. 19). E. P. Thompson's concept of a “moral economy” of the poor serves as a theoretical frame of several chapters, especially those pointing to the defensive character of subaltern activism and its particular emergence in key transitional periods. As the authors suggest, while the state was becoming centralized and modernized, and the economy more market oriented and competitive, negatively affected groups (which were most often situated at the lower levels of the social scale) demanded a return to the “good old days” when justice was more equitably distributed. Popular discourse often demanded a return to what was imagined as the status quo ante. Therefore, concepts such as “natural justice” or “legitimate authority” appeared frequently. Although this does not necessarily mean that such groups were always conservative, their discourse usually intimated that the altered forms of governance were corrupt. The effort should also be seen as one performed by those who were relatively powerless to negotiate and negate the terms of change by using the ideological tools available to them.
One note of caution regarding studies on subaltern groups is that, as the name of the book suggests, we mostly hear the voices of those who took part in some form of “social protest,” such as riots, rebellions, or other acts of resistance. If, as the editor of the volume suggests, “subaltern groups most often emerge” on center stage only during episodes of social protest, “tend to appear in the written sources only when they withdraw their cooperation from elite projects and agendas” (p. 2), and otherwise remain invisible, subsumed, or hidden from scholarly inquiry, then it becomes a serious theoretical and methodological problem for the researcher to hear the voices or write the history of those who did not protest or resist. In other words, establishment of an organic link between protest and the appearance of the subaltern might also limit the reaches of our scholarly inquiry regarding survival strategies of those “below.” How can we trace their methods of coping? Because most of the studies focus on elite discourses and subsequent dissent by the oppressed, we do not have a sense of subordinated groups that exhibited no signs of dissent but instead resorted to accommodation and adjustment. Hence, hearing subaltern voices presents an even more difficult task than that which is typically associated with the subaltern-studies field.
Moreover, it is necessary to note the hierarchical nature of relationships within largely conceived subaltern categories themselves. It is usually the relatively empowered sections within a larger subordinated group on which the researcher is able to focus. In other words, what can be discovered and brought to the forefront in the study of subaltern groups may be biased in its privileging of the power of the opposition and thus fail to recover the silences of common people from oblivion.
Scholars of the Middle East and North Africa have communicated the difficulties they face identifying, locating, and utilizing source material. Diaries, memoirs, and other such sources exist only in limited numbers even for the upper classes. While ethnographic studies and oral histories can bring us closer to the experiences of marginal groups in contemporary times, historical subalterns are hidden in the obscure corridors of bureaucratic chains of knowledge. Therefore, studies on nonelite and nonliterate groups require a process of creative reading or rereading of the sources in order to find otherwise unnoticeable details regarding ordinary people's points of view. Still, the assertion of this compilation's editor that there has been little success in using police, prison, and legal records in Middle Eastern and North African contexts seems to be an underestimation when the large body of literature based on Ottoman police and court records (sijil) is considered. Although legal sources usually provide only a “thin” description of the experiences of ordinary people, the “social history” of the Middle East has been and continues to be written in large part thanks to court records. It is incontestable that such studies point to a fairly significant success.
The historical depth and geographical reach of this volume leaves the reader with fruitful inspiration for new inquiries. One concerns the relationship between modernity and the emergence of centralized efforts to manage, govern, or restrain the masses. For instance, how were the demands to sedentarize the Gypsies during the Ottoman Empire's “classical age” different from those exerted on nomads in Iran's early Pahlavi period? If 16th-century Gypsies were as resistant to certain forms of centralization (sedentarization, taxation, etc.) as 20th-century Iranian peasants were to accepting the modern state's new regulations on private property and taxation, then what differentiates the two regimes and their respective forms of dissent from one another? What are the meaningful differences and similarities between a relatively centralized empire and a modern state?
Despite the obvious complications related to theory and sources in subaltern studies on the Middle East and North Africa, Subalterns and Social Protest is a courageous attempt to focus on the oppressed and excluded and a remarkable challenge to the elitist nature of historiography.
