This fine volume helps to redress a striking paradox in the study of Latin American politics and society. Observers stress that elites have a great deal of clout in the region, but very few scholars investigate these elites. Analyses of social movements have long proliferated, and the turn to institutionalism prompted an upsurge of attention to political parties and electoral politicians. Yet partly due to the narrow focus on political institutions, interest organizations such as trade unions and business associations have suffered increasing neglect. The tendency of many Latin Americanists to “side with the underdogs” and focus their scholarship accordingly has led to a particular neglect of business. Therefore, area specialists know surprisingly little about a sector that is widely seen as highly influential.
Precisely because observers know so little about business, simplistic claims abound. Concerning class approaches, for instance, capitalists are assumed to have a clear grasp of their interests, advance them systematically, exert considerable influence, and reach many of their goals. These assumptions suggest that entrepreneurs will combat politicians who campaign for policies opposed to their interests and that this resistance will make it difficult for such candidates to win elections.
In contemporary Latin America, the most prominent politician who fits this description is Hugo Chávez in Venezuela. As a presidential candidate in 1998, Chávez was anathema to domestic and foreign businesses because he attacked market reforms. Fearing his leftist rhetoric and his unpredictable style, entrepreneurs mobilized to sway the electorate against this firebrand. But many Venezuelans did not listen and elected Chávez anyway, and some powerful entrepreneurs actually supported this populist rabble-rouser.
These surprising events raise the two puzzles that Leslie C. Gates's book elucidates: Why did Venezuelan voters disregard the concerns of business, and why did some entrepreneurs back a candidate whose pronouncements diverged from their policy interests? On the basis of wide-ranging biographical investigations and thorough analyses of survey data, the author solves the “voter puzzle” by demonstrating that involvement in egregious corruption scandals and prominent participation in Venezuela's discredited governing circles exposed business people to high levels of disrepute. Since the public held entrepreneurs in low esteem, business opposition did not hurt Chávez, but may have helped this antineoliberal candidate win the 1998 election. Gates argues that without considering this factor, established hypotheses that highlight corruption in general, the exclusionary nature of Venezuela's institutions, and the social costs of neoliberal reforms cannot fully explain the victory of this populist leader. Antipathy to business also played a significant role, both in shaping the electoral outcome directly and in exacerbating the three problems emphasized by other theories; for instance, while less-well-off sectors felt excluded by Venezuelan parties and governing institutions, business people gained an increasingly prominent and influential role in them, drawing popular ire.
Gates solves the “business assistance puzzle” by demonstrating that the entrepreneurs who broke with their “class” and backed Chávez had specific self-interests in maintaining and enhancing access to this leftist despite the policies he propounded. It is interestingly to note that this unexpected support did not emerge from uncompetitive sectors that found Chávez's promise of protectionism attractive. Rather than being policy driven, Chávez's backers came mostly from state-dependent firms, had personal connections to the candidate or feared targeted reprisals from the aides of his main opponent in the 1998 contest. Accordingly, a number of bankers helped Chávez win because they feared that otherwise, leading government positions would be filled with economic experts who had hurt them in Venezuela's severe financial crisis of 1994 and who might disadvantage them again in the future. Gates uncovered these intricate, particularistic calculations through intensive field research, especially interviews with business people and other well-placed informants.
With these findings, Electing Chávez makes several important contributions to the analysis of Venezuelan politics and to elite studies. Empirically, Gates documents the prominent role of business people in Venezuela's economic decision-making bodies and shows that aversion to the private sector helped Chávez win the 1998 election. Moreover, she does an excellent job reconstructing the calculations of entrepreneurs who broke ranks with their peers and backed this left-wing candidate; her analysis of the logic underlying these decisions is truly masterful.
In theoretical terms, Gates shows that the currently predominant institutionalist theories cannot on their own explain Chávez's election. Instead, behavior that deviates from institutional norms, such as egregious corruption, also needs to be taken into account. Moreover, the author emphasizes the skewed social repercussions of institutions, especially growing social inequality that entailed privileges for business. Important institutional positions were occupied by entrepreneurs, which exposed them to popular aversion and made other firm owners fear unfair, discriminatory treatment by competitors; these rivalries in turn played into Chávez's hands.
Like many authors who call attention to a neglected actor or factor, however, Gates tends to exaggerate its role. For instance, she uses terms such as “vital” and “so pivotal” in the conclusion (pp. 133, 137), although her empirical analyses often found fairly moderate effects (e.g., pp. 45, 57, 72–74, 78–79) or were based on limited direct evidence, for example, interviews with only three of 27 business people who were likely Chávez supporters (p. 88).
Furthermore, the theoretical conclusions that Gates draws from her thorough, intensive research are relatively modest. She certainly sheds some additional light on a crucial event in Venezuelan politics and complements established explanations, but she does not produce any major unexpected insights or blaze new theoretical trails. This problem has, of course, hampered elite studies for decades: They require a huge investment of time but often yield mostly descriptive findings; observers understand better how an elite sector operates and what influence it exerts, but they usually do not gain any insights that would be truly novel. Scholars know that elites are pretty powerful—not much surprise when a researcher demonstrates this point one more time.
On this theoretical level, however, Gates misses a good opportunity to make a bigger point. Venezuelan business certainly does not act in the way that established arguments, especially those derived from class approaches, would suggest. Rather than pursuing clear interests in a determined, systematic, and skillful way, entrepreneurs in Venezuela seemed to be confused and had difficulty sorting out divergent interests and concerns. Moreover, rather than acting with reasonable cohesion, they were at odds with one another, even when facing a clear and consequential threat from a left-wing populist. In Venezuela in 1998, the capitalist class was missing in action! While business' high degree of state dependence may make the country a special case, scholars know from the few other empirical investigations of entrepreneurs in Latin America that unclear interests, incoherent action, and, consequently, limited success are common characteristics of business politics in the region. These findings cast serious doubt on the class approach underlying the “social polarization” thesis that Gates discusses and that the recent rise of left-wing governments in Latin America has, unfortunately, revived. By invoking her solid findings to contest this often ideologically driven interpretation of Latin American politics, she could have made a more significant theoretical contribution.
Despite these quibbles, the present volume offers an interesting, well-documented analysis that will be of interest to students of contemporary Venezuela and to analysts of the role of business in politics.
