The Roman Empire in the first and second centuries was administered by letters sent to and from emperors and provincial governors, as exemplified by Pliny's letters from Bithynia et Pontus under Trajan. During the third century there was often more than one emperor who was frequently not in Rome, and the number of provinces increased too. Praetorian prefects became increasingly important for administration and by the early fourth century Constantine had added an additional layer of administrators between them and governors: the vicarii. Lukas Lemcke looks at how late Roman emperors and their governors, cities and subjects routinely communicated with each other. He focuses on the period between Constantine and Justinian using the evidence preserved by the Codices Theodosiani and Justiniani.
The two opening chapters lay out the current state of research and introduce the evidence, particularly the two legal collections. The way that the imperial chancery edited documents for different officials is well brought out (28), as is the theoretical right of a praetorian prefect to reject a law (59, 99). The core of the work is ch. 3, looking at communications sent to the emperor, and ch. 4, looking at communications from the emperor to his subordinates. Both chapters have an excellent graphical summary showing changes in document routing over time (ch. 3: 84–5, ch. 4: 131–2). Ch. 4 also makes good use of six epigraphic dossiers, all interestingly enough from Anatolia, showing multiple levels of government (102–8). L. stresses the less well-known period of the late fifth and early sixth centuries, though the surviving laws of Leo, Zeno and Anastasius, the epigraphy, especially the dossier from Casae (105–6), and the military regulations under Anastasius (Onur, Monumentum Pergense (2014)) suggest little change in the east, while lack of evidence makes statements about the west in this period problematic.
Ch. 5 focuses on the administration required for taxation, with significant coordination between prefects and the comes rei privatae and the comes sacrarum largitionum required by the mid-fourth century. L.'s statement that no cadastral lists have survived (153) overlooks the inscriptions from Anatolia and the Aegean recently discussed by P. Thonemann (Chiron 37 (2007), 435–78, dating them to the early fourth century) and K. Harper (JRS 98 (2008), 83–119, with stronger arguments for dating them towards the end of the century). L. suggests more energy was devoted to collecting taxes than to keeping assessments up to date (153). Ch. 6 sums up the work with a historical overview, dividing communication mechanics into two major periods, from Constantine to 450 and from 450 to Justinian, though the shortage of evidence from the late fifth and early sixth centuries means that what L. says about his second period is mostly about Justinian. In the first period, vicarii played little role in communications from the emperor, which tended to come through prefects, but vicarii were important in communication (especially about taxes) from provinces to a prefect or emperor. This pattern continued until the reign of Justinian, who abolished the vicarii as intermediate administrators in 535, after which communication to the emperor always flowed through prefects. Four appendices cover laws with difficult dates and discuss the data for chs 3 and 4.
The focus on mechanics of government means that this is a very different sort of approach to running the empire than is found in P. Brown, Power and Persuasion (1992), C. Kelly, Ruling the Later Roman Empire (2004) and F. Millar, Greek Roman Empire (2006), all of which concentrate on the humans involved and show the flexibility of Late Roman administration in which it was always possible to ignore the rules in communications both to and from the emperor. L.'s approach allows him to deal more briskly with distinctions between various types of provincial governors than a Roman might (15) and brings out well the strong infrastructure of the state that made administrative flexibility possible, especially the heavy workload of judges (48–56), the volume of material transmitted to the emperor via the cursus publicus (53) and the frequency of communication regarding taxes, not least because of quarterly payments (152). At the same time, the focus on the lawcodes means that less use is made of documents in the Collectio Avellana, Symmachus’ Relationes and ecclesiastical affairs than another scholar might have done, but it also means that discussion of these sources can now proceed in a more confident fashion. Overall, a useful book that expands our knowledge of the effectiveness of late Roman government and adds new insights into what vicarii did.
