New studies of modern Irish theatre by Paige Reynolds, Melissa Sihra, and Bernadette Sweeney can all be described as acts of recovery. In the face of scholarship that has typically focused on the Abbey Theatre and on canonical figures of the stature of Yeats, Joyce, and Beckett, these scholars insist on a wider perspective that challenges critical orthodoxy and addresses important gaps in the existing critical discourse. In Modernism, Drama, and the Audience for Irish Spectacle Paige Reynolds takes up the historically tumultuous period between 1907 and 1927 that is too often represented as a time of cultural isolation if not, especially after 1916, desolation in Ireland. Melissa Sihra edits a wide-ranging collection of a dozen essays on representations of women in Irish drama in and beyond the twentieth century, entitled Women in Irish Drama: A Century of Authorship and Representation. Focusing on the period between 1982 and 1995 (before and just as the economic prosperity associated with the Celtic Tiger reached the general Irish population), Bernadette Sweeney in her book Performing the Body in Irish Theatre examines five productions that typify a sea change in performance on the Irish stage. Sihra's anthology appears in the Palgrave series “Performance Interventions,” and all three studies share an emphasis on performance and on criticism as an intervention.
Women in Irish Drama spans the twentieth century and considers not only women playwrights, but also the representation of women and women as theatre practitioners. Since C. L. Innes published her groundbreaking Woman and Nation in Irish Literature and Society, 1880–1935 in 1993, more than a dozen important books on Irish women writers have appeared. One might imagine that today a study of modern Irish women dramatists would tread familiar ground. Not so. In 2002 Susan Cannon Harris published her brilliant and often hilarious Gender and Modern Irish Drama, but as the first book on the subject, Harris focused primarily on canonical figures—Yeats, Synge, O'Casey, and Gregory. That same year, the publication of the fourth and fifth volumes of The Field Day Anthology of Irish Writing was the landmark in the recovery of women's writing in Ireland. At 1711 pages, its two volumes offered excerpts from seventeen women playwrights from the past fifty years, but elsewhere its structural principles were governed more by theme than by genre. As playwright Marina Carr's foreword to Sihra's anthology aptly notes, Women in Modern Irish Drama begins to address the need for “the naming of these vanished women” (xi). One of the most valuable features of Sihra's book is bibliographic: the appendix chronologically lists more than 700 plays by 258 Irish women dramatists from 1663 to 2007. The breadth of the essays is suggested by a provocative afterword by one of Ireland's most accomplished and innovative theatre practitioners, Olwen Fouéré.
Organized chronologically, Women in Irish Drama groups its essays in three historical periods, which it links via interchapters (“1900–1939,” “1940–1969,” “1970–2005”) that provide an overview of women's history and theatre history in Ireland. The essays are framed by rereadings of Ireland's most widely recognized and prolific women playwrights: Lady Augusta Gregory (b. 1852) and Marina Carr (b. 1964). Over three decades Gregory wrote dozens of plays, many of them one-acts or adaptations from Molière. In “Women as Fantasy Object in Lady Gregory's Historical Tragedies,” Paul Murphy employs a Lacanian approach to three of Gregory's best-known folk-history plays: Kincora (with valuable comparison of the 1905 and 1909 versions), Dervorgilla, and Grania. Infused with the spirit of Greek tragedy, Gregory's plays partake of a common treatment of heroines drawn from myth and history: in each, Murphy argues, “desublimation occurs when the heroine exercises agency in terms of desiring another lover or choosing a different political allegiance” (38). Indeed, the conflation of woman and nation is a strand that runs through much of modern Irish theatre and its criticism.
Several of these essays are timely and valuable production records or archival recoveries. Mark Phelan considers three Northern Irish Women “doubly occluded from the Irish canon” (124) by gender and geography: Alice Milligan, Helen Waddell, and Patricia O'Connor. Similarly, works by two Cork playwrights, Geraldine Cummins and Susanne Day from early in the twentieth century, are recovered in Velma O'Donoghue Greene's archival research.
In her introduction, Sihra identifies a strong undercurrent in women's writing and in the representation of women: “push[ing] the borders of dramatic Realism, renegotiating the very frame of the ‘real’ and pre-ordained social structures” (12). One striking thread connecting several of these essays is the willingness of many of the women dramatists to transgress the well-established boundaries of realism on the Irish stage. Anthony Roche, for instance, documents the 1994 Irish-language production of Éilís Ní Dhuibhne's Dún na mBan Trí Thine (The Fort of the Fairy Women Is on Fire) at the Peacock Theatre that employed realism as well as presentational dramatic styles. Even more intriguing is what Cathy Leeney identifies as the nonmimetic dramaturgy in Eva Gore-Booth's 1916 The Buried Life of Deirdre. The mythological Deirdre had been fetishized by male playwrights in the first decade of the century: Deirdre by A. E. (George Russell) appeared in 1902; Yeats's version played at the Abbey four years later; Synge died before completing his Deidre of the Sorrows, which was performed posthumously 1910. In Gore-Booth's version, argues Leeney, the fluidity of the dramaturgy recapitulates the eponymous character's fluidity.
Although the interchapters touch on dozens of women theatre practitioners, including the first woman to win a Tony for directing (Garry Hynes), the essays here focus on women playwrights. In addition to the crucial but usually anonymous behind-the-scenes contributions of women in twentieth-century Irish theatre history, a surprising number of women played central roles as producers and directors on Irish stages.
Paige Reynolds's Modernism, Drama, and the Audience for Irish Spectacle brings together modernism and the questions of audiences for public spectacles in and, more often, outside the Abbey—and sometimes outside any purpose-built theatre. Ideas about Irish modernism remain as amorphous and contested as ideas about modernism itself. Two theatrical events frame Reynolds's study: the 1907 premiere of Synge's The Playboy of the Western World and the 1926 production of O'Casey's The Plough and the Stars. Both productions polarized the Dublin, if not the Irish, populace. Reynolds argues that while these theatre productions exposed the “fantasy of a cohesive Irish audience” (12), other public spectacles, some improvised by an unscripted public, more nearly achieved just that.
Reynolds considers the audiences for four spectacles in Ireland between 1907 and 1927, a period that saw a series of major political and social upheavals: the 1916 Easter Rising, the Anglo-Irish War, the formation of the Irish Free State, and the Irish Civil War. Many of the spectacles discussed in her book are not theatre pieces; even in the instances of The Playboy of the Western World and The Plough and the Stars, the drama quickly spilled out of the theatre and onto the streets.
Her opening chapter argues for a distinct Irish modernism grounded in the imperative of Irish independence that faced the dilemma of trying to reconcile the past-oriented revival and the forward-looking modernism. Her account of Irish modernism touches on Yeats, Joyce, and Beckett, two of whom lived and worked outside Ireland by choice. In her account, Irish modernism takes on agency, as if it were a coherent agent rather than a nebulous phenomenon. Perhaps most important, she positions Irish modernism not in benighted isolation, but in its proper European context.
Throughout this period, spectacle might arise in theatres, stadiums, and in the streets—not only from women, but also from vast, demotic constituencies, as when the former mayor of Cork, Terence MacSwiney, was mourned. Reynolds charts the persistence of MacSwiney's conception of a “consistent person” through his early one-act plays, his political writings, and his 1914 play The Revolutionist, all of which foreshadow his own hunger strike, death, and funeral in 1920. Of his hunger strike and in anticipation of his death MacSwiney famously said, “I am confident that my death will do more to smash the British Empire than my release.” MacSwiney's funeral rites were elaborately staged in London, on the docks at Holyhead in Wales, in Dublin, and in Cork when his body was diverted in its journey to Ireland from Dublin, where widespread political demonstrations were feared. Contemporary newspapers and other print accounts described MacSwiney's starvation and death as a performance piece played out to a national audience as well as an international one that he hoped to draw into solidarity with his advanced nationalist agenda.
Grappling with the complexities of Irish modernism, Reynolds examines the Dublin Drama League's 1924 premiere and revival of Pirandello's Henry V—a play that took on unique resonance in the context when “the rulers of the new Irish state similarly wished to maintain the pretense of the past” (192). Here as elsewhere, this study positions Irish modernism in the context of its European and American counterparts and reaches beyond the confines of purpose-built theatres to discover revelatory similarities.
Reynolds's most engaging chapters are also her most original. After Irish independence, the Irish Free State invested scarce resources to “resurrect” the ancient Celtic Tailteann Games, a textbook example of what Eric Hobsbawm describes as “the invention of tradition” (The Invention of Tradition, 1992, 1–2). The carefully orchestrated 1924 Tailteann Games sought to stage the spectacle of a distinctive Irish identity in “a bustling modern city comparable to Paris, London, or New York” (165). This is one of many examples that revisit and revise the Irish “provincial backwater” that Seamus Deane and others have too easily dismissed. For Reynolds, “these years [are] particularly creative and teeming with ideas about how culture might renovate perceptions of Irish identity” (157).
In Performing the Body in Irish Theatre Bernadette Sweeney theorizes her approach through a heady amalgam of postcolonial, feminist, phenomenological, and drama critics, among them Declan Kiberd, David Lloyd, Sue-Ellen Case, and Maurice Merleau-Ponty. Her methodology is a distinct hybrid that draws on postcolonialism, performance studies, and gender studies, but is neither, strictly speaking, a reception study nor a feminist analysis. She looks to the period between 1983 and 1992, in a pre–Celtic Tiger Ireland, when only the first waves of the unprecedented economic prosperity were beginning to reach the general Irish population. (In 1991, the unemployment rate in the Republic of Ireland was still the highest in the European Union, a staggering 16.1%.) Sweeney might have reached back to Brendan Behan, to Friel's landmark Philadelphia Here I Come! (1973), or to a Tom Murphy play such as A Whistle in the Dark (Theatre Workshop, dir. Joan Littlewood, 1961), or The Sanctuary Lamp (Abbey, dir. Jonathan Hales, 1975). The rationale for her decision to focus on 1983–92 is shaped by her choice of five plays: Tom Mac Intyre's adaptation of Patrick Kavanagh's The Great Hunger (Abbey, dir. Patrick Mason, 1983); David Rudkin's The Saxon Shore (Almeida [London], dir. Pierre Audi, 1986); Brian Friel's Dancing at Lughnasa (Abbey, dir. Mason, 1990); Vincent Wood's At the Black Pig's Dyke (Druid, dir. Maelíosa Stafford, 1992); and Marina Carr's Low in the Dark (Crooked Sixpence, dir. Philip Hardy, 1989). During this same especially fertile period, she might have considered Frank McGuinness's Observe the Sons of Ulster Marching Toward the Somme (Abbey, dir. Mason, 1985), Macnas's adaptation of Táin Bo Cuailnge (as Táin; Macnas, dir. Páraic Breathnach, 1992), Tom Murphy's Bailegangaire (Druid, dir. Garry Hynes, 1986) or The Gigli Concert (Abbey, dir. Mason, 1983), as well as the productions of Rough Magic, Charabanc Theatre Company, and the Field Day Theatre Company. In this period, Sweeney notes, “Perhaps it was easier to experiment, theatrically, when there was nothing to lose” (171).
Two of these plays, The Saxon Shore and Low in the Dark, had relatively short runs in their premiere and did not tour. Two others, The Great Hunger and At the Black Pig's Dyke, were more widely seen. Although first performed in small theatres (Druid's Chapel Lane Theatre seats only 54; the Abbey's Peacock ca. 157), both plays toured and were widely and frequently revived. Dancing at Lughnasa is among the most successful plays to have come out of Ireland in the twentieth century.
The production history of these five plays sketches, perhaps inadvertently, an outline of contemporary Irish theatre history outside of the Abbey, often outside of Dublin. While the Irish capital continues to burgeon and sprawl, its theatrical hegemony is challenged by “regional” companies: Derry's Field Day, which commissioned but then declined to produce Rudkin's play; Galway's Druid; and a host of small, independent companies, here typified by Crooked Sixpence Theatre Company, which produced Carr's Low in the Dark. Sweeney attributes this to “actors … looking abroad for training and influence” (171), which might be seen as another manifestation of the globalization or Europeanization of Irish drama.
Sweeney argues that, in Ireland, “[o]n attaining independence, or a measure of it [in 1922], the male acquires a privileged status. In the Irish Republic masculine subjectivity assumed the privileges of the white Western male” (17). One of the abiding characteristics of the puritanical Irish Catholicism from the 1930s and beyond was that male physicality and sexuality were often synonymous with violence, as in Tom Murphy's A Whistle in the Dark or Eugene McCabe's The King of the Castle (1964), as well as in Behan's plays. Many of these productions brilliantly represented this heritage specifically by transgressing the boundaries of realism. Sweeney convincingly argues that the five productions on which she focuses display a far greater candor about the human body, especially the female body, by developing a more physical performance style than had been typical on Irish stages.
Until recently, the presence of women in Irish drama was usually hearthside, typically depicted if not confined to a domestic space, or wandering an allegorical landscape like Cathleen ni Houlihan or even the Countess Cathleen. These productions, however, move out of the default setting for the Abbey peasant play, the kitchen. Although the kitchen remains an oppressive presence or a conspicuous absence in The Great Hunger or Dancing at Lughnasa, these productions reimagined theatrical space for Irish audiences. Stage design, acting styles, in fact every element of dramaturgy was mined in productions like At the Black Pig's Dyke to transform the familiar into the revelatory. Strikingly, Sweeney shows that moving away from the shackles of realistic dramaturgy was key in addressing Irish theatrical traditions.
New production companies in particular facilitated the more expressive treatment of the body exemplified by these five productions. As well as the continuing successes of the Gate and Druid, other companies include Barabbas … The Company (notably its 1997 freewheeling, inventive reworking of Lennox Robinson's The Whiteheaded Boy), The Fabulous Beast Dance Theatre Company, and Corcadorca. Sweeney observes that for theatre practitioners in Ireland, the rejection of the familiar categories of writers, directors, actors, or choreographers typified by Low in the Dark “marks a transition between the centrality of the writer and a developing emphasis on devising, collaborative script-writing and the role of the director” (171). Sweeney also acknowledges the contributions that specific actors including Tom Hickey, Mikel Murphi, Olwen Fouéré, and Maelíosa Stafford have made in reclaiming indigenous traditions of dance, mumming, and storytelling.
In a sweeping final chapter, Sweeney navigates the intricacies of influences and interactions that have revitalized the Irish stage. Beyond the purely documentary nature of Sweeney's book, itself an important record, her analysis of contemporary Irish theatre styles helps to explain a contribution to English-speaking drama out of all proportion to Ireland's population or geographical size.
