Like all the Very Short Introductions in this excellent series, these two rich yet compact paperbacks from Oxford University Press could well be renamed the Books that Leave a Lot Out. The key to success in such a difficult task lies in devising a structure that leaves readers unaware of how much is missing, and at the same time prevents hostile reviewers from complaining that their particular speciality has been omitted. Very sensibly, William Bynum and Thomas Dixon have both adopted thematic rather than chronological schemes, although their strategies are very different from one another.
Bynum's tactic is disguise. In his History of Medicine, the material is ostensibly organized by location: his six chapters focus respectively on the bedside, the library, the hospital, the community, the laboratory and the modern world. However, as the last of these suggests, Bynum's is essentially a chronological account, one that is divided into three unequal sections by the French Revolution and the First World War. ‘Bedside’ medicine turns out to be Greek, while ‘Library’ medicine takes the story up to the Enlightenment by including such unbookish topics as anatomy, Paracelsus and Islamic hospitals. These are followed by three chapters on the nineteenth century, when – Bynum writes – ‘the modern categories of hospital, community, and laboratory medicine emerged in their current forms … and are what we think of as “modernity”’ (p. 3). Most of the sixth and longest chapter, on the twentieth century, is taken up with ‘What-happened-next?’ discussions of each of the first five chapter headings, and it considers more recent developments such as penicillin, AIDS and Nazism – although not alternative therapies. Unlike the earlier chapters, it also embraces recent analytical approaches, such as interest in hospital architecture. This shift as Bynum's book nears its end may well reflect its origins in lectures that he gave to great acclaim for many years, and it can be confusing: for instance, early modern hospitals are unindexed, but appear in the final chapter rather than in the one dedicated to hospitals, which is mainly (but not entirely) about post-Revolutionary France.
Whereas Bynum states that science is one of Western culture's most significant achievements, Dixon refuses to take sides, aiming instead to help defenders and opponents to continue arguing but to ‘disagree with each other in a well-informed way’ (p. xii). His Science and Religion is a marvellous book that should be required reading for dogmatic fundamentalists of every persuasion, scientific as well as religious. Like Bynum's, it has six chapters with misleading titles: Dixon's give the impression of an old-fashioned concentration on Galileo and Charles Darwin, although in fact he ranges from the Quran to quantum mechanics, from Adam and Eve to Zygon (the first specialist journal on science and religion), and from onanism to immortality.
Dixon's is a reader-centred book that poses questions and encourages thought (even if his impartiality does waver somewhat when he gets to intelligent design). Although packed with information, Science and Religion convinces rather than tells people that current controversies about evolution have deep historical roots and strong political connections. For example, Dixon makes it clear that both the Scopes trial and Galileo's condemnation were about claiming the authority to produce and disseminate knowledge rather than about the knowledge itself. A third of the book explicitly covers the histories of Darwinian evolution and creationism; the other four chapters comprise more philosophical discussions – well illustrated with many examples – of such fundamental yet unanswerable issues as God's role in the world, the nature of consciousness and the origins of morality.
OUP has been generous with illustrations – nineteen for Dixon, twenty-eight for Bynum – but the two authors use them differently. Dixon only gives short captions, and not all of them add much to the argument: a photograph of Darwin and a painting of St Agatha carrying her breasts on a plate do not seem immediately helpful. In contrast, Bynum has taken the opportunity to slip in several insights that are absent from the text. The long-standing distinction between surgeons and physicians appears only in the description of a seventeenth-century engraving, captions reveal that vaccination was often ridiculed, a government lantern slide about reporting dirty milk jugs imparts a new appreciation of public health measures.
Other writers would have chosen different structures and contents for both these books, but, as Dixon points out in his final paragraph, people who believe that they are right should be careful. What sort of world would it be, he asks, if everyone agreed about all the important questions?
