In his most recent contribution to understanding the politics of Japanese security issues and policy outcomes, Andrew Oros argues that Japan is in the midst of a historic ‘security renaissance’, brought about by a gradual awakening to the security challenges of the twenty-first century. Deeming the decade from 2006 to 2016 the height of this renaissance period, Oros gives a detailed survey of Japanese security policy that is inclusive of political power shifts, legacies of Japan's past, and regional security developments. It is a rare although welcome occasion to read a review of Japanese security policy developments that incorporates both policy change relating to military issues as well as impending demographic and social challenges that will be exceedingly important to Japan's strategic trajectory in the years to come.
In his book, Oros joins the fray of Japan-focused international relations scholars assessing how developments in Japanese defense policy in the post-Cold War era should be understood. At the crux of this long-standing debate is the binary of change and continuity: does Japan's security policy trajectory represent an evolution or a revolution? Evolutionists argue that defense policy changes should be understood as natural adjustments within the boundaries of Japanese pacifism. Revolutionists, on the other hand, perceive a rather radical break from the past in Japan's grand strategy. Proponents of this change camp point to the series of recent defense upgrades, most notably the reinterpretation of Japan's constitution to allow for collective self-defense, as evidence of Japan's parting with its anti-militarist identity. In Japan's Security Renaissance, Oros contends that the change that Japanese security policy has been undergoing since 2006 is, like the European Renaissance, rooted in its past (pp. 6–7) and is more evolutionary in nature. He points to three legacies that continue to shape Japan's future as a security actor, namely: (1) contested memories of the Pacific War and Japanese colonialism, (2) postwar antimilitarist constraints on Japan's defense establishment, and (3) Japan's Alliance with US (pp. 24–9).
But how comparable are Japan's contemporary security policy developments to the rebirth that Europe experienced in the fourteenth century? The European Renaissance, which has been primarily understood as a cultural bridge, marked an era when Europe arose from an extended period of cultural decline and stagnation. What evidence suggests that the same can be said of Japanese security policy developments since 2006?
One of the clear strengths of Oros’ analysis is that it offers updated empirical insights into the political processes that have led to policy outcomes in Japan. This may, however, at times come at the expense of providing more convincing explanations for his renaissance packaging. Oros contextualizes his renaissance thesis in a chapter on ‘Gradual Awakening’, which occurred during the first six decades of Japan's postwar experience and involved incremental steps towards the security renaissance that was initiated in 2006 (p. 37). He tracks turning points in Japan's strategic trajectory, such as Japan's economic rise and decline, its growing role in its security alliance with the US, and its moves towards a more ‘normal’ security role after 9/11, as well as the passing of anti-terror legislation as part of an evolution leading up to the renaissance. His analysis focuses on Japan's evolving strategic posture propelled by domestic political dynamics and the numerous security policy developments that originated during the second administration of Prime Minister Shinzō Abe (2012-). Oros argues that the security changes since 2006 show that today there is no longer just thinking about new approaches to security, as there was during the Gradual Awakening period, but also ‘cautious implementation of the approaches by political actors from the left and right’ (p. 21). One wonders, though, if this implementation indicates that Japan is coming out of a tumultuous period, as the renaissance metaphor suggests, or rather entering one? At times, Japan's Security Renaissance tells a dual story of both change and continuity. The author himself writes that one cannot dismiss the importance of what is happening in Japan, yet also cannot say that the developments since 2006 reflect wholesale change or a dramatic deviation from the past (pp. 6–7, 125).
The theoretical framework of Japan's Security Renaissance is betwixt a realist and constructivist approach in that it is aligned with the realist paradigm, yet differentiates itself by considering the concept of Japan's ‘security identity’ – ‘the collectively held principles that have attracted broad political support regarding the appropriate role of state action in the security arena and that are institutionalized in the policy-making process’ (p. 18). The ‘security identity’ concept is drawn from Oros’ 2008 title, Normalizing Japan, which similarly argues that this identity is an immanent driver in the policymaking process. Oros also stresses that China is a major driver of transition in Japan's security policy, so it would be interesting to explore further how the role of one of Japan's main others relates to Japan's broader security identity construction and the implications of this on policy. Several recent contributions on the relational aspect of identity formation have highlighted how Japanese identity is constructed through observations of its others (see for instance Hagström, Reference Hagström2016; Yennie Lindgren and Lindgren, Reference Yennie Lindgren and Lindgren2017).
With his monograph, Oros provides what is arguably one of the most comprehensive treatments of Japanese security policy developments that has taken place over the past 15 years. The author's accessible writing style and versatility in addressing military security developments alongside broader societal issues lend to a good read. This book can definitely be recommended as an informative resource for students of Japanese politics and society and for researchers interested in the politics around security issues and how they relate to policy outcomes.
