Reuniting scholars from fields such as anthropology, communication studies, cultural studies, environmental studies, geography, history and sociology, Consumer Culture in Latin America feels out diverse textures of practices and processes of consumers and consumption in the region. Arguing that ‘Latin America has long been central to the global development of mass consumption, ranging from the export of raw commodities in colonial times, through the rise of middle-class consumers in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, to the contemporary involvement of many Latin American people in global networks of consumption’ (p. 2), Sinclair and Pertierra bring together a wide range of chapters examining consumption practices and consumer culture within specific socio-historical contexts in Latin America. In the introduction, which tends toward an overly justificatory tone, the editors trace the interconnectedness of the region to global networks of consumers and consumption, as well as Latin American consumption studies.
Divided into five parts, Consumer Culture in Latin America provides fragmentary views into the distinct ways in which different facets of consumer culture have come to be understood. Starting off with solid chapters, the first part examines transnational flows of capital and cultural production in two industries central to understandings of consumer cultures in ‘New Social and Business Models in Latin American Musics’ by George Yúdice and ‘The Advertising Industry in Latin America: A Contemporary Overview’ by John Sinclair. Moving on to the ways in which consumers construct identity both individually and collectively through spending, the next part includes ‘From “Country of the Future” to Emergent Country: Popular Consumption in Brazil’ by Ruben George Oliven and Rosana Pinheiro-Machado, ‘Chile's Forgotten Consumers: Poor Urban Families, Consumer Strategies, and the Moral Economy of Risk in Santiago’ by Joel Stillerman, and ‘Peasants and Pirámides: Consumer Fantasies in the Colombian Andes' by Jason Antrosio. Stillerman's insightful chapter, which examines low-income consumers' disparate experiences in two of Santiago's poorest municipalities, challenges assumptions and teases out complexities in the relationship between consumption and social class. Part III, which includes Tomás Ariztia's ‘Decorating the New House: The Material Culture of Social Mobility’, Marie Francois' ‘Stitching Identities: Clothing Production and Consumption in Mexico City’, and Patricia Vega Jiménez's ‘Christmas Tamales in Costa Rica (1900–1930)’, analyses connections between consumer cultures and different domestic practices. Vega Jiménez's examination of the cultural impact of the practice of eating a particular kind of tamales at Christmas is especially thought-provoking.
As well as including Vander Chasqui's ‘Images of Work for Consumption: Factory's Representations in Ideological Propaganda and Advertising’, the next part delves into the images and soundscapes of consumer cultures in Latin America and includes the book's strongest and weakest chapters. Anna Cristina Pertierra's excellent ‘Quinceañera: Coming of Age through Digital Photography in Cuba’ not only delimits the cultural significance of the quinceañera within a particular socio-cultural context, but also explores various cultural practices attached to shooting quince photography. Unfortunately, Ronaldo Helal and Hugo Rodolfo Lovisolo's chapter ‘Tango, Samba, and National Identities: Similarities and Differences in the Foundational Myths of “Mi Noche Triste” and “Pelo Telefone”’ does little to advance our understanding of the meanings of consumer cultures in Latin America. Somewhat out of place, the chapter offers a comparative analysis of foundational songs of musical genres (tango and samba) that have come to be closely identified with national identity in Argentina and Brazil.
Perhaps the strongest overall, the final part consists of ‘Spaces of Consumerism and the Consumption of Space: Tourism and Social Exclusion in the “Mayan Riviera”’ by David Manuel-Navarrete and Michael Redclift, ‘Singing for Shaved Ice: Glacial Loss and Raspadilla in the Peruvian Andes’ by Katherine W. Dunbar and Damacia Medina Marcos, and ‘Becoming Middle Class? Consumption, Respectability, and Place in Sex Tourism’ by Megan Rivers-Moore. Exploring consumer culture within spaces and places connected to tourism, these chapters examine local, regional and transnational features of consumer culture. Though very different, each compels the reader to reflect upon how consumption practices interact with our built, natural and social environment(s).
Although several suffer from infrequent editorial errors (an absent figure, a missing reference and so on), the chapters are generally well organised and will undoubtedly be of interest to scholars in many fields. The fragmentary views of Consumer Culture in Latin America show the centrality of consumption to ways in which individuals experience their connections to their communities in narrow (local, regional) and broad (national, transnational) contexts and with varying degrees of success. While some experiences are more immediate than others – let us compare, for example, buying a raspadilla shaved from ice blocks extracted from an Andean glacier to the regional workings of global advertising firms – they shape individual consumption practices and collective creations of consumer cultures in Latin America. While the volume does not provide a comprehensive study of consumer culture in Latin America, if such a thing is even possible, it is successful in its aim to invite ‘researchers and readers to think about how consumer culture is both distinctive within Latin American communities, and is connected to the wider world of consumption and late modernity’ (p. 11). Instead of theorising Latin American consumer culture, its chapters target the meanings of specific consumption practices and consumer cultures.
