Amid the hundreds of books in Western languages on the Ottoman Balkans, few highlight the Ottoman contribution to Balkan development. Nikolay Antov studies the foundation of one of the largest Muslim communities in the Balkans—that of Deliorman and Gerlovo in Bulgaria—and its relationship to the Christian communities around it. The book makes the case of Deliorman easily comparable to studies on other localities, and it approaches arguments about Islamization in the Balkans from a radically new angle, setting Islamization in the context of colonization and settlement processes, local economic changes and population movements, and events occurring elsewhere in the empire. In the process Antov makes a valuable contribution to understanding the transformation of a frontier region into a heartland.
Antov employs an admirable variety of sources to make up for the thinness of the historical record, mainly Ottoman tax registers for population and land use, and hagiographies for the attitudes and worldviews of the heterodox groups that populated the Balkan countryside. An introductory chapter gives (too briefly) a broad historical outline and discusses theoretical issues around frontier societies. This is followed by a chapter on the northeast Balkans and three chapters on the demographic, socioeconomic, and cultural development of Deliorman. The final chapter discusses conversion and confessionalization in the region. I cannot relay his entire argument, but his integration of the numerous issues surrounding his topic is fertile with ideas for new research directions.
In Antov's view, Islamization in Deliorman cannot be addressed outside the larger issue of Bulgaria's establishment as a nation with a large population of heterodox Turkish-speaking Muslims, referred to as Kızılbaș. Antov describes the historiographical arguments concerning the balance between migration and conversion in forming the Muslim community. This section is useful for outsiders who need to understand the significance of Antov's argument, as well as for Balkan historians with positions on the balance between migration and conversion. Nationalist historiography provides accounts of “forced Islamization and ethnic assimilation now proven to be spurious” (p. 7). Early Ottomanist historiography cites a migration of Kızılbaș from Anatolia, or more recently a descent from remnants of Shaykh Bedreddin's anti-state movement. The latest attempt to account for these Muslims focuses on the Abdals of Rum under Otman Baba and Demir Baba. Antov unites and complicates these monocausal explanations, questioning the role of the Ottoman state in the Turkification and Islamization of the Balkans.
Agents of colonization in the Deliorman region included semi-nomadic Turcoman tribes and heterodox “colonizing dervishes” (Ömer Lütfi Barkan's term) as well as groups relocated by the state from Anatolia and southern Rumelia. Antov omits mentioning the conquerors themselves and their followers, timar holders and other military groups, admittedly fewer in number, and conflates the Turcoman tribes with the Turcoman followers of non-tribal provincial military leaders. As for the colonizing dervishes, he critiques Barkan's heavy emphasis on the state's role in their migration, arguing that it was the distance from the centralizing state that attracted the Abdals of Rum, a heterodox Sufi group associated with Otman Baba, to the frontier region.
Tracing these warrior-dervishes’ participation in the conquest of southern Rumeli, he examines their activity in gaza, raiding or warfare on behalf of Islam. Early Ottoman rulers rewarded them with waqf lands, where their settlement domesticated the wandering ascetics. Ottoman empire-building gradually divided the centralizing state from its antinomian supporters, beginning in the reign of Mehmed II. A 15th-century historiographical battle between defenders of each side of this conflict embodied their positions in literature, the state's side in chronicles and the dervishes’ side in hagiographies. The confrontation of these two types of sources is one of the most creative aspects of Antov's work.
Antov uses the hagiographies of Seyyid Ali Sultan (Kızıl Deli) and Otman Baba, both Abdal saints of the southern Balkans, to capture dervish attitudes during the periods of cooperation and alienation respectively. Kızıl Deli's late-15th-century hagiography portrays the dervishes as actually in charge of the conquest of Rumeli, which they settle after the conquest. The later mystic, the itinerant Otman Baba, wanders through Ottoman territory as the kutb or pole, the “lord of the two worlds.” At the end of his life, he settles down and urges his followers to cut trees, tend an orchard, and build a city. Rather than being at the forefront of Ottoman development, Otman Baba is not active in gaza and only belatedly accepts the empire's transformation into a sedentary state; his followers struggle for survival in the new dispensation and migrate to the distant frontier.
Moving to the northeast Balkans, Antov describes the Deliorman region, a tumultuous scene of rebellions and invasions. The region's long history of Turkic invasion and settlement prior to the Ottoman conquest shows that Turkification, Islamization, and Ottomanization were not synonymous or simultaneous in the region. Shaykh Bedreddin's revolt, which started here, left behind numerous supporters, but the Crusade of Varna (1444–45) precipitated the flight of much of the region's population and the invasion of Vlad Tepeș in 1461–62 inflicted renewed demographic losses. Survey registers from the 1470s and 1480s reflect clearly Deliorman's depopulation in the late 15th century. The remaining Muslim population was pastoralist and concentrated in the south, on the Balkan mountain slopes. This evidence of depopulation contradicts the idea that the later heterodox population descended from followers of Shaykh Bedreddin or early migrants from southern Rumeli.
Tracking the repopulation of Deliorman and Gerlovo in the 16th century, Antov opposes the “Islamization of space,” the integration of territories into an Islamic religious and sociocultural sphere, to the “Islamization of people,” the conversion of individuals. The population multiplied tenfold between the 1480s and the 1570s, and it was these new immigrants that created the later Muslim, Turkish-speaking community, Islamizing the space of Deliorman. The immigrants were mostly nomads and dervishes from the southern Balkans and Anatolia, the largest segment of which was Turcoman tribesmen, mainly Kızılbaș deportees from Anatolia. They settled in the rural areas, while the towns were settled by supporters of the Ottoman state and “Sunni orthodoxy.”
The 16th-century registers of Deliorman and neighboring Silistre testify to many Turcoman migrants and a few converts to Islam in Christian villages. As the century progressed, both Muslim and Christian populations rose and mixed villages outnumbered totally Christian villages, attesting to ongoing conversions. The number of tax exemptions dropped as deportees, nomads, and military auxiliaries, along with Sufis, lost their special tax status and became regular reaya, normal taxpayers. While the state did not control the dervishes or their activities, it negotiated to reduce and finally eliminate their special status, integrating them into its administrative system.
With respect to urban transformation, Antov transcends the duel between Bulgarian and Turkish nationalist theories of urbanism in the Balkans to uncover a multiplicity of patterns of urban growth. The Ottoman state's strategic priorities, he asserts, formed the greatest single influence on the planting of cities or the enhancement of already existing settlements at specific spots, such as crossroads or fortifiable locations or centers of rebelliousness. For example, Hezargrad, founded as an outpost of orthodox Sunnism around the mosque complex of İbrahim Pașa, became a thriving Muslim commercial and industrial center. Shumnu, a medieval Bulgarian fortress city, was destroyed in 1444 by the Crusaders; the rebuilt town had a mixed population and a prosperity based more on agriculture than on trade. Cernovi, an important medieval town, attracted little Ottoman attention as it was no longer on the frontier; its small Muslim population prevented it from acquiring a mosque and other attributes of an Ottoman city. Finally, Eski Cuma, initially a village established by Muslim converts, experienced economic growth and rose in status to a town due to its thriving market attracting Christians from the region and migrants from Anatolia. Antov concludes that, in contrast to the countryside, whose evolution is specific to the region and its history, the cities do not show an identifiable pattern of growth. Some cities became centers of Islamization, but others did not.
For insight into the region's religiocultural dimensions, Antov compares Demir Baba, spiritual successor to Otman Baba in Deliorman, through his hagiography (vilayetname), with the mosque complex of İbrahim Pașa in Hezargrad, as described in its foundation document (vakıfname). Demir Baba's story, in contrast to Otman Baba's, reveals a coherent spiritual community settled in convents and belonging to a hierarchically organized network of communities, socially acceptable and integrated into the Ottoman administrative order. Demir Baba himself, unlike Otman Baba, does not claim political authority. Heterodox Islam in the countryside, Antov concludes, was moving toward a more hierarchical and institutionalized form of Sufism. Meanwhile, orthodox Islam was building up in urban areas, as seen in the foundation of Hezargrad around the mosque complex of Grand Vizier İbrahim Pașa, whose vakfiye presents the world order as upheld by the sultan's hierarchy rather than that of the Sufi kutb. This argument is suggestive, but it demands additional support.
This information enables Antov to determine the relative weight of conversion and confessionalization in the Islamization of the Balkans. Tracking conversion through personal name and tax status, he finds 8 to 11 percent of Deliorman's households headed by converts. Most lived in villages founded by Turcoman colonists, moving out of Christian villages and assimilating with the Turcoman majority rather than experiencing conversion by dervishes. Urban conversions follow more closely the well-known patterns seen elsewhere in the Balkans. Confessionalization took the form not of enforcement of religious homogeneity but of establishment of confessional boundaries and the primacy of state-sponsored Sunni orthodoxy.
The study of Deliorman exposes the links between local events and larger processes of empire-building and expansion. Tax registers show the repopulation of the area in the late 15th century, with heterodox Sufi groups from elsewhere in the Balkans and semi-nomadic Turcoman tribes of Balkan Abdal or Anatolian Kızılbaş origin. The state's role in this repopulation was not dominant. The predominance of Turcoman migrants gave local converts their Turkish identity and speech. Intense Islamization of space, the integration of the region into the Ottoman landscape, led to Islamization of people and made conversion a socially acceptable choice. The spread of Sunni orthodoxy resulted from the imposition of imperial culture, and it marginalized the heterodox and nomadic groups that had contributed to the rise of the frontier principality. Antov describes the Ottoman state adapting to and channeling assimilation movements it could not fully control, structuring its tax regime to favor sedentary agriculture and orthodox Islam over nomadism and heterodoxy, accommodating and integrating deviant groups. This is a valuable intervention, complicating and nuancing Karen Barkey's view of the Ottomans as negotiating difference. Sections of it need additional support, but Antov's narrative connects and makes sense of the diversity of influences involved in creating the Muslim population of the northeast Balkans.
This is not a book for beginners, but graduate students as well as scholars could learn a lot from it, not just about the forces at work in the foundation of the Ottoman Empire but about research possibilities and integration of research with theory and historiography. Much of it is suggestive rather than demonstrative and needs corroboration. Still, this study shows how it is possible to make up for deficiencies in the sources to clarify our understanding of historical processes on which the participants themselves failed to comment. The detailed reading of tax registers to track population changes over time, not only in numbers but also in composition and origin, is brilliantly carried out. The use of hagiographies is more dubious, since each provides only a single example. What is fascinating is how the tax registers corroborate elements of the hagiographies, while the hagiographies interpret the data from the registers. One disappointing aspect of the historical overview is its failure to use the work of Halil İnalcık’s students from Chicago: Rhoads Murphey on tribe-state relations, Palmira Brummett on international relations in the eastern Mediterranean, including the Safavids, and my own work on early Ottoman administration and the timar system. None of these is directly relevant to conditions in Deliorman, but they might have allowed Antov to come to grips with questions he left open in his overview. Still, the book should inspire further studies of the issues it raises, and it will be required reading for anyone interested in the rise and transformation of the Ottoman Empire.
