What is Enlightenment? In 1784, the German philosopher Immanuel Kant famously asked and answered this question, declaring that ‘Enlightenment is mankind's exit from its self-incurred immaturity.’ ‘Public’ enlightenment, Kant urged, was ‘nearly inevitable’, if only the public were ‘allowed freedom’. For Enlightenment, ‘nothing more is required than freedom … namely the freedom to make a public use of one's reason in all matters’, he proclaimed.Footnote 1 Ostensibly universalist and cosmopolitan, Kant's vision of Enlightenment was predicated on a belief that the autonomous exercise of reason was a fundamental characteristic of humanity. As twenty-first-century philosophers and intellectual historians have, however, abundantly demonstrated, Kant's universalism was both imbricated with and undercut by his repeated theorisations and exemplifications of human difference. ‘In the critical philosophy Kant writes as if all humans, regardless of race or gender, have reason,’ Theodore Vial observes. ‘Yet in [his] writings about non-Europeans and women, many people seem to be deficient in reason.’Footnote 2 Kant's 1775 essay ‘Of the Different Human Races’, his 1785 essay on ‘Determination of the Concept of Human Race’ and his 1788 essay ‘On the Use of Teleological Principles in Philosophy’, indeed, played such foundational roles in theorising ‘natural’ human differences that some scholars credit him ‘with “inventing” the concept of race’.Footnote 3 Feminist critics have likewise underlined the exclusionary implications of Kant's dim view of women's ability to reason. Any laboured learning ‘or painful pondering’ the female of the species undertook, Kant suggested, worked against the natural grain of her limited understanding; a scholarly woman, he observed, ‘might as well even have a beard’.Footnote 4
Over the past two decades, historians have done much to illuminate the central tension in Enlightenment treatises between universalism, on the one hand, and perceptions of gender- and race-based difference, on the other.Footnote 5 In this lecture I build on those foundations, by interrogating the imperial and material pathways by which universalism, gender and race came to be instantiated in – and erased from – the Enlightenment museum. Eighteenth-century European museums were physical, material and organisational structures calculated to elicit the autonomous, public exercise of reason.Footnote 6 They thus lie at the heart of the Enlightenment project, and share its conflicted, questionable claims to universalism. To surface these issues, I explore the colonial collecting practices that brought material objects from the Middle East into Europe's Enlightenment museums. Beginning my lecture in Bloomsbury, in the present-day Enlightenment Gallery of the British Museum, I travel to Enlightenment-era Bombay, Basra and Baghdad, with brief excursions to the ruins of ancient Babylon and to Kurdistan, before returning to contemporary London. This vantage point affords an opportunity to integrate an analysis of late Enlightenment colonial collecting cultures with some preliminary reflections on potential next steps for the twenty-first-century agenda of decolonising the museum.Footnote 7
My lecture is underpinned by three basic research questions. It begins by asking, ‘How “universal” is the universal museum?’ The Altes Museum in Berlin, the British Museum in Bloomsbury, Paris's Louvre and New York's Met are all commonly described as universal museums. This usage has recently become a central plank in museums’ defensive platforms, in the face of increasingly clamorous claims for the restoration of heritage objects.Footnote 8 Assertions of the European museum's universalism, of course, have an extended genealogy, one that is rooted in the museum's Enlightenment function as a built environment designed to foster the public's exercise of reason through scientific scrutiny of global material cultures.Footnote 9 Here, instead, I underscore the contribution of Enlightenment imperialism to the making of these museum collections. My second research question, then, is ‘How colonial or imperial was the Enlightenment universal museum?’ This is hardly a novel material turn on my part.Footnote 10 My bookshelves bulge with studies of Enlightenment collectors such as Sir Joseph Banks and Sir Hans Sloane, contextualised within a colonial frame, and excellent new studies are now extending this line of analysis to less familiar eighteenth- and nineteenth-century museum donors.Footnote 11 My third research question is more novel. It adds another gender to this male mix by asking: what happens to our understanding of the universal museum and its entanglement with Enlightenment colonial collecting practices if we not only posit that there were women in the Enlightenment, but also acknowledge that imperialising women contributed to the making of the Enlightenment museum? By inserting women back into the Enlightenment Gallery of the British Museum, I hope to accomplish two main goals. The first is to reveal more fully the broad spectrum of social, material and political practices that undergirded East India Company collecting cultures in the Enlightenment era. My second purpose is to use the archival traces left by European women to recover contributions made to colonial collecting by male and female South Asian and Middle Eastern labourers, servants, go-betweens and governing elites. For, if we are to contextualise – much less to decolonise – the museum, these historical agents and their vital engagement with the Enlightenment's conflicted universal histories will also demand to be acknowledged.
I
To visit the British Museum's Enlightenment Gallery today is to stand in the centre of a universal museum. Or, is it? The celebration of the Museum's 250th anniversary in 2003 saw this gallery reopen after a major refurbishment engineered to explore ‘the way people of the time looked at the “natural and artificial curiosities” being collected from all over the world by scholars and collectors, who then sought to make sense of their past and their present’. For Neil MacGregor, then the Museum's director, Enlightenment universalism was the taproot that had fed the Museum's evolving practices of collecting and display from its foundation in 1753 through the late Enlightenment of the 1820s. MacGregor argued that Enlightenment universalism, recast for ‘an age of global citizenship’, also provided the justification for the Museum's continued existence in the twenty-first century. ‘The universal scope of the Museum's collections’, he suggested, made the British Museum ‘a unique repository of the achievements of human endeavour’ and thus ‘truly the memory of mankind’.Footnote 12 Part I of the exhibition catalogue published to accompany the gallery's relaunch was, appropriately, entitled ‘The Universal Museum’, and the title of the volume itself celebrated the European Enlightenment's ‘discovery’ of the world.Footnote 13
From the vantage point of 2019, the ‘discovery’ paradigm now appears inherently flawed, suggesting that Europe is the centre of the universe, and that Europeans were precocious or are exceptional in the exercise of their reason.Footnote 14 Three significant absences, moreover, mark the Enlightenment Gallery's celebration of an enduring universalism born in the age of reason. The first is empire, and is closely implicated with the second – which is slavery. Both of these defining features of the Enlightenment universe are at once conspicuously on display in the gallery's material culture and curiously invisible in the textual interpretations that elaborate on exhibited objects’ identity and meanings. An informed visitor is, for example, struck by the embodiment of imperialism and slavery manifest in the gallery's many busts. Sir Hans Sloane, the Irish physician whose collecting began in earnest in 1687 when he resided in the British slave colony of Jamaica and whose West Indian specimens were among the British Museum's founding collections, and Sir Joseph Banks, the botanist who accompanied Captain Cook on his first Pacific voyages and later advised the British government to colonise Australia, are both prominently on display.Footnote 15 Textual references to empire and slavery – much less to indigenous or enslaved peoples – are, however, exceptionally thin on the ground.Footnote 16 The Enlightenment Gallery's explanatory leaflet observes that the room that houses its objects was completed in 1828 and ‘now contains an exhibition about the Age of Enlightenment, a time when people – including the collectors who created the British Museum – used reason and first-hand observation of the world around them to understand it in new ways’.Footnote 17 The leaflet, like the gallery itself, proceeds to organise the Enlightenment within seven broad themes. Concealed within the seventh theme, ‘trade and discovery’, empire and slavery lie submerged under a rubric that depicts the violently acquisitive practices of ‘Merchants, diplomats, explorers and collectors’ as a modernising, scientific impulse ‘in which objects were classified by culture rather than as exotic curiosities’.Footnote 18
Complementing this amnesia with respect to empire and slavery is the third salient absence from the Enlightenment Gallery: the roughly half of adult humankind who are women. To be sure, there are female forms in this room: no fewer than four goddesses and seven female mythic figures grace the Enlightenment Gallery. A lion-headed Egyptian goddess and a Roman statue of Demeter are thus visibly displayed.Footnote 19 We can, perhaps, also deduce the presence (offstage) of yet another mythical woman from the fact that the Roman cupid on display is depicted stringing his bow. Historical women are, however, entirely absent. Only by exiting the gallery and turning left into the corner of an adjacent room do we encounter an Enlightenment woman who is also a human. Here Sarah Sophia Banks is mentioned as an Enlightenment collector – albeit one who was ‘Less well-travelled’ than her eminent brother, Sir Joseph Banks, and whose collection, ‘put together at home’, featured ‘popular prints … and general ephemera’, rather than the universalising global goods encased next door in the Enlightenment Gallery.Footnote 20 The texts that elaborate on the Enlightenment Gallery's material objects likewise ignore women, or relegate them to an historical side-room. The gallery leaflet depicts Sir Hans Sloane's bust prominently on its cover and cites two named men in its synopsis, but it otherwise effaces gender from its analytical repertoire, employing instead putatively generic collective nouns such as ‘people’, ‘Europeans’, ‘scholars’, ‘collectors’ and ‘Britain’.Footnote 21 ‘Women too’ were part of the Enlightenment, the exhibition catalogue does acknowledge.Footnote 22 But a visitor to the gallery is hard-pressed to find them in the figures that embellish the exhibition itself.
In the decade and a half since the relaunch of the Enlightenment Gallery, a burgeoning scholarship on Enlightenment women has made this absence much more obvious than it can possibly have been in 2003.Footnote 23 In what follows, two types of archaeology serve to reveal women whose histories are both materially present and entirely hidden from the public in the Enlightenment Gallery's display cabinets. By deploying forms of reason that include the well-tested methodologies of feminist historical recovery – that is, digging into both new and old archives and reading manuscripts and the printed record against the grain – and by looking for actual women who participated in Enlightenment archaeological digs, this lecture both expands upon and challenges the universalising claims of Enlightenment museum collections.Footnote 24 Case 15 of the Enlightenment Gallery, labelled ‘The Search for Modern Babylon’, provides my point of departure.
II
Focusing on early nineteenth-century excavations in what was then a marginal outpost of the Ottoman Empire and is now Iraq, Case 15 is subdivided into six sections. Three upper compartments contain a combination of small objects and textual exegeses, while the three compartments below display larger archaeological finds from ancient Nineveh and Babylon. The descriptive texts that interpret these objects recite a familiar late Enlightenment narrative, inflected by English nationalism.Footnote 25 ‘In the seventeenth century’, they assert, these ancient cities ‘were still undiscovered’. With the coming of Enlightenment, however, and the arrival of ‘A young Englishman, Claudius James Rich’, Babylon and Nineveh were ‘discovered’ by European collectors. Scientific practices – exemplified by Claudius Rich's geographical mapping of these sites and his removal from them of material artefacts destined for the British Museum – gave birth to a new, modern form of alchemy. Through archaeological investigation, ‘rubble’ was distilled by reason into scholarly knowledge of the ancient world.Footnote 26
Who was Claudius Rich, and how did his collections come to embody English Enlightenment in the British Museum? We can only answer these questions if we subvert the logic of the Enlightenment Gallery by interrogating his Englishness and situating Rich in the context of empire. To unpack Case 15 fully, we need as well both to follow the money and to cherchez la femme. Rich features in Case 15 as ‘A young Englishman’, but he was born in France, the bastard son of a military officer of Scottish and Irish heritage who had been cashiered from the British army for his leading part in a notoriously brutal wartime scandal in Europe's West Indian slave colonies.Footnote 27 Rich's illegitimacy is reflected in the uncertainty that continues to surround the precise date and place of his birth. It is also registered in his surname: Rich was the maiden name of his Irish paternal grandmother; his father was Colonel (later Sir) James Cockburn.Footnote 28 Raised and educated in Bristol, Rich as we shall see insisted that he was Irish.Footnote 29 Lacking a family fortune but displaying a precocious ability to master foreign languages, he was an obvious candidate for employment in the East India Company. Appointed in London to the Bombay civil service in 1804, Rich was first dispatched to Aleppo, Alexandria and Cairo, honing his Oriental languages. He fetched up (dressed as a turbaned Mamlūk) in colonial Bombay in September 1807.Footnote 30
Bombay in 1807 had a population of a few hundred East India Company men. The city was also home to at least ninety-nine adult British women, accompanied by their many daughters. Enumerated among these women in a census of 1806 was Lady Mackintosh, the second wife of the Recorder of Bombay's main court.Footnote 31 It was to the Mackintosh residence that Claudius Rich repaired upon his arrival, swiftly gaining the approval and patronage of the Whig historian, politician and judge Sir James Mackintosh, and also winning the heart of Sir James's eldest daughter, Mary. Seventeen years old when she met Claudius Rich and just eighteen when they wed a few months later, Mary Mackintosh had been educated by a combination of boarding school, a governess and her father. She spoke French, Italian and German and was a voracious reader of both history and novels.Footnote 32 Like her husband – with whom she was deeply in love – she lacked a fortune: her father's improvidence had forced the sale of his Highland estate in 1801, precipitating his exile to the Bombay judiciary, where Mackintosh's spendthrift habits continued unabated.Footnote 33 His patronage, however, secured Claudius Rich's appointment as the East India Company's Resident or diplomatic representative at Baghdad. Within a few weeks of the couple's marriage in January 1808, they were sailing from Bombay for Basra.Footnote 34
Both a major Persian Gulf port and a caravan city, Basra lay at the interface between the Indian Ocean world and the Ottoman Empire. Its roadways carried commerce to Persia, Syria, Kurdistan, Armenia and Asia Minor; its waterways carried goods and people, via the Tigris and Euphrates, 300 miles north-west to Baghdad, and thence toward Constantinople.Footnote 35 The city's population was dominated by Sunni Arabs but was also home to Shia tribesmen, Armenians, Jews, Syrian Christians, Indians and Europeans.Footnote 36 English merchants had been trading at Basra since 1635, and the East India Company had established its first factory (or warehouse) there in 1723.Footnote 37 The Company's agent at Basra when the Riches’ ship docked in March 1808 was Samuel Manesty. The eighth son of a successful Liverpool slave trader, Manesty had been in the Company's employ since 1778, acting as Resident at Basra from the early 1780s and developing a lucrative private trade both as the owner of substantial shipping and as the husband of an Armenian Christian whose family owned extensive date plantations.Footnote 38 Claudius Rich took an instant dislike to Manesty and refused to allow his wife to disembark at Basra, determined that Mary should not be tainted by contact with Manesty's spouse, who Rich insisted was merely a concubine and whom he described in a letter to Sir James Mackintosh as both a ‘Trull’ and ‘a dirty Armenian drab’.Footnote 39 The first salvo in an extended battle between Rich and Manesty, this comment – which Rich's in-laws in Bombay found deeply offensive – conveys the fragility of his class, race and gender identities as the unacknowledged illegitimate son of a disgraced British military officer.Footnote 40
From Basra the Riches sailed by schooner to Baghdad, arriving in May at this provincial seat of government. By 1808, Baghdad had been under the turbulent dynastic rule of Mamlūk pashas for decades. The Mamlūks were Georgian warriors, enslaved and imported as boys by the Ottomans, converted to Islam and set to govern the empire's unruly Iraqi borderlands.Footnote 41 By the later eighteenth century the Baghdad province or pashalik had attained an unstable quasi-independence.Footnote 42 Claudius and Mary Rich's residence in the city from 1808 to 1821 coincided with a period of instability that saw successive sons and sons-in-law of the Mamlūk pasha Sulaymān the Great vie for power.Footnote 43 Defeat in these dynastic contests was violent and decisive, resulting in the death and beheading of successive vanquished pashas. Women in Baghdad – as Mary Rich was to find to her discomfort – lived enclosed lives physically confined to their own and each other's female quarters within the home. But it would be mistaken to assume that the wives, sisters and mothers of Mamlūk men lacked power or political agency. To the contrary, their role as dynastic marriage partners, their personal immunity from beheading during episodes of regime change and their ability to accumulate substantial fortunes ensured that ‘Many Mamlūk pashas owed the continuation of their power to the use of status and wealth brought to them through their wives.’Footnote 44 In this context, Mary – who, unlike her husband, could socialise freely with the ladies of Baghdad in their homes, and who learned Turkish to do so – proved a valuable asset to Claudius as a diplomat.Footnote 45
Baghdad mattered to the British in these years chiefly because they feared that Napoleon's troops would use Mesopotamia as a route to reach and conquer the Indian subcontinent.Footnote 46 Claudius Rich's duties as the Company's Resident combined official diplomatic relations with management of an extensive spy-ring that transferred clandestine information about the French and their allies between Britain and India via Basra and Constantinople.Footnote 47 In defiance of the Company's orders, he also intervened in Mamlūk succession disputes. Over 100 letters to family in Bombay written by Mary and Claudius Rich survive from these years. In this correspondence, Mary's letters veer between thinly veiled expressions of terror during the violent coups that marked Mamlūk succession disputes, and prolonged recitals of the couple's great boredom and lassitude during the interminable summer months.Footnote 48 They document her own and her husband's political views, their diplomatic endeavours and their labile, racialised perceptions of the Ottoman population. Her correspondence also positively pullulates with material objects. It is animated with thick descriptions of the couple's strategic circulation of luxury goods, obtained in the modern consumer markets of Europe, India, the Persian Gulf and the Ottoman Empire; it also registers Claudius's efforts to extract ancient artefacts and medieval manuscripts from Mesopotamian, Kurdish and Indian collectors.
The Riches rapidly established a twofold pattern of material and epistolary communication with Mary's kith and kin in Britain and India.Footnote 49 By sail, letters and goods travelled to and fro between London, Bombay, Basra and Baghdad; at the same time – on horseback and in caravans – boxes, parcels and correspondence journeyed via the overland route between continental Europe, Constantinople and Kurdistan to Baghdad, from whence the Riches dispatched selected items onward to Bombay via Basra.Footnote 50 In both the overland and the maritime iterations of this communication network, material goods flowed alongside – and enabled – a constant exchange of gossip, tactical information, political news, patronage, scholarly expertise, emotion, labour and human beings.
Most of the couple's surviving letters from Baghdad were written by Mary Rich to her sister Maitland in Bombay. Named by her father to honour the trustee of his debt-ridden Highland estate, Maitland Mackintosh at age seventeen married a Bombay civil servant several years her senior.Footnote 51 Her husband, William Erskine, had been her father's private secretary before obtaining his judicial appointment, and became a distinguished scholar of Indian languages and history.Footnote 52 In Bombay, Claudius Rich had lived with Erskine before his marriage to Mary. The brothers-in-law shared a passion for Oriental manuscripts and material culture, an ambition to compensate for their lack of inherited wealth by accumulating cultural capital, and a sense of humour about their own personal idiosyncrasies. Although Mary wrote the great bulk of their surviving letters, these manuscripts also include letters and insertions authored by Claudius, which allow us to see the couple's sexual division of marital labour and the extent to which his diplomacy, mental health, scholarship and collecting activities rested on his wife's intellectual, social and acquisitive investment in global material cultures.
In keeping with established gender norms, Mary assumed responsibility for provisioning the household at the Baghdad Residency and for ensuring that her own and her husband's material comfort appropriately registered their identities, dignity and status. Her requests for snuff, shoes, textiles, books and musical instruments were at once a means of retaining links to distant family, and assertions that even in distant Baghdad the Riches upheld elite, contemporary, Enlightenment values of propriety and elegance. Mary was an exacting commissioner of goods, determined to combine economy, taste and signification through her vicarious purchasing.Footnote 53 Having discovered that only slippers could be obtained in Baghdad, she requested many pairs of shoes from her sister in Bombay, but instructed her to send footwear made in Bengal or China, instead of ‘vulgar ill made Bombay shoes’.Footnote 54 Not just nail brushes but ‘Smyths Nail Brushes’ must be dispatched to her; the flute for Claudius ‘must be a Patent Flute of the newest kind with all the additional keys’.Footnote 55 In return, she sent Persian Gulf and Ottoman luxuries that included attar of roses, pearls, embroidered Turkish handkerchiefs, velvet and silk, as well as mobilising the overland European route via Constantinople to obtain yard upon yard of fine but inexpensive French lace.Footnote 56
These commissioned goods served political ends, allowing the Riches to express specific national identities and to mobilise selected forms of Britishness when engaging in Mamlūk diplomacy. The couple's seemingly obsessive demands for Irish linen for Claudius's trousers illustrate the ways in which material culture bolstered their unstable personal claims of belonging. His contemporaries associated Claudius with Bristol, but both he and Mary laboured to underline his essential Irishness, and thus his association with his reputed father's Cockburn family line.Footnote 57 Assertions that Claudius was Irish had a habit of surfacing when husband and wife perceived his status to be under threat. Suspected lapses in their acquaintances’ sexual propriety and references to their own economic precarity both triggered their invocation of Rich's Irish identity. It is thus unsurprising that Claudius couched his objection to Mary meeting with Samuel Manesty's Armenian wife in Basra in terms of his own Irish nationality, or that Mary ascribed their lack of a Scottish country seat to having ‘married an Irishman’ rather than to her Scottish father's notorious improvidence.Footnote 58 This leitmotif of Irish identity took material form in Mary's persistent efforts to clothe Claudius's nether regions in Irish linen. In 1809 she wrote to remind Maitland that she had commissioned two dozen pairs of Irish linen trousers for Claudius, which had yet to arrive.Footnote 59 Repeated reminders that Claudius would soon have nothing decent to wear gave way, when the commissioned trousers finally arrived, to complaints that the cloth was ‘so horribly coarse’ that Claudius had ‘declared he will not wear anything you have sent’.Footnote 60 Worse yet, on inspection the ‘Irish linen’ trousers Maitland had sent proved instead to be merely ‘Indian long cloth, and so tight & rotten that hardly any of them now remain’.Footnote 61
Mary's rejection of Indian textiles was selective, focusing primarily on Claudius's person and his personal dignity as the British representative in Baghdad.Footnote 62 The Dardanelles Treaty of Peace, Commerce and Secret Alliance signed in 1809 ended the Anglo-Turkish War, pledging the British to protect Ottoman interests and restoring British access to Turkish markets.Footnote 63 In this context, Mary not only commissioned Maitland to supply fine Indian textiles for her own Baghdad wardrobe, but also ordered items from the subcontinent to serve as diplomatic gifts at the Mamlūk pashas’ court. As in India, the Company's Residents were, soon after their arrival at Baghdad, invested with robes of honour to mark their incorporation into the ruler's ambit, and were expected to offer fine gifts in return as signs of fealty. As pasha succeeded beheaded pasha, Claudius repeatedly processed to the palace to be invested with a pelisse made from cloth of gold and lined with sable.Footnote 64 In return, he offered expensive gifts of luxuries, the cost of which Mary sought to reduce by commissioning Indian textiles from her sister in Bombay.Footnote 65
In time, moreover, Mary emerged as a diplomat in her own right. The norms of Sunni propriety in Baghdad prohibited her from meeting with Muslim men other than her household servants.Footnote 66 Mary's circle of even female acquaintances was, moreover, initially very narrow: there was only one other Englishwoman in Baghdad when she arrived, and the Anglo-Turkish war prevented the ladies of the pasha's family from visiting. Armenian women did come to the Residency, and were duly entertained with coffee and sweetmeats, but Mary initially reported that they were ‘disgustingly ugly and indecent and I am obliged to keep them at a great distance’.Footnote 67 In sharp contrast, when the cessation of war allowed her to visit the Muslim ladies of the pasha's court, their elite status trumped their race and religion, and Mary fulsomely praised their pleasing politeness.Footnote 68 Her sometimes esteem for elite Ottoman men derived from their solicitude for these women, which protected them from physical violence when successive pashas were overthrown. As Mary observed to Maitland in the midst of the bloody coup of 1810, ‘The respect and tenderness of Turks towards women is astonishing, and in a different manner equals any of the most civilized nations in Europe.’Footnote 69
Once welcomed into the women's quarters of Baghdad's courtly elite, Mary Rich reported to her sister that she had become the frequent recipient of ‘very handsome presents, [and] of course I am obliged to do the same, but find Jewellery so very expensive that I wish much to procure some Indian goods which they will esteem more, as they are not to be procured here’.Footnote 70 Deploying domestic sociability, limited verbal communication and the exchange of luxury goods, Mary Rich cultivated unprecedented European relations with Baghdad's governing-class women.Footnote 71 We can see the impact of her friendships in Claudius Rich's repeated interventions to save the male kin of deposed pashas from execution in the aftermath of violent succession disputes: it was the women whom Mary entertained at the Residency and whose houses she visited who pleaded for Claudius Rich to appeal to the newly installed pashas who had supplanted their sons and husbands. Already in 1812, trust between Mary and these women was sufficiently robust to allow the late pasha's widow to defy etiquette and travel to the British Residency, where she appealed directly to Claudius to intervene on behalf of her son.Footnote 72 This behaviour reflects a new style of European material diplomacy exercised by the Riches as a couple, rather than – as the extant secondary literature suggests – providing yet another example of Claudius Rich's personal charisma and his exceptional command of the ‘Oriental mind’.Footnote 73
III
What of collecting, archaeological excavation and Enlightenment science? Here too we can only understand Claudius Rich's contributions if we recognise his reliance on and partnership with his wife. Neither Mary nor her sister read Oriental languages, a major impediment to participating actively in the accumulation of Arabic, Persian and Syriac texts – to which their husbands devoted much time, effort and money.Footnote 74 Their correspondence, however, demonstrates that the two men expected their wives both to facilitate and to take an active interest in their acquisitions. Claudius thus wrote to Maitland, rather than to William Erskine, to report that he had purchased ‘a very famous work’ of Arabic ‘natural magic’ for her husband, which although the price was ‘rather extravagant’ was ‘just the thing he wants’.Footnote 75 Mary's letters to her sister routinely interlarded information about consumer goods with information about the acquisition of manuscripts and antiquities; her correspondence brought together in the same sentences and paragraphs news that she was sending ‘excellent velvet’ from Constantinople, complaints that she was yet again disappointed by her sister's dispatch of ersatz Irish linen, and notification that she was sending books of Oriental scholarship which Claudius had ordered from Constantinople, Vienna and Paris.Footnote 76
Both ancient history and archaeology, moreover, allowed Mary Rich to participate directly in Claudius's scholarship and collecting. In preparation for the couple's archaeological excursions, Mary read ancient history avidly. Shortly after arriving in Baghdad, she took up the multi-volume Universal History produced by eighteenth-century London booksellers to bolster her understanding of the history of Islam.Footnote 77 A year later, Mary was supplementing the Universal History with the works of Enlightenment historians such as Edward Gibbon and developing a preference for Islamic military culture. ‘I have lately been reading again with fresh instruction and delight the Chapters in Gibbon respecting these Countries, and his most elegant account of Mahomet, and the first Arabian Heroes for surely they deserved that appellation in contradistinction to the cowardly & effeminate Greeks,’ she observed in a letter to Maitland.Footnote 78
Historical understanding was a collaborative, not an individualistic, enterprise in the Rich household. The couple replicated the sociable practices of domestic reading Sir James Mackintosh had instituted in Bombay to instruct his family in history. In the long, hot afternoons at the Baghdad Residency, Mary read aloud from historians such as Gibbon, allowing Claudius simultaneously to refresh his historical knowledge of the ancient world and to hone his skills of drawing and draughtsmanship as he listened to her.Footnote 79 These artistic and technical skills came into active use as the couple began to venture beyond Baghdad to explore the ruins of ancient Babylon, 60 miles to the southwest. The precise location of this famous biblical city was hotly disputed by East India Company men of science.Footnote 80 Cartography was an Enlightenment and an imperial science par excellence, and Claudius Rich's initial visit to the reputed site of Babylon in 1811 figures in twenty-first-century historiography as a case study in Enlightenment reason put to the service of empire.Footnote 81 Wielding astronomical, mathematical and surveying instruments,Footnote 82 Claudius Rich exercised his reason in the rubble of Babylon to dispute his predecessors’ assumptions – which had been based on armchair cartography – about the ancient city's location relative to the banks of the Euphrates.Footnote 83 More than merely measuring, Claudius set his companions to dig in the ruins. These excavations amid what Claudius in his journals repeatedly described as the ‘rubble’ of Babylon, revealed the inscribed cuneiform bricks, clay tablets, coins and cylinder seals that now populate Case 15 of the British Museum's Enlightenment Gallery.
Absent from modern accounts of Rich's excavations at Babylon are both Mary Rich and her errant younger sister, Kitty Mackintosh.Footnote 84 Both were indisputably present, as their letters to their sister Maitland in Bombay attest. Kitty Mackintosh had been dispatched at the age of fifteen by her father to Baghdad to keep Mary company. Described by her elder sister as a ‘madcap’ and only lightly chaperoned, on shipboard she had attracted the attention of a twenty-seven-year-old naval lieutenant, whose proposal of marriage Kitty rashly accepted.Footnote 85 She was rescued before the marriage could take place by the Riches, who – as Mary reported to Maitland – set sail hastily from Baghdad to the port of Bushire ‘to restore our giddy sister I hope to her senses’.Footnote 86 Sequestered with the Riches for several months at the Baghdad Residency, Kitty remained resolute in her marital intentions, and it was immediately prior to her marriage, aged sixteen, that the Riches travelled en famille to the site of Babylon.Footnote 87 Now a safe distance from the strictly policed gender regime of Sunni Baghdad, Kitty ranged freely over the ruins with Mary, and observed that she was ‘very pleased’ with the ancient site. She also reported to Maitland that ‘Mary has told me that she has sealed her letter to you with a seal dug up at Babylon & therefor begs you will observe it particularly.’Footnote 88
When in 1813 Claudius Rich began to bring his analysis of the ‘heaps of rubbish’ he had excavated at Babylon into the public domain, he erased Mary and Kitty entirely from the record of his scientific investigations.Footnote 89 His popular Memoir on the Ruins of Babylon thanked ‘a gentleman who accompanied me (Mr. Lockett), who superintended’ the surveying operations, referred to both Arabic and European male scholars and mentioned in passing his use of Turkish men as ‘native’ informants.Footnote 90 Rich expressly wrote both this text and his 1818 Second Memoir of the Ruins of Babylon in the style of a reasoned scholarly conversation among men, principally conducted with Major James Rennell, the East India Company's renowned surveyor general of Bengal. In these publications, Rich made relentless use of personal pronouns and possessives – ‘I’, ‘me’, ‘myself’ and ‘my’ – to describe his research methodology: these four words appear no fewer than thirty-seven times in the first four pages of the Second Memoir.Footnote 91 His usage prefigures the stylistic convention that was to be adopted in the 1830s by Mary's half-brother, Robert James Mackintosh. When Robert composed a memoir of their father, Sir James Mackintosh, he too was to write Mary and her sisters out of the annals of Enlightenment science. In Robert's memoir, Claudius James Rich and his relations with Sir James Mackintosh merited many pages of attention. Mary's first mention in this work – without the dignity of a name – occurred only when she married Claudius. Like her sister Maitland, with whom she thus became indistinguishable in the text, Robert signified her presence in the historical record only by the letter ‘M’, followed by a dash.Footnote 92
If we allow these persistent forms of erasure to stand uncontested, we lose sight of multiple layers of Enlightenment universalism. For effacing the records left by European women such as Mary Rich and her sisters also erases from the record South Asian and Middle Eastern women and men who participated in Enlightenment knowledge-making. Mary's descriptions of domestic life in Baghdad and the couple's travels in the wider Ottoman territories highlight this point. Servants, go-betweens and political elites from the Indian subcontinent and a cosmopolitan mélange of Armenians, Arabs, Baghdadis, Jews, Kurds, Mamlūks, Syrians and Turks enabled the Riches to read, write, eat, travel, dig and collect during Claudius's tenure as Resident.Footnote 93 His texts are unusual in acknowledging the existence and role of many of these collaborators,Footnote 94 but by consulting Mary's unpublished personal correspondence as well as the careful annotations and footnotes of her editions of his posthumous works, we can add both substantial volume and human detail to her husband's records. Indeed, it is precisely Mary's female gender identity, her responsibility as a married woman for management of her husband's household, which predisposes her writings to the task of recovering the lost names and voices of their servants in particular.
The ‘servant problem’ is a cliché in middle- and upper-class British household history. Locating, training, tolerating, disciplining, paying and perhaps most of all retaining servants was a perennial source of anxiety for British and imperial women alike.Footnote 95 Mary Rich was no exception. Claudius brought thirty Indian sepoys with him to Baghdad to act as a personal bodyguard and also employed a small troop of European hussars; he had a Company surgeon, who served as his assistant, at least one manservant, a Slavic household steward, grooms and several interpreters and clerks.Footnote 96 Mary's letters underscore the relative paucity of her available human resources in Baghdad. Unlike the ladies of the pashas’ families with whom she socialised, who could rely on bevies of slave girls imported from the Caucuses to boost their status and perform their menial tasks, she had brought only one Indian maidservant with her in 1808. By autumn, this woman insisted on leaving for Bombay with Claudius's Indian manservant, Abdullah – ‘indecent conduct’ that her mistress decried as ‘abominable’.Footnote 97 Mary then reluctantly made do with a young female relation of Claudius's Armenian chief interpreter.Footnote 98 In 1810 she added an Indian tailor from Madras to her minuscule establishment of servants.Footnote 99 Several months later, the arrival of a so-called ‘Portuguese’ – a term denoting a mixed-race Indian Christian – swiftly confirmed Mary's existing race prejudices about the colonial lower orders. To her ‘no small annoyance in such a place as Bagdad [sic] where they are remarkably particular in everything respecting a [harem]’, Kitty's maid ‘proved a useless idle creature’ and was soon discovered to be with child. Mary promptly sacked her, and wrote to Maitland to ‘beg you will immediately stop her wages & to never let me see the face of a Portuguese woman again’.Footnote 100
It is nonetheless through Mary's anxious correspondence with Maitland about servants that we first catch fleeting glimpses of non-European agency, personal preferences, prejudice and reason. The initial reactions of Claudius's Indian manservant, Abdullah, to the Muslim women of Baghdad were captured by Mary in a letter to Maitland a few days after their arrival at the Residency, in which she described a visit from the wife and mother-in-law of one of Claudius's officers. ‘You never saw such witch-like figures in your life as they all appear coming into a room with a thick black gauze veil over their face and a blue-check shawl covering their body,’ she reported. ‘Abdulla very genteelly calls them so many Devils.’Footnote 101 A few months later, despite Mary's offers of presents and additional payments, her Indian maidservant emphatically articulated her dislike for Baghdad and desire to travel with Abdullah home to Bombay, and voted with her feet. The Portuguese maidservant who arrived in 1811 – already pregnant when she set sail from Bombay – may instead have seen the Baghdad Residency as a conveniently distant Company home in which to bear an illegitimate child.Footnote 102 The instrumental uses to which empire could be put were not enjoyed equally by the Riches and their servants, but neither were the latter entirely powerless within the imperial master–servant relationship.Footnote 103
In Baghdad, Claudius's physical and mental health declined sharply from 1812 onward. Mary's letters record an alarming escalation of symptoms such as fits, fevers and fainting, and she and Claudius both wrote openly about his mounting ‘melancholy’ and inability to shake off the ‘blue devils’ of depression.Footnote 104 Seeking relief from the social isolation, political upheaval and intolerable heat of Baghdad, they made extended journeys to the Kurdish provinces to the north, using their travels to explore ancient ruins and collect both antiquities and manuscripts. These activities necessitated large-scale mobilisations of colonial labour.Footnote 105 Their Kurdish expedition of 1820, for example, was undertaken with perhaps sixty tent-pitchers, muleteers and other skilled labourers – Arabs, Christians, Indians, Jews, Persians and Turks, commanded by Claudius's Armenian steward, Aga Minas.Footnote 106 Combing Mary Rich's writings yields many more records of the personnel who enabled their travels and excavations than does reading her husband's journals alone. For Mary's records also allow us to enumerate and name specific women among their servants, go-betweens and interlocutors.
Both Claudius and Mary kept journals of their 1820 Kurdish expedition, and Mary chose to print her text as well as Claudius's when she published a posthumous edition of his works in 1839. Before the couple departed Baghdad, they were feted, at gender-segregated events, by the men and women of Baghdad's governing elite, many of whom they had now known for over a decade. Claudius's account of these festivities mentions that Mary's exclusively female gathering included ‘her friend Salkha Khatoon, one of the widows of old Suleiman Pasha’. Mary's account also mentions this powerful woman, but describes her as ‘my Koordish friend Salkha Khanum’, and endows her with both a birthplace and opinions, by suggesting that her friend ‘seemed not a little to envy me my excursion to her native mountains’. Additionally, Mary named ‘my constant and intimate friend Hanifa Khatoon, who was very angry at our fancy, as she called it, of flying off to such a solitary savage place as Koordistan, and leaving all the comforts and amusements of Baghdad’. A third named female friend in Mary's account was Zabit Khatoon, who in stormy weather, had mounted her horse and arrived at the women's gathering late at night, to bid Mary farewell.Footnote 107
Just as Mary Rich's letters to Maitland registered – however schematically – the volition and views of her domestic servants in Baghdad more fully than Claudius's writings, so too her Kurdish travel narrative attended more carefully to servants’ identities, lives and labour than did his. Claudius for example mentioned that he was accompanied by a bodyguard of twenty-five Indian sepoys and that Mary initially travelled in a covered mule-litter or takhtrawan and was ‘attended by women servants, and all the state of a haram’.Footnote 108 Mary's parallel description identifies her two attendants: one was her maidservant ‘Taqui’ and the other was the mother of Claudius's interpreter, Aga Minas. She accorded them an ethnicity and a social identity. And unlike Claudius, whose comments spoke only of the great dignity with which he and his wife travelled, Mary's account elaborated on the discomfort her female attendants must have endured. She travelled in a recumbent position in her takhtrawan, but her attendants instead journeyed sitting up in ‘mohoffas, or a kind of cages, two of which are swung on one mule, and balance each other’, she reported. ‘It is by no means a comfortable conveyance, owing to the constrained posture the person is obliged to sit in.’Footnote 109
In Kurdistan, as in Baghdad, Mary continued to visit the harems of the governing elite, meeting the mothers, sisters and wives of Kurdish pashas and, if they spoke Turkish, conversing with them. The couple stayed for several months in Sulaimani, a northern provincial capital and Kurdish seat of learning where Claudius avidly sought Oriental manuscripts and Mary too engaged in the work of Enlightenment. In June 1820, accompanied by her female attendants, she was greeted at the pasha's harem by ‘a crowd of slave-girls’ and introduced to the ‘ladies of the family’. The pasha's wife was a woman of Mary's own age, Adela Khanum. Mary noted in her journal that she was the pasha's only wife, and that ‘they … have been endeared to one another by their common sorrow for the death of many children by the smallpox’. Adela Khanum had learned Turkish as a child in Baghdad, and Mary – by birth, marriage and personal inclination a daughter of Enlightenment science – mustered her own Turkish language skills to convince her new friend of the wisdom of vaccinating her surviving son. ‘Perhaps too when they hear their Pasha has consented to try the vaccine on his only child, the common people may be induced to allow us to vaccinate their children,’ she mused, in keeping with a Kantian conviction in the power of public reason. ‘Our journey to Koordistan will then indeed not have been in vain.’Footnote 110 Conducted in good faith, this experiment ended fatally. The vaccine ordered at Mary's behest by express delivery from Baghdad duly arrived in the autumn, but both Adela Khanum's young son and her infant nephew died of the disease itself, an outcome Claudius blamed on the inept administration of the vaccine by a Turkish inoculator.Footnote 111
IV
What do the imperial and material lives of Mary and Claudius Rich tell us about the claims to universalism of ‘Western’ museums today? How can we best acknowledge the myriad, cross-cultural forms of Enlightenment knowledge production – powerfully marked by empire, slavery and patterns of prejudice – which extended from Bombay to Basra, Baghdad and Babylon? Should we bin the Enlightenment as a concept, or perhaps boycott the Enlightenment Gallery of the British Museum?
I think not. Instead, in concluding this lecture, I make three modest proposals. The first is that, beginning with Case 15, the British Museum should take a first step toward ‘universalising’ its history by acknowledging the existence of Enlightenment women and their contribution to public forms of reasoning. Mary Rich was with Claudius Rich for every day and night of his tenure at the Baghdad Residency. She kept him in Europeanised clothing, read Gibbon's history aloud to him, wrote letters for Claudius, copied his diplomatic correspondence, tended him through a succession of physical and mental illnesses, negotiated on his behalf with the East India Company when he fell out of their favour and accompanied him on archaeological digs and manuscript purchasing expeditions.Footnote 112 When he died of cholera in 1821, it was Mary who settled his estate, preserved his collections, shipped them to England and (with her father's assistance) sold them to the British Museum.Footnote 113 In the 1830s, as the race to decipher cuneiform began to accelerate in Europe, it was she who carefully annotated and produced scholarly editions of Claudius's published and unpublished works.Footnote 114 Surely she too deserves some mention.
My second modest proposal is that we acknowledge that Claudius Rich worked collaboratively not only in tandem with his European wife but also with a wide, cross-cultural universe of servants, agents and go-betweens that included princely elites in Baghdad and Kurdistan who shared his collecting habits as well as the grooms, muleteers and river navigators whose skills ensured that his wife and his collections journeyed safely via Baghdad, Basra and Bombay to Britain. Mary Rich's writings, as I have argued here, enhance our ability to recognise – and in some instances, even to name – specific non-European persons who – sometimes wittingly, and not always willingly – sustained Claudius's colonial collecting. Just as her letters chronicle domestic scenes that allow us briefly to glimpse moments of opportunism or resistance among the servants of the Rich household, so too the fakes from the Rich collection that are displayed in Case 15 remind us that the empire does strike back.Footnote 115 We know from her writings that Mary Rich had opinions – about politics, about history and about the myriad Mesopotamian peoples with whom the Riches lived for over a decade. Although many of her views are unpalatable today, by writing Mary Rich back into the historical and material record of the European Enlightenment we can nonetheless take steps toward ‘universalising’ the Museum by recognising the existence, labour and agency of these men and women. They too merit explicit reference in Case 15 of the Enlightenment Gallery.
Third and finally, we need to name empire and colonialism – rather than merely referencing ‘trade and discovery’ – in the Enlightenment Gallery, and more broadly in the universal museum. Acknowledging histories of both race and slavery is vitally important in that context. But recovering the full range of gender at play in colonial collecting is also integral to the task of decolonising the museum. In defending Britain's ‘universal’ museums from restitution claims, Tristram Hunt has recently argued that ‘There remains something essentially valuable about the ability of museums to position objects beyond particular cultural or ethnic identities, curate them within a broader intellectual or aesthetic lineage, and situate them within a wider, richer framework of relationships.’Footnote 116 Gender is entirely absent from this ostensibly universalising gaze. The history of Mary and Claudius Rich reminds us, however, that it is precisely such sweeping claims to universalism that have, historically, allowed us to write the roughly half of humankind who are non-men out of museum histories, and in so doing to entrench the effacement of non-Europeans from ‘universal’ museum collections. Today, at so many levels, Immanuel Kant's argument of 1784 – that ‘Public’ enlightenment is ‘inevitable’, if only the public is ‘allowed freedom’ – may ring hollow. Perhaps, by replacing the ‘bearded’ learned ladies of Kant's imagination with analyses of actual historical women who engaged with Enlightenment reason, we can begin to improve upon this partial and unsatisfactory interpretative tradition by replacing the ‘universal’ with the ‘human’.
