Germany's politics of citizenship, immigration, and more broadly, belonging are complicated and at times short on coherence, and so it is unsurprising that this broad-ranging examination of the topic shares in these characteristics. The book excels by treating German immigration policy as complex, multifaceted, and strongly context driven, and it fully merits Rainer Münz's back-cover endorsement of being “authoritative and comprehensive.” The encyclopedic coverage of various aspects of migration policy produces a definitive reference work, yet one that faces the challenge of integrating all these elements equally within the overall analytic framework that is postulated in the introduction and explained in the first part.
Rogers Brubaker's much-cited (1992) Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany argues that German adherence to the principle of jus sanguinis in conferring citizenship reflected an ethno-national conception of national identity that also produced Germany's rather exclusive immigration stance. While such considerations dominated past policies, some scholars criticize this view as too deterministic in terms of adequately describing Germany's present, or, much less, prognosticating its future. Douglas B. Klusmeyer and Demetrios G. Papademetriou similarly avoid such a singular argument, and instead posit that the Federal Republic of Germany's constitution—which is the basis for immigration and citizenship policy—rests upon five “dimensions of membership” (p. xv). These are distilled into an international dimension that aligns the country's destiny to Europe, a federalist dimension that balances between unity and subnational diversity, a civic dimension that privileges citizens in its allocation of fundamental rights, and a social dimension that accords benefits rather equally to all residents. The final dimension is the national one, emphasizing the “qualities of collective identity that distinguish one people from another and are understood to be transmitted across generations” (p. 22). Thus, the authors identify several, often competing, conceptions from which German governments could choose when establishing the criteria of membership, yet the emphasis of the book and their analysis mostly revalidates Brubaker's characterization of Germany as following an exclusivist ethno-national variant of membership, a fairly ubiquitous argument. Evidence of the other logics in operation is far less frequent, generally accompanied by less thorough analysis, and so the primary contribution of the book is in its compilation of information, rather than in the persuasive forwarding of a new argument.
After presenting the dimensions of membership in the first part, the author divides the book divides into three further parts, beginning with a predominantly postwar historical overview of immigration and citizenship up through reunification. This is followed by a consideration of Germany within the European Union, plus the final part, which focuses on the most recent policies. This chronological rather than thematic organization reflects the book's primary focus on providing a complete and multifaceted history of German immigration and citizenship policy, as opposed to a theoretically centered analysis. The chapters offer extensive background and explanation of the political developments that have produced policy in the individual areas, referencing the most influential literature on Germany. This descriptive approach is far from atheoretical, often integrating broader frameworks, such as T. H. Marshall's delineation of social rights (p. 19) and Jürgen Habermas's discussion of democratic citizenship (p. 165), both of which offer criteria for evaluating the German constitution's concepts of membership. The book serves as a tremendous resource, compiling an enormous body of scholarly literature, with uniquely broad coverage across issues as general as national identity and as particular as bilateral agreements. With 27 separate chapters, it addresses a variety of policy areas and can serve as an invaluable nexus for research.
Rather than simply positing that Germany's particular context has produced a unique configuration of results, the analysis provides extensive contextual background, whether by means of a detailed discussion of the constitutional challenges for German reunification or the particular manner in which German Länder remain empowered through the Maastricht Treaty. While the focus is on Germany, the book is rich with comparative evidence, featuring charts presenting statistics from other countries that provide a much-needed context for evaluating the aspects that make Germany unique.
Comprehensive attention is granted to Germany's position in the EU and to the EU immigration system's incremental expansion. Clearly, the Dublin convention, which permits EU countries to return asylum claimants to the first EU country of entry, facilitated Germany's ability to curtail the right to asylum in 1993. However, the new Aussiedler policy and that concerning Jewish immigration, similarly discussed within the EU section, neither derive from EU obligations nor are linked analytically to the union. The book's synthetic nature—essentially relying on secondary sources—does not lend itself to a pursuit of original research on the impact of EU policy on German policy. For example, the suggestion that the creation of EU citizenship spurred Germany to relax its naturalization requirements (p. 197) not only inflates the importance or desirability of EU citizenship but would demand greater evidence in support, since it has not been shown before by others. Similarly, the final chapter's discussion of integration measures suggests that these have been implemented in concert with wider European designs, but this would require further demonstration.
The recency and prominence of Germany's 2005 immigration law prove ideal for examining the degree to which competing membership conceptions currently impact policy. The Christian Democrats' insistence upon identifying a Leitkultur (guiding culture) whose elements would provide the criteria for membership in German society at the turn of the millennium appeared to have been repudiated by the Independent Commission on Immigration's recommendations that placed the integration onus not only on the migrant population but also upon the host society, together with expanded avenues toward immigration. However, the final version of the law falls considerably short of the commission's vision, as well as the provisions of the original 2002 draft, signaling that ethno-nationalism remains a potent ideology. Building on Klusmeyer's previously published work, the discussion of the German Leitkultur and its continuing resonance presents a meticulous explanation of how difficult it has been for Germany to liberalize citizenship and immigration, even if economic interests and the desire to match European standards align positively.
The well-documented and convincing closing part certainly reinforces the impression of a conflicted Germany that is laudably progressive in providing social and civil benefits as well as supporting a European integration that presupposes diversity, while exhibiting continued discomfort with its own heterogeneity. Indeed, despite championing Germany's need to more resolutely embrace the nonethno-national conceptions of membership, the authors seem unsure whether that also implies accommodating immigrants who practice “traditional Islam.” The government's decision not to avoid a debate over whether a veiled Muslim woman should be represented at a federally supported conference on Islam is deemed wise (p. 281), and it is considered worrisome that some Muslim immigrants have “reverted back to their Muslim heritage to reidentify with an Islamic way of life” (p. 283). Such doubts reflect the unresolved debates taking place throughout Europe over integration and immigration and whether multiculturalism necessarily prescribes the fostering of views of ethnic minorities or immigrant groups that may be more nationalistic and exclusive than the new body of social and civil rights that are in the process of being crafted not only for EU citizens but for all who reside in Europe.
