In the introduction to Damn Great Empires!, Alexander Livingston repeats a charge by Amy Kaplan: “The absence of the United States in the postcolonial study of culture and imperialism curiously reproduces American exceptionalism from without” (13–14). This volume seeks to correct this error, and suggests that the philosophy of William James is best understood in the context of his anti-imperial politics. Livingston has rescued a series of letters, essays, speeches, and papers made by William James that were critical of the expansion of the American empire at the turn of the twentieth century. At the time, James was most especially concerned with American involvement in the Philippines, which he saw as a strong turn away from isolationist policies. Livingston is quick to point out that James was incorrect in his assumption of previous American innocence, even as he lauds his objections to American counterinsurgency in the Philippines. This is the great dilemma of Damn Great Empires!: from the contemporary vantage, James appears naive and even subject to the “certain blindness” that he is famous for diagnosing.
Livingston takes a piece of advice from his subject in crafting this book. James said it is best not to overly fetishize particular texts or words when approaching a thinker; you must first grasp “his center of vision, by act of imagination” (10). Livingston is proposing that contemporary readers place James's anti-imperialist sentiments at the center of his philosophical vision, and that by situating the pragmatist texts and vision within the historical context of American imperialism and the discontents of democracy during the Gilded Age, we will understand William James anew. Livingston's claim is that “the originality and importance of James's political thought lies in its philosophical examination and transformation of the psychic, affective, and cultural roots of American imperialism at a crucial moment in the nation's rise to global hegemony” (7).
Livingston begins his project by sweeping away more-common interpretations of William James, including the notion that he was not a political thinker. He has a more involved project in wresting James from the grips of Ralph Barton Perry, author of The Thought and Character of William James (Little, Brown, 1935), which won the Pulitzer Prize and has long been considered the necessary guide for all things relating to James. Perry characterized James's political commitments as secondary to his philosophical commitments, and also profiled him as a mugwump, an elitist liberal. Livingston carefully compares Perry's text on James with a social history published twenty years earlier and finds that “the rough contours of the ethical creed Perry claims to find in James's political sentiments are already sketched out in great detail in his account of American political culture nearly two decades earlier” (47). In other words, Perry's James had been smothered with a predetermined interpretive apparatus, not imaginatively reconstructed.
Livingston sees anti-imperialism driving James's engagements with questions of faith, courage, and the moral decay evident in Gilded Age America. One of the most interesting elements in this book is James's connection between a craving for authority that emerges from the acceleration of modernity and its social forms and the desire for empire. This desire for authorities in the midst of their collapse “drives philosophers and lay people alike to affirm patterns of thinking and practices of perception that impose order on experience, disavow complexity and difference, and engender hostile and dogmatic reactions to perceived threats to this fantastic order” (11). Indeed, it would be difficult to find a proclivity that seems more relevant for understanding American politics in 2017.
There is excellent support for Livingston's corollary that James was suspicious of American militarism and the machismo politics espoused by Theodore Roosevelt. Chapters 3 and 4 convincingly establish the fact that James was an astute critic of the impulse to solve the crisis of meaning in Gilded Age America through imperial and wilderness conquest. James argues that interior struggle is a more apt location to assert meaning: “The frontier that James's pacifist pioneer would tame is internal and moral rather than external and physical” (100). James also fears for the ability of individuals to struggle in a meaningful fashion given subservience in the era of “bigness”; he feared for our souls as we drowned in a world in which a single person seems to have no impact.
If Livingston's goal was to make it clear that James's philosophy reveals aspects of American political culture that are still extremely important, he succeeded in doing so with Damn Great Empires! Yet it seems that Livingston's goal is to say that James was actually an anti-imperialist thinker whose work helps place American intellectual history within the debates about colonialism and postcolonialism; of this claim I remain unconvinced. There is only brief discussion of empire in the book's main chapters and so I found little evidence of James's concerns for the citizens of the Philippines; most of James's ideas are presented as domestic dilemmas. This raises the question whether you can find anti-imperialism within an imperialist epistemological framework. While interior proclivities may have played a role in sustaining empire, as Livingston says, it is crucial to remember that the maintenance of empire itself was also an external struggle. This does not mean that there is not an interior debate, and a profound dislocation through imperialism as described so hauntingly by Frantz Fanon. In the end, James frames empire as a problem for American character and democracy, not as a system of oppression. This may establish him as a brave critic in his own time, but I am not sure it demands a recategorization of James in contemporary terms.
Livingston's excellent fifth chapter about James's response to reading W. E. B. Dubois's The Souls of Black Folk helps establish the limits of his political perspective. On the one hand, James read The Souls of Black Folk and was deeply shocked and disturbed by it, and lent his name to antilynching campaigns shortly after reading the book. On the other hand, as Livingston points out, that “James, a man who lived through the civil war, Reconstruction, and the rise of Southern redemption, could have remained oblivious until this moment of the living legacy of white terror over black bodies in the United States” (143) demonstrates the challenges that DuBois was facing to awaken a national audience. “For Dubois, a faith in the progress of American democracy too often came at the cost of a strange amnesia concerning the nation's past” (143). The question that continues to haunt me about Damn Great Empires! is whether critiques of American democracy are similarly hindered by such amnesia.
Livingston's book is an excellent reminder that William James can provide essential guidance for understanding American political culture and our country's tortuous relationship to authority and democratic responsibility. We long to rule ourselves and others, yet fear and often avert the responsibilities that ruling entails. Damn Great Empires! helps illuminate why William James can provide the psychological key for understanding contemporary political dysfunctions.
