No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 November 2004
This book presents a very interesting explanation of the rise of Judeophobia in Western civilization, as it concentrates mainly on one aspect of this phenomenon—anti-Semitism. The author, Stephen E. Bronner, uses the infamous forgery The Protocols of the Elders of Zion as the cornerstone of his analysis. The core argument in the book brings to light three different aspects of the phenomenon of anti-Semitism: religious, social, and political anti-Semitism. The author suggests that, “Just as religious intolerance made way for social prejudice, social prejudice began to make way for a political antisemitism directed not merely against Jews, but against the quintessentially modern world they supposedly dominated” (p. 59). This is the leitmotif that dominates the author's analysis. Bronner examines various historical periods in which two societal forces were on a collision course. On one side were the “modern” liberal movements that strived to change the existing order; on the other side were the “old order” conservative forces that wanted to retain their control. The group caught in the middle of this recurring conflict was the Jews—or, in accordance with Bronners' argument, what the Jews were portrayed to be by the conservatives. According to Bronner, conservative anti-Semites would spread various lies about Jews, mainly using the Protocols as their proof text.
The book's layout is very appealing. After a brief Introduction, it begins, in Chapter 2, with the presentation of a selection from The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, which is considered one of the main anti-Semitic manifestations of late-19th-century in Europe. Chapter 3 continues with a historical analysis of the roots of the three facets of anti-Semitism, interspersed with direct references to the Protocols. This, in my opinion, is the most interesting part of the book. In this chapter, the author retraces the various displays of anti-Semitism mainly in Europe from the early 1900s (with some references to earlier periods), and ties them to the various anti-Jewish fables that began to appear in European culture. In addition, he sets the contextual and chronological framework in which these different facets of anti-Semitism appear and become central in Europe, supported mainly by the Protocols and occasionally by other texts written by various “traditionalist” groups. As he argues, “[D]ifferent mixtures of these antisemitic forms assume primacy at different historical moments” (p. 35). The broader societal conflict, which results in the anti-Semitic outbreaks, has been presented throughout the book as “the great battle between forces of modernity and the forces of tradition” (p. 56). The author argues that, whereas traditionalist elites are the breeders of anti-Semitic sentiments, the liberals who supported the emancipation and other liberal institutions (such as constitutionalism) are free of such dispositions. Chapters 4, 5, and 6 are an attempt to cement the argument presented in the previous chapters and look at the present situation. Chapter 4 is the tale of the history of the Protocols' invention. In Chapter 5, the author traces the Protocols throughout European history since the last century and its influence on various events and the legal battles that surrounded them. Finally, Chapter 6 presents a current overview of antisemitism today, its projected future and the role of the Protocols in shaping it.
This book serves several important functions. It documents the European origins and history of anti-Semitism, mainly throughout the last century. Moreover, it reveals a process that started with the composition of fallacious hatred literature by a few disfranchised people and went on to affect major socio-political events in Europe.
This book has some minor problems that are related to the theoretical basis of its central argument and to its source selection. As the author presents it, the Protocols have been used as a tool to sustain the existing order by “old” and “conservative” regimes and elites in the face of attacks on their reign by “modern” and “liberal” forces. While the author explicitly uses the terminology of “old” verses “new,” he provides no theoretical basis for this argument and no logic explains this clash between the “old” and the “new.” I expected to find a framework explaining the argument with reference to a plausible theoretical context. The obvious choices are, first, a Marxist framework that would set the argument within the political-economic realm, or second, the elite theory, which shifts attention from economic determination to elite conflict. Either of these approaches would lend additional depth to the argument by anchoring it in a theoretical framework.
The second issue has to do with the sources the author uses. The book relies heavily on the Protocols as its main reference source, with rare references to other anti-Semitic literature. This makes the influence of the Protocols very clear while reading the book but may result in an under-estimation of the impact of other anti-Jewish hatred literature. Finally, the author works mainly within the European context; there is no in-depth comparative analysis with other parts of the world. (Brief and insufficient mentions of other parts of the world include the Middle East by referring to Egypt and the Japanese case in East Asia.) I think that a comparative outlook would benefit this work and its attempt to explain the broader phenomenon of anti-Semitism.
All the same, this book presents a very rich and detailed analysis of a very important subject and could benefit both scholars in the field and lay readers. To make this good book even better, I recommend broadening its comparative aspect across cultures and its selection of anti-Semitic texts, and adding a theoretical framework to make it more suitable for interdisciplinary academic use.