Inpatients on isolation precautions have less frequent healthcare personnel (HCP) visits, presumably due to the time and effort required to don and doff personnel protective equipment (PPE) to enter the room.Reference Franck, Behan, Herath, Mueller and Marhoefer1 The “red box” is a 0.28 m2 (3 feet2) space, at the entryway of a patient’s room and facilitates full view and clear communication with the patient.Reference Franck, Behan, Herath, Mueller and Marhoefer1 Within the red box, HCP remain at a distance of ∼2 m (6 feet) or more from the patient, eliminating the need to use PPE or wash hands while interacting with patients who are on contact or droplet precautions.Reference Franck, Behan, Herath, Mueller and Marhoefer1 Use of the red-box strategy has been shown to improve isolation practices and to be cost-effective through preservation of PPE.Reference Franck, Behan, Herath, Mueller and Marhoefer1-Reference Lones, Ramanathan and Fitzpatrick5 Prior studies have used direct observers to document compliance with PPE protocolsReference Malhotra, Khameraj and Salim2-Reference Lones, Ramanathan and Fitzpatrick5; however, the method has multiple limitations.Reference Haas and Larson6,Reference Armellino, Hussain and Schilling7 We used remote video auditing to compare the rates of HCP compliance with infection prevention protocols in isolation rooms with and without the red box.
Methods
A prospective observational study was conducted over a 1-year period to evaluate the effect of red box on HCP compliance with PPE use using remote video auditing. The red box was demarcated using red floor tape as a 0.28 m2 (3 feet2) area at the room’s entrance, >2 m (6 feet) from the head of the bed. Our institution had been using the red-box strategy in certain units for 3 years prior to the study period. Cameras were placed at the entrance of 4 isolation rooms with a red box and 2 rooms without a red box (control rooms) on a single hospital unit. Video recordings were reviewed by remote observers who assessed compliance with PPE use and hand hygiene (HH). Type of isolation (ie, contact, droplet, or contact and droplet) was recorded. Compliance with HH, glove, gown use, and doffing (at exit only) were recorded. The study was approved by the institutional review board.
The primary end point was compliance with PPE use and HH. In observations wherein HCPs stayed in the red box, percent compliance for each end point (PPE use and HH) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were constructed using the Wilson method.
When HCPs moved beyond the red box into the room, compliance was compared between HCPs entering or exiting the red-box rooms versus control rooms using the χ2 test or the Fisher exact test. Separate binomial regression models with log link were used to compare PPE use and HH at entry or exit. Models were adjusted for HCP category, isolation room type, and visit type. Observations with unviewable outcomes were excluded. Rate ratios (RRs) and 95% CIs were reported. A P value < .05 was considered statistically significant. Analyses were performed using SAS version 9.4 software (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).
Results
Rates of PPE use and HH among those who stayed in the red box
In 976 events, HCPs entered the red box but did not venture beyond its boundaries into the room. Consistent with the red-box protocol, 69.9% HCPs did not practice HH, 95.1% did not use gowns, 91.5% did not wear gloves and 54.9% did not wear masks when within the red box.
Comparison of compliance between those who went beyond the red box into room and those in control rooms
There were 6,626 events wherein HCPs entered either the red-box room (went beyond the boundaries) or the control rooms. HCPs who entered the red-box rooms had lower compliance rates for HH (35.53% vs 45.5%; P < .05), glove use (38.93% vs 48.48%; P < .05), and gown use (39.41% vs 49.88%; P < .05) (Table 1). When stratified by type of isolation, glove use, gown use, and HH were significantly lower in rooms on contact precautions with a red box than in rooms without a red box, but not in rooms on droplet or droplet and contact precautions (Table 1). The following healthcare-associated infection (HAI) rates were monitored as a part of standard infection prevention strategies using National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) criteria: MRSA bacteremia, central-line–associated bloodstream infections, catheter-associated urinary tract infections, carbapenem-resistant organisms, and Clostridium difficile. No increase from prior years was observed for the unit, though we could not determine room-specific rates.
Lower Compliance Rates With HH/PPE Use in Red-Box Isolation Rooms When Going Beyond the Red Box Versus Control Rooms

Note. RR, rate ratio; CI, confidence interval; HH, hand hygiene.
a Compliance and noncompliance rates by isolation type as compared between the red box and control group are unadjusted. The model did not converge with adjustment.
b 95% CI = 95% confidence interval calculated using the Wilson method.
c P value based on χReference Malhotra, Khameraj and Salim2 test or the Fisher exact test for unadjusted comparisons.
d Rate ratio (RR) from binomial regression models, evaluating the effect of the red box vs control on noncompliance (event no.), adjusted for provider type and isolation room type.
e Overall glove use gown use and HH total may not add up as certain observations were unviewable.
f For doffing and gown use, only unadjusted effects are presented.
g The model for doffing only included exit observations.
h The model for mask only included observations with droplet or droplet/contact isolation type.
Discussion
Our study showed that when HCPs ventured beyond the red-box boundaries into the room, they were less compliant with infection prevention protocols than in control rooms without the red box. It is possible that HCPs may have ventured beyond the red box without donning the required PPE due to time constraints or due to a false sense of security that was induced because of the presence of the red box. This finding is concerning as noncompliance to PPE has the potential to increase HAI rates.
This study highlights the importance of using remote video auditing in infection control surveillance to monitor compliance and identify pitfalls and potential areas for improvement. In prior studies, remote video auditing with real-time feedback has been used to improve safety and efficiency measures.Reference Overdyk, Dowling and Newman8-Reference Pedersen, Getty Ritter, Beaton and Gibbons10 Implementation of such a strategy to enhance infection prevention practices in red-box rooms may be beneficial.
Our study has several limitations. Remote video auditing recordings were not always continuous and may have missed certain events. Among the events that were audited, some were unviewable. However, this is likely balanced by similar events in control rooms. Because we collected only anonymized data (no patient or HCP identifiers), we could not were unable to adjust for correlation with either patient or HCP.
Given the findings of our study, we suggest reconsidering the use of the red-box strategy to ensure safer infection prevention practices. Alternatively, intensive education should accompany use of the red box to ensure compliance when venturing beyond their boundaries. Future studies implementing remote video auditing with real-time feedback for infection control practices are worth exploring.
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge the staff members of our Infection Prevention Unit.
Financial support
This study was supported by the Karen Brown Research Fund.
Conflicts of interest
All authors report no conflicts of interest relevant to this article.

