Ernest Tucker's short monograph, Nadir Shah's Quest for Legitimacy in Post Safavid Iran, is a refreshing contribution to the literature on the important but still inadequately understood reign of Nadir Shah Afshar (1736–47). The illustrious conquests of this 18th-century warlord, who rose from obscurity but eventually extended his suzerainty over vast territories across the Iranian Plateau, Asia Minor, the Caucasus, Central Asia, and the Indian subcontinent, captured the minds of faraway observers and court chroniclers, such as Mirza Mahdi Astarabadi. Already in the 18th century, James Fraser had collated a handy History of Nadir Shah in English, and the king of Denmark had commissioned William Jones to redact and translate Astarabadi's history of “Nader Chah” into French. The tradition of Orientalist scholarship culminated in comprehensive works by Vladimir Minorsky and Laurence Lockhardt that first appeared in the 1930s but still remain unsurpassed in several respects.
After tumultuous upheavals in the wake of the dethronement of the Safavid dynasty, in 1736 an assembly of nomadic and sedentary tribal chieftains met at the Moghan plain on the banks of the Aras River in the southern Caucasus and recognized Nadir as rightful sovereign. Nadir Shah spent the subsequent eleven years of his reign leading military expeditions and negotiating with, inter alia, Ottoman, Afghan, Mughal, and Russian adversaries. He dispatched and received numerous diplomatic delegations in order to negotiate with his opponents and reportedly even sought the hand of the Russian empress Yelizaveta Petrovna (1741–62) in marriage. Among his other feats, Nadir Shah appropriated from Mughal treasuries the famed Peacock Throne and the legendary diamonds known as kūh-i nūr and daryā-ʿi nūr.
Over the past three decades, researchers have increasingly employed social-science concepts in order to reformulate and reexamine a wide spectrum of issues in various subfields of Middle Eastern studies. In the same vein, Tucker sets out to answer two ringing sociopolitical questions that Weber formulated in these terms: “When and why do men obey? Upon what inner justifications and upon what external means does this domination rest?”
Tucker employs the concept of “imagined communities,” as developed by Benedict Anderson, to argue that concepts of national identity transcend mere expressions of loyalty to the legitimacy of the divinely ordained, hierarchical dynastic realm. He also borrows Eric Hobsbawm and Terrence Ranger's phrase “invention of tradition,” originally used to examine 19th- and 20th-century British history, to describe the ways in which Nadir Shah refined religious and political concepts. The author suggests that “Nadir was inventing tradition to foster an imagined community of Muslims that focused on broad cultural and ethnic commonalities between the Ottomans, the Mughals, and himself as well as their shared religious beliefs and practices” (p. 10). The imagined community of a unified Muslim world under the sovereignty of various Turkic dynasties had never really existed. Therefore Nadir tried to “recover” the lost norms of the medieval Turko-Mongol world and sought to fashion new identities through the rediscovery of traditions asserted to have been lost but that were indeed a mixture of invented and authentic historical elements.
The proposition that the Jaʿfari madhhab should be recognized as canonical along with the four other more widely accepted schools of Islamic law plays a significant part in Tucker's representation of Nadir's invention of tradition to fashion an imagined community of Muslims. However, this attempt to join Sunni and Shiʿi Islam “at an international level” failed.
Tucker argues that the ways Nadir tried to reorganize religion and politics to legitimize his rule conditioned the emergence of modern Iran. He regards Nadir's thwarted schemes as precocious attempts at defining political legitimacy in Iran in modern terms. Nadir had begun to confront questions about the proper relationship between politics, religion, and national identity with “modern” answers—in that they represented radical breaks from long-held views. His reign was not only an attempt to revive the past but was also a harbinger of political and religious struggles to come. The author links Nadir's legitimizing policies, especially in regard to religious matters, with the growing divide between royal and clerical authority in Iran that ultimately caused “great upheaval in the twentieth century” (p. 14).
Tucker suggests that Nadir's inventions of tradition were necessary but not sufficient means to gain legitimacy. He goes on to mention the ruler's direct reliance on personal charisma and record of military success as complementary elements. One could further emphasize that doctrinal reform, appeal to Turko-Mongol solidarity, personal charisma, and military prowess do not exhaust the range of legitimizing factors. Schemes of tax extraction and wealth redistribution, especially by way of modifying patterns of land ownership, are certainly no less revealing than expressing a doctrinal preference or exchanging letters and diplomatic delegations with the rival courts. These issues are not addressed in the monograph.
In researching Nadir Shah's Quest for Legitimacy in Post-Safavid Iran, the author has utilized a variety of primary and secondary sources. Tucker's incorporation of Turkish material into his work, especially his examination of Ottoman defters, is noteworthy and commendable. His research has also been enriched by the works of contemporary historians writing in Iran who have contributed immensely to the field through collecting documents, preparing catalogues, and publishing monographs about the reign of Nadir Shah and his immediate descendants.
