In P. D. James's novel The Children of Men (1992), a global epidemic of infertility occurs when the collective male sperm count falls to zero. Alfonso Cuarón's adaptation of James's novel alters this premise in a subtle but telling way: the film Children of Men (2006) is set in a world imperilled by female, rather than male, infertility. Cuarón has contended that infertility is just “a metaphor” and “a point of departure” in the film, but his intervention into the novel's reproductive landscape suggests otherwise (137). It is the politics of creative decisions such as these that form the substance of Heather Latimer's new book Reproductive Acts: Sexual Politics in North American Fiction and Film, which interrogates works produced between the 1980s and the 2000s. Latimer argues that fiction both engages with and helps to construct reproductive politics, “Whether this leads to revolutionary ways of reimagining the body, technology, and humanity, reifies old assumptions and positions, or achieves something in between” (161).
The book, which is organized chronologically, begins with innovative readings of 1980s novels by Margaret Atwood and Kathy Acker. Latimer convincingly argues that Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale (1985) and Acker's Blood and Guts in High School (1984) and Don Quixote (1986) register the polarization of North American abortion politics during this decade. The second chapter tracks a shift “from politics to ethics” in Nancy Huston's Instruments of Darkness (1997) and Toni Morrison's Paradise (1997). In a nuanced interpretation that draws on ideas of race and abjection, Latimer observes that both novels imagine reproduction “outside fundamentalist or absolutist categories, such as pro-life or pro-choice, which framed reproductive politics in the decades before they were written” (70–71). Chapter 3 examines reproductive technologies in Shelley Jackson's Patchwork Girl (1995) and Larissa Lai's Salt Fish Girl (2001), two retellings of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein which Latimer places in productive conversation with Donna Haraway's cyborg feminism. Latimer discovers in these fictions “a different type of cyborg than the one most commonly associated with new reproductive technologies,” which resists both the “monstrous subjectivity” ascribed to Frankenstein's creature and the “naturalized subjectivity” of the foetal image (118). Finally, the book critically examines the film Children of Men, drawing a fascinating parallel between cultural constructions of the foetus, on the one hand, and of the refugee, on the other. Modifying Giorgio Agamben's notion of “bare life,” Latimer asserts that “fetal citizenship occupies a special position biopolitically, one that is akin to how the refugee functions, just on the other end of the political spectrum” (159). As right-wing forces in the US continue to push for the legal recognition of foetal personhood, this parallel makes an important intervention into mainstream debates surrounding abortion.
Latimer rightly critiques the “recursive” nature of the dominant discourse of reproductive rights (4). However, the book's continual return to the abortion question seems at odds with its stated aim of moving beyond “cyclical frames concerned with rights and choices” (5). As American scholars of reproductive justice have argued, terms like “pro-choice” are limiting precisely because they prioritize abortion and marginalize issues that disproportionately affect women of colour, such as forced sterilization.Footnote 1 Latimer attends to the relationship between race and reproduction in her discussion of Morrison, but she does not fully address the tensions between the dominant discourse of abortion rights and black feminist movements for reproductive justice in North America. Arguments between radical and post-structuralist feminists are similarly glossed over. The book constructs a continuum of post-1970s feminist thought on abortion that begins with Catherine MacKinnon's 1984 critique of Roe v. Wade and proceeds through thinkers including Mary Poovey, Judith Roof, and Drucilla Cornell. Yet the important ideological differences between these theorists are not drawn into the story: Cornell, for one, highlighted MacKinnon's failure to “affirm feminine sexual difference as other than victimization” in her review of Toward a Feminist Theory of the State (1989).Footnote 2
In the first chapter, Latimer notes Acker's “ambivalent relationship” with radical feminism, but adds that the author “leaned towards the radical in all of her politics and her characters at times earnestly (while certainly at other times ironically) reflect many radical feminist ideals when they talk about the pitfalls of patriarchy” (57). This statement conflates two senses of the term “radical” in a troubling way: in fact, radical feminism's insistence that patriarchy is the primary mode of oppression strikes many of its critics as far from revolutionary. Arguably, Acker's engagement with radical feminism tested the limitations of its deterministic model of patriarchy. Whatever one's opinion of Acker's affiliations, these feminist debates on the nature and extent of agency are part of the substance of North American reproductive politics. They feel like a missing piece of the puzzle in this otherwise timely and original study.
