This book presents a microhistory of the society and economy of Tebtunis in the mid-first century a.d., mostly using the papyrus archive of Kronion, the head of the village's scribal and notarial office (grapheion). The archive's c. 200 documents include over 100 contracts in varying states of completeness and, crucially, three registers of the documents drafted at the grapheion in four months of 42 and a sixteen-month span during 45–46. These registers give basic descriptions (and sometimes detailed abstracts) for over 1,100 documents, thus providing a snapshot of the sectors of the village economy in which transactions involved written instruments, and of the parties to such transactions. Most of the archive was published in the 1930s and ’40s; ever since, papyrologists have exploited this trove of quantifiable data to answer specific questions. Langellotti's is the first published study to exploit the Kronion archive systematically, and the result is a wonderfully rich and multifaceted picture of the village. Also valuable is the book's sober analysis of the archive's evidentiary limitations.
The Introduction (ch. 1) sets out a microhistorical methodology, discusses the relevance of Tebtunis to the study of villages in Egypt and the Roman Empire, and summarises the settlement's archaeology. The second chapter examines the archive's history, the nature of its texts, the operations and functions of the grapheion and the activities and lives of the scribes.
The following four chapters present the substantive results. Ch. 3 examines the demographic characteristics of the c. 1,600–1,700 unique individuals from Tebtunis mentioned in the registers as parties, who comprised c. 25–28 per cent of the village's population of c. 6,000. Around 88 per cent of parties were male, which prompts valuable discussion of the restricted opportunities for independent economic activity by women. L. also exploits the parties’ onomastic characteristics for hints of their cultural and religious affiliations; theophoric names are especially useful here. The chapter also discusses houses, households and families: the archive demonstrates how house ownership featured in loan contracts and how people coped with owning part-shares in houses, usually because of partible inheritance practices or divorces.
Ch. 4 examines stratification in the village. Using mainly onomastic criteria, L. identifies two elite groups: reasonably affluent Egyptian priests, who administered public land; and people of Hellenic (or Hellenised) ancestry, often with Macedonian names, who were landowners and had dominant roles in debt and lease contracts. As for the sub-elite, slaves are rarely evidenced, and many people lived well above subsistence level, to judge from the size of plots leased, the value of dowries and the sheer number of creditors and members of voluntary associations (which had membership costs).
The final chapters concern the economy. Ch. 5 concentrates on the agricultural economy, which included crop cultivation, pastoralism and some viticulture. The archive shows that the village's land transactions had a seasonal rhythm, and illuminates the economic strategies behind land leases. Apparently, no unbridgeable chasm stood between landlords and tenants: the same individuals were sometimes both. The non-agricultural sector, discussed in ch. 6, was necessarily smaller, but not negligible, to judge from the number of professional associations in the village and the range of occupational titles. The archive shows how many trades and crafts were operated as state concessions, therefore producing revenue for the government. There are signs, too, of the non-agricultural sectors being integrated into regional trade networks.
The book's findings often confirm rather than upend existing consensuses on rural Egypt — for instance, on issues such as the limitations on female economic activity, the existence of a middling stratum of people who lived above subsistence level and the substantial monetisation of village economies. But on such issues, the grapheion registers give a statistical rigour far superior to what an impressionistic reading of scattered papyri provides. Moreover, L. does convincingly undermine one influential theory: that the Kronion archive evidences an economic crisis prompted by an excessive inundation in a.d. 45. The book's use of onomastic analysis is also methodologically instructive. L. avoids the reductionist assumption that people's names necessarily declared their ethnicity, and acknowledges mixed descent and cultural shapeshifting. But she still fruitfully investigates why, for example, farmers of public land mostly had Egyptian names, but creditors in loan contracts disproportionally bore Greek names. It seems plausible that Greek names correlated with wealth and Hellenic cultural affiliation, even if not always with biological descent from Greek settlers.
L.'s overarching goal is to offer Tebtunis as a model useful for the study of ancient villages generally (26–7, 230–3). She illustrates this heuristic potential by comparing features of Tebtunis with those of other Egyptian villages for which relevant data exist. For instance, she adduces evidence on land plot sizes in Karanis and the Mendesian nome (157–8), and house sizes in Soknopaiou Nesos and Karanis (22), datasets which have striking similarities to those from Tebtunis. Other comparisons are perhaps less pointed, such as the discussion of scribes’ roles in village society in first-century Tebtunis and eighth-century Jeme (50–1). If meaningful comparisons with villages outside Egypt are to be made, relevant non-papyrological datasets will need to be identified and exploited. Regardless of whether this proves viable, the model provided by Tebtunis will certainly now play a role in discussions about villages in the Roman empire.
