In 1970, Belgian conductor Philippe Herreweghe founded the Collegium Vocale Gent, its members a group of friends studying at the city's university. From its humble beginnings, the ensemble acquired the enviable distinction of being among the first to employ Baroque performance practice in their concerts and recordings of vocal music. In keeping with the baroque aesthetic, their emphasis is largely on text and rhetoric, a quality that is also evident in their 2013 recording of the Stabat Mater, as envisioned by nineteenth-century Czech composer Antonín Dvořák (1841–1904). In a collaboration with the Royal Flemish Philharmonic, for which Herreweghe has served as principal conductor since 1997, the result is a clean, transparent rendition of one of Dvořák's greatest works. The chorus of 60 supplies a well-focused tone with the appropriate amount of warmth when needed and, at the same time, one that is admirably balanced with the superb quartet of soloists.
When evaluated against other signature recordings of this work, notably those of Helmut Rilling with the Oregon Bach Festival Orchestra and similarly titled choir (1996) and Jiří Bělohlávek with the Czech Philharmonic and the Prague Philharmonic Choir (1991), Herreweghe's is classically fresh and appealing. In contrast, Rilling has taken the approach of the Romantic, conveying a luxuriously expansive but warm and sensuous interpretation. Bělohlávek has the Czech Philharmonic at his disposal, an ensemble known for its superior readings of works by the nation's composers. While the soloists in the latter recording are very effective, the choir is muffled at times, and consequently consonants are lost. No such distraction occurs in the Herreweghe release. Diction from both the soloists and chorus is immaculate, accents are intelligently placed and the text is clearly understood at all times. In fact, the only reservation that can legitimately be levelled against this recording is the tempo Herreweghe has chosen, a consistently quick pace from start to finish. In the opening movement, Dvořák's sensitively nuanced score should invite the performer to convey (deliberately, but not ponderously) the immediacy of the intense sadness of mother Mary at the foot of the cross as her Son hangs dying upon it. Bělohlávek, at approximately 19 minutes, has set the most satisfying opening pace to convey the mood Dvořák must have intended. Herreweghe's tempo results in a comparatively brisker 17-minute rendition, during which the composer's lyrical motivic patterns at times take on the slight sway of a waltz. While the tempo of the opening ‘Stabat Mater dolorosa’ may initially seem quite effective compared to other recordings, several of the sections that follow lose much of their textural and musical message. In the third movement ‘Eja, Mater, fons amoris’, the suggestion of a funeral march in the orchestra as the chorus sings, ‘Blessed Mother, fount of love, make me feel the depths of thy sorrow that I may mourn with thee’ becomes simply a march.
It is in the eighth and ninth movements (‘Fac, ut portem Christi mortem’ and ‘Inflammatus et accensus’), however, that the quick tempo becomes most distracting. For the eighth-movement text regarding the desire of the main character of Dvořák's drama to share in Christ's passion and to be ‘wounded with His wounds’, Herreweghe's quick gait works only if one imagines the supplicant's state, projected by the mix of recurring semiquaver/semiquaver/quaver motives accelerating to constant semiquaver passages, as one of controlled anxiety or barely contained anticipation. The composer marks the subsequent ‘Inflammatus et accensus’ as Andante maestoso. Under Herreweghe's baton, the music takes the listener on a moderate run rather than a stately and dignified march. In fact, this rendition overall delivers a certain lilt that undermines much of the poignancy the composer has written into the music.
It must be said, however, that the last movement, a reflection of the first, works quite well at the quicker tempo. Here the mood is one of optimism instead of grief, of unwavering faith that the soul of the supplicant will reside in Paradise after death. Herreweghe opens this movement with a calming swaying motion from the soloists, reminiscent of being lovingly cradled to dispel any fear, then proceeds on to the obligatory Amen section, set with extensive imitation applied in Baroque fashion and rendered with the anticipated attitude of triumph. The following homophonic chorale, delivered a cappella by the choir alone, provides a welcome aura of simple majesty that is superseded only by the tranquility and spiritual certainty of the final series of major-key iterations of the Amen. The voices descend into the refuge made possible by faith as the strings make their way upward to paradise. The result is exquisite.
While it could be argued that all sacred music requires a certain reverence in performance, such a conviction is especially true in the case of Dvořák's Stabat Mater. The truth of this assertion lies in the genesis of the work. On 21 September 1875, Dvořák lost his two-day-old daughter Josefa. While such deaths were not uncommon in the nineteenth century, this fact would make the reality of losing a child, however young, no less painful for the parents. Whether this loss was the primary reason the composer began to express a more melancholy and, at the same time, defiant emotional tone in his works is uncertain. Nevertheless, the change in Dvořák's musical personality was uncharacteristic when considering the works that came both before and after the tragedy.
In February 1876, five months after his daughter's death, Dvořák, a devout Catholic, turned to the text of the Stabat Mater, and between 19 February and 7 May he completed the initial version in seven movements for four soloists, choir and piano. He then abandoned the work before orchestrating it, perhaps because of more pressing projects. Dvořák scholar Jarmil Burghauser suggests a more intimate reason, however, proposing that the composer was attempting to find an escape from the oppressive state of mind that had occupied him since his daughter's death.Footnote 1
The works that followed do, indeed, mark a return to an earlier and more optimistic creative outlook; but in the late summer of 1877, tragedy struck again, this time twofold. On 13 August, Dvořák's 11-month-old daughter Růžena drank a fatal dose of a phosphorus solution, used in making matches; less than a month later, on 8 September, his three-year-old son Otokar died from smallpox. The parents’ home and lives must have seemed barren, suddenly deprived of the laughter of their children.
After finishing his Symphonic Variations, the work then in progress, Dvořák returned to the score of the Stabat Mater, adding three movements (nos 5–7) and rewriting the piano accompaniment for orchestra. The work was completed in its final form in November 1877 and was premiered on 23 December 1880, an unlikely date for such a work, at a concert in Prague conducted by Adolf Čech with orchestra and soloists from the Provisional Theatre. The first foreign performance took place in Budapest on 5 April 1882, followed by a concert in London on 10 March 1883. The latter performance in England, where the choral tradition was exceptionally strong and the performance of larger-scale sacred works preferred, was a resounding success and marked Dvořák's first great triumph abroad.
On 13 March 1884, the composer was himself at the podium, directing his Stabat Mater in London's Royal Albert Hall to, according to Dvořák's letter home, a capacity crowd of nearly 12,000. His response to this performance was one of both joy and disbelief, a far cry from the distressed mood that had led to the work's creation. In a letter from London to his wife Anna, dated 17 March 1884, Dvořák indicated that he was immensely happy that he had received such recognition. A week earlier, on 10 March, he had written to his Prague publisher Urbánek after the first rehearsal, relaying his sense of awe at the enormous size of Albert Hall and the number of members in the orchestra and choir (250 sopranos, 160 altos, 180 tenors and 250 basses, complemented by an equally large orchestra). The result was truly in the spirit of a Handelian revival.
While Dvořák was impressed by the London performance, he no doubt would have also approved of Herreweghe's interpretation with greatly reduced forces, one that adheres more closely to his original concept. The composer's own writings betray his appreciation of more modest performances, as relayed in the excellent liner notes by Jan Kachlík. Brisk tempo aside, this recording is exemplary in all other ways. Its clarity and precision, combined with the skill of the chorus and soloists and the beauty they bring to the music, has resulted in a valuable addition to the performance history of this remarkable work.
