This is a history of what the British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society did and how its leadership represented the organization's activities through its main publication, the Anti-Slavery Reporter. It is a book written from the perspective of the Anti-Slavery Society's offices in London, distant from the direct experience of slavery. The author, James Heartfield, dwells in familiar detail on the nineteenth century, then proceeds with less certainty into the twentieth century until 1956, reflecting the organization's own uncertainty about where and how to focus its efforts after the First World War and into the era of decolonization. The book then shifts focus to consider regions of the world, in accordance with the predominant interests of the Anti-Slavery Society itself, demonstrating that at least through the late nineteenth century there were discernible, significant changes in the organization's tactics, though not in its basic ideological commitment to the civilizing mission of empire.
Heartfield recounts decisions taken by the leaders of the Anti-Slavery Society, but he does not illuminate the participation of British anti-slavery supporters beyond the metropole. One of the effects of this approach is to marginalize women, who played their most significant roles in abolition as local organizers and as missionaries overseas, as writings by Clare Midgley and Pamela Scully have demonstrated. While Heartfield ignores gender, he does observe class, noting that the British anti-slavery movement was a middle-class project consistently committed to the principles of free trade and moderate constitutionalism — in contrast to its more radical counterparts in the United States with whom it had strained relationships. He acknowledges but understates the role of Christianity in British anti-slavery, in terms of both popular religious motivation and the connection between ‘Christianity and commerce’, which was a tenet of Britain's justification for its colonial expansion into Africa. Heartfield does make an important observation that competition with Muslim slave traders in Central and East Africa gave European Protestant and Catholic missionaries a common cause, a subject that deserves further historical study.
For all the ideological durability of Christianity and commerce, there were several major changes in the ideas and objectives of the Anti-Slavery Society. The organization shifted from ‘immediatism’ to gradualism and from pacificism to a tacit acceptance of military force as it drew closer to the British foreign office after 1870. This coincided with the organization shifting its focus from the Americas to Africa in the aftermath of the U.S. Civil War and the Union victory that secured President Abraham Lincoln's emancipation proclamation. Whereas the Anti-Slavery Society had advocated crown rule for white settler colonies in the Americas, it advocated governance on the ‘voluntary principle’ in Africa. It is noteworthy that throughout his discussion of Britain and Africa after 1870, Heartfield exaggerates the influence of the Anti-Slavery Society in official policymaking. Although the Anti-Slavery Society was excluded from the Berlin Conference of 1884–5, Heartfield asserts that ‘over the months and years they had played a big part in the talking that shaped the outcomes there’ (299). To the contrary, Suzanne Miers has shown that in the midst of hard-headed geopolitical maneuvering, British Foreign Office officials proposed to include an anti-slavery declaration in the final multilateral treaty as a moral pretense. Miers makes clear that the other representatives were prepared to stand in the warm glow of Britain's declaration, but only after being assured that it entailed no responsibility whatsoever to enforce abolition, which Britain had never intended it to do in the first place.
Scholars of African and imperial history will find Heartfield's heavy reliance on the Anti-Slavery Reporter to be problematic. Like the Reporter, he draws few cultural distinctions among African peoples or indigenous systems of labor and trade. He appears to quote directly from British government documents, but one finds in the book's endnotes that he is quoting selected excerpts reprinted in the Anti-Slavery Reporter (e.g., 250–1, 452). Although the bibliography includes major works of scholarship on African history, these are seldom brought into play in Heartfield's treatment of Africa, which effectively follows the Anti-Slavery Reporter’s lead.
This book is the first broad survey of the Anti-Slavery Society, but readers will be better served by a combination of previously published texts that employ a range of sources to offer fuller, multifaceted perspectives on the organization and its work. These include Howard Temperley, British Anti-Slavery, 1833-1870 (1972), Richard Huzzey, Freedom Burning: Anti-Slavery and Empire in Victorian Britain (2012), and the many fine works by Miers extending from the nineteenth century into the late twentieth century.
