The vast geographical areas of Central Asia are viewed with increasing interest by historians, politicians and commercial enterprises. The pre-modern era fascinates owing to the intersection of different cultures that occurred along pan-Eurasian trade routes; historians of the modern era explore the region in terms of the ‘The Great Game’ in which Britain and Russia vied for influence; under Soviet domination the area was regarded as remote and closed; in the past decade policymakers have been making great efforts to understand the legacy of Soviet control, engaging with the governments of the modern republics for their vast reserves of natural resources and their role in the ongoing struggle against Islamic terrorism. Often these seemingly disparate themes are considered in isolation, but this atlas provides an excellent overview of how they are connected by physical geography. The Farghona Valley is but one example of a geographical feature whose importance continually reoccurs in contexts that are chronologically diverse, from the first proto-states to current demographic problems and the rise of Hizb-ut-Tahrir. Moreover, besides relating political history, Rafis Abazov effectively explains the regional impact of complex, long-term and global trends through use of uncomplicated language. In doing so, the atlas goes beyond the simple illustration of political realities on a geographic stage. An example is the political turmoil brought about by the decline of land-based trade routes and manufacturing centres owing to the combination of European countries’ industrial output combined with naval supremacy. Somewhat ironically, in turn this turmoil left Central Asia vulnerable to European domination.
The Central Asian region is defined in this atlas (Map 1) as the five modern republics of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. After the “Introductory Maps” (Maps 1–5), which cover modern general political, physical and demographic characteristics, the historical sections commence with the emergence of proto-states in Transoxiana in the sixth century bce and extend up to the present day [i.e. 2007 (Map 49)]. From the era of colonialism in the eighteenth-century Central Asia entered an era of increasing historically complexity. Happily Rafis Abazov specialises in the modern era as Adjunct Assistant Professor at the Harriman Institute/ School of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University; he is a former regional analyst.
The fifty maps are presented in a chronological sequence and are divided into six sections: “Introductory Maps”; “Early History, sixth century B.C. to sixth century A.D.”; “The Islamic Golden Age, seventh to twelfth centuries A.D.”; “The Mongols and the Decline of Central Asia”; “The Era of Colonialism and Nation State Building”; and “Post-Communism and Independence”. The maps are preceded by a preface, a general key to the maps and two very helpful sections: a series of tables listing the changes in toponyms after 1991 for each of the Central Asian republics and a list of acronyms and abbreviations. The work concludes with a select bibliography and a useful index.
The volume follows the same format as the other works in the Palgrave Concise Historical Atlas series with maps printed in shades of two colours: greys and greens. Each map is numbered; there is no pagination after p. xvii until the select bibliography (p. 114). Each map is printed on the recto leaf and exactly the same geographical area presented at the same scale in all maps up to section six, and so comparisons between maps are straightforward. Accompanying descriptive and explanatory text is printed opposite on each verso leaf facing each map. The format imposes a limit on the possible amount of accompanying text. On one occasion there is an obvious mismatch between the quantity of text required to adequately cover a series of complex issues and the usefulness of the maps: The Mongol Empire – the polities mapped in Maps 23 and 24 are for all intents and purposes the same. This is, however, understandable giving the format of the atlas and an exception.
The atlas was designed as an accessible tool for general readership and does not require any prior knowledge of the history of Central Asia. Rafis Abazov has handled this formidable brief splendidly, especially given the word-limit for accompanying text imposed by the format. Although the maps illustrate Central Asia, the accompanying text often provides a broader context for the effects wrought on the region by events elsewhere. The region was never self-contained, but rather frequently at the periphery of a series of major political powers. In consequence there is often detailed and essential coverage of more general historical matters. For example, the text accompanying Map 10 is essentially a brief general historical survey of the Sasanian Empire – no mean feat in itself – with emphasis on the eastward expansion of Sasanian influence which is relevant to the geographical area illustrated by the map. Throughout the atlas the text is consistently informative and highly readable; the maps are concise, detailed and rewarding for repeated study. However, it is up to the reader to marry the two together, a sometimes challenging task. Occasionally the direct relevance of maps to the text is lacking. In Maps 41–45, which elucidate the history of the five modern Central Asian republics from independence in 1991, information is interesting but largely superfluous to the text which is clearly primary. These five maps are also the only ones whose page orientation is altered. However, the accompanying text was not also re-orientated, so it is difficult to look at the maps in conjunction with the accompanying text.
The information presented in the maps is clear. The cartography is expressly described as in “a basic format” (p. viii) and this is one of the great strengths of the atlas, given that the historical complexities of Central Asia could all too easily have led to maps encumbered with too much detail. Each map has a brief key, in the top right hand corner. The maps are as sympathetic to the vagaries of historical information as they can be without sacrificing clarity. There is intelligent use of solid blocks of colour to suggest areas of political domination or influence in the maps illustrating the history of Central Asia before the eighteenth century (often a frontier was a zone rather than a fixed point). Lines are used to show trade routes, movements of peoples or forces but are otherwise eschewed until they can be rightly used to show political boundaries between territories or national borders in the modern era.
One of the more vexing aspects of the atlas is the impreciseness encountered in some of the titles of the maps. This possibly occurs because the accompanying text, of necessity, covers wider historical developments. But given that the book is entitled as an atlas it would have been preferable to offer titles based on the maps themselves rather than the text. With “The Sassanid Empire” (Map 10) the title correctly applies to the text, but the map is of Sasanian penetration into the south-western parts of the area mapped rather than of Sasanian Persia. On other occasions the titles display a surprising looseness of language: “The Middle Ages” (Map 14) is actually a map of Central Asia in the sixth and seventh centuries only. Dates are consistently given a suffix of B.C. or A.D., which is understandable for a general readership, but occasionally these appear incongruous. In the main title of the third section “A.D.” sits most uneasily alongside the phrase “Islamic Golden Age”.
One of the most fascinating parts of the atlas is the illumination of the exceptionally complex process of ‘nation-state delimitation’ undertaken by the Soviet government between 1924 and 1936 (Maps 37–38). The details are fascinating. The Soviet policy of ‘nation-state delimitation’ arose from the Bolshevik Party's undertaking to discontinue the tsarist policy of ethnic discrimination. Nevertheless, the full implication of what the Soviet authorities completed by 1936 was essentially suspended until 1991, because the boundaries between the Soviet Socialist Republics were in fact largely irrelevant before they became independent republics. The borders were only demarcated in 1992 and 1993, a process that pushed ethnicity to the fore and helped fuel territorial disputes, most conspicuously in the Farghona Valley (Map 48).
The Palgrave Concise Historical Atlas of Central Asia contains a wealth of clear and easily accessible information; it is a bold attempt to describe and graphically illustrate the history of a complex region and the author is to be warmly congratulated for it. The paperback atlas is an affordable and worthy addition to any library and would also enhance any collection of travel literature as well. While much of the information can be considered of historical interest, there is also much, especially in the later sections, which is relevant to the current political situation of the region and preparation for wary travellers to the Central Asian republics. Rafis Abazov's achievement is to neatly marry the two together and demonstrate that the past ever intrudes on the present.
