The Great Depression of the 1930s: Lessons for Today, edited by Nicholas Crafts and Peter Fearon, is not the first book to claim that the history of the Great Depression has lessons for the contemporary world, and neither is it likely to be the last. An upsurge in interest in the crisis has produced an entire literature of books purporting to draw lessons from the event in the late 1980s and early 1990s, such as Peter Temin's Lessons from the Great Depression (1989). In the light of the latest global economic crisis, the “Great Recession” of 2008–9, there has been renewed interest in making comparisons to the 1930s. It is therefore timely that Crafts and Fearon have brought together a volume of fourteen essays from distinguished economists and historians examining what can be learnt from the history of the Great Depression for the 2010s and beyond.
Many journalists and members of the “commentariat” have already compared the most recent “Great Recession” of the late 2000s to the Great Depression of the 1930s. Yet, as Martin Daunton and many others have pointed out, the circumstances around the sets of events are not entirely similar. Most notably, the data and policy tools available to policymakers back then were fewer in number than they are now. And conflating the problems of the gold standard with those of the eurozone today ignores one big point: the European Central Bank expands the money supply by printing euros in a way that cannot be done with a gold standard in place. Therefore an academic project to have a level-headed look at what lessons should be taken from the Great Depression is overdue and Crafts and Fearon's attempt to do so should be warmly received from both inside and outside the scholarly community.
In short, the authors argue there are three main lessons from the Great Depression. The first comes in the form of a lesson remembered by policymakers in the most recent crisis: that financial crises are destabilizing and clear monetary and fiscal intervention by governments and central banks are needed to combat them. The failure of the Hoover administration to vigorously combat the waves of banking crises that hit the United States in the early 1930s turned a cyclical downturn into a deep depression. That failure was not forgotten in the most recent crisis. The prompt monetary and fiscal intervention of the US Treasury in bailing out the banking system and the Federal Reserve in cutting interest rates prevented the failure of Lehman Brothers in September 2008 from turning into a 1930s-style depression.
The second two come in the form of lessons forgotten. The first of these is that prudent financial regulation is needed to ensure the stability of the banking system through the minimization of risk. As the book's chapter by Charles Calomiris suggests, for all the criticism heaped upon the New Deal's banking reforms in America, they did contribute to more than half a century of relative financial stability. In comparison, the period of light-touch regulation since the 1980s has been a failure. Although Calomiris's chapter, and the next one by Michael Bordo and John Landon-Lane, do briefly explore the positives and negatives of the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 as the latest attempt at banking regulation after the Great Recession, some more analysis on this important topic would have been welcome.
The other forgotten lesson that Crafts and Fearon mention is the lack of government intervention to support recovery. Their focus is mainly on the risks of contractionary fiscal policies that hold back growth. They argue that this is not wise. Such policies reduce tax revenues, increase the real burden of public- and private-sector debt, and hold unemployment at artificially high levels, at which human and social capital starts to deteriorate. The lessons of the 1937–38 recession, they say, suggest that withdrawing fiscal stimulus too early can have catastrophic macroeconomic effects. This may be so, but it ignores that the fact that economists now say the present risk mainly lies in excessively tight monetary policy in America, Britain and Europe. In particular, the euro-area is presently at risk of falling into a deflationary spiral, primarily due to the tardy adoption of unconventional monetary policies by the European Central Bank. By contrast, the prompt adoption in America and Britain of policies such as quantitative easing and low interest rates seems relatively successful. In view of this, a greater focus by Crafts and Fearon, in the introduction to their book, on monetary policy in addition to fiscal issues would have been welcome.
As the book covers the entire world rather than simply America, the chapters of greatest interest for the readers of this journal are those by Calomiris on banking reform, Bordo and Landon-Lane on banking panics, Price Fishback on US monetary policy in the 1930s and the New Deal, Tim Hatton and Mark Thomas on labour markets, and Alexander Field on US growth. Nevertheless, the content about the Great Depression around the rest of the world, and the comparative analysis provided in many of the chapters, should make this book useful for American-oriented scholars who wish to view their subject in context.
If this volume suffers any general fault, its problem is that much of the material is not very fresh or radical in tone. Little of the information is new: many chapters and most of the ideas have been published before. In spite of this, the essays brought together in the volume do provide a convenient, useful and balanced survey of recent research on the Great Depression. Reassuringly, the book avoids going overboard in terms of making tenuous links between the issues of the 1930s and today. Written in a clear and lucid style, this volume will prove useful for both students and researchers alike in the years to come. The long and detailed bibliographies at the end of each chapter also provide fertile ground for further reading. Though this book will not be the last attempt by economic historians on what lessons from the Great Depression are relevant for today, it will surely become known as one that is well worth reading on the topic.
