In his classic book Arab Politics (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1977), Michael Hudson chose the “search for legitimacy” as the organizing theme for his analysis of the many challenges to the region's leaders and political systems. Since then, legitimacy has often been invoked by analysts and scholars, but few have focused their studies on it. In a significant departure, Catherine Warrick has chosen to place the relationship between culture and political legitimacy at the heart of her book on gender and law in contemporary Jordan.
Warrick's argument runs as follows. Legitimacy, “a crucial component of successful democratic systems, is significantly dependent upon cultural factors that affect the political system,” and “the politicization of elements of culture contributes to the ability of the regime and other political actors to claim sociocultural legitimacy.” While she acknowledges that several factors contribute to legitimacy, she argues that sociocultural legitimation is the most fundamental because it is basic “to the state's stability and, in the end, to the prospects for the development of democratic characteristics such as free contestation, equal rights and social tolerance” (p. 1). Warrick justifies her selection of Jordan as a case study on the grounds that in Jordan “the nature of the political system and the proper character of national culture are topics of intense and public debate” and that “the state's pursuit of legitimacy is readily traced in its approach to gender issues and the law, an arena where the state seeks to entrench its legitimacy by engaging various social actors and appealing to more than one basis of governing authority” (p. 1).
After the introduction and an initial theoretical chapter, subsequent chapters look at dual legal systems (civil and shariʿa), criminal law, nationality law, access to divorce, women's participation in state institutions, the women's movement, and government institutions. The early chapters are notable for the degree to which Warrick capably and usefully situates Jordan in relation to other Arab states’ (especially Egypt's) legal systems and legislation. She also does a fine job of providing material on comparable questions from outside the Arab world, including from the United States, to remind readers that some aspects of legislation and practice related to gender in the Middle East are not so different from what one finds in the West. In the later chapters, the empirical material on, for example, the evolution of institutions addressing domestic violence and sexual abuse and on the evolving role of Jordanian women in the military is rich and fascinating, although it left this reader hoping for more consideration of its theoretical implications.
It is in its theoretical aspirations and grounding that the study has problems. Although Warrick includes a discussion of Gramsci's concept of hegemony and Habermas’ theory of crises of legitimacy, she does not succeed in linking her theoretical concerns with the case material in a way that advances our understanding of legitimacy or its connection to culture. The problem begins at the point of definition, for she does not elaborate on the thorny concept of culture or legitimacy itself. She classifies gender as an element of culture but does not relate gender to any cultural issue aside from Islam or largely unspecified “tribal norms.” In addition, legitimacy's importance is asserted, but the discussion makes no theoretical strides in operationalizing it. I appreciate that Warrick does not see herself as a positivist, and thus asking her to develop a set of testable hypotheses would be unfair, but she has failed to specify the question or puzzle she is trying to address. Instead, Warrick tell us that gender is an area through which the state is trying to reinforce its legitimacy, and then she in effect provides case studies of laws or legal areas in which she claims such contestation for legitimacy is at work.
It is not that those of us who have worked on Jordan would reject the contention that the country has had and continues to have “culture wars” and that gender figures centrally in a number of key issues. Quite the contrary. But instead of carefully detailing not just the stakes but also the range of actors—both within the regime and outside it—and the elements involved in order to support her contention, she rather cursorily treats the unfolding of contestation in these issue areas. Instead of tying the empirical material to theory, she merely repeats her contention about the importance of cultural legitimacy.
Particularly troublesome in Warrick's discussion of the role of culture and legitimacy is the fact that she accepts and uses the “modern vs. traditional” dichotomy despite having stipulated earlier that it is problematic (p. 6). Rather than analyzing or deconstructing the discourse of the political/social/cultural actors involved, she accepts the labels that they employ. That said, Warrick does show that she understands the problem. In her discussion of honor killings, for example, she demonstrates that arguments both for and against them can derive from so-called “tradition.” But in general, Warrick devotes far too little attention to exploring the forces responsible for constructing what the terms “tradition,” “modernity,” “liberalism,” or “royal liberal” mean at any particular historical juncture—a step that is critical to explaining how state legitimacy needs to be pursued. In addition, her analysis should have explored why a particular issue—nationality, divorce, honor crimes—becomes the focus of rancorous contestation in the kingdom at a particular juncture. Warrick's discussions of these battles lack the deep contextual grounding needed to explain their full dimensions and the timing behind their unleashing.
Finally, the book seems preoccupied with insisting on its relevance for possible democratization in Jordan, perhaps the result of an editor seeking a broader audience. Warrick is certainly correct that absent meaningful political and economic enfranchisement of women, Jordan will remain a nondemocratic state. However, much more basic to discussions of regime or state legitimacy and the future of authoritarianism in Jordan is that the country's political system is one in which a hereditary king both reigns and rules. Unless the nature of the monarchy changes, the cultural elements that interest Warrick will remain only symptomatic of a much larger structural impediment to serious political reform.
In sum, Catherine Warrick has taken on a tough but critical topic. She has gathered a wealth of empirical information and framed it with theory. That the book falls short in effectively integrating the two does not reduce the importance of the attempt. One hopes that other scholars will take on the critical question of legitimacy in the Arab world in its many dimensions and continue to push the boundaries—both empirical and theoretical—of our understanding of it.
