As a result of workplace clean air regulations and strict guidelines imposed by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations in 1993, most hospitals in the United States are now virtually smoke free.Footnote 1 Although evidence suggests that these restrictions both cause smoking employees to consume fewer cigarettes per dayFootnote 2 and induce some employees to quit smoking entirely,Footnote 3 the policies have also driven many healthcare providers—including physicians—onto the public sidewalks for their cigarette breaks. Patients entering many hospitals pass white-coated medical students and residents puffing away at the curbside. At Columbia University's New York-Presbyterian Hospital in New York City, one finds physicians indulging their habits in the same public garden where cardiac patients recuperate; the doors to Rhode Island Hospital, Brown University's primary teaching affiliate, are often clouded in a haze of tobacco smoke. Physicians use tobacco at considerably lower rates than does the general population, but 17% self-identified as cigarette smokers as recently as 1993.Footnote 4 At least one study suggests that the sizable number of physicians who smoke visibly encourage smoking among their patients.Footnote 5 If a connection does exist between doctors “modeling unhealthy behaviors” and patients mimicking those behaviors,Footnote 6 the medical profession must confront a challenging ethical question: To what degree may physicians engage in an unhealthy activity that is also likely to induce destructive behavior in their patients and the public at large?
Much has been written about the ways in which physicians serve as role models for younger members of the medical profession.Footnote 7 In contrast, the literature on physicians as role models for patients or the general public is relatively scant. Several journal editorials have argued in broad terms for doctors to serve as exemplars of good health for their communities.Footnote 8 None has argued that this noble aspiration should be elevated to an ethical obligation alongside such traditional aspects of medical duty as confidentiality and beneficence. State licensing boards have been uniformly unwilling to censure physicians for otherwise legal but unhealthy conduct that occurs outside the clinical setting. The supreme court of at least one state has found that “disciplining physicians for lack of good moral character, and for conduct that undermines public confidence in the integrity of the profession,” is well within the rights of professional authoritiesFootnote 9—yet, to date, regulatory bodies have limited their extraclinical mission to disciplining physicians who engage in illegal acts such as drug use or machine-gun possession.Footnote 10 Although smoking remains the “leading preventable cause of death in the United States,” and smoking by physicians threatens to undermine the anti-tobacco message that the medical community is urging upon patients, no medical school has added an anti-tobacco pledge to its graduation oath and no state licensing board has yet considered a blanket prohibition upon smoking by physicians.Footnote 11 With approximately 440,000 Americans dying from tobacco-related deaths each year, such a radical approach may be merited.Footnote 12
Physician Autonomy versus the Public Good
Personal autonomy—what John Stuart Mill calls “pursuing our own good in our own way”—is one of the core values of American society.Footnote 13 This is particularly true in bioethics. We now regularly speak of patient autonomy in the medical decisionmaking process and also of physician autonomy in the context of insurance companies and managed care plans. More recently, advocates for the interests of tobacco users have adopted the language of autonomy to challenge laws restricting public smoking.Footnote 14 Even many who favor some form of tobacco regulation, like Harvard Law Professor W. Kip Viscusi, now acknowledge a “right to smoke.”Footnote 15 To place restrictions on smoking smacks of naked paternalism—and, to many, is fundamentally un-American. Yet acknowledging an autonomy interest in tobacco use does not necessitate privileging it as a right. Instead, one should balance the interests of smokers in indulging their habit with the impact of their actions upon society. In 1996, the village of Friendship Heights, Maryland, banned smoking in most outdoor public places. One defender of this legislation explained: “Just as we regulate what's in the best interest of the community with seat belt laws, alcohol restrictions, and motorcycle helmets, in this case we're trying to persuade people to stop smoking with a little gentle pressure.”Footnote 16 Another motive for the hamlet's action was to decrease the social acceptability of the habit—particularly among adolescents. Although such general bans on smoking by laypersons raise complex questions about how to balance personal autonomy and the public health, the historical and ethical grounds for curtailing smoking by physicians are far stronger.
State regulation of professionals dates “from time immemorial,” and regulating the behavior of physicians so “that the community might trust with confidence those receiving a license under authority of the state” was endorsed by the Supreme Court more than a century ago.Footnote 17 It is now an established principle that “when a conflict arises between a physician's right to pursue a medical profession and the state's right to protect its citizenry, the physician's right must yield to the state's power to prescribe reasonable rules and regulations in order to protect the state's people.”Footnote 18 The practice of medicine, in other words, is not a right. It is a public trust. From this understanding of the relationship between the individual physician and society, it follows that any behavior on the part of the physicians that undermines this trust can be restricted. That criterion would clearly embrace smoking on the sidewalk in front of the hospital. Or in a nearby cafe frequented by patients. But ought such a prohibition extend to the privacy of the physician's home? Several factors suggest it should. First, evidence suggests that “physicians and nurses who smoke are less likely to counsel patients to stop smoking”;Footnote 19 one could rectify this problem by requiring disclosure on the part of the healthcare provider, but that would undermine the principal goal of providing healthy role models. Moreover, the nature of smoking makes such a public–private distinction virtually impossible to maintain. Physicians who purchase cigarettes in public places, physicians who smell like tobacco, and physicians whose social networks overlap with those of their patients will all quickly undermine a “don't ask, don't tell” approach to tobacco use. This appears to be one of those instances where a blanket rule best serves the public.
Lessons from Other Professions
Other professions have been far less reluctant than medicine to prohibit their members from engaging in a variety of off-duty activities that are perfectly legal for the public at large. Despite a widespread perception to the contrary, professional sports authorities have consistently sanctioned participants for legal off-the-field behavior. Baseball Commissioner Bowie Kuhn shocked the sports world in the early 1980s by banning Hall of Fame players Mickey Mantle and Willie Mays for doing public relations work for Atlantic City gambling casinos.Footnote 20 Their association with gambling, according to Kuhn, brought baseball into ill repute. Other individuals punished for “associating with gamblers” or betting on activities not related to baseball include manager Leo Durocher (1947), owner George Steinbrenner (1990), and player Lenny Dyksra (1991).Footnote 21 Commissioner Bud Selig banished Cincinnati Reds owner Marge Schott from the sport in 1992 for off-the-field remarks that were judged to be racist and anti-Semitic.Footnote 22 At the time of Schott's removal, Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz observed that the First Amendment did not apply because “owning a baseball team is a privilege” that comes with ethical obligations not imposed upon the general public.Footnote 23 In a similar incident, the National Basketball Association fined star Dennis Rodman $50,000 in 1997 for derogatory remarks about Mormons.Footnote 24 Although the rules governing moral conduct by professional athletes are often hazy and the imposition of punishment haphazard, participants have long accepted that their status as “role models” allows their leagues to restrict their off-duty behavior in certain ways.
School teachers are also held to codes of off-duty conduct. Although precise regulations differ from state to state, most proscribe behavior that is “unbecoming” or “immoral.” Society tolerates these restrictions because “the teacher's role is unique in our society” and “teachers are intended by parents, citizenry, and lawmakers alike to serve as good examples for their young charges.”Footnote 25 These rules have been used to remove from office teachers who were living with a person other than their spouse or were pregnant outside of marriage.Footnote 26 Even lawyers have obligations as role models. The most famous legal case on the subject is that of Matthew Hale, a 1998 graduate of Southern Illinois Law School and an avowed white supremacist who founded the World Church of the Creator. Holding that Hale's racist views “diametrically opposed the letter and spirit” of the state's Rules of Professional Conduct, the Illinois Supreme Court rejected his application for admission to the bar.Footnote 27 Another prospective attorney was denied a license to practice in Minnesota for failing to repay his student loans in a timely manner—even though he had legally discharged them through bankruptcy.Footnote 28 In these cases, maintaining confidence in the bar was a valid enough reason to exclude law-abiding citizens from the profession.
From military rules prohibiting tongue splitting to restrictions on the right of Department of Housing and Urban Development officials to manage slum property, nearly every established profession or calling places some limits upon its members off-duty behavior.Footnote 29 Many of these regulations proscribe activities far less deleterious and far less threatening to the credibility of the profession than smoking by physicians is to the principles and goals of medicine. When viewed in this context, a ban on tobacco consumption by doctors no longer appears so radical.
Implementation
The prospect of medical licensing authorities breaking down the doors of physicians’ homes in search of contraband tobacco is both unappetizing and unlikely. It should also be unnecessary. The moral authority of such an ethical rule might well be enough to substantially reduce the ranks of smoking physicians. If not, three other approaches should help conform physician behavior:
1. Amend and publicize state ethics codes: State professional ethics codes should be specifically amended to prohibit smoking by physicians. These changes should then be widely publicized and the new codes should be posted in doctors’ offices and hospitals—not only to obtain compliance, but also to emphasize the collective will of the medical community. Patients who do witness noncompliant physicians, if they recognize such behavior as a grave violation of ethical guidelines, will be less likely to be swayed by it.
2. Abstinence pledges: All medical students upon graduation and physicians applying for licenses should be required to sign pledges foreswearing tobacco. Such declarations would both remind the signatories of the importance of their commitment not to smoke and would create additional antismoking peer pressure among their colleagues. At those medical schools using modern versions of the Physician's Oath, a statement on the importance of serving as a healthy role model for patients should be added to the doctors’ pledge.
3. Anonymous blood testing: Some may argue that individual blood testing for tobacco use followed by disciplinary action against offending physicians is in order—and, eventually, as smoking increasingly becomes anathema, it may be. Until that time, blood tests should be conducted on all physicians with hospital admitting privileges, and the collective totals should be calculated and disseminated so that hospitals can understand the overall scope of their physicians’ compliance. State resources should then be used to target antismoking programs at the least satisfactory facilities. Finally, the individual test results should be returned to each physician as a reminder to the guilty that they are flouting the ethical guidelines.
It is true that the lives of physicians, and particularly house staff officers, can be exceedingly stressful. This might explain why some use tobacco; it does not justify their behavior. Consideration ought to be given to those healthcare providers who are already addicted to tobacco—and the financial and medical resources should be made available to help them quit. Even addiction, however, does not justify a public health hazard. An alcoholic surgeon might elicit our sympathy; we would not let him wield a scalpel while drunk. No more should we permit smoking physicians, pleading nicotine addiction, to model toxic behavior for patients.
Conclusions
Some will inevitably argue that restrictions on smoking by medical professionals will open the floodgates to the further regulation of physician behavior. If doctors cannot ethically smoke, can they sky dive? Or ride motorcycles? Or eat red meat? Should obese individuals be able to practice medicine? These are serious questions worthy of consideration; they do not diminish the need for smoking restrictions. As Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas wrote: “It is no requirement . . . that all evils of the same genus be eradicated or none at all.”Footnote 30 And for those who do think physicians should serve as public role models, but question the practicability of the radical measures advocated in this article, it is worth noting that, 30 years ago, the advocates of smoke-free dining and mandatory seat belt laws were also seen as quixotic. Someday the canons of ethics will prohibit physicians from smoking. It is merely a question of when, not if, the profession will have the courage to throw down the gauntlet.
