In Highbrow/Lowdown: Theater, Jazz, and the Making of the New Middle Class, theater historian David Savran explains that he has “strung chapters together as if [he] were assembling a vaudeville show or revue” (9), and the analogy is apt. Reworked bits from earlier writings stand alongside newly created sections. The assortment of characters, topics, works, and ideas that crowd the book are breathtaking and entertaining, just like a good variety show. There is a thrill factor to the study, similar to what Savran identifies as a distinguishing aspect of vaudeville (36). But too often the intellectual juggling act makes it hard to keep track of everything in the air. Although all seven chapters treat jazz and theater in some way, a cohesive argument for their relationship, or even for what constitutes jazz, is elusive. Perhaps this book is best dipped into a chapter at a time, rather than read straight through.
Savran confines his scholarly revue to a single decade of U.S. theater, the 1920s, “a period of extraordinary social and economic change” in the United States (2). He locates the emergence of legitimate theater within the “Age of the Flapper,” “The New Era,” and “The Jazz Age,” and points to the systematic construction and branding of Eugene O'Neill “as the savior who drove the money lenders from the temple of art” (2). Readers sense early on that Savran is not a disciple of O'Neill, the Messiah of the influential theater critic George Jean Nathan (1882–1958). As the final chapter makes clear, O'Neill's and Nathan's disparagement of everything associated with jazz places them deep within enemy territory in Savran's construction of 1920s culture wars, where jazz, he argues, was ubiquitous and all important.
For Savran, jazz is more than music, and this helps explain the relative absence of a sustained discussion of jazz as many contemporary musicians might construe the term. Jazz is a “portal to a new world,” “a structure of feeling,” “a particular quality of social experience and relationship” (4), or the representation of “a social relation” (6). Jazz is a Weltanschauung, a way of being (12). Adopting Isaac Goldberg's characterization of the term, Savran understands jazz as “a mésalliance, an example of miscegenation” (14). He reads Broadway as a metonym for jazz (16), and jazz as a “fulcrum dividing . . . universalizing modernism from its popular mongrelized other” (19), and as “a diasporic art” (34). The metaphorical mélange is evidence of the range of Savran's representations of the term, and perhaps of his discomfort with the actual sounds. Although he acknowledges that jazz was invented by musicians, he quickly turns from musical sound per se to his interest, which is the ways multiple art forms, and theater most especially, “capitalize[d] on its cultural and social power and allure” (35).
Savran treats an enormous range of ideas with virtuosic confidence. If the structure of the book invites comparison with vaudeville, the critical underpinning, the tone, and the performance style of the prose speak decisively to the “intelligent minority” that the author associates with the legitimate theater. Theodor Adorno, Gilbert Seldes, Milton Gordon, and Robert and Helen Lynd make appearances; Pierre Bourdieu is an omnipresent partner in Savran's exegesis. And although Savran criticizes the “substitution of moral judgment for sociological analysis” (46) he does not shy away from offering his judgments along with analyses, which are interwoven throughout the book. It is hard not to read judgment in the phrase “a phobic response” that Savran uses to describe William Emerson's reaction to the working classes (128), or in the simultaneously biblical and ironic cadences that Savran adopts in his introduction to the chapter on O'Neill (221). Although Savran criticizes reductive thinking that pits highbrow against lowbrow, or constructions of black and white as monolithic categories (24), he appears comfortable presenting Anglo-Saxon/Protestants and Jews as exclusive types loyal to opposing artistic endeavors and locked in a death dance that was regularly enacted on stage. Old money, Protestant Yankees are invariably characterized as opponents of Jews and “Jewish Jazz,” and more generally as opponents of progress. The Jewish contribution to an American vernacular musical style, on the other hand, is heroic and read as “less appropriative than collaborative” (70). No informed person questions the roles played by Jewish composers, performers, producers, or entertainers in twentieth-century U.S. musical culture, but it is a stretch to claim in regards to jazz that “Jews . . . were . . . primarily responsible for its popular and commercial success with white audiences” (31). This is hard to reconcile with the historical record and Savran's earlier statement that “for the vast majority of white Americans, the aptly surnamed Mr. Whiteman was indeed the (self-crowned) King of Jazz” (24). And then there was Duke Ellington at The Cotton Club.
Savran marshals his point of view to provide a mind-expanding study of class, gender, race, and the power of critics in the 1920s. He reviews jazz historiography, surveys intellectual property laws as they applied to written scores and recorded performances, explains the basics of music business economics, and offers insights into the interrelationships of social classes and forms of capital à la Bourdieu. Among Savran's outstanding achievements are his discussions of Shuffle Along, Noble Sisle's and Eubie Blake's 1921 all-black musical, and Elmer Rice's 1923 American expressionist play The Adding Machine, which allow him to explore convincing, jazz-inspired connections. His comparison of John Alden Carpenter's Skyscrapers and George Antheil's Ballet mécanique reveals his idea of jazz cosmopolitanism, his own term for populist modernism (176). The final chapter, “The Canonization of Eugene O'Neill,” presents one of the most coherent and convincing statements regarding the notion of canon, and contains an extended attack on the critic George Jean Nathan and the role he played in the canonization of O'Neill. Savran argues that the playwright enjoyed posthumous success, compliments of an “interpretive framework for his life and work” that was shaped by Nathan and other critics (263).
Savran writes lucidly and engagingly, and readers don't have to work hard to understand his arguments or appreciate the breadth of knowledge and experience regarding American theater that he brings to this study. That said, scholars of American music might want more. I wondered about his characterization of 1920s jazz as “the first and arguably the most heated of the culture wars fought over music in the United States” (10). Late eighteenth-century debates over “regular” singing, and mid nineteenth-century declarations of artistic independence were heated. A small factual correction relates to the placement of Rhapsody in Blue in Paul Whiteman's 12 February 1924 “Experiment in Modern Music” concert. Gershwin's Rhapsody was the penultimate piece, not the final one; it was followed by Edward Elgar's “Pomp and Circumstance March No. 1.” The incongruity of the pairing, and the close of a modern music concert with a piece that has become synonymous with tradition and now de rigueur at American graduation ceremonies sheds light on the variety of musical styles regularly vying for air time in the early years of the twentieth century.
A final point regards Savran's discussion of Carpenter's Krazy Kat: A Jazz Pantomime (1921). The author correctly notes that the work was “the first piece of art music to use the word jazz in its title,” but he seems to question its jazz credentials because it “owes far more to Spanish dance music . . . than to the hot jazz that had taken Chicago by storm” (190). Musicologist Charles Hiroshi Garrett devotes a chapter of his book Struggling to Define a Nation to Jelly Roll Morton and the Spanish tinge. He likens the origins of jazz as “to a musical gumbo, the product of a creative collision that was centered in the city of New Orleans” and directly related to the Creole culture so influential there.Footnote 1 Spanish, Latin, and Caribbean sounds and rhythms were original ingredients in the jazz gumbo, not afterthought seasonings: John Alden Carpenter got that right.
Everyone interested in twentieth-century American music culture can learn from Savran's boundary-crossing book. His perspective from outside the confines of music scholarship brings fresh insights to our understanding of the cultural contests at work on multiple levels of society, and especially to those being enacted on stage. Highbrow/Lowdown underscores the intimate and sometimes contentious relationships tying together music and what Savran believes to be the closest of her sister arts, theater.
