Catherine Hindson's West End Actresses and the Origins of Celebrity Charity, 1880–1920 is a carefully focused study of the charitable work and performances of professional British actresses at the turn of the nineteenth century. As an introductory study of this relatively little-known subject, Hindson's book is revelatory for the amount, variety, and significance of charitable work that it uncovers. Drawing on newspaper and periodical accounts as well as the diaries and letters of participants and spectators of celebrity charity events, Hindson provides details about their planning, production, and reception. Hindson goes beyond listing statistics. Instead, with an approach influenced by performance studies, she aims to “centralize the embodied experiences of these events” (18) and help the reader “understand what a spectator/participant saw and did at such occasions” (19). This is not easy to do, but the wealth of details helps. The study also helps readers understand the events by contextualizing and analyzing them in terms of the theatrical profession and the changing status of actresses, and as vital components of British society and culture at the time. For those interested in the ways in which actresses constructed their own identities, Hindson's work provides interesting insights into how charitable appearances or performances played a part in this process.
The book is divided into three major parts. Part 1 looks at charitable work in the context of the West End theatre industry, focusing on the “charity matinees” (44) or benefit performances. Part 2 includes case studies of charitable events other than theatrical performances, such as charity bazaars, costume balls, tea parties, and garden parties. Part 3, “The Stage and War,” is particularly interesting for focusing on the role played by charity performances in constructing an iconography of national identity in wartime Britain (during the Boer War and World War I).
While tightly focused on her topic, the author makes fine distinctions among the types of charitable performance and roles played by actresses in differing kinds of work. An actress might sell goods in a bazaar, host a tea party, or play a character for a costume ball. The author acknowledges the complicated interrelatedness of these separate roles and events. Partly due to so many variables, it is difficult to quantify the effect of celebrity charity work in terms of exact numbers—for instance, how much money the appearance of a celebrity at a given event might raise or to what extent the positive publicity earned by individual actresses through charitable appearances might translate to increases in salary or career opportunities. But even as the influence of charitable celebrity work on theatre, society, and individual careers is not reducible to precise statistics, the descriptions and arguments in Hindson's book present a convincing case for their importance historically. The nature and phenomenon of celebrity itself is an issue that runs through all three major sections. One can see parallels to modern celebrities’ responses to natural or national disasters in Hindson's accounts of events such as the 1912 Titanic charity matinees described in Chapter 2. Organized by an alliance of West End theatres, participants included British actress Mrs. Pat Campbell, who appeared in one of her most popular roles as the eponymous character in The Second Mrs Tanqueray, as well as international celebrity Sarah Bernhardt.
Another issue that runs through the book is that of actresses’ respectability. Although charity work generally reflected positively on individual actresses and the theatrical profession as a whole, there were also “troublesome area[s]” (102) of participation. For instance, in the charity bazaar the actress functioned as a kind of salesperson and, in her desire to be effective, sometimes came across as too brash or aggressive. When selling something, even for charity, the persuasive charm of the actress might cross the line into what some uncomfortable observers thought unladylike or even disreputable seduction, which made some observers uncomfortable. In costume balls as well, Hindson argues, there could be a fine line between allure and debauchery in the actress's performance.
Especially interesting are the sections dealing with performances in hospitals for wounded soldiers and near the front lines during World War I. The popular “Concerts at the Front,” an entertainment organization devised by Lena Ashwell to bring classical music directly to British soldiers on the European front, developed into “Plays at the Front.” Such events functioned both to reinforce the image of the British soldier as culturally superior and to demonstrate the medical and therapeutic benefits of entertainments that distracted soldiers from the horror and tedium of trench warfare. Hindson provides evidence of how such wartime theatrical performances were part of an important media network that also included print journalism and film, which produced patriotic and morale-boosting propaganda and helped construct the British public's understanding and response to World War I.
Interestingly enough, wartime theatrical activities also provided the concept for a very successful recent production of Gilbert and Sullivan's HMS Pinafore at the Stratford, Ontario Shakespeare festival this past summer (2017). The production was conceived as a WWI-era performance given to lift the spirits of wounded soldiers recuperating at an English country house reminiscent of Downton Abbey. Soldiers and nurses played the roles in HMS Pinafore as part of their Christmas entertainment. The satirical but ultimately affectionate and affirmative portrayals of stereotypes of English manhood, such as the honest British sailor/soldier, took on added power when performed within the frame of wartime patriotism and morale building. The production was a timely demonstration of the viability of Hindson's argument regarding theatrical activities during major military campaigns.
The book contributes to many areas of interest to theatre scholars. Beyond wartime performance, it gives us a picture of the economic and administrative functioning of late nineteenth-century London theatres and of theatre's relationship to other media and society. Perhaps most significantly, it adds to our understanding of women's place, historically, in the theatrical profession as well as the ways in which the actress constructed a workable and successful persona in the context of that profession.
