“Katrina Seven Years On: The Politics of Race and Recovery” was a roundtable to be presented at the 2012 APSA Annual Meeting. Participants were prepared to discuss developments in rebuilding New Orleans since Hurricane Katrina toppled the faulty levees and flooded 80% of the city in 2005. However, the APSA meeting itself was washed away from the city of New Orleans by the approach of Hurricane Isaac. This time, the levees held and New Orleans was spared all but relatively minor damage and days of power outages. But the flooding in some New Orleans-area towns lying outside the federal levee system was just as deep, if not as widespread, as the post-Katrina flooding. And by the time Isaac made its final landfall on what was to be the first day of the APSA meeting, the conference had been canceled.
While not the most tragic outcome of Isaac's wrath, the canceled roundtable was a lost opportunity for participants and would-be attendees to exchange ideas and information about racial justice and post-disaster recovery exactly seven years after Katrina hit the Gulf Coast. As a member of the APSA Committee on Siting and Engagement, and thus one of the roundtable organizers, I had the privilege of reading and assembling comments by and about the research and activities of the scholars and activists recruited for the roundtable, for readers of PS. Roundtable participants include:
-
– Carol Bebelle, executive director and co-founder of the Ashé Cultural Arts Center, New Orleans
-
– Marla K. Nelson, associate professor of planning and urban studies, University of New Orleans
-
– James Perry, executive director of the Greater New Orleans Fair Housing Action Center, New Orleans
-
– Loretta Pyles, associate professor, School of Social Welfare, University at Albany, State University of New York
-
– Steve Striffler, Doris Zemurray Stone Chair in Latin American Studies and professor of anthropology, University of New Orleans.
As residents of the hard-hit areas in Hurricane Isaac's path began the arduous rebuilding process in 2012, New Orleans continued to show signs of recovery from 2005's Hurricane Katrina. The city's population had risen to three-fourths of its pre-Katrina level and was rising still, as New Orleans was the fastest growing US city between 2010 and 2011 (Plyer Reference Plyer2013). Katrina's aftermath had damaged 70% of the occupied housing stock, resulting in a blighted housing rate that was still the nation's highest at 34% in 2010. But by 2012 the blight rate had dipped to 21% and continued to fall, while blight in some other cities increased and eclipsed that of New Orleans (Plyer and Ortiz Reference Plyer and Ortiz2012a). Tourism, one of the city's major industries, expanded steadily after Katrina, reaching 9 million visitors in 2012, the highest level since 2004's record of 10 million (Travel Agent Central 2013).
RACE AND RECOVERY: DISPARATE IMPACT
Recovery, then, is humming along in many respects, but to whose benefit and at whose expense? The storm's aftermath exacerbated previously high rates of poverty and inequality as family and neighborhood support systems were uprooted and broken. Like the storm itself, the rebuilding process has had a disproportionately negative impact on African American residents (Dawson Reference Dawson2012 Footnote 1 ; Johnson Reference Johnson2012; Logan Reference Logan2006; Simmons and Casper Reference Simmons and Casper2012). Black residents were not only more likely than white residents to live in the most flood-damaged areas; they also faced greater challenges in their efforts to return and rebuild. The city's African American population percentage dropped from 67% in 2000 to 59% in 2010, indicating that proportionately fewer black residents have returned permanently. The poverty rate among New Orleans whites is 14%; among blacks it is 32%. For children the disparate poverty rates are starker still: 48% for blacks, 7% for whites (Plyer and Ortiz Reference Plyer and Ortiz2012b). New Orleans ranks among the highest cities in the nation in income inequality, homicide and other violent crime, and homelessness (Quigley Reference Quigley2008). The state of Louisiana incarcerates more of its people, proportionately, than any other state; one out of seven black men in New Orleans is in prison, on parole, or on probation (New Orleans Times-Picayune 2012). Currently Orleans Parish Prison is under a consent decree with the US Department of Justice for human rights violations so severe as to be potentially unconstitutional (Gogola Reference Gogola2012).
Racial disparities in Americans' perceptions of the disaster and recovery are huge, as political scientist Michael Dawson notes. In the months following the storm, “90 percent of blacks and only 38 percent of whites believed that Katrina had anything to teach us about continuing racial inequality in the US”; “84 percent of blacks and only 20 percent of whites believed that the US response to Katrina would have been faster if the majority of its victims had been white” (Dawson Reference Dawson2012, 669; see also Dawson Reference Dawson2011). The disaster's disparate impact and the wide perceptual gap between blacks and whites, Dawson suggests, reflect the contrasting experiences of black and white Americans more broadly, shaped by enduring patterns of discrimination and neoliberal ideology.
PROFITS, NONPROFITS, AND DISASTER CAPITALISM
Roundtable participants expressed similar concerns about neoliberalism's effects on New Orleans' recovery, as private-sector and political elites seized opportunities created by the devastation to privatize public services and turn some tidy profits. Loretta Pyles' fieldwork as researcher and community organizer, both in New Orleans after Katrina and in Haiti after the devastating earthquake of 2010, uncovered numerous markers of “disaster capitalism” (Klein Reference Klein2007; see also Gotham Reference Gotham2012; Review Symposium 2012). In recent years, Louisiana's state government has exerted much effort to privatize public services, an effort accelerated by the near-total destruction of entire neighborhoods across New Orleans. One result is the ongoing “dismantling of public housing, health care, and education in New Orleans” (Pyles Reference Pyles2012).
Profit-driven enterprises do not dominate the city's recovery and drag it down in every case. There are, Pyles notes, numerous nonprofit and well-meaning nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) involved in rebuilding and providing crucial services. Furthermore, Louisianians statewide are engaged in debate about the costs and benefits of neoliberalism in the wake of multiple initiatives to privatize public services by the government in Baton Rouge: Does the replacement of public housing developments with mixed-income, partially subsidized developments expand people's choices and opportunities or increase the difficulty of finding an affordable place to live? Do the expansion of school vouchers for attending private schools, and the replacement of traditional public schools with charter schools, expand choices and opportunities for children stuck in failing schools or lead to the end of the public school system? Do the elimination of the state's charity hospital system and the outsourcing of public health care to private-sector clinics and hospitals replace a two-tiered health care system with more holistic and prevention-based care or take health care further out of reach for the uninsured? To the extent that any of these measures intensify people's post-Katrina struggles, they affect lower-income New Orleanians—and thus especially African American single-mother families with children—the most.
Many outside actors and organizations arrive with the best intentions of helping residents navigate the post-Katrina landscape. Nevertheless Pyles observes that in New Orleans, as in Haiti, interactions between local neighborhood groups and NGOs tend to be more supply-driven than demand-driven, with residents accountable to organizational interests more often than the other way around. Obstacles to more effective and participatory partnerships with the locals include “a lack of cultural competency, silencing discussions about inequality and racism in the community, an over-emphasis on accountability to donors, and an attachment to outcomes at the expense of processes” on the part of the NGOs (Pyles Reference Pyles2012; see also Pyles Reference Pyles2011).
URBAN PLANNING HAZARDS: JACK-O-LANTERNS AND GREEN DOTS
Urban planning professionals inject their research-based expertise into the negotiations among developers, NGOs, and residents, often to great benefit. However, Marla Nelson suggests that they face challenges similar to those that Pyles observes—challenges driven by disparate impacts across racial and class lines, as well as residents' social and cultural attachments to home and neighborhood. When the levees broke in 2005, New Orleans already had been declining in population after peaking in the 1960 Census. Developed land had expanded even as the population declined; thus population density also dropped while the number of vacant and blighted properties increased. Blight proliferated following Katrina, after the city sat in fetid water and heat for several weeks—conditions friendly to the burgeoning black mold that destroyed much of what the water and wind did not.
Devastation on such a grand scale presents opportunities for strategic rebuilding that smaller disasters would not. No one in the urban planning community savors such widespread destruction and human suffering. But Nelson and co-author Renia Ehrenfeucht cite numerous planning and redevelopment professionals who “framed the massive destruction as an ‘opportunity’ to comprehensively address the city's long-standing problems” (Ehrenfeucht and Nelson Reference Ehrenfeucht, Nelson, Dewar and Thomas2012, 133). After decades of population decline, attempts to reconcentrate the population and demolish abandoned structures were too overwhelming to tackle comprehensively—until the post-Katrina flooding (and post-flooding bulldozers) left much of the city as nearly a clean slate. Now the city could be “right-sized” by clustering rebuilding and increasing population density in the most viable and least flood-prone areas. Population clustering in this way also facilitates more efficient use of utilities and public transportation, and lends itself to safe, convenient, and pedestrian-friendly business development at the neighborhood level. The influx of federal disaster aid, philanthropic contributions, and volunteer organizations could be channeled into supporting a strategically planned recovery (Nelson Reference Nelson2012).
Well-planned redevelopment also avoids many of the problems that follow a major disaster, Nelson notes. One problem to be avoided is the haphazard, individually driven rebuilding that results in the “jack-o-lantern” effect: the patchwork of rebuilt homes and businesses, blighted structures, and empty lots resembling the gap-toothed grin of a jack-o-lantern. A second, related, problem is that of sparsely populated neighborhoods attracting little in the way of services, from grocery and retail stores to schools and hospitals. As a result, resilient homeowners who come back quickly risk finding themselves isolated in a sea of overgrown lots and a dearth of city services. This sad state of affairs is most likely to occur in lower-income, primarily African American, neighborhoods, where fewer residents have the resources for a quick return-and-rebuild. Thus, the less advantaged stand to gain the most from a citywide strategic planning process (Nelson Reference Nelson2012).
The dream of a strategically planned recovery collides with reality when residents hear that their neighborhoods, their homes and community support systems, are to be uprooted for the sake of right-sizing the city. Many New Orleanians rebelled against yet another traumatic round of dislocation and upheaval. The shrinking footprint and the “green dot” became notorious symbols of exclusion. Some city planners and policy makers discussed shrinking the city's footprint—that area of the city zoned for redevelopment and extension of services and infrastructure—much to the dismay of residents in low-lying, hard-hit areas eager to rebuild but fearful of being redlined out. Green dots on the redevelopment map produced by urban planners for the mayor's Bring New Orleans Back Commission suggested that entire neighborhoods should not be rebuilt but rather left as green space for parkland and drainage. African American residents, more likely than whites to live in the hardest-hit areas of the city, were disproportionately battered first by the flooding, and then again by the threat of neighborhood displacement (Nelson Reference Nelson2012).Footnote 2
The storm's physical destruction and economic impact on the city also overwhelmed the influx of resources and volunteers. Infrastructure was decimated; half of city employees were laid off; chaotic crisis management replaced daily routines. Under these conditions the city struggled to develop even minimal recovery strategies, to say nothing of garnering the resources, capacities, and public support for devising ways to compensate displaced residents, such as land swaps or relocation aid. The demolition of public housing developments, which federal and local public housing officials deemed too expensive to rehabilitate, and their replacement with less dense, mixed-income developments further constricted the housing options for lower-income African American residents wishing to return. “Absent a citywide strategy to deal with weak market neighborhoods and the residents that live within them, the resulting patterns of recovery and redevelopment stand to exacerbate historic injustices and inequities among neighborhoods and residents” (Nelson Reference Nelson2012; see also Ehrenfeucht and Nelson Reference Ehrenfeucht, Nelson, Dewar and Thomas2012).
LABOR CHALLENGES AND PROTEST MOVEMENTS
Therefore, crafting a rational, humane, and nondiscriminatory recovery process presents myriad challenges, even assuming well-intentioned altruism among contributors to the process. It is all the more challenging in the context of disaster capitalism and economic opportunism. Roundtable participants generally agree that any remedy to the problems must include progressive, collective citizen participation. But Steve Striffler's participant observation leads to his conclusion that “there is no viable, coherent Left in New Orleans” (Striffler Reference Striffler2012; see also Striffler Reference Striffler2011). The city certainly is not devoid of progressive grassroots activity, including a variety of mostly single-issue NGOs, labor unions, neighborhood-based community groups, and committed individual activists, but most are resource poor and “so overwhelmed that they can barely tread water” (Striffler Reference Striffler2012—speaking metaphorically after the flood waters were pumped out of the city). Unions are declining in membership and facing strong corporate and political opposition. This situation, he notes, is not so different from the rest of the country, but the city's poverty and post-disaster devastation inhibit strong, united action even with activists streaming into the city to aid the recovery. In addition, while local politics is Democratic-dominated, the local political class “regardless of its racial makeup is focused primarily on keeping power … , feels no political threat from progressives, and does little to challenge more reactionary political forces on the state level” (Striffler Reference Striffler2012).
Two events that Striffler attended during one weekend in 2011 illustrate both the potential for mobilizing grassroots action and the fragmentation of the Left that limits its influence on public policy. One was the initial organizing meeting of Occupy NOLA, one of many Occupy groups around the country inspired by Occupy Wall Street. Comprised of “a vaguely radical, largely white, contingent who shared, among other things, a complete disconnect from organized labor” (Striffler Reference Striffler2012), Occupy NOLA, like Occupy groups elsewhere, drew some significant media and public attention to poverty and inequality by staging marches and camping out in front of City Hall.
The other event, the Save Our Shipyard march and rally, protested the planned closure of Avondale shipyard, one of the region's largest employers with nearly 5,000 workers. At a time of nationally high unemployment in a struggling post-recession economy, the threatened loss of thousands of high-paying unionized manufacturing jobs drew more than 500 people—a racially diverse crowd reflecting the demographics of both the region and Avondale's workforce—to “probably the largest labor march in New Orleans' recent history” (Striffler Reference Striffler2012). Although numerous sectors of the community, including local businesses, political leaders, and churches, support the effort to keep Avondale open, and media coverage is sympathetic, the marchers were almost exclusively union members. Striffler recognizes the distinct goals, ideologies, and group cultures that separate Occupy NOLA's actions from those of Save Our Shipyard and, more broadly, the variety of goals and activities of local progressive organizations. But the lack of active, influential allies constrains organized labor's ability to influence even merely defensive policies that could save jobs. Currently, Avondale may remain open, not as a shipyard with 5,000 employees but perhaps as an energy-sector manufacturing facility employing up to 2,000, after the Save Our Shipyard campaign helped persuade the federal government to withdraw funding for shutting down the facility while persuading the state government to contribute financial incentives for keeping it open (Striffler Reference Striffler2012). Would a broader and more united effort of the Left have greater success in preventing massive downsizing and job loss?
FIGHTING DISCRIMINATION IN HOUSING
The absence of a broadly coherent and united progressive force in New Orleans prior to Katrina helps to explain what happened after the storm: the deaths and the squalid shelter conditions televised to a shocked nation and world, the massive destruction exacerbated by the city's high poverty rate and substandard structures and infrastructure, the difficulties suffered by residents anxious to return and rebuild, and the difficulties in organizing grassroots resistance to neoliberal privatization efforts. The ongoing restriction and transformation of housing, schools, and health care in particular “funnel ever greater profits to elites while at the same time making it ever more difficult for a viable Left to emerge” (Striffler Reference Striffler2012).
Multiple progressive efforts have nevertheless successfully organized residents to fight injustice, rebuild their broken homes and lives, and recapture that particular widespread brand of New Orleans joie de vivre. Two of the roundtable participants are among the leaders of those efforts: James Perry in the struggle for fair housing policies, and Carol Bebelle in the cultural and artistic aspects of disaster recovery.
Perry's Greater New Orleans Fair Housing Action Center (GNOFHAC) promotes widespread access to housing as well as fairness and nondiscrimination in all aspects of housing policy such as lending, zoning, and rebuilding. In a city with 70% of its housing stock severely damaged or destroyed, what issue could be more crucial than fair housing access?
Two major post-Katrina housing issues illustrate GNOFHAC's range and influence. The first is the disparate racial impact of the home rebuilding grants provided by Louisiana's federally funded “Road Home” program—the largest post-disaster housing recovery program in US history. Road Home grants were issued to homeowners based on the pre-storm value of their homes, rather than on the cost of rebuilding. Those who lived in predominantly African American neighborhoods generally had their houses appraised at lower amounts than similar homes in predominantly white neighborhoods. The market value of a New Orleans house, in other words, varies with the racial composition of the neighborhood. The cost of building materials, however, does not change from one area of the city to another. As a result, African American homeowners tended to receive less toward the overall cost of rebuilding than did white homeowners. A class-action lawsuit brought by GNOFHAC, the National Fair Housing Alliance, and five homeowners resulted in a settlement bringing additional rebuilding funds to thousands of residents (Eaton Reference Eaton2011).
The second issue involves alleged housing discrimination in St. Bernard Parish, a mostly white middle- and working-class suburban parish just to the city's east that was almost entirely inundated by the post-Katrina flooding. Soon after the storm, parish officials had imposed a moratorium on the construction of multifamily residential structures and also had passed an ordinance restricting rentals of single-family homes to homeowners' blood relatives, in a parish where 93% of homeowners are white (Adams Reference Adams2012). Although the Parish denied any racial discrimination, GNOFHAC's class-action lawsuits charged otherwise. Ultimately the blood-relative ordinance was changed; disputed multifamily housing developments got the green light in federal court; and the parish was ordered to pay fees, costs, and damages to GNOFHAC and coplaintiffs (Alexander-Bloch Reference Alexander-Bloch2012). “Everyone should have an opportunity to choose where they want to live regardless of their race,” Perry said, “and we sincerely hope that new Parish leadership will take the appropriate steps necessary to end discrimination on the part of the Parish once and for all” (Adams Reference Adams2012, 1).
CULTURE AND RECOVERY
Fulfilling material needs like housing is critical in the wake of catastrophic destruction. Cultural and spiritual fulfillment is crucial as well; emotional recovery and physical recovery are inextricably linked. Carol Bebelle, and the Ashé Cultural Arts Center, which she co-founded in 1998, are in the vanguard of New Orleans' cultural and spiritual recovery. Ashé is a multiuse facility hosting a variety of art exhibits, cultural productions, and community events and gatherings. Ashé's “innovative programs and projects … are designed to utilize culture to foster human development, civic engagement and economic justice in the African-American community” (Ashé Cultural Arts Center 2012a).
Creative, artistic, and cultural endeavors are important to both disaster preparation and post-disaster recovery, Bebelle explains in a presentation to the Japan Society. People did not just lose their homes and material possessions in Katrina's aftermath; they also lost social connections with neighbors and loved ones and with the city's unique cultural networks and traditions. Many of the storm's casualties are attributable to the trauma and sadness of loss and dislocation. For survivors, spiritual healing is critical to physical recovery; people do not simply bounce back on automatic pilot. Creative and recreational outlets such as festivals, theater, poetry, music, and dance help to heal the spirit, generate the energy for rebuilding, and restore the joy of living (DocNOproductions 2009).
Ashé led a consortium of cultural, educational, and community groups to form the Katrina Warriors Network shortly after Katrina. The Katrina Warriors hatched a wide variety of productions and activities primarily aimed at promoting the well-being of Katrina-area women and girls, and more generally at reviving New Orleans' cultural, artistic, and spiritual life. The theatrical production Swimming Upstream is perhaps the best known of these: co-produced by Eve Ensler, “it tells the raw and soulful stories of women who lived through Hurricanes Katrina and Rita with grace, rage and great resiliency, punctuated by a flair for storytelling, humor and music that comes from being New Orleanian” (Ashé Cultural Arts Center 2012b; see also Fensterstock Reference Fensterstock2008).
CONCLUSION
Hurricane Isaac may have thwarted the APSA's determination to meet in New Orleans, to demonstrate its support for the recovering city, and to enjoy the city's cultural and culinary delights. In the process, Isaac also thwarted the opportunity to gather this distinguished group of scholars and activists for the roundtable on “Katrina Seven Years On.” But neither Katrina nor Isaac can defeat their message of resilience, recovery, and racial justice.
