In Nietzsche, Naturalism, & Normativity, editors Christopher Janaway and Simon Robertson compile and contribute to an excellent selection of essays that focus primarily on issues raised by Nietzsche’s philosophy. More specifically, these papers aim “to assess Nietzsche’s normative views and their relation to the naturalistic worldview it has become common to attribute to him.” (p. 1) The strength of this collection is its ability to confront problems in Nietzsche’s philosophy that, to some readers, may appear as not only paradoxes, but downright contradictions, and to offer explanations as to how Nietzsche may uphold views that are seemingly incompatible. One such problem that is explored by a number of authors deals with Nietzsche’s positive values amidst his critique of all normative and objective morality. While he rightly calls himself an immoralist, it is clear from his work that he strongly affirms a higher way of existence that the strongest individuals will strive towards. These essays demonstrate in different ways how Nietzsche’s critique of normativity is better understood as a rejection of certain types of values, such as Christian morality (i.e., slave morality) or Kantian ethics, but not of all values. Indeed, if we do not see that Nietzsche called for a revaluation of values, rather than a dismissal of any and all values, we certainly miss the aims of this great thinker’s philosophy. One of the more interesting approaches to problems raised by Nietzsche’s critique of normativity deals with his aesthetic response to various ways of living.
The collection begins with three essays by Peter Railton, Peter Poellner, and Simon Robertson that examine how Nietzsche’s normative stance may rightly be understood as aesthetic. Broadly speaking, Nietzsche’s aesthetic approach to morality denies many traditional notions regarding normativity, yet affirms a certain way of living that is in part founded on taste and intuition. Janaway and Robertson note that on an evaluative level, Nietzsche critiques the value of morality, arguing that it has stunted human flourishing and excellence. Moreover, Nietzsche goes on to deny the foundational presuppositions to morality, such as the claim that morality is objective, authoritative, and hence non-optional. (p. 2) The question remains, however, how Nietzsche might still defend any sort of positive ideals in his philosophy.
One of the more helpful illustrations of Nietzche’s aesthetic stance comes in Railton’s “Nietzsche’s Normative Theory? The Art and Skill of Living Well.” Railton argues that Nietzsche’s attack on free will, autonomous agency, and morality can, in part, be explained if we think of the Nietzschean higher individual as analogous to someone expertly skilled at her craft. The most excellent composers, doctors, even parents are, Nietzsche might say, great at what they do—not by adhering to moral principles or by exercising their autonomy over conflicting impulses, but by acting from their nature through some sort of profound intuition. If Railton’s analogies are correct, then this is indeed an interesting and effective response to the normativity problem posed by Nietzsche’s works. In the same way that we might admire a novelist yet know that there is no “rule-like ‘standard of good [writing],’” (p. 32) we can look at the higher individual, the Übermensch who lives beyond good and evil, and understand that we can affirm, perhaps even assent to some way of life without necessarily endorsing normative principles along with this affirmation. More simply put, for those that live well in the Nietzschean sense, there are no normative principles at all. Railton also notes how Nietzsche likely saw himself as an artist, a claim that is not hard to embrace considering not only Nietzsche’s more boastful moments, but also his poetic and aphoristic style. These elements of Nietzsche’s prose help to express his life-affirming philosophy while avoiding most normative language. “Like an artist,” Railton explains, “[Nietzsche] wants his chosen audience to see things differently but realizes he cannot do this simply by explaining or arguing for his ideas”. (p. 46) Rather, Railton’s paper demonstrates how Nietzsche seeks to compel and challenge his readers to see, feel, think, and act for themselves in new ways, (p. 46) allowing himself—as a philosopher—to affirm a way of life without appealing to fixed ideals or duty.
The aesthetic values that are put forth by Nietzsche lead to important questions concerning the self that Christopher Janaway and Lanier Anderson consider in their respective contributions. Janaway navigates us through Nietzsche’s complex notion of drives, noting how Nietzsche argues for a sort of unity among the drives that the greatest individuals will have. Janaway resists a purely naturalistic reading of the self and its drives, arguing that, while Nietzsche certainly does not deny that some higher beings may become great by nature, other factors such as culture and will can, no doubt, play a formative role. Janaway relates these drives to the eternal recurrence, offering a clear and innovative approach to one of Nietzsche’s more confusing doctrines. Anderson puts forth an interesting view of the Nietzschean self as opposed to the Kantian subject. Central to this comparison is the idea of autonomy. While Nietzsche lambasts Kantian notions such as the categorical imperative and practical reason, he still values his own conception of autonomy. In fact, Anderson notes that this view of autonomy is central to the individuality Nietzsche extols: “the free spirit [Nietzsche] idealizes is supposed to be independent from custom and tradition; she ‘creates herself’ precisely in the sense of giving herself values or laws of her own; she has ‘independence of the soul.’” (p. 204) Like in Janaway’s paper, this discussion focuses heavily on the drives of the individual and how they are related (and unrelated) to naturalistic and transcendental views of the self.
With Nietzsche, Naturalism, & Normativity, Janaway and Robertson have compiled an excellent collection of essays that will provide insight into contemporary debates on not only Nietzsche’s philosophy, but ethics in general. A virtue of the collection is its relevance to philosophers within both the analytic and continental traditions, which further demonstrates the far-reaching impact of Nietzsche’s work.
