Roger B. Manning follows a series of known as well as lesser-known writers from Heraclitus to Kant who have dealt with issues of war and peace by presenting them in the context of their historical periods. The novelty in this work is that not only is this a treatise on theories of war—of which there are too many—but it also attempts to give equal space to theories of peace. Thus, we learn about the development of just war theory, attempts to reduce violence in war, the realities of Pax Romana, the notions of holy wars, and the thought of Machiavelli and his contemporaries More and Erasmus, until we finally reach the Enlightenment. There are connections and continuities, including stimulating cross-references. While giving us this grand overview, Manning also provides interesting side observations. He remarks on the Gate of Janus in Rome, the closure of which when there was peace in the Empire was a rare occurrence (1–2). He mentions Wulfila who banned the Old Testament from being translated into the Goth language as it dealt with war in an “inflammatory” way (63). Most peace utopias, Manning observes, describe perfect communities on the periphery of the European world, and so do not really confront the war of the larger world surrounding them (197–98).
Thus, this work is an important achievement in its ambition to trace peace thinking through the ages. It comes at a time when international peace studies also have begun to take up this topic. For instance, “exploring peace” was the theme of the International Studies Association in 2016, which invited more empirical studies of peace as an independent phenomenon. Manning demonstrates the theoretical complexities of simultaneously achieving internal peace (within a state or an empire) and external peace (the need to defend borders). Most thinkers attempt to solve only one of these problems, or avoid both altogether in order to pursue an ethically satisfactory and coherent position seemingly without regard for political realities.
Manning displays a continuity in the peace discourses through the ages. Some themes that always engaged philosophers are, for instance, the merits or dangers of mercenaries and standing armies. These are elements that Greek philosophers confronted, as did Immanuel Kant, without anyone evidently finding a generally applicable solution. The issue of unintentionally inviting war is also a matter that transcends the ages. In the times addressed by Manning, this issue related primarily to the navy and its possible provocative impact on outsiders. These examples indicate that the technological changes in warfare during the two thousand years covered by the book were relatively limited compared to what followed in the last two centuries. The effects of the industrial revolution on economies, wars, and peace include chauvinism, world wars, air bombings, and nuclear weapons, as well as humanitarian action, democratization, gender equality, and the Internet. These changes could reduce the relevance of this array of thinkers for our present predicaments and solutions.
However, there are perennial themes that require consideration. Military coups continue to plague societies, sometimes resulting in civil war and international intervention, just as was observed by the philosophers. Thus, the problem of standing armies remains, and the ability of civil society (a notion Manning seems to attribute to Ferguson and Smith, 260–61) to withstand them is a continued challenge. The ideas of war as a last resort and as requiring the proper declaration to be legitimate are still important. Particularly pertinent is Manning's extensive section on Holy War and crusades. He establishes that this is a notion from post-Roman times that was elaborated in Christianity as well as in Islam and that both fostered the belief that defeat in such a war provides a fast track to heaven/paradise, thus increasing the intensity of fighting.
Kant is credited by Manning as being “the first major philosopher to imagine a world free of war” (257). Kant's Perpetual Peace is consequently presented in detail and described as one of the “last works of the Enlightenment” (260). Published in 1795 and a best seller in its time, Kant's essay continues to have an impact. Its influence definitely extends beyond many of the other writers that are presented from this age, with the exception of Thomas Hobbes and Adam Smith. However, ending the presentation at this particular time makes sense, although one would wish for another volume of thinkers from our time.
If Kant is one of the last thinkers that Manning discusses, one of the first is the Roman “man of peace” Cicero. Manning points out that he is often misquoted. His well-known statement that “laws are silent during wartime” was uttered by Cicero when defending a man in a murder trial and was nothing but “rhetorical flourish,” Manning asserts. It referred to chaos created by armed mobs. However, it has often been used as a justification for excessive violence in wars. In reality, Cicero had an ethical position that argued for restraint in the use of wars and even advocated a negotiated settlement with Carthage (29–30). Similarly, Manning repeats throughout the book that Pax Romana was not as peaceful as has been claimed. There was an element of internal peace, but Rome was permanently engaged in wars in defending or expanding its external borders. This, then, remains one of the challenges forwarded to peace thinkers by Manning: is it possible to achieve both external and internal peace through peaceful means? He does not offer a solution, but points to Benedict Spinoza's attempt at defining a stable state that does not pose threats to its inhabitants or instill fear in its neighbors, while being strong enough to repel an attack (252). What kind of wisdom that can bring about this sophisticated position, we are left to wonder.
Manning's book is full of interesting observations and learned reflections. It is a pleasure to read. There is not much more to wish for, except that Voltaire, surprisingly, is entirely absent from the discussion on Enlightenment. Also, in this long history of thinking about peace, only one female writer is introduced, albeit a highly interesting one: Anna Comnena, daughter to Byzantine Emperor Alexius I (90). Furthermore, in a rich book like this, a more elaborate index would have been useful. That does not deflect from the fact that this is a timely volume which should find its place in any syllabus on peace, or on war, for that matter.
