I received this book with great anticipation, as its title suggested that it might help redress a general trend of academic neglect of the fate of postwar Central America in general, and of its human rights movement in particular. Unfortunately, although this slim volume has its merits it does not fully live up to its title. Nor in fact does it satisfactorily deal with the more circumscribed subject matter actually addressed in its pages.
The volume contains interesting and possibly valuable interview material from three of El Salvador's historic grassroots human rights organisations (HROs) at just over a decade's distance from the 1991 Salvadorean peace accords. In the book's most successful sections, much can be gleaned from this recent first-hand material, collected and presented by someone who is clearly well acquainted with the country and the subject at hand.
Unfortunately, a host of structural and analytical weaknesses limit the book's capacity to live up to its promise. Chief amongst these weaknesses is an inadequately justified selectivity: by page 4 the author has summarily dismissed church-based HROs from his analysis, despite his own later acknowledgement that many of the groups he does choose to focus on attribute their existence to church support and/or to the key role of San Salvador Archbishop Oscar Romero in inspiring and sheltering incipient HROs in the late 1970s. One serious consequence is that the author's chief argument, that wartime links between the FMLN guerrilla and the human rights movement were both stronger and proportionately more significant than has generally been acknowledged, suffers greatly from the a priori exclusion of such a large and influential sector of the movement. Whether church groups were more, less or equally likely to have such links, and/or whether they were particularly inclined or placed to resist what Sprenkels suggests were attempts by the FMLN to co-opt HROs into the guerrilla's ‘revolutionary project’, would all have been fascinating and important questions to explore.
However, these questions are not addressed. Instead we are given an unduly breathless tour of related academic literature and Salvadorean political history, before being returned to the central, and fairly narrow, subject matter of links between the FMLN and so-called ‘Mothers' Committee’ HROs, and in particular what Sprenkels was told about these links in a two month data collection period around mid 2003, comprising 31 individual and two group interviews. Here, although there is undoubtedly source material of interest, we are not told enough about methodology. In particular we do not find out how the author resolved the dilemma of the acknowledged insufficiency of the use of post-hoc narrative alone to recover what he calls ‘deeper truths’ about particular political and social episodes. Questions about what such narratives can and cannot tell us, how they are best collected and complemented, and how and to what extent they were or ought to be triangulated against official versions and contemporaneous records, are neglected. A related point is that the disciplinary roots of the work, which apparently began life as a masters' thesis, are not made clear.
More mapping of the human rights community in El Salvador before, during and after the war would have assisted greatly in providing ‘missing’ data about change and the causes of change, in patterns of activism. Regarding what the book claims as a central revelation, the existence and extent of links between certain HROs and the FMLN in wartime El Salvador is perhaps not as novel as the book claims. Indeed it is and was one of the more open secrets of the period. The fact that it was not more often remarked upon or more openly discussed by analysts and academics of the period has to do with fairly evident, and eminently justifiable, ethical and humanitarian considerations which might themselves have repaid closer attention or at least a mention in this work.
The author correctly identifies early on some important research questions about El Salvador: how did the postwar transition affect the human rights movement and what were the social processes underlying change? Unfortunately, the work as presented does not satisfactorily answer or even return to these central questions, preferring to conclude with some remarks about questions of identity and representation. In general, this work would have benefited from tighter editing, a more controlled research focus and a structure more clearly setting out its methodology, suppositions and conclusions.
