In Ibn Tufayl's classic tale of man in nature and nature in man, we learn how the protagonist Hayy ibn Yaqzan came to understand the utility of fire for cooking. Throwing various materials into fire to test how they burned, Hayy on one occasion tossed a fish into the flames. As the animal's flesh roasted, it sent off pleasant aromas that aroused Hayy's appetite. It was in this way, Ibn Tufayl tells us, that Hayy learned how to cook and eat meat.
In Resurrecting the Granary of Rome—another story about nature and the narratives told about nature—Diana Davis has similarly thrown multiple literatures, sources, and historiographies into the fire of her historical analysis, giving us a sweet-smelling account of the Maghribi environment and French colonialism that will serve as a model for future work on the intersections of environmental and colonial histories. Her primary argument rests on an analysis of what—following from the American environmental historian William Cronon—she identifies as the “declensionist narrative” of the North African environment. This colonial fiction claimed that a once fertile and verdant North Africa—the classic “granary of Rome”—was desertified and deforested by Arab pastoralists beginning shortly after the 11th-century “Arab invasion” of the region.
This declensionist narrative represented a rather different French account of North Africa than the one expounded before European conquest. In the precolonial story, inept North Africans were unable (and perhaps unwilling) to harness the inherent richness and potential of their local environments. For the French, this was particularly evident in “primitive” North African burning strategies that had been used effectively for centuries to increase the production of grains and livestock. The supposed environmental degradation of an ancient fertility that came to be the dominant account after conquest was used by French colonial officials to justify much of their imperial project in Algeria, Tunisia, and Morocco: the expropriation of land, the appropriation of natural resources, the creation of a colonial economy based on commodity production rather than subsistence, the sedentarization of nomads, reforestation schemes, the pitting of the “sedentary and benevolent” Kabyle against the “marauding and irrational” Arab, and other similarly draconian initiatives. Furthermore, the scientification and institutionalization of the declensionist narrative in the young sciences of phytosociology (plant ecology), phytogeography (botanical geography), forestry, and eventually in environmental policy and law ensured the longevity of this particular French-imperial casting of the North African environment from the colonial period to the postcolonial present.
By tracing how the declensionist narrative became the dominant environmental history of North Africa, Davis has paved the way for other environmental accounts of North Africa challenging this colonial narrative. This is perhaps the single most significant contribution of the book. Davis's detailing of how the French imagined the North African environment thus leaves us with ample space within which to reconstruct countersubaltern and even counterimperial narratives to this colonial story. Davis does indeed reference some of these latter “voices of dissent” (pp. 12–13 and 45)—for instance, the work of Charles-Louis Trabut and Jules-Aimé Battandier espousing an alternative narrative of botany in colonial Algeria. Her reliance on French-colonial sources and the imperial archive begs us to wonder about the existence of numerous other parallel environmental accounts in the local sources and archives of North Africa. What other narratives of North African environments could be written from Arabic, Ottoman Turkish, or other sources of the period? How, for example, did nomads, peasants, and others appear in and use the Islamic courts of North Africa to adjudicate disputes involving forests, irrigation, and the like? Davis has constructed for us the structure of the dominant French narrative of North African environments so that future work can be put toward challenging, refining, and dismantling this colonial account.
Moreover, as Davis notes near the end of her book, scholars of the Middle East have yet to fully embrace environmental history as a mode of analysis on par with gender, culture, or class. Given the obvious fact that the vast majority of those in the Middle East over the last few millennia of documented history have lived in constant consort with land, water, and natural resources, environmental history—as Davis cogently argues and embodies in her analysis—offers us new interpretative frameworks for the study of the Middle East. Thus, as Davis masterfully shows us, assertions of the supposed decline of North African environments were integral to French colonization of the region.
This book is not simply a call to historians of the Middle East to take note of the utility of an environmental perspective, however; it also has much to say about the literatures of environmental history and colonial and postcolonial studies. As evidenced by a recent award from the American Society for Environmental History (one of several awards for this book), Davis's study has done more than any other previous work to place the Middle East on the agenda of environmental history. She shows, for example, how the French experience in 19th-century Algeria influenced colonial debates over desiccation, desertification, and deforestation in South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa and contributed to the emergence of plant ecology and other environmental sciences in France. She is, more generally, interested in “interrogating the deep origins of ideas and constructions” (p. 175) like potential vegetation maps, deforestation, desiccation theory, the environmental policies of postcolonial North African states, and the environmental work of international nongovernmental organizations. With regard to colonial and postcolonial studies, Davis's book outlines how French-colonial environmental policies influenced those of Algeria, Tunisia, and Morocco after independence and, indeed, continue to do so today. Again, Davis has worked to place the environment alongside law, gender, economy, and social policy as legacies of colonialism in the postcolonial Middle East.
With an extremely useful synthetic appendix on the geography and ecology of the Maghrib, a bibliography, an index, and various figures, maps, and illustrations (some in color), this pathbreaking book should be required reading for all those interested in the history of the Maghrib, environmental history, and the history of colonialism.
