Studies in late antique rhetoric, paideia and epideictic oratory are thriving and while imperial panegyric of this period has been assessed for its ceremonial, historical and literary value, comparatively little has been done on its close relative, invective. Richard Flower's Emperors and Bishops in Late Roman Invective is a welcome contribution to this field. The book focuses on the invectives against Constantius II written by the bishops, Athanasius of Alexandria, Hilary of Poitiers and Lucifer of Cagliari, and F. offers valuable insights into the nature, function and development of epideictic oratory, the rhetorical tactics of those seeking the authority of Christian orthodoxy in this critical period, and the accommodation reached between Church and State.
F. takes as his opening illustration the Altercatio Heracliani, and the trial of Heraclianus, Firmianus and Aurelianus in Sirmium in a.d. 366. Having described a scene familiar from martyr texts, the altercatio or moral argument between accused and inquisitor, F. pulls back to reveal that the inquisitor is not the villainous Roman official the reader expects, but the Christian bishop Germinius who is angered that the layman Heraclianus is a Homoousian rather than a Homoioan. This manipulation of familiar narrative tropes will become a familiar pattern in texts which deal with the competing theologies in the newly legitimate Church.
In ch. 1 (‘Praise and Blame in the Roman World), F. summarizes the importance of classical paideia in the Empire and the rôle of rhetoric in defining imperium. As an intrinsic part of late antique ceremonial, imperial panegyric did more than simply remind the people of the virtues expected of a good ruler. By selective use of the vocabulary and images of kingship, panegyric could construct the ideal emperor in the minds of his subjects while invective, reversing the tropes of panegyric, could create the model of bad rulership. Yet although classical paideia had equipped Christian writers with these critical tools, criticism of the Empire was slow to emerge and during the persecutions writers preferred to focus on the sanctity of the martyrs rather than the vices of their tormentors. In the work of Lactantius and Eusebius, however, the language of epideictic oratory began to serve Christian ends. Imperial virtue was redefined as inseparable from Christianity and Constantine was cast as the ideal Christian ruler, identified with biblical rather than classical exempla.
The second chapter (‘Constructing a Christian Tyrant’) shows how Athanasius, Hilary and Lucifer used the conventions of invective to present Constantius II as a tyrant and his Arianism as a latter-day persecution of the Church. Reversing the themes of panegyric, the bishops condemned the emperor's vices and accused him of injustice and interference, a tyrant who sought to corrupt the Church with heresy. Replacing classical exempla with models relevant to Christianity, they identified Constantius as the heir to the persecuting emperors, Nero, Decius and Maximian, and to the biblical tyrants, Pharaoh and Pilate.
Ch. 3 (‘Writing Auto-Hagiography’) concentrates on a specific aspect of this exemplarity: the use of martyr literature. F. shows how this technique had the double purpose of condeming the emperor and of creating an authoritative and orthodox persona for the writers, who implicitly claimed for themselves the bold speech, parrhesia, of the martyr. With casual regard for factual accuracy, the bishops presented themselves as having suffered exile and persecution in order to claim legitimization as champions of truth and orthodoxy. A martyr was redefined as one who remained true to his faith and the bishops described themselves as martyrs and confessores. Further, as exponents of parrhesia, the bishops took on the authority of Old Testament prophets, particularly those who, like Samuel and Elijah, had challenged the impious ruler.
By addressing the emperor in the second person, the bishops identified Constantius with the evil governor of martyr texts. In ch. 4 (‘Living Up to the Past’), F. discusses the use of biblical allusion to show that Constantius was part of a long history of persecutors, imitating their actions and words. The genealogy of Arians was simple: Judas and the Jews. By contrast, the opponents of Arius, descended from the outspoken prophets of the Old and New Testament, could claim scriptural authority for their theology. The death of Constantius marked a change in imperial invective and later emperors who disagreed with the bishops were presented only as being led astray by their counsellors. In his epilogue, F. considers the reasons for this but admits that all such theories are speculative and that it is simplistic to assume a single motive.
F.'s monograph will be of value to students of late antique history, rhetoric and Christianity, but his assertion that invective plays the same rôle functionally as panegyric (55) is arguable, and even undermines his interpretation of the invectives themselves. Certainly, tropes of invective mirror in reverse those of panegyric and both forms of oratory concern the public persona of the subject (F.'s comments on Claudian's vilification of the eunuch consul Eutropius are very much to the point). However, invective's lack of a ceremonial function makes a significant difference between the two modes of speech. In actual fact, F. shows that the invectives written by the bishops had an aim beyond that of panegyric and demonstrates clearly that the invectives were vital weapons in the writers’ aim of personal rehabilitation and as concerned with promoting the bishops themselves as in denigrating the emperor.
