Kaxton Siu's new book is an impressive comparative study of garment factory workers in Hong Kong, China, and Vietnam. It provides ethnographic detail and rigorous analysis of our understanding of labor, economics, and the state with a recognition of change over time.
Siu argues that the image that most readers might have of Chinese garment factories, with young girls migrating to factories, living in dormitories, with no autonomy, is outdated. It was more accurate in the 1990s, but he argues that scholars need to see beyond what he calls the “subjugation model” (p. 6).
His study is organized into three parts. First, Siu examines Hong Kong garment workers in the 1980s and early 1990s to provide a historical counterpoint to China and Vietnam's contemporary industries. Next, he looks at factories in Shenzhen in southern China (near Hong Kong) and the growing diversity of labor control and negotiations. He ends the study by traveling to Vietnam to compare how the government does (or does not) protect its workers in the international garment industry. Throughout it all, Siu analyzes the relationship between the state and the economy, with an emphasis on gender and workers’ rights in all three locales.
Siu begins with the history of garment work in Hong Kong from the late 1970s through the early 1990s. His relationship to the topic is personal: his mother was a garment worker, and he visited the factories with her as a child. He uses two life stories to provide personal and compelling stories about Hong Kong women's experiences in the garment industry. He highlights their pride in the skills they achieved, arguing against the notion that they were unskilled workers. Despite their experience and skill, macroeconomic forces shifted the factories to China, and these women entered Hong Kong's low-wage service sector in the 1990s.
The heart of the book is in chapters 3, 4, and 5, in which Siu analyzes contemporary garment factories in Shenzhen. In these chapters, he provides detailed information about gender politics, maximum hour and minimum wage laws, and the relationship between the shop floor and workers’ leisure time. He opens with a study of letters written by Chinese women garment workers in the early 1990s that outline their struggles and desires. He argues that today's factory workers are more heterogeneous than they were twenty years ago, and he explores the relationship between their factory work, their social lives, and village-based networks.
Next, Siu turns to the factory floor. Siu conducted a survey of 389 factory workers, and through this tool, he learned that most knew about China's minimum wage laws but were unaware of any maximum hour laws. In fact, undercompensated overtime was a fact of life for almost all workers. He writes, “Workers simply did not believe the Chinese labor law could be so good. The content of the law contradicts their everyday working experience” (p. 96).
In contrast to the 1990s, Siu argues that there was more negotiation in the twenty-first-century Chinese factory. It continued to be difficult for Chinese workers to quit their factory jobs (because of recruitment deposits) or avoid “voluntary overtime.” However, at the same time, there were also regular negotiations between workers and supervisors, demonstrating how “affective ties” added to more coercive forms of control. He calls this “a new regime of ‘conciliatory despotism’” that has “replace[d] the dormitory labor regime” (p. 146). While I imagine there was also negotiation on the shop floor in the 1990s, Siu demonstrates that management had less of an iron-clad grip on their employers than they did previously.
Finally, he turns to Vietnam. Unlike in China, more Vietnamese workers come from nearby the factory-sites, and more people migrate in family units. This means that both women and men have responsibilities outside the factory than individuals who migrate to Shenzhen. The result is that workers spend less time on-the-job in Vietnam. In contrast to China, Siu argues that the Vietnamese minimum wage law is so low as to be negligible and invisible in workers’ lives. At the same time, Vietnamese workers were far more likely to go on strike than Chinese workers. (There were more than eight hundred strikes in 2011.) Siu suggests that the government tolerated this level of worker activism to increase the overall financial investment in the country without having to change its laws.
Overall, the book succeeds in integrating macro-level analysis at the state level in Hong Kong, China, and Vietnam while still providing personal stories of workers in all three locales. It also provides a strong gender analysis that emphasizes women's experiences. At times, Siu's discussions of Karl Marx, Michel Foucault, and E. P. Thompson distract somewhat from his original research. That said, the combination of comparative qualitative and quantitative methods is exemplary, and Siu succeeds in documenting larger economic trends and workers’ lived experiences. Chinese Migrant Workers and Employer Domination is a valuable contribution for scholars of labor, migration, and capitalism in the twenty-first century.
