Throughout the ages, monsters have lurked in the dark recesses of humanity's collective psyche; and as long as human beings exist, these creatures will continue to capture our imaginations and provide entities upon which to project our fears and cultural anxieties. Theorists who explore monsters have eagerly taken up many of the foreboding, fantastical beings who inhabit our written and filmic texts, seeking to explain their function within society and culture. But while there are many studies devoted to monsters present in literature and film, often the portrayal of monsters on the stage has been absent from cultural genealogy. With his book The Monster in Theatre History: This Thing of Darkness, Michael Chemers attempts to fill that gap with ruminations on several well-known monsters that have occupied a central place within theatre history.
The book comprises case studies of several popular monsters that have played an influential role in the development of Western theatre. The characters Chemers chooses to discuss—Caliban, Frankenstein's monster, the vampire, the golem, the ghost, and the werewolf—are a rather eclectic bunch and seem somewhat haphazard. Yet these disparate choices allow Chemers to cover a wide range of periods and productions, offering a broad sampling of monstrous creatures who have taken center stage down through the ages. Each chapter focuses on one particular monster or monster type, using brief explications of the character's genesis in literature and descriptions of the character's onstage manifestations as an opportunity to release cultural insight. Chemers is particularly interested in teasing out how concepts surrounding these monsters are sometimes deployed to “justify modern marginalization, persecution, and even atrocities” (4).
In Chapter 1, “Caliban's Legacy,” Chemers reads the figure of Caliban through the seven theses laid out in Jeffrey Jerome Cohen's opening essay of his edited volume Monster Theory: Reading Culture (University of Minnesota Press, 1996):
1. “the monster's body is a cultural body” (27);
2. “the monster always escapes” (29);
3. “the monster is the harbinger of category crisis” (31);
4. “the monster dwells at the gates of difference” (32);
5. “the monster polices the borders of the possible” (37);
6. “the fear of the monster is really a kind of desire” (38); and
7. “the monster stands on the threshold … of becoming” (40).
By exploring Caliban through these seven propositions, Chemers uncovers the ways in which this character functions as an ever-changing expression of cultural anxiety. In Chapter 2 Chemers takes up the figure of Prometheus as a forerunner of Frankenstein's monster, beginning with Aeschylus’ play Prometheus Bound and then shifting into a recounting of how Mary Shelley came to write Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. Chapter 3 discusses various stage adaptations of Shelley's story, beginning with Richard Brinsley Peake's Presumption; or, The Fate of Frankenstein, and then moving to Henry M. Milner's The Man and the Monster! or, The Fate of Frankenstein, and on to several more adaptations. Chemers points out how our current popular conception of Frankenstein “carries a very different set of meanings” than did those earlier iterations (55). Chapters 4–7 take up vampires, the golem, ghosts, and werewolves respectively. Each of these chapters continues the foregoing pattern: Chemers introduces a broad array of disparate literary and theatrical texts containing the character under discussion and then draws lines among the resources in order to open up new insights into the cultural connections and connotations of each monstrous entity.
Throughout the book Chemers makes use of several theoretical frameworks, applying them unsystematically. As he readily admits, his method involves “employing analytical tools from whichever domains of human inquiry seem most productive to the purpose” (5). That being said, Chemers does position himself strongly in relation to Joseph Roach's concept of “surrogation” (5), borrowing his technique of conducting research that is both deep and broad in order to uncover aspects of material practice and theoretical frameworks that were previously hidden. Chemers also finds a useful model in Rosemarie K. Bank's Theatre Culture in America, 1825–1860 as he endeavors to lay out “spatial histories” (3), which help bring to light an array of indirect relationships among subjects. Bank's model suggests that historians look beyond a single domain of critical theory when conducting a study in order to reveal concealed connections and associations. Chemers follows Bank's suggestion, using a wide array of theoretical frameworks in order to avoid a positivist or reductionist view of his subject matter. Due to this wide sampling of critical techniques, however, the book can read more as a loosely connected set of reflections upon Chemers's favorite stage monsters than a sustained deep engagement with theory. This is not necessarily a bad thing, though. Through his serendipitous use of several critical frameworks, Chemers makes some insightful observations and unearths interesting connections that are rife with opportunities for further study. Instead of new information, there is old information here explored in new ways. The book also contains a wide-ranging bibliography that can offer inspiration for additional research, although it does contain some notable omissions. For example, Chemers does not include David J. Skal's Hollywood Gothic: The Tangled Web of Dracula from Novel to Stage and Screen (Norton, 1990) or his The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror (Norton, 1993), two texts with extensive information about staged monsters. I was also surprised to discover that Noël Carroll's The Philosophy of Horror (Routledge, 1990) was not referenced. In spite of these omissions and its idiosyncratic approach to theory, this book does successfully demonstrate how theatre animates ideas about monsters in ways that books and films cannot. It stands as a reminder that not only have monsters played an important role in the history of the theatre, but theatre has played an important role in the history of monsters.
